Zoneomics Logo
search icon

Parma City Zoning Code

TITLE SEVEN

Use, Height and Area Regulations

1181.01 EXISTING NONCONFORMING BUILDINGS AND USES.

   (a)   Except as provided in Chapters 1171, a use of a building or land lawfully existing on or prior to May 4, 1931, or for which a permit has lawfully been issued, may be continued even though such use does not conform to the provisions of such Zoning Code for the use district in which it is located, but no enlargement, expansion or addition shall be allowed or permitted except as a variance under terms set forth in Chapter 1127, and no substitution or other change in such nonconforming use to other than a conforming use shall be permitted except by special permit granted by the Board of Zoning Appeals in accordance with the provisions of Chapter 1127. Such permit may be issued only after notice by publication of a public hearing to be held thereon and after the Board finds, in such hearing, that such substitution or other change is no more harmful or objectionable than the previous nonconforming use in floor space or other space occupied, in volume of trade or production or kind of goods sold or produced, in daily hours or other periods of use, in the type or number of persons to occupy or to be attracted to the premises or in any other characteristic of the new use as compared with the previous use.
    (b)   The publication of notice as stated in subsection (a) hereof shall be made in two local newspapers and shall be published twice in a thirty-day period.
   The hearing required shall be fixed for a day certain within two weeks following the final publication. All costs shall be borne by the applicant for a variance use.
   (c)   This section shall not in any way affect the force and legality of previous orders requiring the discontinuance of nonconforming uses nor extend the time limit already established for the discontinuance of existing nonconforming uses.
   (d)   Nonconforming signs shall be regulated under Chapter 1196.
(Ord. 115-60. Passed 6-6-60; Ord. 157-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1181.02 ABANDONMENT OF NONCONFORMING USES.

   (a)   A nonconforming use of a building or premises which has been abandoned shall not thereafter be returned to such nonconforming use.
   (b)   For the purposes of this section a nonconforming use shall be considered abandoned when:
      (1)   The owner's intent to discontinue such use is apparent;
      (2)   The specific characteristic equipment, material and furnishings of the nonconforming use have been removed from the building or premises and have not been replaced within six months by similar equipment, unless other facts show the intent of the owner to resume the nonconforming use;
      (3)   It has been replaced by a conforming use; or
      (4)   It has been changed to another lawful use under proper permit of the Board of Zoning Appeals acting under the provisions of Chapter 1127 and the rules and regulations enacted by the Board regulating its internal affairs and conduct.
(Ord. 113-60. Passed 6-6-60; Ord. 279-99. Passed 2-7-00.)

1181.03 REPAIR AND RESTORATION OF BUILDINGS OF NONCONFORMING USES.

   (a)   Nothing in this chapter shall prevent the strengthening, restoration, completion, reconstruction, extension or substitution of a nonconforming use to a safe condition of any structural part of any building declared unsafe by the Building Commissioner or other authorized administrative official or agency of the City. Such repairs shall not exceed fifty percent of the valuation of such building as specified on the tax duplicate contained in the County Recorder's office, unless the building is being changed to a conforming use.
   (b)   A nonconforming use or building which is more than fifty percent destroyed or removed by whatever cause, including acts of God but excluding malicious mischief or vandalism, shall not be permitted restored or replaced except to a conforming use in the use district.
(Ord. 112-60. Passed 6-6-60.)

1183.01 RECREATION BUILDINGS NEAR SCHOOL AREAS.

   In any use district, no poolroom, skating rink, dance hall or amusement park shall be located within 400 feet of the premises of a public school or premises purchased for school purposes.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1183.02 LOCATION OF GASOLINE STATIONS, GARAGES AND STABLES.

   In any use district, no gasoline filling station, garage for more than four vehicles or stable for more than four horses shall have any entrance or exit for vehicles or horses on the same side of the street within 200 feet, measured along the sidewalks, from any generally used entrance or exit of the premises occupied by any church, public or denominational school, playground, hospital, library or institution for dependents or for children, except when the distance is intersected by a street or alley. The premises of such filling station, garage or stable shall not be nearer than 100 feet from the premises occupied by any of the institutions mentioned in this section, except when the distance is intersected by a street at least sixty feet in width.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1183.03 LOCATION OF GASOLINE PUMPS.

   At any garage or gasoline filling station, no filling appliance shall be erected within twelve feet of any street, unless the appliance is within a building and distant at least twelve feet from any entrance or exit thereof, or unless the appliance is so arranged that service can be given only to vehicles inside the premises.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1183.04 DESIGNATION OF DISTRICT FOR OPEN AREAS.

   Any area shown on the Zone Map as park, school, cemetery, water, street, right-of-way or other similar open area shall be considered as being in the same use district as the adjoining land.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1183.05 UNDEVELOPED AREA FOR RADIO AND TELEVISION EQUIPMENT.

   In any use district, any undeveloped parcel of land having an area of not less than three acres which is owned by one person, firm or corporation, may be used for the purpose of erecting, maintaining and operating thereon one or more radio towers, television towers, other communication towers, power lines, transmitter houses, studio buildings, administration buildings, office buildings and other buildings, equipment installations and appurtenances necessary or incidental to the operation of a radio station or stations, or of a television station or stations, or of combined radio and television station or stations, or of any other communications facility, including, but not limited to, a mobile telephone communications installation. However, no such radio towers, television towers or other towers shall be so constructed upon any parcel of land which would not be of sufficient size in such instance wherein one-half of the entire length of such tower, as measured from its base, not including the height of the pad, upon toppling or destruction, would not be contained within such parcel of land.
   No such undeveloped parcel upon which a tower is erected may hereafter be subdivided unless a permanent easement is created for the benefit of the owner of the parcel upon which such tower is situated, so that access to the tower will be maintained, and any owner of such a tower shall continue to be a responsible party for the maintenance of such tower notwithstanding that a lessee may also be held responsible.
   No installation of any device, including, but not limited to, a transmitter or receiver, shall be made upon any communication tower until a permit is first obtained, and a fee paid therefor, to the Building Commissioner.
   For the purpose of this section, a parcel used for farm purposes, or not used for any purpose, shall be considered as undeveloped.
(Ord.139-90. Passed 6-18-90.)

1183.06 MANUFACTURE OR SALE OF FIREWORKS.

   No building or premises in any use district shall be used by any person for the manufacture, possession for sale, or sale, of fireworks, as defined in Section 1305.01 of the Fire Prevention Code.
(Ord. 140-87. Passed 6-15-87.)

1183.07 COMMERCIAL OUTDOOR RECREATIONAL FACILITIES.

   (a)   Notwithstanding any other provision of these Codified Ordinances, and regardless of the use district, no person shall construct, establish or operate a new commercial outdoor recreational facility on property which is within 500 feet of any residential use district.
   (b)   For purposes of this section, a "commercial outdoor recreational facility" means and includes any commercial recreational facility in which the participants' activities are not conducted entirely within one or more structures that are fully enclosed on all sides. A commercial facility shall include, but not be limited to, batting cages, miniature golf courses, go-carts, archery ranges and golf ball driving ranges.
(Ord. 297-91. Passed 1-21-92.)

1185.01 HEIGHT DISTRICTS CLASSIFICATION.

   The City is hereby divided into three height districts which shall be known as:
   (a)   No. 1 (or Thirty-Five Feet) Height District, designated on the Zone Map by (-1).
   (b)   No. 2 (or Fifty Feet) Height District, designated on the Zone Map by (-2).
   (c)   No. 3 (or Unlimited) Height District, designated on the Zone Map by (-3).
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1185.02 DISTRICT NO. 1.

   In a No. 1 Height District, the height of a building at the building line shall be limited to thirty-five feet.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1185.03 DISTRICT NO. 2.

   Except for a building designed for and occupied in whole or in part as a residence, in a No. 2 Height District, the height of a building at the building line shall be limited to fifty feet; but no portion of a building shall exceed in height one and one-half times the distance of that portion from the center of the street upon which the building is to face. In a No. 2 Height District, no building designed for and occupied in whole or part as a residence shall exceed thirty-five feet in height.
(Ord. 132-72. Passed 10-16-72.)

1185.04 DISTRICT NO. 3.

   Except for a building designed for and occupied in whole or in part as a residence, in a No. 3 Height District, the height of a building shall be limited to 100 feet; but no portion of a building shall exceed the height twice the distance of that portion from the center of the street upon which the building is to face. In a No. 3 Height District, no building designed for and occupied in whole or in part as a residence shall exceed thirty-five feet in height.
(Ord. 132-72. Passed 10-16-72.)

1185.05 HEIGHT DISTRICT EXCEPTIONS.

   The foregoing requirements in the height districts shall be subject to the following exceptions:
   (a)   In any height district the height limit may be exceeded by a tower, provided the area of its horizontal cross-section above the height limit does not exceed twenty-five percent of the ground area of the building of which it is a part and the tower is not nearer to any side lot line at the height limit than twenty-five feet.
   (b)   In any height district, penthouse, water tanks, cooling towers, ornamental towers, scenery lofts, radio towers, chimneys and other necessary appurtenances, when erected upon and as an integral part of the building, may be erected or extended above the height limitation of the district.
   (c)   Nothing in this Zoning Code shall prevent the projection of a cornice beyond the street wall to an extent not exceeding five percent of the width of the street nor more than five feet in any case.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)
   (d)   In residence districts, an accessory building shall not exceed fifteen feet in height at the highest point of the roof nor more than one story.
(Ord. 305-89. Passed 10-2-89.)
   (e)   In any height district, any radio tower or television tower or other structure erected under Section 1183.05, for use in connection with the operation of a radio station or television station or combined radio and television station, may be erected or extended above the height limit of the district in which it is located, and the tower shall not be subject to the provisions of subsection (a) hereof.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1185.06 HEIGHT REGULATIONS IN APARTMENT HOUSE DISTRICTS. (REPEALED)

   EDITOR'S NOTE: Former Section 1185.06 was repealed by implication by an ordinance initiated by the electors and adopted by them on November 2, 1971. This ordinance is codified as Section 1529.37.

1185.07 PROPERTY NOT CLASSIFIED AS TO HEIGHT DISTRICTS.

   Unless otherwise provided for in use district regulations, the height of any building upon property not classified as to a height district contained in this chapter, shall be limited to thirty-five feet.
(Ord. 132-72. Passed 10-16-72.)

1187.01 AREA DISTRICTS CLASSIFICATION.

   (a)   Minimum lot area requirements are as follows:
Area Designation on Zone Map
Minimum Lot Area per Dwelling Unit For Residential Types
Minimum Lot Size (Feet)
AA
20,000 sq. ft. 1-F
(without sanitary sewers)
(100 x 200)
12,000 sq. ft. 1-F
(with sanitary sewers)
(75 x 160)
A
15,000 sq. ft. 1-F
(without sanitary sewers)
(75 x 200)
9,000 sq. ft. 1-F
(with sanitary sewers)
(60 x 150)
B
15,000 sq. ft. 1-F
(without sanitary sewers)
   (75 x 200)
7,800 sq. ft. 1-F
(with sanitary sewers)
   (60 x 130)
4,800 sq. ft. 2-F
(with sanitary sewers)
Multiple dwelling (M-F):
(1)   2,400 sq. ft. for each 1 or 2-bedroom unit (with sanitary sewers)
(2)   3,000 sq. ft. for each 3-bedroom unit (with sanitary sewers)
(3)   3,600 sq. ft. for each 4-bedroom unit (with sanitary sewers)
(4)   4,200 sq. ft. for each unit with 5 or more bed rooms (with sanitary sewers)
C, D & E
(sewer available for all types)
6,000 sq. ft. 1-F
4,400 sq. ft. 2-F
Multiple dwelling (M-F):
(1)   2,400 sq. ft. for each 1 or 2-bedroom unit
(2)   2,900 sq. ft. for each 3-bedroom unit
(3)   3,400 sq. ft. for each 4-bedroom unit
(4)   3,900 sq. ft. for each unit having 5 or more bedrooms
 
   In the above schedule:
    1-F denotes one-family dwelling
   2-F denotes two-family dwelling
   M-F denotes multi-family building.
    (b)   No multiple dwelling shall be constructed upon any lot of land which is not improved by a sanitary sewer.
(Ord. 207-72. Passed 3-5-73.)

