Standards and considerations for architectural review. In passing upon applications for architectural review permits, the Village Manager (for applications that qualify for Level I architectural review), the Commission (for applications that require Level II architectural review), and the Board of Trustees (in the case of an appeal) shall consider and evaluate the propriety of issuing said permit in terms of its effect on the stated purposes and goals of architectural review. To that end, the Village Manager, Commission, and Board of Trustees shall consider the appearance of a proposed construction, alteration, enlargement, or remodeling project in terms of the quality of its design and the relationship to its surroundings. A proposed project should harmonize with and support Bannockburn's unique character, with special consideration accorded the preservation and enhancement of landmarks and the preservation and enhancement of natural features, including without limitation existing trees and landscaping. Furthermore, a project should be consistent with all of the ordinances and regulations of the Village, including without limitation the Bannockburn Zoning Code, Comprehensive Plan, and Tree Ordinance. In addition, the Village Manager, Commission, and Board shall consider, among other factors, the following particulars:
(1) Landmarks.
(a) The quality of landmarks should be preserved by avoiding excessively similar or dissimilar nearby buildings that detract from a landmark's uniqueness.
(b) Landmarks should not be dwarfed or obstructed from view by nearby buildings.
(2) Site plan.
(a) The site should be planned to meet, if not exceed, setbacks and to establish, protect, and enhance bufferyards between properties and to minimize disturbance to the natural landscaping on the site. Further, the project should be designed to preserve and enhance natural features on the site, including without limitation existing trees, wooded areas, bufferyards, and landscaping.
(b) Access to the site and circulation thereon should be safe and convenient for pedestrians, cyclists, and vehicles.
(c) Driveways should be located to maintain adequate space between cuts in the streetscape.
(d) Driveway and parking areas should be screened to reduce visual intrusions into surrounding properties and to enhance the secluded appearance of the Village.
(e) Screening or fencing should be consistent in design and materials with the principal buildings on the subject and adjacent properties.
(f) Monotony should be avoided.
(g) Exterior lighting should be designed to be consistent with the Village's dark-at-night character and shall, at a minimum, comply with the lighting restrictions contained in the Bannockburn Zoning Code.
(3) Elevations.
(a) The scale and height of the project should be visually compatible with the landscaping and topography of the site and with buildings on the site and in the surrounding area.
(b) The relationship of solids to voids in the front facade of a project should be visually compatible with buildings, public ways and places to which it is visually related.
(c) The visual continuity of roofs and their contributing elements (such as parapet walls, coping, and cornices) shall be maintained in building development or redevelopment.
(d) Monotony should be avoided.
(e) Garage doors should be designed, whenever possible, so that the doors are not facing the front yard of the site.
(f) Fences should be installed, whenever possible, with structural elements facing interior to the property that is the subject of the application and set back at least three inches from the property line; provided, however, that these standards may be altered if deemed appropriate in light of existing perimeter fences on adjacent properties or with the consent of adjacent property owners.
(4) Landscaping.
(a) Landscaping plans should be consistent with the natural environment of the site, adjacent properties, and the surrounding area; provided that, when a site is open, suitable landscaping consistent with the wooded nature of the Village should be provided.
(b) Existing natural features should be appropriately preserved and integrated into the project. Under appropriate circumstances, a conservation strip consisting of landscaping and natural growth but excluding lawns and any impervious surface between adjacent properties would promote this objective.
(c) The project should be designed to meet, if not exceed, the bufferyard requirements of the Bannockburn Zoning Code to maximum screening and buffering in order to protect neighboring properties from the project.
(5) Type, color and texture of materials.
(a) Materials should be new and of first-rate quality.
(b) Materials should be selected for both their durability and beauty.
(c) Colors of the materials for the project should be harmonious with only compatible accents.
(d) A project that is obviously incongruous with its surroundings or unsightly and grotesque should be avoided.
(e) A project whose design or color may be distracting to vehicular traffic so as to cause a safety hazard should be avoided.
(6) Vicinity map.
(a) The building layout should maximize the distance between buildings on the site and buildings on adjacent properties.
(b) The building layout should maintain appropriate distances between buildings on the site itself.
(c) The size, scale, and nature of a building or project should not be inconsistent with the planned Village character for the area as expressed in the Comprehensive Plan; nor shall such building or project cause a substantial depreciation in the property values of adjacent buildings, the neighborhood, or the Village.
(d) The project should not unduly detract from the natural environment of the site, adjacent properties, or the surrounding area.
These criteria are not intended to restrict imagination, innovations, or variety, but rather seek to preserve and enhance Bannockburn's unique character.