Zoneomics Logo
search icon

New Buffalo City Zoning Code

ARTICLE 8

Administration and Enforcement

Section Z8-01 General application requirements.

A. 
Authorization.
1. 
An application for any zoning procedure, except for zoning text or map amendments, may be filed only by the owner or lessee of the property, or by an agent or contract purchaser specifically authorized by the owner to file such application.
2. 
An application for a zoning text or map amendment may be filed by an owner, lessee, agent, or contract purchaser of property located in the City or by the City Council, Planning Commission, or the Zoning Administrator.
B. 
Filing.
1. 
An application for any zoning procedure shall be filed with the Zoning Administrator.
2. 
The application shall be on forms provided by the City and shall be filed in such number as the instructions provide.
3. 
All plans shall be at a scale sufficient to permit a clear and precise understanding of the proposal.
4. 
The application shall include all information, plans, and data, specified in the application requirements manual.
C. 
Completeness.
1. 
The Zoning Administrator shall determine whether the application is complete.
2. 
If the application is not complete, the Zoning Administrator shall notify the applicant of any deficiencies and shall take no steps to process the application until the deficiencies are remedied.
3. 
Once the Zoning Administrator has determined that the application is complete, the application shall be reviewed and acted upon by the Zoning Administrator or scheduled for consideration at the appropriate meeting.
D. 
Fees.
1. 
Every application shall be accompanied by the required filing fee as established and modified, from time to time, by City Council.
2. 
The failure to pay such fee when due shall be grounds for refusing to process the application and for denying or revoking any permit or approval for the subject property.
3. 
No fees shall be waived and no fees shall be refunded except those authorized by the City Council.
4. 
The City Council shall adopt the City Fee Schedule by resolution.
E. 
Withdrawal of application. An applicant shall have the right to withdraw an application at any time prior to the decision on the application by a City official, commission, or board. Such withdrawal shall be made in a written statement to the City.
F. 
Successive applications.
1. 
A subsequent application shall not be reviewed or heard within one year of the date of denial unless there is substantial new evidence available or if a significant error in law or of fact affected the prior denial.
2. 
Such subsequent application shall include a detailed statement of the grounds justifying its consideration.
3. 
The Zoning Administrator shall make a determination as to whether the subsequent application is substantially the same as the original application.
4. 
If the Zoning Administrator finds that there are no grounds for consideration of the subsequent application, they shall summarily and without hearing deny the request.

Section Z8-02 Zoning procedures responsibilities.

A. 
Zoning Administrator. Except where herein otherwise stated, the provisions of this Ordinance shall be administered by the Zoning Administrator, or such other official or officials as may be designated by the City Council. The Zoning Administrator shall have the power to:
1. 
Make inspections of buildings and premises necessary to carry out the duties of administration and enforcement of this ordinance.
2. 
Review applications for and issue zoning permits and certificates of occupancy.
3. 
Issue and serve appearance tickets on any person with respect to any violation of this Ordinance where there is reasonable cause to believe that the person has committed such an offense.
4. 
Maintain and safely keep copies of all plans other than for single-family dwellings and fees submitted with such application, and the same shall form a part of the records of the Zoning Administrator's office and shall be available to the Council and all other officials of the City.
5. 
Perform such other functions necessary and proper to enforce and administer the provisions of this Ordinance.
B. 
Building Inspector. The Building Inspector shall have the following powers and duties with regard to this Ordinance:
1. 
To review requests for and to issue building permits and sign permits;
2. 
To conduct inspections of buildings and structures to determine compliance with the terms of this Ordinance and other applicable ordinances;
3. 
To provide technical assistance to the City Council and other bodies with authority under this Ordinance.
C. 
Board of Appeals.
1. 
Creation and membership. A Board of Appeals is hereby created in accordance with the laws of the State of Michigan, which shall consist of the City Council of the City of New Buffalo, except that in the event the City Council so desires, it may appoint a Board of Appeals consisting of not less than five members, each to be appointed for a term not to exceed three years.
2. 
Jurisdiction. The Board of Appeals shall not have the power to make any change in the terms of this Ordinance, but does have power to act on those matters where this Ordinance provides for an administrative review, interpretation, and to authorize a variance as defined in this section and the laws of the State of Michigan. The Board of Appeals shall not have the authority to hear appeals from a decision made in respect to any special land use, planned unit development, or rezoning. The powers of the Board of Appeals include:
a. 
Hearing of Appeals. To hear and decide appeals where it is alleged by the appellant that there is an error in any order, requirement, permit, decision or refusal made by the Zoning Administrator or any other administrative official in carrying out or enforcing any provisions of this Ordinance;
b. 
Granting of variances. A variance from the specific requirements of this Ordinance may be granted by the Board of Appeals in accordance with the requirements and procedures of Section 8-07;
c. 
Zoning ordinance interpretation. The Board of Appeals may interpret the provisions of this Ordinance to carry out the intent and purposes of the Ordinance where the meaning of the provisions is uncertain as specified in Section 8-12.
D. 
Planning Commission. With respect to this Ordinance, the Planning Commission shall:
1. 
Hear, consider, and make a written report with findings of fact and recommendations to the City Council on all applications for site plan review, map and text amendments, special uses, and planned unit developments;
2. 
Make decisions on other matters referred to it upon which it is required to pass under this Ordinance;
3. 
Assist in the development, review, and amendment of the Master Plan, as requested by City Council.
E. 
City Council. The City Council shall, with respect to this Ordinance, make final decisions on applications for text and map amendments, planned unit development, and special uses, with or without conditions. City Council shall also formally approve the Master Plan as recommended by the Planning Commission in accordance with state statute.