1187.02 AREA DISTRICT REGULATIONS.

   (a)   In an "AA" and "A" Area District in a Single or Two-Family House District, no building to be used as a residence shall be erected, altered or used for other than a dwelling house.
   In an "AA" and "A" Area District in any use district, no building or portion of a building to be used as a residence shall be erected, altered or used to accommodate or make provision for more than one family on an interior lot less than sixty feet wide nor for more than one family for each sublot as outlined in Section 1187.01.
(Ord. 371-02. Passed 12-9-02.)
    (b)   In a "B" Area District in a Single or Two-Family House District, no building to be used as a residence shall be erected, altered or used for other than a dwelling house.
   In a "B" Area District in any use district, no building or portion of a building to be used as a residence shall be erected, altered or used to accommodate or make provision for more than one family for each sublot, except that in any area district, other than an "A" Area District, residence for two families may be provided on any lot that was separately owned, or on any lot in a recorded subdivision that was on record on or prior to May 4, 1931.
    (c)   In a "C" or "D" Area District, no dwelling house or multiple dwelling shall be erected, altered or used to provide residence for more than one family for each sublot as outlined above.
    (d)   In computing the area of the lot for the purpose of this chapter, the area shall be considered as extending to the center of any abutting alley.
    (e)   For the purpose of this Zoning Code, a corner lot shall be considered as extending not farther than fifty feet from the side street line, measured at right angles thereto, nor greater in depth than three times the width.
    (f)   No yard or other open space provided about any building for the purpose of complying with the provisions of these regulations shall again be considered as the yard or other open space of any other building.
    (g)   Council may grant a variance in the lot area requirement on the recommendation of the City Planning Commission.
(Ord. 97-55. Passed 5-2-55.)
    (h)   Notwithstanding the requirements set forth in other sections of this chapter, in the development of an apartment project of two or more buildings, the creation of a single sublot for each building shall not be required.
(Ord. 210-63. Passed 10-7-63.)

1187.03 WIDTH AND DEPTH OF LOT IN RESIDENCE DISTRICTS. (REPEALED)

   (EDITOR'S NOTE: Section 1187.03 was repealed by Ordinance 349-94, passed November 21, 1994.)

1187.04 LANDSCAPED AREAS AND LOT COVERAGE FOR MULTIFAMILY DISTRICTS.

   (a)   Not less than fifty percent of the area of a lot, parcel or site upon which any apartment house building is situated shall be landscaped. Landscaped areas shall be construed to be those parts of such lot, parcel or site, exclusive of driveways, open parking areas and loading areas, developed with walks, terraces, recreation areas, lawns, shrubs, trees or other plantings.
    (b)   Not more than fifteen percent of the area of any lot, parcel or site upon which any apartment house building is situated shall be covered with buildings. The term "building," as used herein, includes each main building, accessory building and structure on such lot, parcel or site. The building coverage of any such lot, parcel or site shall be construed as the total area of the:
      (1)   Largest level (in area) of each main building;
      (2)   Ground level of each accessory building and structure; and
      (3)   Exposed roof of each accessory building or structure which extends beyond four feet from a building wall.
(Ord. 208-72. Passed 3-5-73; Ord. 234-91. Passed 12-2-91.)

1187.05 LOT WIDTH ABUTTING STREET.

   Each one and two-family lot shall abut upon a dedicated street equal to the required lot width, except that on curved streets, the width at the front line may be less, provided that the lot width at the building line meets the required lot width of the particular district.
(Ord. 311-95. Passed 2-5-96.)

1189.01 ERECTION OF BUILDINGS BETWEEN BUILDING LINE AND STREET.

   Between the front yard building line as established by this chapter and the street line, no building or portion of a building may be erected above the grade level, except as otherwise provided in this chapter.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1189.02 RESIDENCE DISTRICTS.

   In a residence district, front yard lines are hereby determined as follows:
   (a)   General Provisions. On any street frontage on either side of a street between two successive intersecting streets, but excluding the frontage along the side line of a corner lot, a line which is set back of the street line a distance equal to fifteen percent of the average or normal depth of the lots having their front lines along the street frontage, shall be the front yard line, but the distance such front yard line is back of the street line need not be more than thirty feet. Where, in any portion of the street frontage, there are lots of markedly less depth than the normal, the Board of Zoning Appeals in defining and applying this front yard line regulation may, when in its opinion the general purpose and intent of this chapter will be better served thereby, divide the street frontage into sections for the application of the above fifteen percent front yard line requirement.
   (b)   Existing Alignment. On a street frontage on either side of a street between two successive intersecting streets, but excluding the frontage along the side line of a corner lot, where twenty percent or more of the frontage is improved with buildings built back of the street line, the alignment of the existing buildings along the frontage shall, in the absence of a specific building line, be the front yard line.
   (c)   To the Street Line. On a street frontage on either side of a street between two successive intersecting streets, but excluding the frontage along the side line of a corner lot, where sixty percent or more of the frontage is improved with buildings that are built to the street line, and where no specific building line is indicated, the street line shall be the front yard line.
   (d)   Frontage on Public Park or Parkway. Where one or more lots front on a public park or parkway, such park or parkway shall be deemed a street frontage for the purpose of the said lines required by this chapter, and the line between the public park or parkway and the privately owned property fronting thereon shall be deemed a street line. This shall not serve to relieve the privately owned property of any other building line requirement.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1189.03 MULTIFAMILY DISTRICTS.

   Notwithstanding the requirements set forth in other sections of this chapter, front yards shall be established hereinafter in all Multifamily Districts as shown on the Zone Map or as described in future amendments.
(Ord. 210-63. Passed 10-7-63.)

1189.04 CORNER LOTS.

   (a)   Along the side line of a corner lot in a residence district, except as otherwise provided herein, the distance of the building line back from the side street line shall be ten percent of the average width of the lot, but the distance back from the side street line need not be more than five feet, nor more than the distance that the building line on the opposite side of the street is set back from the opposite street line.
   (b)   On the rear third of a corner lot in a Single or Two-Family House District, the building line shall be ten feet back from the side street line. In an "A" Single or Two-Family House District where the rear lot line of a corner lot is also the side line of the lot in the rear, the building line on the rear third shall be fifteen feet back from the side street line. However, no building line shall be required along the rear third of a corner lot in any use district where the rear of the lot adjoins a street frontage along which no building line is required by this Zoning Code.
   (c)   On the rear of a corner lot in any use district where the rear lot line thereof is also the side line of the butt lot in the rear upon which a setback building line is established, no building shall be erected nearer the side street at the rear line of the corner lot than the established building line of the butt lot. For each foot the building sets in from the rear lot lire or from the center of the rear alley, if any, it may set one foot nearer the street line, except as limited by subsections (a) and (b) hereof.
    (d)   At the intersection of a residence street with a street on which other than residence uses are also permitted, where the corner and/or succeeding lots were, at the time of the passage of this Zoning Code (Ordinance 42-55, passed February 21, 1955), platted to face the residence street and not more than the first three lots, aggregating a frontage of not more than 150 feet, are included within the less restricted district, the front yard line for the lots included within the less restricted district shall be a continuation of the front yard line of the residence portion of the block.
   (e)   In a use district other than a residence district or a Retail Business District, the building line requirements of this chapter, except in the case of a specific building line, shall not apply along the side line of a corner lot for the depth occupied by the corner building, but not farther than 150 feet from the building line along the front of the lot.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1189.05 USE DISTRICTS OTHER THAN RESIDENCE DISTRICTS.

   Whenever a chapter of this Zoning Code pertaining to a specific use district is silent as to the front yard building line, side street yard building line or other front yard or side street yard regulation or regulations, the provisions of this chapter as they relate to such matters in a residence district shall be applicable in such other use district, except that nothing herein contained shall be construed as to prohibit off-street parking where such parking is either permitted or required by any other provision of this Zoning Code.
(Ord. 101-70. Passed 12-21-70.)

1189.06 SPECIFIC BUILDING LINES; ANY USE DISTRICT.

   (a)   Where, on any street frontage in any use district, a specific building line is indicated on the Zone Map, such building line shall be the front or side street yard line of that street frontage.
   (b)   Where a specific building line is indicated on the Zone Map, but where sixty percent or more of the frontage between two successive intersecting streets, excluding the frontage along the side lines of corner lots, is improved with buildings that are nearer the street line than the specified line, the ground level story of a building may be extended out to the average line of the existing buildings on either side thereof, provided that no existing building be considered as being farther from the street line than the specific building line.
   (c)   Where specific building lines are indicated on the Zone Map for both the front and the side of a corner lot, the side street yard need not exceed ten percent of the width of the lot for the distance, not exceeding 150 feet back from the front building line, that is occupied by the corner building.
   (d)   Where a setback building line is required on a lot that adjoins a street frontage along which either no setback building line is required or a building line nearer to the street is provided, a building may be erected beyond the building line herein provided for the lot to a point midway between the building line and the building line along such adjoining frontage and extending not more than fifty feet from such less restricted frontage.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1189.07 OBSTRUCTION OF VIEW AT CORNER LOTS.

   On any corner lot on which a front yard line is established by this Zoning Code, no wall, fence or other structure shall be erected, and no hedge, shrub, tree or other growth shall be maintained, between the front yard line and the street line in such a manner as to obstruct the view of traffic across the corner.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1189.08 FRONT YARD LINE EXCEPTIONS.

   (a)   The subsequent widening of a street shall not serve to change the location of an established building line, except where it would lie within the new street.
   (b)   Whenever the plat of a land subdivision approved by the City Planning Commission and on record in the office of the County Recorder shows a setback building line along any frontage for the purpose of creating a front or side street yard, the building line thus shown shall, along the frontage, apply in place of any other yard line herein provided, except the specific building lines provided in Section 1189.06.
   (c)   Whenever any parcel of land now separately owned and which was so owned prior to the passage of Ordinance 1384 (May 4, 1931) or at the time of any amendment thereto requiring a deeper front or side yard line as to such parcel, is of such restricted dimensions that it cannot be appropriately improved without building beyond the front or the side street yard line established by this Zoning Code, the Board of Zoning Appeals may, on application in a specific case, authorize the construction of a building beyond the yard line to an extent necessary to secure an appropriate improvement of the parcel of land when not unreasonably injurious to other affected property or to the general interest of the City.
   (d)   Entrance canopies or similar overhanging roofed spaces covering not more than ninety- six square feet in area for each forty feet of lot frontage, porticos or bays projecting not more than eight feet, exclusive of cornices, and not wider than sixty percent of the width of the face of the dwelling, are exempt from the front or side street yard restrictions of this Zoning Code on buildings not nearer the right-of-way line than fifteen feet. Also, exempt are steps and landings below the level of the first floor and hedges, ornamental fences and walls not more than three feet, six inches high above the grade level.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55; Ord. 106-21. Passed 10-4-21.)

1191.01 RESIDENCE DISTRICTS.

   In a residence district, every main building shall have a rear yard the depth of which shall be not less than fifteen percent of the depth of the lot, not less than ten feet, except that in the case of any building more than two and one-half stories in height, the depth shall not be less than one-half the height of the building, but the depth need not be more than thirty feet. Forty percent of the area of a rear yard may be occupied by one-story buildings; however, no such one-story buildings shall be located nearer to any existing residence than ten feet, nor nearer to the front street line than 100 feet, except that where the depth of the lot is less than 121 feet, the rear of such one-story building shall be located no farther than three feet from the rear line. In case garages or other one-story buildings already exist on both adjoining properties closer to the street line than provided above, an applicant may be permitted to build in alignment with existing garages or other one-story buildings.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1191.02 RESIDENCE BUILDING IN ANY USE DISTRICT.

   In any district, any portion of a building used as a residence shall be provided with a rear yard. When the portion of a building used as a residence is above the ground floor, a rear yard shall be provided above the stories used for nonresidence purposes open and unobstructed for the full width of the lot and of a depth equal to that required for other yards, the height thereof being figured from the floor level of the residence part.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1191.03 LOADING SPACE IN ANY USE DISTRICT.

