Zoneomics Logo
search icon

Lockport City Zoning Code

PART 4

Application and Review Procedures

§ 190-40.1 Applicability.

A. 
Review required. Any person or entity seeking to erect, construct, enlarge, alter, improve, demolish a building or structure; or establish, operate, convert, or change the nature of the use or occupancy of any building or structure within the City of Lockport shall first be required to secure all necessary approvals and permits as required by this zoning code.
B. 
Application form. Applications must be submitted in a form and in such numbers as outlined herein. Checklists of application submittal and review requirements may be made available within the Building Department.
C. 
Review body. For the purposes of this zoning code the terms "reviewing body" or "review body," shall refer to the Common Council, commission, committee, official, or other designated decision-making body that is charged with review and/or approval authority as authorized under this zoning code and by New York State Law. This may include, but is not limited to the Code Enforcement Officer, CEO, Common Council, Planning Board, and Zoning Board of Appeals.
D. 
Properties in violation prohibited.
(1) 
No applications that include a building, structure, property, or use that is in violation of this zoning code, other laws of the City of Lockport, or New York State laws, rules, and/or regulations shall be accepted or processed, unless the applicant obtains a variance to remedy a violation of the zoning code.
(2) 
Applications, which, in whole or in part, include a proposal to rectify violations on such property, may be considered in accordance with this zoning code.

§ 190-40.2 Preapplication conference.

A. 
Purpose. The purpose of a preapplication meeting is to provide the applicant with the opportunity to seek nonbinding, advisory direction from the City to better prepare the applicant and project application for the development review process. This process is optional and has no bearing on action on a formal application.
B. 
Conference. Applicants may request a preapplication meeting prior to entering the formal application review process to discuss the nature of the proposed application and to determine the best course of action for submittal. Meetings may be held with City Building Department.
C. 
Advisory opinion. In no way shall any comments or feedback provided by the Committee during a preapplication meeting be construed as an indication of decision or be legally binding in any way.
D. 
Application material. Materials presented during the preapplication meeting may be incomplete and/or conceptual in design. A formal, complete application is required to be considered for approval prior to action.

§ 190-40.3 General application procedures.

A. 
Submittal. All applications considered under this chapter shall:
(1) 
Be submitted to and processed by the City's Building Department.
(2) 
Require the signature of the owner(s) of the subject property. Where there are multiple land owners, a written consent agreement among all land owners must be included. Tenants may submit applications with written consent of the property owner(s).
(3) 
Be provided in the required number and form, including at least 10 hard copies and one electronic copy (digital PDF). Site plan applications shall include one electronic and at least two stamped hard copies of all maps and site plans at the size and scale requested by the Building Department.
(4) 
Include all application fees as established by § 190-40.9 and as may be required elsewhere in this chapter.
B. 
Deadlines. Applications shall be submitted at least 15 business days prior to the meeting at which the applicant wishes to be considered. Supplemental materials and amendments to applications already under review are also due at least 15 business days prior to the meeting of the reviewing body.
C. 
Acceptance and processing.
(1) 
Within 30 days of an application being filed, the City's Building Department shall determine whether to accept the application as ready for processing or reject the application as not ready for processing.
(2) 
An application is considered accepted and ready for processing only if it is submitted in the appropriate number and form, includes all required materials, and is accompanied by the required fee.
(3) 
The acceptance of an application by the City shall in no way be interpreted as a determination of the completeness, adequacy, or accuracy of application materials, but rather serve as an acknowledgement to the receipt of required fee and application materials in the correct number and form.
(4) 
If an application is determined to be not ready for processing, a paper or electronic written notice shall be provided to the applicant, along with an explanation of all known deficiencies that prevent review.
(5) 
No further processing of unaccepted applications will occur. When the deficiencies are corrected, the application will be placed in the next available processing cycle. If the deficiencies are not corrected within 62 days, the application will be considered withdrawn.
D. 
Applicant responsibilities.
(1) 
The applicant and/or their agent is expected to attend all meetings at which the application is to be discussed.
(2) 
In all cases, the burden is on the applicant to show that their application complies with the City of Lockport local laws and regulations, and any other applicable New York State laws, rules, and regulations.

§ 190-40.4 Review body action.

A. 
Initiation of review. The review process(es) provided herein shall begin within 30 days of application acceptance by the City's Building Department. The review and decision period does not begin until such time that the City's Building Department notifies the applicant that the application is ready for processing and the materials submitted are acceptable for review.
B. 
Public hearing. Where required by this chapter and New York State Law, the reviewing body shall hold at least one public hearing prior to the issuance of a decision. Where not required, the reviewing body may hold at least one public hearing at their sole discretion.
C. 
State Environmental Quality Review (SEQR). Where required by New York State Law, the review body shall complete all required documentation and procedures in accordance with the State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA).
D. 
Issuance of decision.
(1) 
Within 62 days following the close of the public hearing the reviewing body shall issue a decision to approve, approve with conditions or modifications, or deny the proposed application.
(2) 
Where county referral is required, no decision shall be issued by the reviewing body until the referral process is complete.
(3) 
The time period in which a decision must be rendered on the application may be extended by mutual consent of the applicant and the reviewing body.
E. 
Waiving application requirements. A reviewing body is authorized to waive or modify, in whole or in part, required application material if, in their sole opinion, one or more of the following apply:
(1) 
Any such material, or part thereof, is not requisite in the consideration of impact to public health, safety, or general welfare;
(2) 
Any such material is inappropriate or irrelevant to the proposal;
(3) 
Any such material is deemed unnecessary for an adequate, informed review.
F. 
Additional application requirements. A reviewing body may require the applicant to provide additional application material if it is found to be necessary for a complete, adequate, and informed review.

§ 190-40.5 Coordinated reviews.

A. 
Concurrent reviews. In some cases, an application may be subject to multiple reviews by this chapter and the City of Lockport Code. Where deemed appropriate by the Building Department to streamline the application review process the following reviews may be conducted concurrently, subject to the reviewing body having vested authority to hear and decide upon such matters:
(1) 
Site plans, in accordance with Article 42.
(2) 
Special use permits, in accordance with Article 43.
(3) 
Subdivisions, in accordance with Chapter 162 of the City of Lockport Code.
(4) 
Variances, in accordance with Article 46.
(5) 
Amendments, in accordance with Article 46.
(6) 
Planned unit developments, in accordance with Article 45.
B. 
Conditions of approvals.
(1) 
Special use permit. If obtained prior to site plan approval, the special use permit shall be conditioned upon the applicant obtaining site plan approval. In the event that a site plan application is denied, the special use permit shall be considered null and void.
(2) 
Subdivision. Where a subdivision application is considered alongside a site plan application, the Planning Board shall first issue a decision on the subdivision plat. Should the subdivision application be denied, the site plan shall be considered null and void.
(3) 
Variance. Where a site plan, special use permit, or subdivision application requires a variance, approval of said variance must be obtained first. Should the variance be denied, the associated site plan, special use permit, and/or subdivision application shall be amended accordingly.
(4) 
Amendments. Approval(s) for any development action considered under this chapter, for which a rezoning is also requested or required, shall be conditioned on the approval of the zoning amendment application by the Common Council. Should the rezoning be denied, all other development application approvals conditioned on the rezoning shall be considered null and void.