Section Z8-03 Administrative procedures.

A. 
Building permits.
1. 
No building, structure, or commercial sign shall be erected, altered, moved, or substantially repaired unless a building permit shall have been first issued for such work.
2. 
No building permit shall be issued for the erection, alteration, moving, or use of any building or structure or for the use of any land which is not in accordance with all provisions of this Ordinance.
3. 
The holder of every building permit for the erection, alteration, repair, or moving of any building or structure shall notify the Building Inspector immediately upon completion of the work authorized by the permit for a final inspection.
4. 
Prior to issuance of a building permit, the Building Inspector may require any information specified in Article 11 which the Building Inspector determines to be necessary in order to properly evaluate the permit request and determine compliance with the applicable requirement of this Ordinance.
B. 
Certificate of occupancy.
1. 
No vacant land shall be used and no existing use of land shall be changed to a different class of use unless a certificate of occupancy is first obtained for the new or different use.
2. 
No building or structure which is hereafter erected or altered shall be occupied or used unless and until a certificate of occupancy shall have been issued for such building or structure.
3. 
Certificates of occupancy, as required by the currently enforced Building Code for the City, shall also constitute certification of compliance with this Ordinance.
4. 
A record of all certificates of occupancy issued shall be kept on file in the office of the Zoning Administrator and copies shall be furnished upon request to any person owning or renting the property which is the subject of the certificate.
5. 
Applications for certificates of occupancy shall be made in writing to the Building Inspector on a form furnished by the City. Certificates shall be issued within 10 days after receipt of such application if the building or structure or use of land is in accordance with the provisions of this Ordinance and the other applicable ordinances of the City.
C. 
Zoning permit.
1. 
Purpose and applicability. In all districts a zoning permit shall be required for:
a. 
Any new use or change of use of a building, structure, or land not involving the construction of new buildings or structures, alteration of existing buildings or structures, or other exterior changes to a property;
b. 
The construction of new or alteration to the building footprint of any existing single-family detached or duplex development or construction of any buildings, structures, or uses accessory to a single-family detached or duplex development.
2. 
Zoning Administrator review and action.
a. 
The Zoning Administrator shall review the zoning compliance permit application to determine whether it conforms to all applicable provisions of this Ordinance.
b. 
Based upon their review the Zoning Administrator shall:
[1] 
Issue the zoning permit;
[2] 
Refer the zoning permit application to the Planning Commission for review; or
[3] 
Deny the zoning permit.
c. 
The Zoning Administrator may refer any application for a zoning permit to the Planning Commission for review and approval upon determining that the input and discretion of the Commission is appropriate.
3. 
Expiration and lapse of approval. A zoning permit shall expire if within six months of the date of issuance of a zoning permit the use has not commenced or the use has not occupied the structure or location. Upon the showing of a valid cause by the applicant, the Zoning Administrator may grant an extension of such zoning permit for a period not to exceed six months.
4. 
Enforcement. Failure to comply with this section relating to zoning permits may be enforced pursuant to this Ordinance, or any other provision of law including, but not limited to, revocation of the zoning permit, injunction, or other civil suit.
D. 
Temporary use permit.
1. 
Purpose. A temporary use permit shall be required prior to the establishment of a temporary use per Section Z8-03D of this Ordinance to certify compliance with all applicable regulations of this Ordinance and the applicable sections of the building code as enforced by the City.
2. 
Temporary use permit review criteria. To approve the issuance of a temporary use permit, the Zoning Administrator shall make an affirmative finding that all applicable provisions of this Ordinance, the applicable building code, and all other City ordinances are met.
3. 
Zoning Administrator action. The application shall be reviewed by the Zoning Administrator to ensure the application conforms to the criteria in Subsection D(2) above. Based upon their review, the Zoning Administrator shall:
a. 
Issue the temporary use permit;
b. 
Issue the temporary use permit with conditions; or
c. 
Deny the temporary use permit.
4. 
Referral to Planning Commission. The Zoning Administrator may refer any application for a temporary use permit to the Planning Commission for review and approval upon determining that the input and discretion of the Commission is appropriate.
E. 
Sign permit.
1. 
Purpose. A sign permit shall be required prior to the display, construction, erection, or alteration of a sign and its structural components on any property. All signs must comply with Article 6, and the applicable sections of the City's Building Code as adopted. All electrical installations associated with the erection and installation of a sign must be done in accordance with the enforced Building and Electrical Codes.
2. 
Applicability. No person shall erect, alter, place or permit to be placed, or replace any sign without first obtaining a building permit, unless such sign is specifically exempted as provided in Article 6.
3. 
Exemptions. Signs exempt from a permit are detailed in Section Z6-04.
4. 
Sign permit review criteria. To approve the issuance of a sign permit, the Building Inspector shall make an affirmative finding that all applicable provisions of this Ordinance, the applicable building code, and all other City ordinances are met.
5. 
Building inspector action. The application shall be reviewed by the Building Inspector to ensure the application conforms to the applicable standards of Article 6. Based upon their review, the Building Inspector shall:
a. 
Issue the sign permit;
b. 
Issue the sign permit with conditions; or
c. 
Deny the sign permit.
6. 
Referral to Planning Commission. The Building Inspector may refer any application for a sign permit to the Planning Commission for review and approval upon determining that the input and discretion of the Commission is appropriate.