   In any use district, every building not used exclusively for residence purposes, or as accessory thereto, erected on any interior lot and extending back to any alley, or on a lot at the intersection of a street with an alley and having a portion of the building abutting on the alley, shall provide on the lot adequate space for the loading and unloading of trucks and commercial vehicles serving the building. The loading space, unless otherwise adequately provided for, shall include a rear yard space extending fourteen feet in height above the grade of the alley and twenty-five feet in depth back from the alley line along fifty percent of the alley frontage. The loading space requirements may be modified or waived by the Board of Zoning Appeals on application in the case of a bank, theater, assembly hall or other building of similar limited loading space requirements.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1191.04 MULTIFAMILY DISTRICTS.

   Notwithstanding the requirements set forth in other sections of this chapter, in the development of an apartment project of two or more buildings, the yards between buildings and the yards between any building and a side or rear lot line shall be designed and constructed in accordance with yard regulations set forth in Section 1193.03.
(Ord. 210-63. Passed 10-7-63.)

1193.01 RESIDENCE DISTRICTS; SPACE BETWEEN BUILDINGS.

   In a residence district, each main building shall have a yard along each side lot line. The sum of the widths of the side yards of an interior lot in a residence district shall be not less than ten feet at any point. No dwelling house shall be erected less than ten feet from any other building in a residence district.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1193.02 SINGLE OR TWO-FAMILY HOUSE DISTRICTS.

   In a Single or Two-Family House District, the interior side yard shall be not less than three feet at any point of a lot of less than sixty feet in width and not less than five feet at any point of a lot of sixty or more feet in width.
(Ord. 182-70. Passed 12-21-70.)

1193.03 MULTIFAMILY DISTRICTS.

   (a)   Minimum Distance Between Buildings. The minimum distance between any two multifamily dwellings or parts thereof in a development area will vary according to the length and height of buildings. Such minimum distance shall be determined by the following formula:
   Minimum distance (S) = LA + LB + HA + HB 
               f
the elements of such formula being defined as follows:
   "Minimum distance (S)" means the required minimum horizontal distance between any wall of building A and the nearest wall of building B or the vertical prolongation of either.
   "LA" means the total length of building A which, for the purposes of the formula, is defined as the length of the portion or portions of any wall or walls of building A from which lines drawn perpendicular to the face of such wall or walls will interest any wall of building B.
   "LB" means the total length of building B, which for the purposes of the formula, is defined as the length of the portion or portions of any wall or walls of building B from which lines drawn perpendicular to the face of such wall or walls will intersect any wall of building A.
   "HA" means the height of building A.
   "HB" means the height of building B.
   "f" means the division factor, which shall be:
         5 for multi-family - walk-up type
         3 for multi-family - elevator type.
   (b)   Minimum Distance Between Buildings and Side or Rear Lot Lines. A minimum distance between any multi-family dwelling or parts thereof in a development area and any side or rear line of the development area shall vary according to the length and height of the building. Such minimum distance shall be determined by the following formulas: Where land zoned as a Multifamily District abuts Single- Family or Two-Family Districts in AA, A, B, C or D areas:
         Minimum Distance = A + L + H
                   F
Where land zoned as a Multifamily District abuts all other zoned uses:
                  A + L + H
         Minimum Distance =       F   
                     2
the elements of such formula being defined as follows:
   A =    20 feet where the (L) is less than 50 feet and the (H) is less than 30 feet. In all other cases "A" shall be 50 feet.
   L =    length of the property line in feet measured between perpendicular lines to the property line where such perpendiculars touch the extreme ends of the building.
   H =    height of building in feet.
   F =    division factor from the schedules below.
Buildings whose length (L) is up to 100 feet and:
   the height (H) is up to 50 feet             F = 5
   the height (H) is 50.1 to 100 feet             F = 3
   the height (H) is 100.1 to 150 feet             F = 2
   the height (H) is 150.1 and up             F = 1.5.
Buildings whose length (L) is from 100.1 feet to 250 feet and:
   the height (H) is up to 50 feet             F = 3.5
   the height (H) is from 50.1 to 100 feet          F = 2.5
   the height (H) is from 100.1 and up             F = 1.5.
Buildings whose length (L) is 250 feet or more and:
   the height (H) is up to 50 feet             F =   2.5
   the height (H) is from 50.1 to 100 feet          F =    1.5
   the height (H) is from 100.1 feet and up          F=    1.
   When computing the setback formula for buildings of more than one wing, all wings that are within fifteen degrees of being perpendicular to the property line shall be considered as a separate building for measurement purposes.
   All attached wings that are not within fifteen degrees of the perpendicular to the property line shall be considered as one continuous building and the entire length between perpendicular lines to the property line shall be used for determining the length requirement of the formula.
   The required setback shall be measured from the wall plane or point that is the closest to the property line.
   Unless the foregoing formula provides for a greater minimum distance, if land zoned as a Multifamily District abuts a Single-Family or Two-Family District in an AA, A, B, C or D area, the minimum distance between any multi-family dwelling or part thereof located on such land zoned as a Multifamily District shall be no less than:
      (1)   Thirty-five feet from any side or rear line abutting any such Single-Family or Two-Family District if the height of such multifamily dwelling is up to thirty-five feet;
      (2)   Fifty feet from any side or rear line abutting any such Single-Family or Two- Family District if the height of such multifamily building is from thirty-five and one-tenth feet to fifty feet;
      (3)   125 feet from any side or rear line abutting any such Single-Family or Two- Family District if the height of such multifamily dwelling is from fifty and one-tenth feet to 100 feet.
   The rear and side yards shall be open and unobstructed from the ground to the sky and no structure, building or accessory use shall be permitted thereon.
(Ord. 449-69. Passed 10-19-70.)
   (c)   Distances from Main Buildings to Accessory Uses. The minimum distances from any multifamily building to parking areas, driveways, walks and recreation areas and to the development area boundaries, as set forth herein, are intended as desirable criteria and are to be applied in the site planning insofar as possible:
 
Minimum Distances (Feet)
From Apartment Buildings
From Boundary Line
Accessory Use
Main Wall
End Wall
Parking areas
20
20
20
Private streets
30
10
10
Walks (public use)
15
10
10
Recreation areas (active play)
40
30
15
 
   The minimum distances set forth in the above schedule are intended to be applied to:
            (1)   The main wall, meaning any exterior wall containing the principal windows of a living, dining or sleeping room or rooms.
            (2)   The end wall, meaning any exterior wall, other than a main wall, containing minor windows of a dining or sleeping room, or principal or minor windows of a kitchen or bathroom, or a blank surface.
            (3)   Private streets at all locations except at the garage entrance or main entrance of the dwelling served.
            (4)   Walks used by the public at all locations except at the entrance to the dwelling served.
            (5)   Recreation areas, meaning areas used for active play.
(Ord. 210-63. Passed 10-7-63.)

1193.04 ALLEYS ABUTTING RESIDENCE DISTRICTS.

   In a residence district, the half-width of an alley abutting the side line of a lot may be considered as part of the yard required on that side.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55. )

1193.05 WALLS OR FENCES IN RESIDENCE DISTRICTS. (REPEALED)

   (EDITOR'S NOTE: Section 1193.05 was repealed by Ordinance 83-85, passed July 15, 1985.)
FIGURE 1
(Class "E" Area District)

1195.01 RESIDENCES IN OTHER USE DISTRICTS; RESIDENCE DISTRICTS.

    A residence may be erected in the rear of another main building in any use district if the required front and rear yards are provided for each and a free and unobstructed entranceway not less than eight feet wide is provided as access to the rear house from the street or from an alley. For each family in excess of two to be provided for in the rear house, two feet more shall be added to the required eight feet, but the entranceway need not be wider than twenty feet. A front yard not less than twenty feet in depth across the full width of the lot shall be provided for the rear residence, which yard shall be independent of the rear yard, if any, required for the front building.
   A building other than a residence permitted in a residence district shall observe the same yard requirements as a residence, except as otherwise provided in this Zoning Code.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1195.02 PROJECTIONS.

   Cornices or eaves not more than two feet wide, or a bay, balcony or chimney not more than eighteen inches in depth, may project into any side or rear yard.
(Ord. 42-55. Passed 2-21-55.)

1196.01 INTENT.

   Sign regulations, including provisions to control the type, design, size, location and maintenance of signs, are hereby established in order to achieve, among others, the following purposes:
   (a)   To enable the public to locate goods, services and facilities without difficulty or confusion;
   (b)   To provide a safe environment by prohibiting conditions hazardous to vehicular and pedestrian traffic and by prohibiting signs which prevent police surveillance of commercial and industrial buildings;
   (c)   To protect property values and neighborhood character by prohibiting conditions which have undesirable impacts on adjacent development;
   (d)   To ensure that signs will be aesthetically harmonious with their surroundings and with an overall urban design for the area in order to further the other purposes of this chapter;
   (e)   To promote development and economic activity in accordance with the objectives of the Master Plan; and
   (f)   To ensure that the constitutionally guaranteed right of free speech is protected and to allow lawfully displayed signs as a means of communication.
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1196.02 APPLICATION OF CHAPTER.

   Signs shall be designed, erected, altered, moved and maintained, in whole or in part, in accordance with the regulations set forth in this chapter. The provisions of this chapter shall not govern the display of the following signs:
   (a)    Signs erected by the municipal, county, state and federal governments, the Greater Cleveland Regional Transit Authority (RTA), and all other signs regulating traffic and parking in the City;
   (b)   Signs which are part of the original construction of a vending machine, fuel pump or similar device;
   (c)   Any monument within a cemetery or grave markers;
   (d)   Cornerstones and permanent building plaques not displaying a commercial message and not exceeding eight square feet in area;
   (e)   Up to two signs, each not exceeding two square feet in area, displayed on a property with an individual single-family, two-family or townhouse dwelling;
   (f)   Holiday displays, excluding advertising;
   (g)   Messages displayed on vehicles regularly and customarily used to transport persons or property for a business;
   (h)   Works of art that do not include a commercial message;
   (i)   Signs that cannot be viewed from a public right-of-way or another property;
   (j)   Signs carried by a person; and
   (k)   Other signs determined by the Planning Commission to be outside this chapter's scope of regulation with respect to a reasonable and customary interpretation of the intent of this chapter.
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1196.03 DEFINITIONS.

   As used in this chapter, the terms listed below shall be interpreted according to the following definitions. Other terms shall be interpreted according to the definitions provided elsewhere in these Codified Ordinances or according to their ordinary English usage.
   (a)   “Banner sign.” A temporary, lightweight sign that is attached or imprinted on a flexible surface that deforms under light pressure and that is typically constructed of non-durable materials, including, but not limited to, plastic, cloth or cardboard.
   (b)   “Billboard.” A sign directing attention to a specific business, product, service, entertainment activity or other commercial activity sold, offered or conducted elsewhere than upon the lot on which the sign is located.
   (c)   “Canopy sign.” A sign displayed on the fascia or soffit of a canopy or covered entrance or displayed on a permanent awning or marquee.
   (d)   “Community facilities.” Public buildings, schools, religious institutions, hospitals, recreation centers, meeting halls, athletic fields, and similar uses as permitted in residential districts under the Zoning Code.
   (e)   “Development sign.” A temporary free-standing sign that does not exceed fifteen square feet in area per side and eight feet in height displayed on a property from the date that a binding contract exists for development of the property until the sooner of the date construction on the property has been completed or an occupancy permit has issued.
   (f)   “Electronic message center (EMC).” A digital sign whose variable message and/or graphics can be electronically changed by remote or automatic means. EMCs typically use light emitting diodes (LEDs) as a lighting source.
   (g)   “Entryway/exit sign.” A free-standing sign placed at an entry to or an exit from a lot or parcel of land.
   (h)   “Feather sign.” A type of temporary sign consisting of a piece of vertically elongated, flexible material such as cloth or vinyl which is affixed to a single pole driven in the ground. The pole may be rigid or flexible but is not permanent.
   (i)   “Flag.” A sign made of cloth or similar material, varying in size, shape, color, and design, attachable by one edge to a pole or rope and used as a symbol, signaling device, decoration, or to attract attention.
   (j)   “Flashing sign.” A sign illuminated by intermittent light in a manner designed to attract attention.
   (k)   “Free-standing sign.” A sign which is not attached to a building, and which is either attached directly to the ground or elevated on a supporting structure attached to the ground, including signs commonly known as pole signs, ground signs and monument signs.
   (l)   “Inflatable sign.” An air-supported, air-inflated or tension-membraned structured sign.
   (m)   “Monument sign.” A freestanding major sign having the appearance of a solid base of landscape construction materials such as brick, stucco, stonework, textured wood, tile or textured concrete materials compatible with the materials of the primary structure on the subject property.
   (n)   “Pennant.” A flag usually tapering to a point or swallowtail.
   (o)   “Portable sign.” A sign which is not permanently attached to any part of a building or to the ground and which is designed to be moved using only ordinary hand tools.
   (p)   “Projecting sign.” A sign erected on the outside wall of a building and projecting out at an angle therefrom.
   (q)   “Roof sign.” A sign erected upon and completely over the roof of any building, excluding an inflatable sign.
   (r)   “Sign.” Any visual communication designed to be seen from an outdoor location and used to convey a message.
   (s)   “Sign panel.” A structural object or portion of a structural object designed to form a distinct background area or frame for the display of a sign's information.
   (t)   “Temporary sign.” A sign displaying messages of a transitory or temporary nature and intended for use for a limited period of time.
   (u)   “Unit of a building.” In the determination of maximum sign face area, “unit of a building” or “building unit” refers to a space occupying a portion of the ground floor of a building, containing an entrance from the building exterior, and separated from other such spaces by a party wall or walls.
   (v)   “Wall sign.” A sign integral with the exterior face of an exterior wall of a building, structure or structural object, or attached to the wall and parallel with the wall and projecting not more than fifteen inches therefrom and not perpendicular to the surface of the wall.
   (w)   “Window sign.” A sign displayed on, directly behind or in front of a window or the glass portion of a door.
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1196.04 PERMITS; APPLICATIONS.