§ 190-40.6 Referrals.

A. 
Internal referral. The reviewing body may refer any application to another board, committee, department, or official for review, comment, and advisement.
B. 
Professional referral.
(1) 
The reviewing body may seek the opinion of any engineering, architectural, historical, planning, technical, environmental, legal consultant or attorney, or other expert or professional to aid in the review of an application.
(2) 
The applicant shall reimburse the City for any costs incurred as part of such professional review in accordance with § 190-40.9.
C. 
County referral. The City shall refer applications to the Niagara County Planning Board pursuant to New York State General Municipal Law 239-m and in accordance with any planning referral agreements between the City and County.
D. 
Waterfront application referrals. Applications in waterfront designated districts and the LWRP area (see Chapter 187 of the City of Lockport Code) may be referred to the New York State Department of State.

§ 190-40.7 Expiration, revocation of approval or permit.

A. 
Expiration. Except for variances granted in accordance with New York State Law, the approval of an application shall expire if one or more of the following occur:
(1) 
The approved use(s) cease operation for more than 12 consecutive months for any reason;
(2) 
The applicant fails to obtain necessary building permits or certificates of occupancy within one year of the approval date;
(3) 
The applicant fails to comply with the conditions of approval within one year of the date of issuance or completion of construction, where applicable;
(4) 
The applicant fails to initiate construction or operation of use within one year of the approval date;
(5) 
The applicant fails to complete construction;
(6) 
The applicant fails to renew a time limited permit prior to the stated time period ending; or
(7) 
Another provision of this chapter expressly sets a term of expiration.
B. 
Extensions. The reviewing body may grant an extension for any condition in Subsection A upon written request by the applicant. The applicant shall include in such request the desired time period for the extension and the reasoning for requesting the extension. A fee may be required to process extension requests. The time period of such extension, if granted, shall be determined by the reviewing body.
C. 
Revocation. The Code Enforcement Officer may revoke the building permit associated with an approved project if the applicant violates the conditions of the approval or engages in any construction, alteration, or operation not authorized by the approval and/or related permit(s). Such action shall include the revocation of any special use permit or other zoning authorization issued under this zoning code.

§ 190-40.8 Public hearings and notices.

A. 
Public hearing required. The reviewing body shall schedule, notice, and conduct a public hearing for applications as required by this zoning code and New York State Law.
B. 
Joint hearings. Where there are multiple applications for a single property or use before the reviewing body concurrent or joint public hearings may be held.
C. 
Public notices. Public notice of public hearings shall be made in accordance with this zoning code and New York State Law, this may include mailed, media and posted notice.
D. 
Media notices. The City Clerk or designee shall cause publication of a notice in the City's official newspaper and official website.
E. 
Mailed notices.
(1) 
Written notice of public hearings to adjoining municipalities, Niagara County, and the State Commission of Transportation shall be provided where required by New York State Law.
(2) 
Notice of public hearings shall be mailed to adjacent properties, which shall include the name of the applicant, nature of application, and description of the property involved, to be sent by ordinary mail by depositing same in a plain sealed envelope addressed to the last known address of all owners of affected property located within an area bounded by lines drawn parallel to and a distance of 400 feet from the property lines of the applicant, at least eight days before the hearing.

§ 190-40.9 Fees.

A. 
Fee schedule established. A schedule of fees for all permits, applications, deposits, and copies shall be provided in a fee schedule, set by resolution of the Common Council. Such schedule may be amended from time to time as deemed necessary by the Common Council.
B. 
Consultant fees.
(1) 
The amount of a consultant fee shall be determined and approved by the Common Council. Consultants shall estimate their fees based on the services to be rendered on behalf of the City from a review of the application, including such documents, maps, plans, specifications, drawings and the like as may be a part thereof.
(2) 
The consultant will be retained pursuant to the procurement policy of the City. The applicant shall make an escrow deposit with the City, equal to the amount of the fees so determined. This escrow deposit shall be utilized to pay the cost of the special consultant's fees involved. The application shall not be deemed complete until such time as said escrow deposit has been made. If during the review the need for further specialist consultation is deemed reasonably necessary by the Board, the same cost estimate and escrow deposit procedure shall be followed.
(3) 
Upon issuance of decision and within a period of 45 days thereafter, the Common Council shall adopt a resolution specifying whether the escrow deposit amount specified was sufficient, excessive, or insufficient. In the event the Common Council determines that said amount is excessive, the balance shall be returned to the applicant within 60 days. In the event the Board determines that the escrow deposit was insufficient, it shall so specify, and the applicant shall be required to make payment of such additional amount within 60 days.

§ 190-41.1 Permits required.

No person, firm, or corporation shall commence, cause to be done, or perform any other work associated with the erection, enlargement, alteration, improvement, conversation, or change in the nature of the use or occupancy of any building, structure, or lot without first obtaining a building permit and certificate of occupancy where required by this chapter and all other applicable local, state, and federal rules, laws, and regulations.

§ 190-41.2 Building permits.