Section Z8-04 Summary of Board/Commission review and approval procedures.

A. 
Summary of Board/Commission review and approval procedures. Table 8-04(A) summarizes the Board and Commission review and approval procedures and identifies the appropriate boards or commissions that serve as recommending or decision-making bodies.
Table 8-04(A): Summary of Board/Commission Review and Approval Procedures
Petition Review Procedure
Planning Commission
City Council
Zoning Board of Appeals
Site plan review
R*
D
Special use
R*
D
Variance
R*
D*
Map amendment
D
Text amendment
R*
D
Comprehensive sign plan
D*
Private roads permit
D*
Interpretation
D*
Appeal
D*
Key:
R = Recommending body
D = Decision making body
* = Public notice required
B. 
Notice types.
1. 
Written notice. Notice shall be written or mailed as required in state statute to all persons to whom real property is assessed within 300 feet of the property that is the subject of the request and to the occupants of all structures within 300 feet of the subject property regardless of whether the property or structure is located in the zoning jurisdiction. The notice describing the nature of the request, stating when and where the request shall be considered, and indicating when and where written comments will be received shall be given not less than 15 days before the date the request will be considered.
2. 
Published notice. Notice of the public hearing shall be published in a newspaper of general circulation in the local unit of government not less than 15 days before the date of the hearing.
C. 
Public notice requirements by procedure. Table 8-04(C) summarizes the requirements for public notices per each Board and Commission review and approval procedure.
Table 8-04(C): Notice Requirements by Procedure
Procedure
Written Notice
Published Notice
Special use
Variance
Map amendment
Text amendment
Comprehensive sign plan
Appeal
Key:
• = Required form of notice

Section Z8-05 Site plan review.