   An application for a permit to erect, place, display, alter, move or paint a sign, excluding alterations which do not alter the sign's copy, dimensions or location, shall be made by the owner or lessee of the property for which a sign is proposed or his or her agent. The application shall be submitted to the Building Department on forms furnished by the City and shall be made either separately or with the application for a permit for a building and otherwise in accordance with the Building Code. The fee shall be assessed pursuant to Section 185.04 of these Codified Ordinances.
   (a)   Permit Required. All signs not exempted under Section 1196.02 shall be subject to the applicable regulations regarding permitted types, number, area, height and location. Permits shall be required for all permanent and temporary signs with the exception of the following:
      (1)    Free-standing signs, window signs, wall signs, or flags with a noncommercial message displayed in any zoning district having a total sign face area of forty square feet for all sign faces visible from any point along the street frontage. Where a sign has two or more display faces, the area of all faces of the sign shall be included in determining the area of the sign, unless the two faces are joined back-to-back, are parallel to each other, are of equal size and are not more than sixteen inches apart, in which case one face shall be included in determining the area of the sign;
      (2)   A temporary sign that does not exceed six square feet in area per side and four feet in height displayed on a property with an individual single-family, two-family or townhouse dwelling, or a vacant property intended for such dwelling, that is offered for sale or lease; and
      (3)   Temporary window signs in Retail Business and Shopping Center Districts as provided for in this chapter.
   (b)   Contents of Applications. Each application shall present the following information through the use of photographs and drawings at a scale which clearly shows details and the design of the sign:
      (1)   The design and colored layout of each sign proposed, including the total area of all signs and the area, height, materials and type of lettering of individual signs;
      (2)   Photographs or drawings of the building for which the signs are proposed and photographs of surrounding buildings, signs and uses. Also included shall be the width of the building or building unit face and the lot dimensions for lots not occupied by buildings;
      (3)   The number and types of lamps and lens material to be used in any illuminated signs and data showing that the illumination meets the standards established in Section 1196.14(d);
      (4)   A site plan showing the exact location of each sign in relation to the building and property; and
      (5)   Details and specifications for construction, erection and attachment as may be required by this chapter, the Building Code, or other applicable provisions in these Codified Ordinances.
   (c)   Temporary Signs. Permits for temporary signs, where required, shall be issued for periods not exceeding sixty-two days, except that permits for development signs shall be issued for a period not exceeding one year and may be renewed while construction is diligently being pursued. Development signs shall be removed immediately upon placement of a permanent sign.
   (d)   Planning Commission Approval. Planning Commission approval shall be required for all signs within shopping centers and industrial parks and in all instances where compatibility in design is required in shopping strip areas. A shopping strip area is defined as an area that has four or more retail or commercial establishments abutting or adjoining each other. All other signs shall be approved by the Building Commissioner.
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1196.05 ZONING DISTRICTS CLASSIFICATION.

   (a)   District Classification. For the purposes of this chapter, all zoning districts shall be classified into the following groupings of zoning districts:
      (1)   Residential districts. “Residential districts” include the following zoning districts: Single-Family House Districts, Two-Family House Districts, Single-Family Cluster Districts and Multi-Family Residential Districts.
      (2)   Commercial districts. “Commercial districts” include the following zoning districts: Retail Business District, Office Building District, Shopping Center District, Automobile Parking District.
      (3)   Industrial districts. “Industrial districts” include the following zoning districts: Industrial Districts, Commercial-Manufacturing Districts, Industrial Park Districts and Research Manufacturing Districts.
   (b)   Mixed Use Districts. Signs for property uses in mixed use districts shall conform to sign regulations for the zoning district which corresponds to the property classification and characteristics.
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1196.06 SIGNS IN RESIDENTIAL DISTRICTS.

   Signs for uses in Single-Family House Districts, Two-Family House Districts, Single-Family Cluster Districts and Multi-Family Residential Districts shall be permitted in accordance with the following regulations.
   (a)   Permitted Types, Number, Area and Height. Signs in residential districts are permitted only in accordance with the regulations regarding maximum number, area and height as presented in the following schedule. Sign types not listed are prohibited. All signs are permanent unless listed as temporary.
   RESIDENTIAL DISTRICTS SCHEDULE OF PERMITTED SIGNS
 
1- & 2-Family
Single-Family Cluster
Multi-Family
Community Facilities
Free-Standing (major)
# - 1 per subdivision of at least 30 lots1 2
SF - 32
Ht - 5
# - 1 per dvlpmnt of at least 15 units1 2 
SF - 32
Ht - 5
# - 1 per lot1
SF - 20
Ht - 5
# - 1 per lot1
SF - 40
Ht - 5
Free-Standing (minor)
# - 2 per dwelling
SF - 2
Ht - 3
# - 1 per dwlg unit
SF - 2
Ht - 3
# 3 
SF - 2
Ht - 3
# 3 
SF - 4
Ht - 4
Wall (major)
not permitted
not permitted
# - 1 per main bldg
SF - 20
# - 1
SF - 20
Wall (minor)
# - 2 per dwelling
SF - 2
# - 1 per dwlg unit
SF - 2
# - 2 per main bldg
SF - 6
# - 2 per main bldg
SF - 6
Canopy
not permitted
not permitted
# - 1 per bldg
SF - 10
# - 1 per bldg
SF - 10
Temporary (free-standing or wall)
# - 2 per dwelling
SF - 6
Ht - 4
# - 1 per dwlg unit
SF - 6
Ht - 4
# - 1 per dwlg unit
SF - 6
Ht - 4
# - 1 per lot
SF - 6
Ht - 4
Portable
not permitted
not permitted
not permitted
# - 1 per lot
SF - 40 per face4
Ht - 6
Flags
# - 2 per lot
SF - 325
# - 2 per lot
SF - 325
# - 2 per lot
SF - 325
# - 2 per lot
SF - 325
Pennants
not permitted
not permitted
not permitted
permitted See 1196.13(f)
 
1 plus 1 additional sign for each 500 ft of street frontage.
2 EMCs are prohibited on lots with dwelling structures.
3 as necessary for traffic safety and public information, determined by City staff.
4 maximum of two (2) faces per sign.
5 cumulative SF of all permitted flags on lot.
# - Max number of signs ~ SF - Max sign face area (sq ft) per side ~ Ht - Max height (ft) for free-standing signs
 
   (b)   Location Regulations. Free-standing signs, as permitted in residential districts, shall conform with the location regulations presented in the following schedule.
   RESIDENTIAL DISTRICTS SCHEDULE OF LOCATION REGULATIONS
 
 
Minor Sign
Major Sign
Minimum Distance From
...........
...........
Lot lines, generally
5 feet
20 feet
Lines of right-of-ways
5 feet
5 feet
Lines of lots occupied by 1- and 2-family dwellings
10 feet
35 feet
 
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1196.07 SIGNS IN COMMERCIAL DISTRICTS.

   Signs for uses in Retail Business Districts, Office Building Districts, Shopping Center Districts, and Automobile Parking Districts shall be permitted in accordance with the following regulations.
   (a)   Permitted Types, Number, Area and Height. Signs by structural type are permitted only in accordance with the regulations regarding maximum number, area and height as presented in the following schedule. Sign types not listed are prohibited. All signs are permanent unless listed as temporary.
   COMMERCIAL DISTRICTS SCHEDULE OF PERMITTED SIGNS
 
Retail
Office
Shopping Center
Automobile Parking
Free-Standing (major)
# - 1 per lot1
SF - 40
Ht - 5
# - 1 per lot1 
SF - 40
Ht - 5
# - 1 per lot1
SF - 60
Ht - 5
# - 1 per lot1
SF - 20
Ht - 5
Free-Standing (minor)
# - 2 per lot entry/ exit
SF - 4
Ht - 3
# - 2 per lot entry/exit
SF - 4
Ht - 3
# - 1 per main bldg or bldg unit
SF - 4
Ht - 3
# - 1 per lot
SF - 4
Ht - 3
Wall (major)
# - 1 per bldg street frontage
SF - 10 + (W x 1.5)
# - 1 per bldg street frontage
SF - 10 + (W x 1.5)
# - 1 per bldg street frontage
SF - 10 + (W x 1.5)
# - 1 per street with vehicle entrance
SF - 6
Wall (minor)
# - 2/main bldg2
SF - 2
# - 2/main bldg2
SF - 2
# - 2/main bldg2
SF - 6
# - 2/main bldg2
SF - 2
Projecting
# - 1 per bldg or bldg unit3
SF - 12
not permitted
# - 1 per bldg or bldg unit3
SF - 12
not permitted
Canopy
# - 1 per bldg or bldg unit
SF - 20
not permitted
# - 1 per bldg or bldg unit
SF - 20
not permitted
Temporary (free-standing or wall)
# - 2 per lot
SF - 6
Ht - 4
# - 2 per lot
SF - 6
Ht - 4
# - 2 per lot
SF - 6
Ht - 4
# - 2 per lot
SF - 6
Ht - 4
Temporary (window)
SF - 25% of window area
SF - 25% of window area
SF - 25% of window area
SF - 25% of window area
Flags
# - 3 per lot
SF - 484
# - 3 per lot
SF - 484
# - 3 per lot
SF - 484
# - 3 per lot
SF - 484
Inflatable
permitted
See 1196.13(e)
not permitted
permitted
See 1196.13(e)
not permitted
Pennants
permitted
See 1196.13(f)
not permitted
permitted
See 1196.13(f)
not permitted
 
1 plus 1 additional sign for each 500 ft of street frontage.
2 as necessary for traffic safety and public information, determined by City staff.
3 with a minimum setback of 20 ft from lot lines and building unit dividing lines.
4 cumulative SF of all permitted flags on lot.
# - Max number of signs ~ SF - Max sign face area (sq ft) per side ~ Ht - Max height (ft) for free-standing signs ~ W - width of bldg or unit frontage
 
   (b)   Location Regulations. Free-standing signs, as permitted in commercial districts, shall conform with the location regulations presented in the following schedule.
   COMMERCIAL DISTRICTS SCHEDULE OF LOCATION REGULATIONS
 
 
Minor Sign
Major Sign
Minimum Distance From
...........
...........
Lot lines, generally
5 feet
20 feet
Lines of right-of-ways
5 feet
5 feet
Lines of lots occupied by 1- and 2-family dwellings
10 feet
50 feet
 
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1196.08 SIGNS IN INDUSTRIAL DISTRICTS.