A. 
Applications.
(1) 
For principal permitted uses. All such applications shall be accompanied by plans, in duplicate, drawn to scale, showing the actual shape and dimensions of the lot to be built upon, the exact size and location of any building, structure, sign, parking or loading area or other physical feature existing or proposed on the lot, the existing and intended use of each building or part of a building, the number of families, housing units, employees, offices or other appropriate units of occupancy which the building is designed to accommodate, and such other information as may be necessary to determine compliance with this chapter. One copy of such plans shall be returned to the owner when such plans shall have been approved by the CEO; and one copy each of all applications with accompanying plans and documents shall become a part of the public record after a permit has been issued or denied.
(2) 
All such applications shall be accompanied by plans as required in Subsection B(1) above and other information as may be required by the Planning Board, except that for planned unit development groups, the following shall also be furnished: A general site plan showing the use or uses, dimensions and locations of proposed structures and of areas to be reserved for vehicular and pedestrian circulation, parking, public uses such as schools and playgrounds, landscaping and other open spaces, and architectural drawings and sketches demonstrating the design and character of the proposed uses and the physical relationship of the uses, and such other pertinent information as may be required to determine that the proposed arrangements and/or uses make it desirable to apply regulations and requirements differing from those ordinarily applicable under this chapter.
B. 
Issuance of permits.
(1) 
It shall be the duty of the CEO, or his duly authorized assistant, to issue a building permit, provided that compliance with all requirements of this chapter are met, and that review and action by any other board or agency, if any, as called for in this chapter have been complied with and all necessary approvals secured thereof.
(2) 
All building permits shall be issued in duplicate, and one copy shall be kept conspicuously on the affected premises whenever construction work is being performed thereon. No owner, contractor, workman or other person shall perform any building operation of any kind unless a building permit covering such operation has been previously issued and is being displayed as required by this chapter, nor shall they perform building operations of any kind after notification of the revocation of said building permit.
C. 
Denial of permits. When an application for a proposed development does not meet the requirements of this chapter the CEO or his duly authorized assistant shall refuse to issue a building permit stating the reasons for said denial which shall be a part of the public record. The applicant may appeal to the Zoning Board of Appeals for a reversal of such decision.
D. 
Revocation of permits. If it shall appear at any time that the application or accompanying plot is in any material respect false or misleading, or that work is being done upon the premises differing materially from that called for in the application filed with the CEO under existing laws or ordinances, the CEO may forthwith revoke the building permit, whereupon it shall be the duty of the person holding the permit to surrender same and all copies thereof to the CEO.

§ 190-41.3 Occupancy permits.

A. 
For new uses.
(1) 
It shall be unlawful to use or permit the use of any building or premises or part thereof, hereafter created, erected, changed, converted, or enlarged, wholly or partly in its use or structure, unless a certificate of occupancy shall have been issued by the CEO.
(2) 
Said permit shall be issued in duplicate within 10 days after notification by the owner or duly authorized agent that all requirements have been met and upon sworn application by the owner or duly authorized agent of same and after actual inspection of the premises by the CEO or the duly authorized assistant and upon finding that the facts are as represented.
(3) 
The occupancy permit will certify that the premises comply with the provisions of this chapter and with the provisions of the Building Code and may be used for the purposes set forth in the permit. No change of use shall be made in any building, structure or premises now or hereafter erected or altered that is not consistent with the requirements of this chapter.
(4) 
Any person desiring to change the use of said premises shall apply to the CEO for an occupancy permit setting forth under oath such facts as the CEO may require.
(5) 
A copy of the occupancy permit shall be kept at all times upon the premises affected and shall be displayed upon request by any building inspector, City fireman, or police officer.
(6) 
A record shall be kept of all occupancy permits issued, and original applications shall be kept on file in the same manner as prescribed for building permits.
(7) 
No owner, tenant or other person shall occupy or use any building or structure thereafter erected or altered the use of which shall be changed after the passage of this chapter, without first procuring an occupancy permit, provided that an occupancy permit, once granted, shall continue in effect so long as there is no change of use, regardless of change in the personnel of tenants or occupants.
(8) 
Under such rules and regulations as may be established by the CEO, a temporary certificate of occupancy may be issued for a part of the building.
B. 
For existing and nonconforming uses.
(1) 
Upon written request from the owner, the CEO shall issue a certificate of occupancy for any existing use legally existing at the time of the effective date of this chapter and a certificate of nonconformance for any uses not legally existing at the time of the effective date of this chapter.
(2) 
The CEO shall certify, after inspection, the extent and kind of use made of the building or premises at the time of inspection and shall charge a fee in accordance with the City of Lockport Fee Schedule.

§ 190-42.1 Purpose and intent.

The purpose of this article is to define the site plan review procedures for development actions proposed throughout the City to preserve and enhance the physical form of the City, achieve compatibility with adjacent development, mitigate potentially negative impacts on traffic, parking, drainage and similar environmental concerns, improve the overall visual and aesthetic quality of the City, and increase the capability of the zoning code to adapt to a variety of unique circumstances, taking into consideration the planning goals and aims provided in the City's Comprehensive Plan.

§ 190-42.2 Optional sketch plan review.

A. 
Sketch plan review encouraged. Applicants are encouraged to submit a preliminary sketch plan to the Planning Board prior to the preparation of a formal site plan application. The purpose of this review is to:
(1) 
Provide guidance on the review and approval process and generally determine the information necessary for formal site plan review.
(2) 
Advise the applicant as to potential problems and concerns with the proposal.
(3) 
Discuss plans for the applicant's entire holdings, including phasing, and define the project and phases to be submitted for site plan review.
B. 
Sketch plan review procedure.
(1) 
Review of sketch plans may occur at any regularly scheduled Planning Board meeting.
(2) 
In no way shall any comments or feedback provided by the City during sketch plan review be construed as an indication of approval by the review body or be legally binding in any way.
C. 
Sketch plan materials. The applicant must provide the following information, as applicable, at least 10 business days prior to the scheduled Planning Board meeting.
(1) 
A map showing the applicant's entire holdings, the parcel under consideration and a general description of all properties, subdivisions, streets, rights-of-way, easements and other pertinent features within 100 feet of the boundaries of the parcel, including property uses.
(2) 
Photographs of the site and any existing buildings thereon.
(3) 
All locations and dimensions of existing and proposed principal and accessory structures, roadways, points of ingress and egress, parking areas, signs, and other development features on the property.
(4) 
A description and approximate location of natural and environmentally sensitive features, including trees, vegetation, and wetlands.
(5) 
Proposed water supply and sewage and waste disposal facilities.
D. 
Considerations for review. Factors to be considered in the sketch plan may include, but are not limited to:
(1) 
The categories of uses to be permitted.
(2) 
The overall maximum density of residential uses and intensity of nonresidential uses.
(3) 
The general location of vehicular and pedestrian circulation systems.
(4) 
The general location and extent of public and private open space.
(5) 
The general location and extent of utility systems.
(6) 
The general location of residential and nonresidential structures.
E. 
Formal application. It is acknowledged that some elements of a sketch plan may change during the formal site plan review process when taking into consideration information obtained through the more detailed inventories and/or assessments required of site plan applications.

§ 190-42.3 Review required.