[Amended 10-21-2024 by Ord. No. 271]
A. 
Purpose. The purpose of this section is to require and review those documents or drawings as specified in the Ordinance, to ensure that a proposed land use or development is in compliance with this Ordinance, other local ordinances, state statutes, and federal statutes. And furthermore, its purpose is to ensure that development taking place within the City is properly designed, safe, efficient, environmentally sound, and developed in such a manner as to protect adjacent properties from adverse impacts.
B. 
Applicability.
1. 
Site plan review shall be required for all construction of new buildings and structures and alterations to the building footprint of existing buildings or structures.
2. 
Single-family detached or duplex development that is permitted by right in the governing zoning district in which they are located shall require site plan review.
3. 
The establishment of new uses or change of use allowed by-right in the governing district not involving construction of or alteration to the footprint of existing structures shall not require site plan review.
C. 
Process.
1. 
City staff review. The Zoning Administrator shall review the site plan for completeness, and shall obtain comments, as the Zoning Administrator considers necessary, from the following staff members:
a. 
Department of Public Works;
b. 
Water Department;
c. 
Police Department;
d. 
Fire Department;
e. 
Other City departments or consultants.
2. 
Transmittal to the Planning Commission. Once the Zoning Administrator determines that the site plan is complete, the Zoning Administrator shall transmit the site plan, along with comments from City departments and consultants to the Planning Commission at least two weeks prior to the next meeting. The Zoning Administrator shall not be required to submit any site plan for review which was submitted less than 40 days prior to the Planning Commission meeting when the review will occur.
3. 
Planning Commission recommendation.
a. 
The Planning Commission shall consider the site plan and shall recommend the City Council:
[1] 
Approve the site plan, as submitted, if all applicable requirements and standards have been met;
[2] 
Approve the site plan with conditions; or
[3] 
Deny the site plan if applicable requirements and standards have not been met. All recommendations of the Planning Commission with regard to site plans shall be accompanied by written findings of fact to support its position for each item under Section Z8-05D standards for site plan review.
b. 
The reasons for the Planning Commission's action, along with any conditions that may be attached, shall be stated in the meeting minutes and a copy provided to the applicant.
4. 
City Council action. For each site plan application, City Council shall consider the Planning Commission's recommendation and shall:
a. 
Approve the site plan;
b. 
Approve the site plan with conditions; or
c. 
Deny the application.
5. 
Record of action. If approved, two copies of the final site plan shall be signed and dated by the Secretary of the Planning Commission and the applicant. One copy shall be kept on file with the City and one copy shall be returned to the applicant or its designated representative.
D. 
Standards of review. To promote orderly development which is safe, efficient, attractive, sensitive to environmental concerns, and generally promotes the welfare of the City's citizens, all developments and uses, in addition to meeting applicable specific standards as identified in this Ordinance, shall also meet the following general standards.
1. 
Ordinance and master plan purposes and intent. The proposed use and development will be in harmony with the purposes for which this Ordinance was enacted and the regulations of the governing district and with the Master Plan.
2. 
Soil preservation. Site plans shall be developed to prevent or minimize problems with soil erosion or sedimentation. Submission of a Soil Erosion Permit approved by Berrien County shall be required as applicable.
3. 
Privacy provisions. The site plan shall provide reasonable visual and sound privacy for all dwelling units located therein. Fences, walks, barriers and landscaping shall be used, as appropriate, for the protection and enhancement of property and for the privacy of occupants.
4. 
Emergency vehicle accessibility. All buildings or groups of buildings shall be so arranged as to permit emergency vehicle accessibility. Fire lanes shall be provided as deemed necessary by the Fire Chief to provide adequate fire protection.
5. 
Compatibility with existing or planned streets and pathways. The arrangement of streets, sidewalks, and other path systems shall respect the pattern of existing or planned streets and pedestrian or bicycle pathways in the area. Streets and drives which are part of an existing or planned street pattern in the Master Plan, Berrien County Transportation Plan, or other City or county policy document shall be of a width appropriate to the traffic volume they will carry and shall have a dedicated right-of-way equal to that specified in any formally-adopted street plan or planned right-of-way.
6. 
Efficient and safe traffic systems. Street systems shall be designed to be as efficient as possible, and in compliance with commonly accepted traffic engineering standards for safety.
E. 
Amendments to approved site plans. A site plan may be amended based upon whether the desired amendment is classified as a major or minor amendment to the site plan. Major amendments shall require review and approval by the Planning Commission. Minor amendments shall only require the approval of the Zoning Administrator.
1. 
Major amendments. Major amendments shall include one or more of the following:
a. 
A change in the original concept of the development;
b. 
A change in the use or character of the development;
c. 
A change in the type of dwelling unit;
d. 
An increase in the number of dwelling units;
e. 
An increase in floor area of more than 10%;
f. 
A change in the basic layout or design of the project;
g. 
A change in the character, function, or location of any street or access driveway;
h. 
A reduction in the amount of open space, or relocation of open space areas;
i. 
The movement of a building footprint by more than 10 feet.
2. 
Minor amendments. Minor amendments shall include one or more of the following:
a. 
A change in floor area of 10% or less;
b. 
Additions to parking lots of up to 10 spaces;
c. 
The movement of a building footprint of 10 feet or less;
d. 
Substitutions in type of landscape plantings not to exceed 20% of the total amount of landscape materials; provided such materials are comparable to those they would replace;
e. 
Accessory buildings having less than 1,000 square feet of area for commercial, industrial, or institutional uses.