   Signs in Industrial, Industrial Park, Commercial-Manufacturing and Research-Manufacturing Districts shall be permitted in accordance with the following regulations.
   (a)   Permitted Types, Number, Area and Height. Signs by structural type are permitted only in accordance with the regulations regarding maximum number, area and height as presented in the following schedule. Sign types not listed are prohibited. All signs are permanent unless listed as temporary.
   INDUSTRIAL DISTRICTS SCHEDULE OF PERMITTED SIGNS
 
Industrial
Industrial Park
Commercial - Manufacturing
Research - Manufacturing
Free-Standing (major)
# - 1 per lot1
SF - 100
# - 1 per lot1 
SF - 100
# - 1 per lot1
SF - 40
# - 1 per lot1
SF - 100
Free-Standing (minor)
# - as necessary2
SF - 4
Ht - 3
# - as necessary2
SF - 4
Ht - 3
# - as necessary2
SF - 4
Ht - 3
# - as necessary2
SF - 4
Ht - 3
Wall (major)
# - 1 for each street frontage w/ vehicular entrance
SF - (W x 1)+15
# - 1 for each street frontage w/vehicular entrance
SF - (W x 1)+15
# - 1 for each street frontage w/ vehicular entrance
SF - (W x 1)+15
# - 1 for each street frontage w/ vehicular entrance
SF - (W x 1)+15
Wall (minor)
# - as necessary2
SF - 4
# - as necessary2
SF - 4
# - as necessary2
SF - 4
# - as necessary2
SF - 4
Temporary (free-standing or wall)
# - 2 per lot
SF - 6
Ht - 4
# - 2 per lot
SF - 6
Ht - 4
# - 2 per lot
SF - 6
Ht - 4
# - 2 per lot
SF - 6
Ht - 4
Temporary (window)
SF - 25% of window area
SF - 25% of window area
SF - 25% of window area
SF - 25% of window area
Flags
# - 3 per lot
SF - 483
# - 3 per lot
SF - 483
# - 3 per lot
SF - 483
# - 3 per lot
SF - 483
Pennants
permitted
See 1196.13(f)
permitted
See 1196.13(f)
permitted
See 1196.13(f)
permitted
See 1196.13(f)
Billboards
# - 1 per lot
SF - 3004
Ht - 255
   not permitted
# - 1 per lot
SF - 3004
Ht - 255
   not permitted
 
1 plus 1 additional sign for each 500 ft of street frontage.
2 as necessary for traffic safety and public information, determined by City staff.
3 cumulative SF of all permitted flags on lot.
4 Limited to 12 feet in vertical dimension and 25 feet in horizontal dimension.
5 Maximum height of free-standing billboard above the grade of the street to which sign is oriented.
# - Max number of signs ~ SF - Max sign face area (sq ft) per side ~ Ht - Max height (ft) for free-standing signs ~ W - width of building or unit frontage
 
   (b)   Location Regulations. Free-standing signs, as permitted in industrial districts, shall conform with the location regulations presented in the following schedule.
   INDUSTRIAL DISTRICTS SCHEDULE OF LOCATION REGULATIONS
 
 
Minor Sign
Major Sign
Minimum Distance From
...........
...........
Lot lines, generally
5 feet
20 feet
Lines of right-of-ways, generally
5 feet
10 feet
Lines of right-of-ways, Commercial-Manufacturing
5 feet
5 feet
Lines of lots occupied by 1- and 2-family dwellings
10 feet
50 feet
 
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1196.09 MEASUREMENT STANDARDS.

   Sign area, sign location and building frontage, as regulated in this chapter, shall be measured according to the following standards. The graphics shown in this section are for illustration purposes only.
   (a)   Sign Area - Eight-Line Method. The face area of signs shall be measured using a maximum of eight straight, right-angled lines to determine the smallest geometric shape (squares or rectangles) that will enclose all extreme points of a sign. A sign's extremity includes any letters, figures, symbols, logos, trademarks, pictures and design elements, together with all framing, nonstructural trim, background material, colored or illuminated areas and attention-attracting devices forming an integral part of a sign's composition.
         Illustrations submitted must be drawn to scale and the scale identified on the drawings, such as one-inch equals one foot. Number the drawings accordingly from one to eight. Use charts to convey exact dimensions and show all mathematical calculations.
 
 
   (b)   Wall Sign Area. Wall signs having no visible boundary, border or clearly defined background shall have the spaces between letters, words, logos or other sign elements intended to be read together and any device intended to draw attention to the sign included in the computation of overall sign area. Such uncontained or undefined sign spaces may be excluded from the calculation of sign area if the width of the building façade on which the wall sign is located is greater than three times the sign's width.
 
   (c)    Window Sign Area. Window sign area is measured using the eight-line method described in division (a) of this section for each individual sign, or by multiplying the full width of the overall sign copy (lettering, logo, graphics) by the overall height of the sign copy in a rectangular manner (A = W x L), regardless of the arrangement of the copy.
 
         Window area shall be measured to include all windows and the glass portions of doors. Each facade or side of the building shall be considered separately. Window area can be an individual pane of glass, or a contiguous area of glass separated by nonstructural elements of dissimilar (non-glass) material or by structural materials. Windowpanes separated by muntins or mullions are not to be counted separately but included in the calculation of the cumulative window area.
 
 
   (d)   Multifaced Sign Area. Only one side of a double-sided sign arranged back-to-back or V-shaped sign is calculated provided the distance between the two faces is less than two feet apart. Where two sides are not of equal size, the larger of the two sides is measured. Where the sign faces are more than two feet apart all sides are calculated to determine sign area.
 
   (e)   Spherical and Three-Dimensional Sign Area. Signs that are spherical or have three-dimensional objects that project less than eight inches from the sign support structure shall be measured as a flat sign. Signs that project more than eight inches from the sign support structure shall be measured using the smallest two-dimensional geometrical shape or shapes which will best approximate the greatest actual sign area visible from any one direction.
   (f)   Awning and Canopy Sign Area. The sign area on awnings and canopies attached to a building shall include all sign elements (copy, striped graphics, patterns, etc.) and all areas that are translucent when illuminated. When the ends of awnings are parallel and contain a sign or are translucent, only one side is counted in addition to the front.
 
 
      Signs on all sides of a free-standing canopy structure are calculated.
 
   (g)    Free-standing Sign Area. Sign area does not include sign support posts or poles that are clearly incidental and are used only to support the sign cabinets, panels or nonstructural trim or serve another permitted purpose separate from the sign, such as a retaining wall, fence or other structure.
         The height of free-standing signs shall be measured from the base of the sign at its highest point of attachment to the ground to its topmost element. The first twelve inches in vertical height above grade is not included when calculating the sign area of a free-standing sign provided it does not contain sign copy; the first twelve inches is considered necessary to elevate the sign above grade or to provide a sign base for a monument type sign
         Support structures or bases that exceed the allowed number, width or height, or that serve a purpose unrelated to supporting a sign, shall be considered part of the sign's background and included in the calculation of sign area.
   (h)   Sign Location. In determining the location of signs in relation to lot lines (including district and street right-of-way lines), distances shall be measured from the vertical projection of the lot line to the closest point on the sign. For corner lots, two lot lines shall be considered street right-of-way lines.
   (i)   Building Frontage. The frontage of a building shall be the width of the above ground facade of the building, excluding any roof overhang or nonbearing decorative wall, which faces the principal street or contains the main entrance. If a building is divided into units, the building unit frontage shall be the width of that unit, as measured from the party wall centerline, on the frontage of the building.
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1196.10 PLACEMENT REGULATIONS.

   The following regulations regarding the location of signs are generally applicable to all land use categories. Regulations regarding the location of free-standing signs in relation to lot lines are found in Sections 1196.06 through 1196.08 concerning particular zoning districts and land use categories.
   (a)   Vertical Clearance. The following regulations shall apply to any sign which occupies the vertical space above a pedestrian or vehicular way and which is designed to permit traffic thereunder. The lowest member of such sign shall be at least eight feet above the finished grade of a sidewalk or other pedestrian way and at least fifteen feet above the finished grade of a pavement used for vehicular traffic if such sign is located within eighteen inches of the vertical projection of the pavement edge.
   (b)   Relation to Traffic Devices. Unless regulated otherwise in the Traffic Code of the City, signs shall not be erected so as to obstruct sight lines along any public way or so as to obstruct sight lines to traffic control lights, street name signs at intersections or signals at railroad grade crossings. Signs visible from the sight lines along a street shall not resemble highway traffic signs or devices or interfere with the effectiveness of any traffic sign or device.
   (c)   Wall Signs. A wall sign shall not extend above or beyond the wall to which it is attached, and such a sign shall be set back from the ends of the building and party wall lines a minimum distance of three feet. This setback shall be a minimum of two feet for buildings or building units with a principal facade less than sixteen feet in width. Wall signs shall fit within any given frame of the architectural space intended for signage.
   (d)   Canopy Signs. A sign which is attached to the fascia of a canopy shall not extend beyond the edges of that surface.
   (e)   Public Property; Utility Pole. Unless approved by the City in a particular location, no private sign shall be placed in or upon any public property, including but not limited to any park, public grounds, sidewalk, tree lawn, street or highway, or utility pole. The City shall remove and dispose of any sign in violation of this section. The penalty for violation of this section is a minor misdemeanor.
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1196.11 DESIGN STANDARDS.

   In order to facilitate information, legibility, traffic safety and general economic vitality, signs shall be designed in a manner compatible with the character and style of the buildings on which they are located and with the character and style of adjoining buildings and neighboring signs, in terms of color, materials and size. More specifically, signs shall be designed in accordance with the following standards.
   (a)   Lettering. The lettering on a sign shall be large enough to be easily read, but not overly large or out of scale with the building upon which it is placed. Visual clutter that could create a potential safety hazard to motorists or pedestrians shall be avoided.
   (b)   Free-Standing Signs. Sign panels on free-standing signs shall face not more than two directions and such panels shall be in parallel arrangement or v-shaped. The distance between parallel, back-to-back sign panels shall be not greater than three feet.
   (c)   Temporary Window Signs. Temporary signs displayed on window areas shall be clustered into one or more groups, where feasible, so that relatively large sections of window area remain uncovered.
   (d)   Supporting Structure. The structural support of a free-standing sign shall not be designed or used in any part as a sign or in conveying the sign's message. Free-standing signs are permitted a maximum of two supporting posts or poles. Sign support posts or poles shall be less than two feet in width and one foot in height.
   (e)   Materials. Signs shall be fabricated on and of materials which are of good quality, good durability. Outdoor signs and display structures, including the supporting structure and all parts, shall be of noncombustible material when required by the Building Code. Wood, approved plastic or other material not more combustible than wood or approved plastic may be permitted by the Building Commissioner in the following locations:
      (1)   For small ornamental moldings, cappings, nailing strips, individual letters, symbols, figures and insignia; and
      (2)   On the face of a sign, provided that the aggregate area of such facing for any sign shall not exceed 100 square feet.
   (f)   Structural Design. The construction, erection, safety and maintenance of all signs shall be in accordance with the Building Code and state regulations. All signs and supporting structures shall be designed and constructed to withstand a wind pressure of not less than twenty pounds per square foot of net surface area, allowing for wind from any direction.
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1196.12 PROHIBITED SIGNS.

   The following types of signs are not permitted in any zoning district:
   (a)   Feather signs, as defined in Section 1196.03;
   (b)   Flashing, revolving, moving scrolling, traveling, spinning, rotating, fading, dissolving or any other moving effects, and all dynamic frame effects and patterns of illusionary movement or simulated movement, other than electronic message centers as specifically permitted in Section 1196.13(c) and digital billboards as specifically permitted in Section 1196.13(b);
   (c)   Roof signs;
   (d)   Any sign displayed on a parked trailer or truck or other vehicle that is not routinely used for transportation purposes between the hours of 6:00 a.m. and 12:00 midnight so that the primary purpose of the vehicle is to display a message or to advertise a product, service, business, or other activity; and
   (e)   Signs displayed on bollards.
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1196.13 SPECIFIC SIGN TYPES REGULATED.