When applicable, no building permit, special use permit, or certificate of occupancy shall be issued until all requirements of this chapter have been satisfied and the site plan has been approved by the reviewing body.
Action
Exempt
Minor
Major
CONSTRUCTION/EXPANSION/ALTERATION
Primary Use or Structure
Single- or two-family dwelling
Multifamily dwelling or nonresidential use, up to 1,000 sf
Multifamily dwelling or nonresidential use, over 1,000 sf
Accessory Use or Structure1, 2
Single- or Two-Family Use, Up to 250 sf
Single- or Two-Family Use, Over 250 sf
Multifamily dwelling or nonresidential use
Accessory Dwelling Unit
Landscaping, Exterior Lighting, Mechanical Equipment, or Stormwater Infrastructure
Single- or Two-Family Dwelling
Multifamily Dwelling or Nonresidential Use
Off-Street Parking/Loading Area
10 Spaces or Less
Over 10 Spaces
Driveways
Residential
Joint or Shared (Residential or Nonresidential)
Within Existing Curbcut
Within New or Altered Curbcut
Other Uses or Structures
Solar Energy System (Accessory Use or Structure)
Parks or Playgrounds (Public Use)
Pools or Playgrounds (Residential Use)
Telecommunications Equipment
OTHER ACTIONS
Ordinary Repair, Maintenance, or Replacement In-Kind
Interior Alteration
Change of Use
Amendment to Approved Site Plan
Planned Unit Development (Article 45)
Demolition of Structures in MU-D District (over 750 sf)
Action involving modification of utility infrastructure
NOTES:
(1)
Accessory use or structure includes decks, patios, porches, garages, sheds, etc. For full list, see § 190-24.4.
(2)
Fences and walls shall be exempt from site plan review, provided such fence or wall conforms to the requirements of § 190-24.13.

§ 190-42.4 Review procedures.

A. 
Authorized review body. All site plan applications shall be reviewed and decided upon by the Planning Board.
B. 
Coordinated reviews. The review of site plan applications may be coordinated with other development applications in accordance with § 190-40.5.
C. 
Public hearings. The Planning Board may hold a public hearing on any site plan application deemed necessary, in the sole discretion of the Planning Board.
D. 
Referrals. All referrals shall be made in accordance with § 190-40.6.
E. 
Action on approval of site plan. An approval endorsement shall be affixed by the Chairman of the Planning Board on a copy of the approved site plan. A copy of the endorsed site plan shall be filed with the CEO.

§ 190-42.5 Site plan application requirements.

A. 
Minor site plan application material. A minor site plan application shall include the following materials, as deemed applicable by the reviewing body. The reviewing body may require some or all application materials be prepared by competent, duly licensed professionals.
(1) 
Application form, including the name, address, and signature of the applicant, property owner, and developer.
(2) 
Description or narrative of all proposed uses and structures.
(3) 
A site plan showing the following, as applicable:
(a) 
The location of all properties, their ownership, uses thereon, subdivisions, streets, easements, and adjacent buildings within 250 feet of the property in question.
(b) 
The location and use of all existing and proposed structures on the property in question, including all building and lot dimensions.
(c) 
The location of environmental features, including, but not limited to, open spaces, woodlands, watercourses, steep slopes, wetlands, floodplains, and watersheds.
(d) 
The location and dimensions of existing and proposed landscaping, screening, walls, and fences, including information regarding the type of materials.
(e) 
The location and dimensions of existing and proposed public and private streets, off-street parking areas, access drives, driveways, sidewalks, ramps, curbs, and paths.
(f) 
A waste and trash management plan including the type, size, location, appearance, and operation of permanent trash receptacles.
(g) 
The type, size, location, appearance, and operation of all outdoor mechanical equipment.
(h) 
The location, height, intensity, bulb type, and light color of all exterior lighting fixtures.
(i) 
The location, height, size, material, and design of all existing and proposed signs.
(4) 
Exterior building elevations (existing and proposed) for all sides showing the location and size of all windows, doors, trim, architectural details and indicating the type of all materials to be used.
(5) 
Identification of any state or county permits required for the project and record of application for and approval status of such permits.
(6) 
All New York State SEQR documentation as required by law.
B. 
Major site plan application materials. An application for major site plan review shall include the following materials, as applicable. Such materials shall be prepared by competent, duly licensed professionals duly, unless otherwise permitted by the reviewing body.
(1) 
All required minor site plan application materials.
(2) 
A site plan showing the following:
(a) 
The location of all properties, their ownership, uses thereon, subdivisions, streets, easements, and adjacent buildings within 500 feet of the property in question.
(b) 
The location of all existing and proposed topography as revealed by contours or key elevations, including final site grading.
(c) 
The location all new or modified downspouts or stormwater systems, including the configuration of a system for stormwater drainage or green infrastructure.
(d) 
The location of existing and proposed utility systems including sewage or septic, water supply, telephone, cable, electric, internet, and fiber.
(3) 
Plans for disposal of construction and demolition waste, either on-site or at an approved disposal facility.
(4) 
Plans to prevent the pollution of surface or ground water, erosion of soil both during and after construction, excessive runoff, excessive raising or lowering of the water table, and flooding of other properties, as applicable.
(5) 
A schedule for completion of each construction phase, where applicable.
(6) 
The reviewing body may require an applicant submit additional materials (e.g., a certified land survey, soil logs, test well, percolation test results, stormwater runoff calculations, natural resource inventory, tree survey, and a traffic study), if the reviewing body determines, in its sole discretion, that review of said materials is necessary to conduct a thorough and complete review.

§ 190-42.6 Review criteria.

The Planning Board shall review the site plan and supporting data taking into consideration the following:
A. 
Conformance with the City's Comprehensive Plan and other adopted plans and studies, where applicable, and conformance with the requirements of this zoning code.
B. 
Compatibility of proposed uses to adjacent uses, considering building and site orientation, design, and transitional and/or buffering treatments.
C. 
Quality of building design and materials, including facades, signs, and site layouts, and compatibility with the desired character of the district and/or neighborhood.
D. 
Adequacy of orientation of structures and the site design for energy efficiency, the extent to which the proposed plan conserves energy and energy resources in the community, and the protection of adequate sunlight for a solar energy system.
E. 
Adequacy and arrangement of vehicular traffic and circulation, including intersections, road widths, traffic controls, traffic-calming measures, and accessibility to fire and emergency vehicles.
F. 
Adequacy and arrangement of pedestrian and bicyclist access and circulation, including separation from vehicular traffic and connections provided internally and externally to the site.
G. 
Adequacy of off-street parking, loading, and vehicular access management provisions.
H. 
Adequacy of landscaping and screening provisions.
I. 
Adequacy of outdoor lighting while preventing light trespass onto adjacent properties.
J. 
Preservation and protection of natural site features and areas, such as wildlife habitat, wetland, and woodland areas. Adequacy of open space areas for passive and/or active recreation.
K. 
Adequacy of stormwater, drainage, and erosion management plans.
L. 
Adequacy of flood damage prevention measures.
M. 
Adequacy of municipal facilities to serve the proposal including, but not limited to, streets, electric service, water supply and wastewater treatment systems, storm water control systems, and fire protection.
N. 
Adequacy of proposed waste and trash management plan.
O. 
Adequacy of snow storage and/or proposed snow removal plan.
P. 
Encouragement of the most appropriate use of land and utilization of the site.
Q. 
Potential for adverse effects to the functioning, economic stability, prosperity, and health, safety, or general welfare of nearby property owners and the community.