Section Z8-06 Special uses.

A. 
Purpose. The intent of this section is to provide regulations and a more detailed review of uses that in many cases would be compatible with the uses permitted by right in a given district, but which, by reason of the special nature of such uses or their location in relation to neighboring properties, would not always be so. Because of their unique characteristics, it is often necessary to place restrictions or conditions associated with the approval of special uses to ensure their compatibility with surrounding development.
B. 
Procedure.
1. 
City staff review. The Zoning Administrator shall review the application for completeness, and shall obtain comments, as the Zoning Administrator considers necessary, from the following staff members:
a. 
Department of Public Works.
b. 
Water Department.
c. 
Police Department.
d. 
Fire Department.
e. 
Other City departments or consultants.
2. 
Planning Commission public hearing and recommendation. The Planning Commission shall review and make recommendations to the City Council for approval, approval with conditions or denial for all special uses.
a. 
Following the submission of the required application materials, the Planning Commission shall hold a public hearing in accordance with this Ordinance and applicable State of Michigan Statutes and provide a written recommendation for final review and approval by City Council.
b. 
The Planning Commission recommendation to City Council shall include written analysis for findings of fact of each standard for approval under Section Z8-06B(4) and any use-specific standards in Article 4.
c. 
The Planning Commission shall recommend in writing that City Council take one of the following actions:
[1] 
Approve the special use;
[2] 
Approve the special use with conditions; or
[3] 
Deny the special use.
3. 
City Council action. For each application for a special use, the Planning Commission shall report to the City Council its findings and recommendations, including the stipulations of additional conditions and guarantees that such conditions will be complied with when they are deemed necessary for the protection of the public interest. The City Council shall:
a. 
Approve the special use permit;
b. 
Approve the special use permit with conditions;
c. 
Deny the special use permit;
d. 
Refer the special use permit to the Planning Commission for further review.
4. 
Standards for special uses. In considering an application for a special use permit the Planning Commission and City Council shall review the responses by the applicant to the standards set forth below.
a. 
Ordinance and Master Plan purposes and intent. The proposed use and development will be in harmony with the purposes for which this Ordinance was enacted and the regulations of the governing district and with the Master Plan.
b. 
Compatibility with surrounding development. The proposed use and development will be constructed, arranged, and operated so as to be compatible with the use and development of neighboring property in accordance with the applicable zoning district regulations.
c. 
Adequate public facilities. The proposed use and development will be served adequately by essential public facilities and services such as streets, public utilities including public water supply system and sanitary sewer, police and fire protection, refuse disposal, public parks, libraries, schools, and other public facilities and utilities.
d. 
Adequate circulation. The proposed use and development will not cause undue traffic congestion nor draw significant amounts of traffic through residential streets. Adequate measures will be taken to provide ingress and egress so designed as to minimize traffic congestion in the public streets.
e. 
No destruction of significant features. The proposed use and development will not result in the destruction, loss, or damage of any natural, scenic, or historic feature of significant importance.
5. 
Issuance of special use permit. Upon approval of a special use application and accompanying site plan by City Council, the Zoning Administrator shall issue a special use permit consistent with this Ordinance, the Master Plan, state law and the terms and conditions approved by City Council.
6. 
Amendments to approved special uses.
a. 
Determination of level of change. Upon receiving a special use amendment application, the Zoning Administrator shall determine whether the amendment is a minor amendment, or a major amendment based on the criteria detailed in Section Z8-06B(6)(a)[1] below.
[1] 
Major amendment. A major amendment is any proposed change to an approved special use that results in one or more of the following:
[a] 
Increase in the intensity of the site's use, including:
[i] 
A 5% or more increase in impervious surface or modification to the approved stormwater management plan;
[ii] 
Request for hours of operation before 8:00 am or after 6:00 pm; or
[iii] 
Additional noise, glare, odor, or other impacts that are detectable from off-site as determined by the Zoning Administrator.
[2] 
Minor amendment. A minor amendment is any proposed change to an approved special use that is consistent with the standards and conditions upon which the special use was approved, which does not alter the concept or intent of the special use, and which is not considered a major amendment as detailed in Section Z8-06B(6)(a)[1].
[3] 
Approval process. A major amendment to an approved special use shall follow the procedure for a special use approval set in Section Z8-06B. A minor amendment to an approved special use may be approved by the Zoning Administrator.