   The display of the following sign types shall be governed by the regulations in this section in addition to other applicable regulations of this chapter.
   (a)   Portable Signs.
      (1)   Location. Portable signs shall be set back at least five feet from street right-of-way lines and twenty feet from side lot lines.
      (2)   Illumination. No flashing or changing lights may be used to illuminate portable signs. All permitted lighting shall be shielded from motorists and adjoining properties.
      (3)   Safety standards. All wiring shall be located underground or in other locations not constituting safety hazards, as determined by the Building Commissioner. Signs shall be designed and placed to withstand customary wind pressures, as determined by the City Engineer.
      (4)   Period of display. A use or group of uses occupying one lot shall not display portable signs for a period of more than sixty-two days during any calendar year.
   (b)   Billboards.
      (1)   Sign types. Billboards shall be permitted as either free-standing or wall signs and may be equipped with Tri-Vision or other similar automatic changeable copy, including electronic digital displays. No other sign shall be displayed on the side of a building which includes a wall displaying a billboard.
      (2)   Location. Billboards shall be located behind the building lines of the lots on which they are located. In addition, billboards exceeding two square feet in area shall be located a minimum distance of twenty-five feet measured in any direction from the point of intersection of the street lines of two intersecting streets. No billboard shall be located less than 200 feet from a residential zoning district.
      (3)   Spacing. The minimum distance permitted between billboards located on one side of a road shall be 500 feet.
      (4)   Digital billboards shall conform to the display standards for electronic message center signs set forth in division (c) of this section.
   (c)   Electronic Message Centers.
      (1)   EMC signs shall be permitted as either monument signs or major wall signs.
      (2)   EMC signs must have automatic brightness controls, either by photocell (hardwired) or via software, that are keyed to ambient light levels in order to bring the EMC lighting levels into compliance with division (c)(3) of this section.
      (3)   EMC signs may not exceed a maximum luminance level of 250 cd/m2 or Nits during nighttime beginning fifteen minutes before apparent sunset and ending fifteen minutes after apparent sunrise, as determined by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and the U.S. Naval Observatory (USNO) for the U.S. Eastern Time Zone (DST). At other times, EMC signs may not exceed a maximum luminance level of 5,000 cd/m2 or Nits.
      (4)   EMC signs shall have a minimum display time of eight seconds. The transition time between messages and/or message frames is limited to one second.
      (5)   The following EMC display features and functions are prohibited: scrolling, traveling, flashing, spinning, rotating, fade, dissolve, any other moving effects, and all dynamic frame effects or patterns of illusionary movement or simulated movement.
      (6)   EMC signs shall be turned off promptly in the event of a malfunction.
   (d)   Flags.
      (1)   Flags may be displayed on any property without the need to obtain a permit subject to the limitations set forth in this chapter.
      (2)   Flags may be mounted on or hung from the structure, or mounted on a single flagpole not exceeding the building height. Flags must be located on-site and must not be located within any street right-of-way (which includes the entire public sidewalk and street terrace area), or vision triangle.
      (3)   In residential districts, flags that display a commercial message are prohibited.
      (4)   In non-residential districts, flags that display a commercial message are permitted, but the area of such flags shall be included in determining the maximum allowable area of signage on the property.
   (e)   Inflatable Signs.
      (1)   The company which installs inflatable signs must be a properly licensed contractor in the City.
      (2)   Construction, erection, safety and maintenance of all inflatable signs shall be in accordance with the Building Code and state regulations, including the Ohio Fire Code and the O.B.C.
      (3)   Inflatable signs shall be secured in an approved manner so as not to encroach upon the air rights of adjoining properties.
      (4)   Inflatable signs shall not be installed below or within ten feet horizontally of any electrical conductors, phone conductors, CATV conductors, fire alarm conductors or any other similar installations.
      (5)   The inflatable structure shall be ground-mounted or attached to supports and guy wires ground-mounted or securely attached to the building roof. No inflatable structure will be permitted to be secured to any mechanical equipment, parapet walls or other items normally found on the roof of a structure.
      (6)   The location of the inflatable structure shall not create a nuisance to adjacent or surrounding properties.
      (7)   Each applicant must pay a fee according to Section 185.04 of these Codified Ordinances and obtain a proper sign permit according to Section 1196.04.
      (8)   Each applicant who uses an inflatable sign is limited to no more than four times per year.
      (9)   The duration of each inflatable display will not exceed thirty days.
      (10)   Each applicant who uses an inflatable sign is required to wait at least thirty days before a subsequent use.
      (11)   No inflatable shall be permitted within a one-mile radius of another inflatable.
      (12)   Signage on the inflatable shall be limited to no more than two lines of advertising.
   (f)   Pennants. The display of banner signs, or strings of pennants, streamers, pinwheels, balloons and similar objects shall be prohibited except as permitted for carnivals and open-air festivals and for new businesses for a single period not exceeding sixty-two days within the first six months after issuance of the initial occupancy certificate for a new business.
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1196.14 SUPPLEMENTAL REGULATIONS.

   The following supplemental regulations shall apply to permitted signs in non-residential zoning districts:
   (a)   Secondary Frontages/Entrances. A building or building unit with frontage on a second street or with a customer building entrance from a rear or side parking lot shall be permitted total additional wall, window, projecting and canopy sign area not to exceed fifty percent of the sign area otherwise permitted. Such signs shall be displayed so that the total sign area placed on any facade does not exceed the maximum sign area permitted for the building's primary frontage.
   (b)   Non-Ground Floor Uses. For uses not located on the ground floor and for ground floor uses which lack direct access from the building exterior, regardless of the number of such uses, the following signs shall be permitted. Not more than one wall sign, a maximum of fifteen square feet in area, shall be placed at each ground floor entrance providing access to the uses in question. The area and number of such signs shall be permitted in addition to the signs otherwise permitted for the building or units thereof.
   (c)   Shopping Centers. A shopping center, as defined in Section 1121.45, occupying one lot or under common ownership and exceeding 100,000 square feet in gross floor area, shall be permitted, in addition to other permitted signs, one free-standing sign not exceeding 100 square feet in area per side and six feet in height, located at a vehicular entrance to the shopping center. A second such sign shall be permitted at a vehicular entrance to the shopping center if such entrance is separated by at least 500 feet, measured along street lines, from the closest other entrance to the shopping center. No other free-standing sign shall be permitted within the shopping center property, other than permitted minor signs.
   (d)   Illumination. Light sources to illuminate signs, where lighting is permitted in this chapter, shall be shielded from all adjacent residential buildings and streets and shall not be of such brightness or intensity so as to cause glare hazardous to pedestrians or auto drivers, or so as to cause reasonable objection from adjacent residential districts. Except as provided in Section 1196.13 (b) for digital billboards and Section 1196.13 (c) for electronic message centers, flashing, moving or intermittent illumination shall not be permitted. In residential districts, only permitted electronic message center signs, nameplates and bulletin boards may be illuminated. All signs in districts other than residential districts may be illuminated.
   (e)   Gasoline Service Stations. Signs for gasoline service stations shall conform with all regulations of this chapter except for those which directly conflict with the following regulations:
      (1)   Free-standing signs. Each station shall be permitted one permanent free-standing sign, not exceeding thirty-two square feet in area and six feet in height.
      (2)   Signs at service islands. Stations shall also be permitted signs at fuel pumps or other service islands, provided the messages displayed on such signs are not legible from the public right-of-way or another property. The number, area and height of such signs shall be as determined by the Planning Commission.
      (3)   Canopies. For canopy structures which shelter service islands, one sign not exceeding twenty square feet shall be permitted on each canopy fascia that faces a public street. The canopy fascia area shall be non-illuminated and shall be designed in a manner which does not call attention to the canopy structure.
      (4)   Other signs. Each station shall be permitted two wall signs not exceeding fifty square feet in total area and not exceeding fifteen square feet for any single sign. Temporary signs shall be displayed only as window signs and shall cover not more than twenty-five percent of the window area.
   (f)   Theaters. The following regulations shall apply to indoor and outdoor movie theaters, playhouses and places of live entertainment. Signs for such uses shall conform to all regulations of this chapter, except for those which directly conflict with the following regulations:
      (1)   Wall and canopy signs. Such uses shall be permitted wall or canopy signs with a maximum combined area of 250 square feet.
      (2)   Free-standing signs. If permitted by other regulations of this chapter, a theater or similar use may display a free-standing sign with a maximum area of fifty square feet. If such sign is displayed, the maximum area permitted, above, for wall and canopy signs shall be reduced to 200 square feet.
      (3)   Drive-in theaters. Drive-in theaters and other uses which lack buildings appropriate for sign placement may be permitted one free-standing sign by the Planning Commission. The maximum area of such sign shall be 150 square feet.
      (4)   Other signs. Such uses shall be permitted directional and information signs as permitted for other retail uses.
   (g)   New Businesses. Upon its initial opening, a new business establishment may display a temporary sign for a maximum period of sixty-two days prior to the installation of a permitted permanent sign. Such temporary sign shall be a wall or window sign, shall conform with all regulations applicable to permanent signs, except clearly inapplicable structural requirements, and shall be counted as part of the maximum permitted permanent sign area.
   (h)   Open Lots. For uses without buildings, and for uses on lots where building frontage in less than twenty percent of lot frontage, maximum sign face area for the use, including free-standing signs, shall be the greater of fifty square feet or the figure resulting from the following formula where “LW” equals the width of the front lot line, as defined in Section 1121.28: LW x 1.0 = SQUARE FEET OF SIGNAGE. The area of a free-standing sign shall in no instance exceed 100 square feet.
   (i)   Outdoor Tobacco Advertising. No person shall display an outdoor advertising sign for a tobacco product if the advertising message can be viewed within 1,000 feet of any church, library, park, playground, school or childcare center. Any retail establishment licensed to sell tobacco products shall be exempt from this section.
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1196.15 MAINTENANCE AND REMOVAL OF SIGNS.

   (a)   Permanent Signs. All permanent signs and sign structures shall be maintained in a safe and attractive condition, in accordance with the following regulations.
      (1)   Permanent signs and sign structures which no longer serve the purpose for which they were intended or which have been abandoned or are not maintained in accordance with the Building Code, Zoning Code and other applicable regulations of the City shall be removed by the last permit holder, by the building owner or by the City at the expense of such individual.
      (2)   Whenever the removal or maintenance of any permanent sign or sign structure has been ordered by the Building Commissioner, and the person who was ordered to remove the permanent sign or sign structure fails to remove or maintain the sign within forty-eight hours after receiving such notice, the Building Commissioner may remove or cause to be removed or maintained such sign at the expense of the person who erected such sign or on whose premises it was erected, affixed or attached. Each such person shall be individually and separately liable for the expenses incurred in the removal of such sign.
   (b)   Temporary Signs. All temporary signs and sign structures shall be maintained in a safe and attractive condition in accordance with the following regulations.
      (1)   Temporary signs shall include those signs defined in Section 1196.03 and any other sign intended for use for a limited period of time.
      (2)   Temporary signs in violation of this chapter shall be removed immediately, without notification to the owner. Such signs shall be taken to the City garage for storage. A notice shall be sent to the permit holder or, if no permit has been issued, to the address on the sign or for which the sign is posted. The owners or permit holders shall have five business days to reclaim the sign(s). Before the sign(s) are returned, the owner or permit holder shall pay any expenses associated with the removal and notification process.
      (3)   In addition to the costs mentioned in division (b) hereof, whoever violates this section is guilty of a minor misdemeanor and shall be fined not more than one hundred dollars ($100.00). A separate offense shall be deemed committed each day during or on which a violation occurs or continues.
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1196.16 NONCONFORMING SIGNS.

   (a)   Generally. A permanent sign, nonconforming as to the regulations prevailing on the effective date of this section (Ordinance 153-22, passed 9-18-2023), but previously lawfully erected in accordance with a City permit, shall be construed as a legal nonconforming sign. A permanent sign conforming as to the regulations prevailing on such effective date but which does not conform with the regulations of a subsequent amendment also shall be construed as a legal nonconforming sign.
   (b)   Maintenance, Repair and Alteration. Except as permitted in this division, a nonconforming sign shall not be altered or moved unless it is made to comply with this chapter. If any sign or part thereof is removed, destroyed or damaged to fifty percent or more of the current cost to replace the sign, including labor and materials, it shall not be rebuilt or relocated unless it is made to comply with this chapter. The addition of an EMC sign to any nonconforming sign is prohibited. Legal nonconforming signs may be maintained, repaired or altered only in the following instances:
      (1)   Routine maintenance and the repair of structural and electrical parts as required by law;
      (2)   Change of copy or sign face on bulletin boards, billboards and other signs that may lawfully display changeable copy under the provisions of this chapter; and
      (3)   Replacement of the face of a wall sign if the face is encased in a structure which is consistent in size and appearance with all other such structures in a unified shopping area.
   (c)   Discontinuance of Use. A nonconforming sign, the use of which is discontinued for a period of thirty days or more, shall thereafter conform to the regulations of this chapter.
   (d)   Temporary Signs. All nonconforming temporary signs shall be removed or made to comply with this chapter. In no circumstances shall temporary signs be considered legal nonconforming signs.
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1196.17 CONFLICTS, SEVERABILITY, SUBSTITUTION.