§ 190-42.7 Amendments.

A. 
No proposed change of and/or addition to an approved site plan shall be executed without approval thereof by an approved site plan containing and depicting such amendment.
B. 
Any proposed change of and/or addition to an approved site plan shall require an application addressing such amendment and decision on that application by the Planning Board pursuant to this article.

§ 190-42.8 Demolition in the MU-D District.

A. 
Permit required. A person, firm, or corporation shall not demolish an existing building or structure having a gross floor or base area of 750 square feet or more within the Mixed Use - Downtown (MU-D) District without first obtaining a demolition permit from the CEO or City designee pursuant to this zoning code.
B. 
Application. An application for a demolition permit shall be on forms supplied by the CEO, shall include an agreement to comply with this zoning code and all other laws, rules, and regulations that may be applicable, and shall be signed by the owner.
C. 
Review. No demolition permit may be issued for within the City without first obtaining site plan approval for a new development proposal as required by this article.
D. 
Validity. A demolition permit shall be valid for a period of 180 days from the date of issue. Failure to undertake demolition activity within this time shall require the issuance of a new demolition permit.
E. 
Unsafe structures. In the event that a structure or series of structures is found to be structurally unsound and/or unsafe by the CEO, this section shall not preclude any immediate demolition or repair action determined to be necessary under such finding.
F. 
Extension. The reviewing body may grant an extension upon written request by the applicant. The applicant shall include in such request the desired time period for the extension and the reasoning for requesting the extension. A fee may be required to process extension requests. The time period of such extension shall be determined by the reviewing body.

§ 190-43.1 Purpose and intent.

A. 
Purpose. The purpose of this article is to regulate special uses, which by nature of their operation, may have a higher potential for incompatibility with adjacent uses or otherwise unique characteristics which require a case-by-case review of their location, design, configuration, and impacts on the surrounding area.
B. 
Intent. The standards of this article are intended to provide for the individual review and approval of such uses to ensure compatibility of the use in its proposed location and mitigate any potential adverse impacts the use may have on the district or neighborhood.

§ 190-43.2 Applicability.

A. 
Permit required. A special use permit shall be obtained for all uses as noted in the district tables of Part 2 of this chapter prior to their establishment or operation.
B. 
Additional use regulations. In addition to the general district and development requirements of this chapter, specially permitted uses shall also conform to the requirements of Article 24, where applicable.

§ 190-43.3 Review procedure.

A. 
Authorized review body. Special use permits shall be reviewed and decided upon by the Planning Board.
B. 
Application requirements. Special use permit applications shall include all materials as required by § 190-43.4.
C. 
Review criteria. In conducting their review, the Planning Board shall consider the special use permit review criteria provided in § 190-43.5, as applicable.
D. 
Public hearings. The Planning Board shall hold a public hearing for all special use permit applications prior to issuance of decision.
E. 
Referrals. All internal, professional, and required referrals shall be made in accordance with § 190-40.6.
F. 
Coordinated reviews. The review of special use permit applications may be coordinated with other development applications in accordance with § 190-40.5.

§ 190-43.4 Application requirements.

A special use permit application shall include the following, as applicable:
A. 
A site plan denoting the location of the subject property and all structures thereon, as well as all property, uses, and structures within 300 feet of the proposed use.
B. 
A description of the proposed use and nature of its operation, including the following, as applicable:
(1) 
A business plan, vision, or model, and/or summary of products, goods, and services to be sold or provided;
(2) 
The proposed hours of operation;
(3) 
The number of employees at maximum shift;
(4) 
The maximum seat capacity;
(5) 
The timing and manner of any and all anticipated deliveries;
(6) 
A recycling and waste management plan; and
(7) 
The nature and type of all mechanical equipment provided and/or required.
C. 
An interior floor plan, including, but not limited to, the arrangement of seats, kitchen and/or bar size and location, storage areas, bathroom facilities, and location of machines or other mechanical equipment.
D. 
A narrative describing how the proposed use will satisfy the review criteria of § 190-43.5.
E. 
All SEQR Documentation as required by New York State Law.
F. 
Where site plan review is also required, the application materials of Article 42 shall also apply.

§ 190-43.5 Review criteria.

A. 
General criteria. In reaching a decision, the Planning Board shall consider and shall determine, either from its own knowledge and investigation or from testimony or other information submitted to it, findings on whether the proposed use:
(1) 
Will be generally consistent with the goals of the City Comprehensive Plan, Local Waterfront Revitalization Program, and other adopted plans and studies;
(2) 
Will meet all relevant goals, standards, guidelines, and requirements set forth in this zoning code, including any applicable additional use regulations of Article 24;
(3) 
Will be an economically viable use of the property and/or will not cause there to be any significant decrease in the future economic viability of the property;
(4) 
Will be compatible with existing uses adjacent to and near the property;
(5) 
Will provide adequate measures (such as landscaping and screening) to mitigate potential adverse impacts on surrounding property and preserve or enhance the traditional character of the City;
(6) 
Will not have an undue burden or effect on the orderly development and character of the neighborhood or upon the development and conduct of other lawful uses in the vicinity;
(7) 
Will not be a nuisance to adjacent residents and property in terms of the production of obnoxious or objectionable noise, dust, glare, odor, refuse, fumes, vibrations, traffic, crowds, parking of automobiles, unsightliness, contamination or other similar conditions;
(8) 
Will not cause undue harm to or destroy existing sensitive natural features on the site or in the surrounding area or cause adverse environmental impacts such as significant erosion and/or sedimentation, slope destruction, flooding or ponding of water, or degradation of water quality;
(9) 
Will not destroy or adversely impact significant historic and/or cultural resource sites; and
(10) 
Will not otherwise be detrimental to the convenience and general health, safety, or welfare of the public.
B. 
Standard for review. Failure to meet one or more of the above criteria may result in denial of an application.
C. 
Waiving application requirements. At their sole discretion, the reviewing body is authorized to waive or modify, in whole or in part, required application material in accordance with § 190-40.4F.

§ 190-43.6 Special use permit time limitations.