Section Z8-07 Variance.

A. 
Purpose. The variance process is designed to provide a narrowly circumscribed means by which relief may be granted from unforeseen applications of this Ordinance that create practical difficulties or particular hardships. A variance may be granted for practical difficulties or particular hardships resulting from the strict application of the regulations of this Ordinance.
B. 
Authority for variances. The Board of Appeals, after public hearing, shall have the power to grant requests for variances from the provisions of this Ordinance where it is proved by the applicant that there are practical difficulties or unnecessary hardship in the way of carrying out the strict letter of the Zoning Ordinance relating to the construction, equipment, or alteration of buildings or structures so that the spirit of the Ordinance shall be observed, public safety secured and substantial justice done.
C. 
Granting of non-use variances. A non-use variance may be allowed by the Board of Appeals only in cases where there is reasonable evidence of practical difficulty in the official record of the hearing and that all the following conditions are met:
1. 
That there are exceptional or extraordinary circumstances or conditions applying to the property in question that do not apply generally to other properties in the same district;
2. 
That such variance is necessary for the preservation and enjoyment of a substantial property right similar to that possessed by other properties in the same district and in the vicinity (the possibility of increased financial return shall not be deemed sufficient to warrant a variance);
3. 
The variance will not be significantly detrimental to adjacent property and the surrounding neighborhood;
4. 
The variance will not impair the intent and purpose of this Ordinance;
5. 
The immediate practical difficulty causing the need for the variance request was not created by any action of the applicant.
D. 
Granting of use variances. A use variance may be allowed by the Board of Appeals only in cases where there is reasonable evidence of unnecessary hardship in the official record of the hearing and that all of the following conditions are met:
1. 
That the building, structure, or land cannot be reasonably used for any of the uses permitted by right or as a special use in the district in which it is located.
2. 
That the condition or situation of the specific piece of property or the intended use of such property for which the variance is sought is not of so general or recurrent a nature as to make reasonably practical the formulation of a general regulation for such conditions or situations.
3. 
That the proposed use will not alter the essential character of the neighborhood.
E. 
Procedure.
1. 
Planning Commission recommendation. Prior to the Board of Appeals hearing on a request for a use variance, the Planning Commission shall consider such request and forward a report to the Board of Appeals. For this report the Planning Commission shall consider the Master Plan, the ability of the property owner to use the property for a use already permitted under the existing zoning district, the effect of the request on the essential character of the neighborhood, and other such factors as the Planning Commission may deem relevant.
2. 
Zoning Board of Appeals hearing and action. The Zoning Board of Appeals shall review the application for a variance, hold a public hearing, and after consideration of the recommendation of the Zoning Administrator, recommendation of the Zoning Administrator and public comment received either:
a. 
Approve the variance;
b. 
Approve the variance with conditions; or
c. 
Deny the variance.
F. 
Effect of denial. No application for a variation shall be filed by property owner which is identical or substantially similar to the requested variation which has been denied within one year of the date of the denial.

Section Z8-08 Map amendments.