   (a)   Conflicts. Any and all provisions contained elsewhere in these Codified Ordinances, controlling or purporting to control signs or their installation, are hereby abrogated and repealed.
   (b)   Severability. If any provision or portion of this chapter or rules adopted hereunder is invalidated by any court of competent jurisdiction, the remaining provisions or portions will not be affected, impaired or nullified and will continue in full force and effect.
   (c)   Substitution. The owner of any sign which is otherwise allowed by this Code may substitute non-commercial copy in lieu of any other commercial or non-commercial copy. This substitution of copy may be made without any additional approval or permitting. The purpose of this provision is to prevent any inadvertent favoring of commercial speech over noncommercial speech or favoring of any particular non-commercial message over any other non-commercial message. This provision prevails over any more specific provision to the contrary.
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1196.99 PENALTY.

   Notwithstanding any other provision of this chapter, whoever violates any of the provisions of this chapter is guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree. A separate offense shall be deemed committed each day during or on which a violation occurs or continues.
(Ord. 153-22. Passed 9-18-23.)

1197.01 PURPOSES.

   Off-street parking and off-street loading requirements and regulations are established to achieve, among others, the following purposes:
   (a)   To relieve congestion so that the streets can be utilized more fully for movement of traffic;
   (b)   To promote the safety and convenience of pedestrians and shoppers by separating parking areas and extensive car movements in the vicinity of pedestrian ways;
   (c)   To protect adjoining residential neighborhoods from vehicular traffic congestion; and
   (d)   To promote the general convenience, welfare and prosperity of residential, business, service and manufacturing developments, which depend upon off-street parking and off-street loading facilities.
(Ord. 254-91. Passed 12-16-91.)

1197.02 PARKING FACILITIES REQUIRED.

   Off-street parking facilities shall be provided as a condition precedent to occupancy of a residential, institutional, business, service or industrial use, in conformance with the provisions of this chapter.
   Facilities shall be provided for the entire building or use:
   (a)   Whenever a building is constructed or a new use is established;
   (b)   Whenever an existing building is altered and there is an increase in the number of dwelling units, seating capacity and/or floor areas of a building;
   (c)   Whenever the use of an existing building is changed to a use requiring more off-street parking facilities.
(Ord. 254-91. Passed 12-16-91.)

1197.025 AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT REQUIREMENTS.

   Construction and alterations of new parking areas and access to and from parking areas for commercial, office, institutional and public uses should conform to the standards of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), which became effective January, 1992. The law requires that all goods and services shall be made available to persons with disabilities. Copies of regulations and guidelines may be obtained from the Office on the Americans with Disabilities Act, and specific information about requirements for accessible design may be obtained from the U.S. Architectural and Transportation Barrier Compliance Board.
(Ord. 368-02. Passed 11-5-04.)

1197.03 UNOBSTRUCTED CONTINUATION OF FACILITIES; AUTOMOBILE SALES OR REPAIR; FACILITY SIZE REDUCTION.

   All existing off-street parking facilities, and those required as accessory to a use of a proposed or altered building, shall continue unobstructed, shall not be used for sale, service or repair of automobiles and shall not be used as off-street loading facilities. They shall not be reduced below the required size as long as the main use is maintained, unless an equivalent number of spaces are provided for such use in another approved location.
(Ord. 254-91. Passed 12-16-91.)

1197.04 DEFINITIONS; MEASUREMENT STANDARDS.

   For the purpose of determining accessory off-street parking requirements, definitions and measurement standards shall be as follows:
   (a)   "Accessory parking space" means an open or enclosed area (garage) directly accessible from a public street for parking of motor vehicles of owners, patrons, occupants, employees, customers or tenants of the main building or use. Each space shall be directly accessible from a drive or aisle and shall have a minimum rectangular dimension of not less than nine and one-half feet in width and nineteen feet in length for ninety degree parking; nine and one-half feet in width and twenty-two feet in length for parallel parking; nine and one-half feet in width and nineteen feet in length for sixty degree parking; and nine and one-half feet in width and nineteen feet in length for forty-five degree parking, exclusive of all drives, aisles, ramps and other circulation areas, and determined from an accurate plan of the area.
   (b)   "Floor area" means the total area of the floors of the building measured from the exterior faces of the building. Basement areas or other floors, or parts thereof, designed, arranged or used exclusively for storage or similar uses, may be excluded from the floor area measurement if the areas or floors, or parts thereof, are not open to the public. Areas such as stairs, hallways, restrooms, equipment rooms, furnace rooms, elevator shafts, etc., shall be excluded.
   (c)   "Gross floor areas," for the purpose of loading requirements, means the total floor areas used for the main and accessory activities and the storage areas of the building served.
   (d)   "Seat" means the number of seating units installed or indicated, each twenty-four linear inches of benches, or space for loose chairs or similar seating facilities. Spacing of rows shall be thirty inches on center.
   (e)   "Employee," for purposes of computing the parking requirements based on employees, means the maximum number of employees on duty on the premises at one time or on any two successive shifts, whichever is the greater.
   Where a computation results in a fractional unit, one additional space shall be provided.
(Ord. 254-91. Passed 12-16-91.)

1197.05 SCHEDULE OF REQUIRED PARKING.

   Off-street parking facilities shall be provided in accordance with the following schedule.
   A building occupied by one use shall provide the off-street parking spaces as required for the specific use. A building, or group of buildings, occupied by two or more uses, operating normally during the same hours, shall provide spaces for not less than the sum of the spaces required for each use, provided, however, that if a business development is comprised of 12,000 square feet or more of building area, the required spaces may be computed for the total area of the building, or buildings, as set forth in items 28 through 32 of the following schedule, unless otherwise specified.
Building or Use
Required Minimum Parking Space
Building or Use
Required Minimum Parking Space
Residential
1.   One and two-family dwellings
2 spaces per dwelling unit
2.   Rooming houses and rented rooms
1 space per each roomer, plus 2 spaces for the resident family
3.   Multifamily dwellings
2 spaces per dwelling unit
4.   Hotels, motels and tourist homes
1 space per guest room or suite, plus 1 space for each 2 employees
Institutions
5.   Hospitals, recovery care centers, nursing homes/assisted living facilities and sanitariums
1 space per 2 beds, plus 1 space for each employee, plus 1 space for each doctor assigned to the staff
6.   Clinics
1 space per 100 sq. ft., plus 1 space per employee or doctor
7.   Places of worship
1 space per each 4 seats in an auditorium or assembly room, whichever is larger
8.   Public buildings, including Municipal and educational buildings, libraries and museums
1 space per full-time employee, plus 1 space per 4 seats in an auditorium and assembly room, plus drop-off zone
9.   Libraries and museums
1 space per employee, plus 1 space per 300 sq. ft., plus drop-off zone
10.   School buildings
1 space per full-time employee, plus 1 space per 4 seats in an auditorium and assembly room, plus drop-off zone
11.   Senior citizen homes and centers
1 space per unit, plus 1 space per 2 employees or 2 doctors
12.   Day care centers and private schools
1 per 400 sq. ft.
Amusements and Assembly
13.   Theatres, lodge halls, auditoriums, arenas, stadiums and other places of assembly
1 space per 4 seats in a building or structure plus 1 space per each 2 employees, or 1 space per 35 sq. ft. plus 1 space per employee, whichever is the greater
14.   Skating rinks and swimming pools
1 space per 50 sq. ft. of area used for assembly skating or swimming, plus 1 space per 2 employees, plus drop-off zone
15.   Bowling alleys
5 spaces per lane
16.   Mortuaries
1 space per 50 sq. ft. of assembly rooms, plus 1 space for each 2 employees, minimum 30 spaces
17.   Golf courses
7 per hole
18.   Driving range
1.5 per tee
19.   Banquet halls, party centers and dance halls
1 space per 35 sq. ft., plus 1 space per employee
20. Tennis, handball, raquetball courts
4 per court
21.   Health Club
1 per 200 sq. ft.
Business (Small Development)
   The following schedule shall apply if a development comprises less than 12,000 square feet of building area:
22.   Medical and dental offices and clinics
1 space per 100 sq ft.
23.   Furniture, appliance, equipment and wholesale, retail stores
1 space per 200 sq. ft.
24.   Drugstores
1 space per 200 sq. ft. plus 5 stacking spaces for the drive-through window
25.   Professional and other office buildings and service establishments
1 space per 200 sq. ft. plus 1 space per 350 sq. ft. on upper floors
26.   Banks
1 space per 200 sq. ft. plus 6 stacking spaces for the first drive-through window plus 2 spaces for each additional window
27.   Eating places, bars and taverns
1 space per 50 sq. ft. plus 10 stacking spaces for drive-through window
28.   Barber and beauty shops and tanning salons
1 space per 200 sq. ft.
Auto Business - Sales and Service
29.   Auto wash establishments
1 space per employee, plus a 40 car waiting zone comprised of at least 2 lanes
30.   Self-service auto washes
1 space per employee, plus a stacking area of 3 cars per bay and drying area of 1 car per bay
31.   Gasoline stations with car wash
1 space per employee, plus a 5 car waiting zone
32.   Motor vehicle sales establishments
1 space per employee, plus 10% of available floor area used in display of motor vehicles, but at least a minimum of 15 space requirement
33.   Motor vehicle services establishments
4 spaces per bay, plus 1 space per employee
34.   Gas station mini-marts
1 space per employee, plus 1 space per 200 sq. ft., but at least a minimum of 5 spaces
Business (Large Unit Development) 
The following schedule shall apply if a development comprises 12,000 square feet or more of building area:
35.   A retail center with an available lot size of less than 200,000 sq. ft.
See shopping centers below
36.   A plaza center with an available lot size of 200,000 to 1,000,000 sq. ft.
See shopping centers below
37.   A shopping center with an available lot size of over 1,000,000 sq. ft.
See shopping centers below
38.   A shopping center mall with an available lot size of over 1,000,000 sq. ft.
See shopping centers below
39.   Shopping Centers: 12,000 sq. ft. to 600,000 sq. ft. building area
4.25 spaces per 1,000 sq. ft. between 12,000 sq. ft. and 600,000 sq. ft.
40.   Shopping Centers over 600,000 sq. ft. building area
4 spaces per 1,000 sq. ft. over 600,000 sq. ft.
41.   Manufacturing plants, commercial, industrial and general service establishments, laboratories, storage facilities, machine shops and similar establishments
1 space per each employee or 1 space per 850 sq. ft. whichever is greater, plus a minimum 5 visitor spaces
42.   Warehouses
1 space per employee or 1 space per 1,000 sq. ft. whichever is greater, plus a minimum 5 visitor spaces
 
   Other Buildings or Uses
43.   For a specific building or use not scheduled above, the Building Commissioner shall apply the unit of measurement of the above schedule deemed to be most similar to the proposed building or use. All parking changes must be noted and approved by the Planning Commission and then approved by Council.
(Ord. 254-91. Passed 12-16-91; Ord. 368-02. Passed 11-15-04.)

1197.06 COMBINED USE OF FACILITIES.

   A building or group of buildings, occupied by two or more uses, operating normally at different hours, may share the same off-street parking facilities. For this purpose, institutions, places of amusement or assembly (items 5 to 9, inclusive, of the schedule provided in Section 1197.05) may assume that up to, but not more than, fifty percent of their off-street parking facility requirements may be shared in adjacent parking areas which are accessory to business establishments and which normally have different hours of operation, provided, however, that where there is a sharing of facilities by different owners, there shall be a contract covering a period of time as may be required by the Planning Commission, and, further, that should any of the uses be changed or the facilities discontinued, then the required spaces for the use or uses remaining shall be provided elsewhere as a condition precedent to the continued use of such building.
(Ord. 254-91. Passed 12-16-91.)