A. 
Duration. A special use permit shall be valid for one calendar year, starting on the approval date by the Planning Board.
B. 
Renewal of permit.
(1) 
Special uses shall be required to reapply for special use permit approval at least 30 days prior to the initial permit's expiration date.
(2) 
Renewal shall be processed through the payment of a fee established by a fee schedule, set by resolution of the Common Council per § 190-40.9A.
(3) 
Should the applicant seek modifications to the initially granted special use permit, renewal applications shall be submitted, processed, reviewed, and decided upon in accordance with the provisions of this article.
(4) 
In granting a special use permit renewal, the Planning Board may remove or modify the conditions of the initial permit, as deemed necessary or appropriate.
C. 
Denial. The Planning Board may deny a renewal of a special use permit when any of the following apply:
(1) 
The petitioner has failed to comply with one or more of the conditions of the prior approval;
(2) 
Substantial new issues regarding the permit conditions during the operation of the use have arisen;
(3) 
The general requirements of this chapter have not been met; or
(4) 
There are changes in the area or neighborhood that would be incompatible with the special use.

§ 190-43.7 Transfer of permits.

Special use permit approval shall be issued to the applicant. Where a change of owner, operator, or occupant occurs, the issuance of a new special use permit shall be required.

§ 190-43.8 Reapplication for denied special use permits.

A reapplication for a special use permit request which has been previously denied shall not be considered unless substantial revisions have been completed from the original application previously denied, as determined by the City Planning Board.

§ 190-45.1 Purpose.

A. 
Purpose. The preservation of the distinctive environmental, and aesthetic character of the City of Lockport is directly related to the economic vitality of the City business districts, stability of property values, appeal of the City as a destination, and the quality of life for Lockport residents. Occasionally on larger projects, conventional use, space, dimensional, and bulk requirements contained in the underlying zoning may not be the best standards to ensure new development achieves the goals states above. It is the purpose of this article to provide flexible performance standards for zoning districts identified as having the potential for redevelopment and new development, and which are identified in this article. The intent of these standards is to:
(1) 
Preserve historic resources and protect environmentally sensitive areas and natural features, including the Erie Canal;
(2) 
Preserve aesthetic community features and important viewsheds;
(3) 
Ensure new construction and development is compatible in design, scale, and use with the City and surrounding area.
(4) 
Foster the creative integration of land uses, and to encourage imaginative design and combinations of development.
(5) 
Foster the efficient use of land and the efficient use of public utilities and streets.
B. 
Intent. The application of the PUD District review process is intended to achieve more creative land use and a higher quality of planning and a higher quality of site planning and design than can be accomplished through conventional zoning regulations.

§ 190-45.2 Applicability.

A. 
PUD approval required. Whenever any planned unit development is proposed, before any permits for the erection of permanent buildings in such planned unit development shall be granted and before any subdivision plat or any part thereof may be filed in the office of the Niagara County Clerk, the developer or his authorized agent shall apply for and secure approval of such planned unit development in accordance with the procedures set forth in this chapter. These procedures shall supersede any inconsistent procedures or regulations set forth elsewhere in the City codes or comprehensive plans.
B. 
Eligibility. To be eligible for the establishment of a PUD District under this article, applicants must demonstrate the proposed project meets or exceeds two or more of the following criteria:
(1) 
The property under consideration is at least one acre in contiguous land area.
(2) 
The project proposes an overall density and/or intensity of use which would not be permitted or required by the underlying zoning while also preserving more open land or providing more amenities to the community.
(3) 
The project proposes a use that is compatible with the surrounding context but is otherwise not permitted by the underlying zoning. In determining compatibility, the reviewing board will consider traffic generation, noise, truck traffic, scale, density, intensity of use, impact to historic resources, viewsheds, aesthetics, and impacts on existing infrastructure.
C. 
Relief from conventional zoning.
(1) 
For projects deemed eligible, the reviewing board may waive City zoning regulations that would ordinarily apply to a property where the applicant demonstrates relief from said regulations is necessary to meet the purposes described herein.
(2) 
It is not the intent of this article to arbitrarily dispense with underlying zoning regulations, but rather to grant the minimum relief necessary to achieve the objectives of this article.

§ 190-45.3 Review procedures.

A. 
Preapplication conference. A preapplication conference per § 190-40.2 is strongly encouraged prior to submitting a PUD application.
B. 
Optional sketch plan review. Applicants are encouraged to utilize the optional sketch plan review process, per § 190-42.2, prior to the preparation of a formal PUD application.
C. 
Application processing. PUD applications shall be submitted, processed, and reviewed in accordance with Article 40 of this chapter.
D. 
Planning Board review and recommendation. The Planning Board shall conduct a review of the PUD application, site plan, and related documents and provide a recommendation of decision to the Common Council.
E. 
Common Council review and decision. Upon receipt of a recommendation from the Planning Board, the Common Council shall review and decide upon such application as an amendment, in accordance with Article 46. If the Common Council approves the PUD application, the zoning map and text shall be amended and filed accordingly.
F. 
Public hearings. A public hearing shall be held by the Common Council for all PUD applications.
G. 
Referrals. All referrals shall be made in accordance with § 190-40.6.

§ 190-45.4 Application requirements.