A. 
Purpose. The Zoning Map may be amended in accordance with the state statute. The amendment process is intended to adjust this Ordinance in response to changed conditions or changes in City policy. Amendments are not intended to relieve particular hardships or confer special privileges or rights upon any person or party.
B. 
Map amendment review criteria. The following review criteria shall be considered in the review and action on map amendment applications.
1. 
The proposed map amendment is consistent with the Master Plan and other adopted policies of the City.
2. 
The requested map amendment is compatible with the existing uses, development patterns and zoning of nearby properties.
3. 
The proposed map amendment does not conflict with existing or planned public improvements or will not adversely impact schools, parks, or other public facilities.
4. 
The natural environment or traffic patterns in the vicinity will not be adversely affected in a manner inconsistent with the planned character of the area.
5. 
The proposed map amendment is not detrimental to the health, safety and welfare of the neighborhood or of the City as a whole.
C. 
Planning Commission hearing and recommendation. The Planning Commission shall hold a public hearing and at the close of the public hearing and after consideration of the recommendation of the Zoning Administrator and public comment received, either recommend that the City Council:
1. 
Approve the map amendment; or
2. 
Deny the map amendment.
D. 
City Council action. City Council shall review the application for the map amendment and after consideration of the recommendation of the Planning Commission, recommendation of the Zoning Administrator, and public comment received either:
1. 
Approve the map amendment; or
2. 
Deny the map amendment.

Section Z8-09 Text amendments.

A. 
Purpose. The regulations imposed and the districts created by this Ordinance may be amended in accordance with the state statute. The amendment process is intended to adjust this Ordinance in response to changed conditions or changes in City policy. Amendments are not intended to relieve particular hardships or confer special privileges or rights upon any person or party.
B. 
Text amendment review criteria. The following review criteria shall be considered in the review and action on text amendment applications.
1. 
The proposed text amendment is consistent with the Master Plan and other adopted City policies.
2. 
The proposed text amendment addresses a particular issue or concern for the City.
3. 
The proposed text amendment does not impose an unreasonable hardship on existing and planned uses.
4. 
The requested amendment will further the compatibility of uses and development patterns of the City.
5. 
The proposed amendments is not detrimental to the health, safety and welfare of the neighborhood or of the City overall.
C. 
Planning Commission hearing and recommendation. The Planning Commission shall hold a public hearing and at the close of the public hearing and after consideration of the recommendation of the Zoning Administrator and public comment received, either recommend that City Council:
1. 
Approve the text amendment; or
2. 
Deny the text amendment.
D. 
City Council action. The City Council shall review the application for the text amendment and after consideration of the recommendation of the Planning Commission, recommendation of the Zoning Administrator, and public comment received either:
1. 
Approve the text amendment; or
2. 
Deny the text amendment.

Section Z8-10 Comprehensive sign plan.

A. 
Intent. The intent of the comprehensive sign plan is to provide an alternative procedure under which signs can be designed, constructed, and erected with innovation, imagination, and creative architecture. The objective of the comprehensive sign plan is to encourage a higher level of design and amenity than is possible to achieve under otherwise applicable sign regulations.
B. 
Applicability. Any building or development may elect to submit a comprehensive sign plan. After the approval of a comprehensive sign plan, no permanent sign shall be erected, placed, or maintained except in conformance with the comprehensive sign plan.
C. 
Conditions. The Zoning Administrator may attach conditions, requirements, or standards necessary to assure that the signs covered by the comprehensive sign plan will not be materially detrimental to persons or property in the vicinity. In making its determination, the Zoning Administrator shall not base any condition on the content of a sign.
D. 
Evaluation criteria.
1. 
Placement. All signs shall be placed where they are visible and legible. Factors to be considered include the location of a sign relative to traffic movement and access points, site features, other structures, and orientation relative to viewing distances and viewing angles. Wall signs may be approved on building walls other than the wall of a unit of a multi-tenant building in which some units have little or no visibility from the street.
2. 
Quantity. The number of signs that may be approved within any development shall be sufficient to provide necessary facilitation of internal circulation of vehicular and pedestrian traffic and wayfinding for safety of the occupants of vehicles and pedestrians. Factors to be considered shall be those that impact safety considerations such as the size of the development and the number of development sub-areas.
3. 
Area and height. All signs shall comply with the sign area and height requirements established for the sign type as established in Sections Z6-05 and Z6-06.
E. 
Application. A comprehensive sign plan shall be submitted in accordance with the requirements in Article 11.
F. 
Review and action. The Planning Commission shall review the comprehensive sign plan application and approve, approve with conditions, or deny the application based on the evaluation criteria. A written decision including the findings on the evaluation criteria shall be rendered to the applicant.
G. 
Appeals. Any applicant who receives a notice of denial from the Planning Commission may, within 30 days after receipt of such decision, appeal such decision to the Zoning Board of Appeals by filing a written notice of appeal with the Zoning Administrator with an explanation as to why said decision was not warranted according to the applicant.