A. 
Site plan. All PUD applications shall include the required site plan review application materials as noted in Article 42.
B. 
PUD District. In addition to the required site plan application materials, all PUD applications shall include:
(1) 
The zoning classification and present use of the subject property.
(2) 
A written statement generally describing the proposed PUD, the categories of uses to be permitted; its relationship to the Comprehensive Plan; and how the proposed PUD is to be designed, arranged and operated. Supporting documentation evidencing the applicant's particular mix of land uses will meet existing community demands, including but not limited to specific studies or reports identifying demand for land uses in the City, shall be provided in support of the written statement.
(3) 
A tabulation of the following information:
(a) 
The total number of dwelling units proposed, by type of structure and number of bedrooms.
(b) 
The total square feet of building floor area proposed for commercial uses and for industrial uses, if any, by general type of use.
(c) 
The total land area, expressed in acres and as a percent of the total development area, proposed to be devoted to residential uses, by type of structure; commercial uses; industrial uses; public and private open space; streets; and off-street parking and loading areas.
(d) 
The total number of off-street parking and loading spaces for each proposed type of land use.
(4) 
Evidence that the applicant has sufficient control over the subject property to effectuate the proposed PUD, including a statement of all legal, beneficial, tenancy and contractual interests held in or affecting the subject property and including an up-to-date certified abstract of title or commitment for title insurance.
(5) 
A statement of the applicant's intent with respect to the ownership, sale and leasing of the various completed units, structures, spaces and areas within the proposed development.
(6) 
Evidence of the financing plan the applicant proposes to use to complete the proposed PUD. Evidence of the applicant's prior completion of projects of similar scope may be offered in satisfaction of this requirement.
(7) 
All interior streets, roads, easements and their planned public or private ownership, as well as all points of access and egress from existing public rights-of-way.
(8) 
The overall water and sanitary sewer system with proposed points of attachment to existing systems, and the proposed stormwater drainage system and its relation to existing systems.
(9) 
Description of the manner in which any areas that are not to become publicly owned are to be maintained, including open space, streets, lighting and others, according to the proposals.
(10) 
If the development is to be phased, a description and graphic representation of the phasing of the entire proposal in terms of length of time, type and number of units or activities completed per phase.
(11) 
A description of any covenants, grants of easements or other restrictions proposed to be imposed upon the use of the land, buildings or structures, including proposed easements for public utilities.
(12) 
If any stage or unit is proposed to contain a proportion of open space or other public or private recreation or service facilities less than its proportion of dwelling units, a statement of what bond, credit, escrow or other assurance is proposed to ensure the development or provision of such open space or other facility.
C. 
Final site plan. The final submission of site plan material approved by the Planning Board and forwarded to the Common Council for PUD approval shall also contain:
(1) 
The legal description of the subject property.
(2) 
The final site plan at a scale of one inch equals 50 feet. Where more than one sheet is required to show the entire development, a key map shall be provided.
(3) 
The lines of existing and proposed streets and sidewalks immediately adjoining and within the PUD.
(4) 
The names of existing and proposed streets.
(5) 
Typical cross sections of proposed streets and sidewalks.
(6) 
Profiles of proposed streets at suitable vertical scale showing finished grades in relation to existing ground elevation.
(7) 
Layouts of proposed lots, including lot numbers and proposed numbering system for buildings.
(8) 
The location and size of any existing and proposed sewers (stormwater and/or sanitary), water mains, and pipes on the property or into which any connection is proposed.
(9) 
Provisions for water supply and sewage disposal and evidence that such provisions have received approval of the Department of Health.
(10) 
Locations of survey monuments.
(11) 
A complete grading and drainage plan showing all existing and proposed contours and elevations and the complete storm drainage plan.
(12) 
A planting plan indicating locations, varieties, and minimum sizes of trees to be planted and of existing trees to be preserved. Existing wooded areas need not be itemized but should be generally described.
(13) 
Brief specifications, or reference to City standards, for any public facilities to be constructed or installed within the PUD.

§ 190-45.5 Review criteria.

A. 
Final plan. The Planning Board, as recommending body, and the Common Council holding final authority, may approve a Planned Unit Development District upon a finding that the PUD meets the following standards:
(1) 
The PUD is consistent with the City of Lockport Comprehensive Plan.
(2) 
The PUD is compatible with existing development in the surrounding area and does not unduly burden existing City infrastructure or services.
(3) 
The developer has sufficient financing and capabilities to complete the project as presented.
(4) 
The PUD provides all necessary water and sewer facilities, storm drainage, highway access, paved surface streets, parking and loading facilities, and lighting and the developer has made reasonable provisions for utility service connections with adjoining properties and other ownerships.
(5) 
All electric, telephone, cable television and similar equipment will be installed in accordance with New York State Public Service Commission standards.
(6) 
The right-of-way and pavement width for internal roads serving all development are adequate and sufficient in size, location and design to accommodate the maximum traffic, parking and loading needs of the development; the pavement meets all applicable City standards.
(7) 
There is adequate access for firefighting equipment, police, and other emergency vehicles.
(8) 
The gross residential density of the development will not result in a substantial undesirable alteration to the character of the neighborhood and to properties adjacent to the development.
(9) 
The development complies with the development standards as set forth in Part 3 of this chapter, as applicable. The reviewing body may waive any development standards set forth therein upon a demonstration by the applicant that waiver of any development standards are justified in accordance with the criteria set forth in § 190-31.2E of this chapter.
B. 
Subdivision. The associated subdivision plat of a PUD application shall be considered as provided by Chapter 162 of the City of Lockport Code.
C. 
Zoning amendment. All PUD applications shall also be subject to the review criteria of § 190-46.1 of this chapter.

§ 190-45.6 Approval not guaranteed.

The fact that an application complies with all of the specific requirements set forth herein shall not be deemed to indicate the proposed development would result in a more efficient and desirable development than could be accomplished by the use of conventional zoning categories or than would result in compatibility with the surrounding development; nor shall such compliance, by itself, be sufficient to require the approval of the site plan or the granting of the zoning amendment to create a PUD District.

§ 190-45.7 Staging.

A. 
If the applicant wishes to stage the PUD development, then they may submit only those stages they wish to develop for site plan approval in accordance with the presented staging plan.
B. 
Any plan which requires more than 24 months to be completed shall be required to be staged and a staging plan must be developed.
C. 
It is the intent of this article that individual stages of the PUD will have an integrity of use in their own right so that if for any reason the entire PUD would not be completed, those portions of the PUD already constructed will be an asset to the community by themselves. Staging plans must take account of this objective, and developers proposing individual stages that deviate significantly from the overall character of the PUD should present convincing evidence that such a stage is in keeping with this section.
D. 
If the PUD is proposed for construction in stages or units during a period extending beyond a single construction season, a schedule for the development of such stages or units shall be submitted, stating the approximate beginning and completion date for each such stage or unit, the proportion of the total public and private open space and the proportion of each type of proposed land use to be provided or constructed during each such stage; and the overall chronology of development to be followed from stage to stage.

§ 190-45.8 Amendments and modifications.

Modification of the PUD and/or final plan, once approved by the Common Council, requires the same procedure as an original approval.

§ 190-46.1 Amendments and rezonings.

A. 
Authority to file.
(1) 
Pursuant to New York State General City Law and the City of Lockport Code and all applicable provisions of this chapter, this chapter may be amended, supplemented, and repealed.
(2) 
Amendments to the text or map of this zoning code may be initiated by the City of Lockport Common Council or as otherwise provided by New York State Law.
B. 
Authorized review bodies.
(1) 
The Planning Board may serve in an advisory role to the review of proposed amendments and issue a recommendation of decision to the Common Council.
(2) 
The Common Council shall review and issue the final decision on all proposed amendments.
C. 
Public hearing. A public hearing shall be held by Common Council for all proposed amendments.
D. 
Referrals. All referrals shall be made in accordance with § 190-40.6.
E. 
Review procedure.
(1) 
The Common Council may, from time to time, by local law or ordinance, and after holding a public hearing, alter, amend, or repeal this zoning law in accordance with the provisions set forth in General City Law Section 83.
(2) 
If the Common Council approves the amendment, supplement, change or modification to the zoning code or zoning map, as applicable, shall be amended after publication and filing with the City Clerk and Secretary of State as required by New York State Law.
F. 
Review criteria. In reviewing and making decisions on zoning amendments, the reviewing body must consider the following criteria, as applicable:
(1) 
Whether the proposed amendment corrects an error or inconsistency in the zoning code or meets the challenge of a changing condition;
(2) 
Whether the proposed amendment is in substantial conformance with the adopted plans and policies of the municipality;
(3) 
Whether the proposed amendment is in the best interests of the municipality as a whole;
(4) 
Whether public facilities (infrastructure) and services will be adequate to serve development allowed by any requested rezoning;
(5) 
Whether any re-zoning will substantially harm the public health, safety or general welfare or the value of nearby properties;
(6) 
Whether any re-zoning is compatible with the zoning and use of adjacent property;
(7) 
Whether the property in question is suitable for the uses and development to which it has been restricted under the existing zoning regulations; and
(8) 
Whether the gain, if any, to the public health, safety and general welfare due to denial of the application outweighs that of the hardship imposed upon the landowner, if any, as a result of denial of the application.

§ 190-46.2 Interpretations.

A. 
Upon appeal from a decision by the CEO or the Planning Board, the Zoning Board of Appeals shall decide any question involving interpretation of any provisions of this chapter. Such appeal shall be initiated within 30 calendar days of the adverse decision. Such appeal may be taken by any person aggrieved or by an officer, department, or board of the City.
B. 
Appeal applications shall be submitted, processed, and reviewed in accordance with Article 40 of this chapter.
C. 
The officer from whom the appeal is taken shall, within 30 days of the filing of the appeal, transmit all papers constituting the record upon which the appeal is taken to the Zoning Board of Appeals.
D. 
An appeal stays all proceedings in furtherance of the action appealed from, unless the officer from whom the appeal is taken certifies to the Zoning Board of Appeals after the notice of appeal shall have been filed with him that, by reason of facts stated in the certificate, a stay would, in his opinion, cause imminent peril to life or property, in which case proceedings shall not be stayed otherwise than by a restraining order which may be granted by the Zoning Board of Appeals or by a court of record, on application, on notice to the officer from whom the appeal is taken and on due cause shown.
E. 
If the Zoning Board of Appeals determines that a public hearing is necessary, the Board of Appeals shall fix a time for the hearing of the appeal and give due notice thereof to the parties, and decide the same within a reasonable length of time thereafter. At the time of the hearing, any party may appear in person, by agent, or by attorney.
F. 
In exercising the appeal power, the ZBA has all the powers of the City official or agent from whom the appeal is taken.
G. 
The ZBA may reverse the appeal or affirm the appeal, in whole or in part, or modify the decision being appealed.
H. 
In acting on the appeal the ZBA must grant to the decision or action a presumption of correctness, placing the burden of persuasion of error on the appellant.

§ 190-46.3 Variance procedure.

A. 
Applicability. The Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) shall have the power, on appeal from the decision or determination of any administrative official charged with enforcement of this chapter, to reverse or affirm, wholly or partly, or modify an order, requirement, decision, interpretation, or determination by the granting of either use variances or area variances as authorized by New York State General City Law. The variance procedures may not be used to:
(1) 
Waive, modify or otherwise vary any of the review and approval procedures of this article; or
(2) 
Waive, vary, modify or otherwise override a condition of approval or requirement imposed by another authorized review board or commission.
B. 
Transferability. Zoning variance approval runs with the land and is not affected by changes of tenancy, ownership, or management.
C. 
Authorized review body. Appeals shall be reviewed by the Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA).
D. 
Burden of proof. The applicant seeking the variance shall have the burden of presenting sufficient evidence to allow the ZBA to reach a conclusion as set forth below as well as the burden of persuasion on those items.
E. 
Application processing.
(1) 
Variance applications shall be submitted, processed, and reviewed in accordance with Article 40 of this chapter.
(2) 
Every variance application shall refer to the specific provision of this chapter involved and shall exactly set forth the interpretation that is claimed.
F. 
Public hearing required. A public hearing shall be held by the ZBA prior to issuing a decision.
G. 
Referrals. All referrals shall be made in accordance with § 190-40.6.

§ 190-46.4 Use variances.

A. 
Authorization. A use variance authorizes the use of land for a purpose that is otherwise not allowed or prohibited by this chapter. A finding of unnecessary hardship is required to properly grant a use variance.
B. 
Review criteria. The ZBA shall not grant a use variance without the applicant having shown that applicable zoning regulations and restrictions have caused unnecessary hardship. In order to prove such unnecessary hardship, the applicant shall demonstrate to the ZBA that for each and every permitted use under the zoning regulations for the particular district where the property is located the following conditions exist:
(1) 
The applicant cannot realize a reasonable return, provided that lack of return is substantial as demonstrated by competent financial evidence; and
(2) 
The alleged hardship relating to the property in question is unique, and does not apply to a substantial portion of the district or neighborhood; and
(3) 
The requested use variance, if granted, will not alter the essential character of the neighborhood; and
(4) 
That the alleged hardship has not been self-created.
C. 
Minimum variance allowable. The ZBA, in the granting of use variances, shall grant the minimum variance that it shall deem necessary and adequate to address the unnecessary hardship proved by the applicant, and at the same time preserve and protect the character of the neighborhood and the health, safety and welfare of the community.

§ 190-46.5 Area variances.

A. 
Authorization. An area variance authorizes the use of land that is not allowed by the dimensional or physical requirements set forth in this chapter. An area variance is one that does not involve a use that is otherwise prohibited by this chapter. A finding of practical difficulty is required to properly grant an area variance.
B. 
Review criteria. In making its determination, the ZBA shall take into consideration the benefit to the applicant if the variance is granted, as weighed against the detriment to the health, safety and welfare of the neighborhood or community by such grant. In making such determination the Board shall also consider the following criteria:
(1) 
Whether an undesirable change will be produced in the character of the neighborhood or a detriment to nearby properties will be created by the granting of the area variance;
(2) 
Whether the benefit sought by the applicant can be achieved by some method, feasible for the applicant to pursue, other than an area variance;
(3) 
Whether the requested area variance is substantial in relation to the requirement;
(4) 
Whether the proposed variance will have an adverse effect or impact on the physical or environmental conditions in the neighborhood or district; and
(5) 
Whether the alleged difficulty was self-created; which consideration shall be relevant to the decision of the board of appeals but shall not necessarily preclude the granting of the area variance.
C. 
Minimum variance allowable. The ZBA, in the granting of area variances, shall grant the minimum variance that it shall deem necessary and adequate and at the same time preserve and protect the character of the neighborhood and the health, safety and welfare of the community.