Section Z8-11 Private streets.

A. 
Permits required.
1. 
No individual, association, corporation, or entity, either public or private, shall construct a private street without first having obtained a private street permit from the City Council.
2. 
The Building Inspector shall not issue building permits for construction of any building or structure on lots served solely by a private street until a permit for the private street has been approved by the Planning Commission and a safe and unimpeded route of travel is available for any such structure requiring a building permit.
3. 
A driveway permit shall be obtained from the Michigan Department of Transportation, as applicable, or from the City.
4. 
A soil erosion and sedimentation control permit shall be obtained, as may be required by the Soil Erosion and Sedimentation Control Act of 1972, as amended.
5. 
All other required State of Michigan permits shall be obtained.
6. 
The Planning Commission may elect to have all design and construction plans reviewed by the City's attorney, engineer, or Zoning Administrator prior to consideration of the application for the private street permit.
B. 
Process. The Planning Commission shall review the private street application and shall take one of the following actions:
1. 
Approve the application;
2. 
Approve the application with conditions or modifications;
3. 
Deny the application.
C. 
Review standards.
1. 
Prior to approving a private street permit application, the Planning Commission shall determine the following:
a. 
The proposed private street will not be detrimental to the public health, safety, or general welfare;
b. 
The proposed private street will not adversely affect the use of land;
c. 
The private street is constructed to assure a safe and unimpeded route of travel for motor vehicle traffic, pedestrians, and emergency vehicles in all weather conditions;
d. 
The private street is constructed so as to protect against or minimize soil erosion and prevent damage to the lakes, streams, wetlands, and natural environment of the City;
e. 
The construction of the private street will conform to the requirements of this section.
2. 
The Planning Commission may require that the applicant comply with reasonable conditions relative to the design and construction of the private street.
3. 
Upon application the Planning Commission may modify any of the private street requirements of this section after finding that all of the following conditions exist:
a. 
Topography, soils, and/or other significant natural features physically preclude or prevent compliance with the requirements of this section without substantial alteration of such natural features. Such natural features shall be clearly identified and described in the application for any such modification.
b. 
The justification of any modification is not due solely to financial considerations which, upon approval of the requested modification would provide a financial benefit.
c. 
No other reasonable private street design alternatives are available that would comply with the requirements of this section.
d. 
The request for modification was reviewed by the Fire Chief or City Engineer or any other appropriate person or official, and a recommendation from such review was submitted to the Planning Commission.

Section Z8-12 Interpretations.

A. 
Purpose. The provisions of this Ordinance, though detailed and extensive, cannot, as a practical matter, address every specific situation which may arise. The interpretation authority established herein is not intended to add or change the essential content of this Ordinance but to allow authoritative application of that content to specific cases.
B. 
Board of Appeals. The Board of Appeals shall hold a public hearing and render an interpretation of any request within 30 days of the public hearing.
C. 
Record of action. The Board of Appeals' decision shall be filed and recorded with the City Clerk.

Section Z8-13 Appeals.

A. 
Purpose. An Appeal may be taken to the Board of Appeals by any individual aggrieved by any order, requirement, decision, interpretation or determination of the regulations of this Ordinance made by the Zoning Administrator or Building Inspector.
B. 
Initiation. An application for an appeal may be filed within 30 days of the action of the Zoning Administrator or Building Inspector.
C. 
Board of Appeals hearing and action. A public hearing shall be conducted by the Board of Appeals for each Appeal. The Board of Appeals may reverse or affirm, wholly or partly, or may modify the order, requirement, decision, or determination relating to this Ordinance, made by the Zoning Administrator subject to the criteria in Section 8-13(D).
D. 
Appeal review criteria. An Appeal of administrative decisions shall be granted only if the Board of Appeals makes one of the following findings.
1. 
The decision constituted an erroneous application or interpretation of this Ordinance.
2. 
The decision constituted an abuse of the administrative official's discretion to interpret or apply this Ordinance.
3. 
The decision was rendered based upon an erroneous material fact.
E. 
Record of action. The Board of Appeals' decision shall be filed and recorded with the City Clerk.