1197.07 LOCATION OF FACILITIES.

   All parking facilities, except those accessory to one or two-family dwellings, shall be developed so that such parking space is directly connected to an aisle or private driveway and arranged so that all vehicles can be driven forward into a street. Facilities shall be located as follows:
   (a)   Residential Districts and Uses. Enclosed or open parking facilities shall be located on the same lot as the dwelling served. Garages and open parking facilities accessory to one and two-family dwellings shall also comply with regulations set forth in this chapter. Enclosed or open parking facilities accessory to multifamily dwellings shall also comply with the regulations set forth in this chapter.
   (b)   Institutional, Amusement and Assembly Uses. Accessory parking facilities shall be provided on the same lot as the institution or place of amusement or assembly served (items 5 to 10, inclusive, of the schedule provided in Section 1197.05). Where no such adjacent land is available, the Planning Commission may approve parking facilities on an adjacent lot if such facility is located within an average walking distance of 250 feet of the entrance of the building served.
   (c)   Business Districts and Uses. Accessory parking facilities shall be located on the same lot or a lot adjacent to the use served and within an average walking distance of 200 feet of the building or use served. However, in the general business districts, where it may not be feasible to provide parking facilities within such locations, and where private fee lots or public lots are available, the Planning Commission may modify the requirements set forth in the schedule provided in Section 1197.05.
   (d)   Commercial-Manufacturing and Industrial Districts and Uses. Accessory parking facilities shall be located on the same lot as the main use served. However, where land is not available on the same or an adjacent lot, the facilities shall be developed so that the parking lot shall be within an average walking distance of 400 feet from the building or use served.
(Ord. 254-91. Passed 12-16-91.)

1197.08 ACCESS DRIVEWAYS.

   (a)   The location, width and number of entrance and exit driveways to accessory parking facilities, except for one-family and two-family dwellings, shall be located in such a manner as to interfere as little as possible with the use of adjacent residential property and the flow of traffic on adjacent streets. For parking areas having a capacity of ten or more vehicles, the centerline of the driveway apron shall be located not less than seventy-five feet from the nearest street intersection right-of-way line. Each driveway apron location shall be approved by the Planning Commission after consideration of each of the above factors.
   (b)   Parking areas having a capacity of twenty spaces or less shall have at least one single-lane driveway. Those having a capacity of more than twenty vehicles shall have two one-lane driveways if possible, or at least one two-lane driveway. Any entrance or exit driveway shall not exceed three lanes in width.
   (c)   The width of driveways shall conform with the following schedule:
 
Lanes
Driveway Width
Minimum (ft.)
Maximum (ft.)
One
10
12
Two
18
24
Three
27
34
 
   (d)   The radius of the edge of the driveway apron shall be at least thirty feet so that a vehicle may enter from or exit onto the curb lane without obstructing vehicles in other traffic lanes.
   (e)   The aforesaid location and width of access driveway regulations shall also apply to driveways for "drive-in" roadside businesses, fee parking lots and public parking lots.
(Ord. 254-91. Passed 12-16-91.)

1197.09 SURFACE CONSTRUCTION; IMPROVEMENTS; GRADING; DRAINAGE PLANS; CURBS.

   All parking areas and access driveways for use by the general public, such as rental and customer parking lots, office building lots, etc., shall be constructed of a bituminous macadam surface over a prepared base of adequate bearing strength approved by the City Engineer. The owner shall maintain the bituminous macadam surface by repairing any disintegration of the surface by patching or resealing, when such disintegration takes place, at his own expense. The above specifications are minimum and a higher class of pavement may be constructed at the owner's expense. All parking areas shall be graded to provide drainage so that damage will not occur to adjacent properties and so that water will not drain across a public sidewalk. All drainage plans must receive the approval of the City Engineer.
   All parking areas shall require concrete six-inch curbs around the parking area to prevent vehicles from projecting into required yards and public rights-of-way and to define parking areas.
(Ord. 254-91. Passed 12-16-91; Ord. 368-02. Passed 11-15-04.)

1197.10 LIGHTING OF PARKING AREAS.

   Parking areas shall be thoroughly illuminated whenever necessary to protect the public safety. Such illumination shall be so designed and located that light sources are shielded from adjoining residential districts and streets, and shall not be of excessive brightness or cause a glare hazardous to pedestrians or auto drivers.
(Ord. 254-91. Passed 12-16-91.)

1197.105 MAINTENANCE OF PARKING AREAS.

   No owner of an office, business, facility, or parking garage shall fail to maintain clearly marked parking lines in accordance with Section 1707.14 and Section 351.04.
(Ord. 10-00. Passed 9-18-00.)

1197.11 LOADING AND UNLOADING FACILITIES.

   Loading and/or unloading facilities shall be provided for all business, service, commercial and industrial buildings hereafter erected or altered for such uses. The facilities shall be maintained so long as the building is occupied, shall continue unobstructed and not be used for repairing or servicing motor vehicles. Space required and allocated for off-street parking shall not be allocated or used to satisfy the space requirements for off-street loading. Loading spaces shall be constructed as follows:
   (a)   Location of Loading Spaces. All required loading spaces shall be located on the same lot as the use served and arranged so that a public street or sidewalk will not be occupied during the loading or unloading process. Such spaces may be open or enclosed. They shall not be located in any required yard or less than fifty feet from a residential district.
   (b)   Access Driveways. Each required off-street loading space shall be designed for direct access to a street or alley in a manner so as to cause the least possible interference with traffic movements on the street. All open off-street loading spaces and driveways shall be provided with surface improvements as required for parking areas in Section 1197.09.
   (c)   Size of Loading Space. A required off-street loading space shall be at least twelve feet wide by at least twenty-five feet in length for buildings with less than 15,000 square feet of gross floor area, and each required loading space for a building with 15,000 square feet or more of floor area shall be not less than twelve feet wide by fifty feet in length. Each space shall have a vertical clearance of at least fourteen feet. The above areas shall be in addition to aisle and maneuvering space. Uses for which off-street loading facilities are otherwise required, but which are located in buildings of less than 5,000 square feet of floor area, shall be provided with a receiving platform or other facilities adjacent to a service drive or other open space on the same lot.
   (d)   Schedule of Requirements. Loading facilities shall be provided in accordance with the following schedule:
Building or Use
Gross Floor Area of Building (sq. ft.)
Required Number
of spaces
Retail stores - all types
5,000 to 10,000
1
10,001 to 40,000
2
40,001 to 100,000
3
Each add. 50,000
1 add. space
All commercial, manufacturing and industrial establishments
Up to 40,000
1
40,001 to 100,000
2
Each add. 50,000
1 add. space
 
(Ord. 254-91. Passed 12-16-91.)

1197.115 DRIVE-THROUGH FACILITIES.

   A minimum of sixty feet is required from the service window to the right-of-way. A drive-through lane (or queuing lane) shall be a separate lane from the circulation lanes and aisles necessary for entering and exiting the property. Drive-through lanes shall be ten feet wide and distinctly marked by special striking to ensure that access to parking spaces or exits is not adversely affected.
(Ord. 368-02. Passed 11-15-04.)

1197.12 APPROVAL OF PLANS.

   Detailed drawings of all multifamily, institutional, commercial and industrial developments shall be submitted for approval to the Planning Commission before an application for a building permit is approved, except that such drawings are not required for development of one and two-family dwellings. The Commission may require reasonable structural or landscape features, such as walls, fences, shrubs, ground cover or hedges, together with the installation of such identifying signs for commercial, industrial, office, institutional and multifamily uses as may, in the opinion of the Commission, be necessary to further the intent and purpose of the Master Plan or of this Zoning Code. The Commission shall not fail or refuse to approve drawings submitted hereunder which show the proposed development to be in compliance with all applicable ordinances of the City and regulations and statutes of the State.
(Ord. 254-91. Passed 12-16-91.)

1197.13 REQUIRED TRASH COLLECTION AREAS.

   (a)   All general business uses that provide trash and/or garbage collection areas that are not within a building or closed structure shall be enclosed on all four sides, three sides enclosed by a solid wall or fence, and the fourth side enclosed by a gate. All sides of the enclosure shall be at least six feet in height. The gate side of the dumpster enclosure shall be closed at all times except during trash collection. Provisions for adequate vehicular access to and from such area or areas for collection of trash and/or garbage shall be required .
   (b)   All businesses using trash and/or garbage collections areas prior to the effective date of Ordinance No. 131-25 shall comply with the provisions of this section whenever the surface of parking areas or access driveways used by such businesses is more than fifty percent improved, repaired, replaced, or altered. The provisions of this section shall not apply to recycling bins for paper material or to donation boxes as defined in Chapter 1707 of these Codified Ordinances .
   (c)   All updated enclosed trash collection areas shall:
      (1)   Have walls made of blocks or vinyl/metal fencing planks designed and arranged in such a way that it fully obscures the contents; and
      (2)   Have installed internal bollards or similar supports to ensure stability and functionality of the screening;
      (3)   Have a fifteen foot long pad concrete approach equal to the width of the enclosure.
   (d)   (1)   For lots 15,000 square feet and above, the enclosure shall be set back twenty feet from any residential property line, five feet from any non-residential property line, and subject to any Planning Commission amendments; and
      (2)   For lots less than 15,000 square feet, the enclosure shall be placed as far from residential property lines as is practicable and is subject to review and approval by the Building Department required.
(Ord. 254-91. Passed 12-16-91; Ord. 131-25. Passed 9-15-25.)

1197.14 PERMIT APPLICATION; SPACE REQUIREMENTS; DESIGN STANDARDS.

   (a)   Application for Providing Facilities. Any application for a permit to construct a building or parking area, or for a certificate of occupancy for a change in the use of land or a building, shall include a site plan drawn to scale and fully dimensioned, showing the proposed design of the parking area and loading facilities to be provided in compliance with the provisions of the chapter.
   (b)   Determination of Required Parking Facilities. The minimum number of spaces required for accessory off-street parking shall be determined by applying the measurement units provided in Section 1197.04, the parking area design standards provided in subsection (c) hereof and the schedule of parking requirements for the various uses provided in Section 1197.05 and any other applicable provisions of this chapter. Where the computation results in a fractional space, it shall be counted as one additional space required.
   (c)   Parking Area Design Standards. The plan for parking spaces of a parking area included with an application to construct a building or parking area, or for a change in use, shall be designed and dimensioned in accordance with the drawing provided below:
Parking Area Design Standards
 
 
Off-Street Parking
Parking Angle
45
60
90
Parallel
Stall Width
9'
9'
9'
9'
Stall Length
19'
19'
19'
22'
Aisle Width
13'
18'
24'
12'
 
(Ord. 254-91. Passed 12-16-91; Ord. 368-02. Passed 11-15-04.)

1197.15 PAINTING OF OBSTRUCTIONS.

   (a)   All establishments that own, control or maintain an off-street parking facility shall paint any poles, guardrails or similar obstructions that are located within the off-street parking facility and would interfere with the operation of vehicular traffic.
   (b)   Such obstruction shall be painted in either a solid white or traffic yellow color.
   (c)   If such obstruction exceeds six feet in height, then only the lower six feet, measured from ground level, is required to be painted pursuant to this section.
(Ord. 16-93. Passed 3-15-93.)

1198.01 DEFINITIONS.

   As used in this chapter, the terms listed below shall be interpreted according to the following definitions. Other terms shall be interpreted according to the definitions provided elsewhere in these Codified Ordinances or according to their ordinary English usage.
   (a)   Collocation. The use of a wireless telecommunications facility by more than one wireless telecommunications provider.
   (b)   Lattice Tower. A support structure constructed of vertical metal struts and cross braces forming a triangular or square structure which often tapers from the foundation to the top.
   (c)   Monopole. A support structure constructed of a single, self-supporting, hollow metal tube securely anchored to a foundation.
   (d)   Open Space. Land devoted to conservation or recreational purposes and/or land designated by a municipality to remain undeveloped (may be specified on a zoning map).
   (e)   Telecommunication. The technology which enables information to be exchanged through the transmission of voice, video, or data signals by means of electrical or electromagnetic systems.
   (f)   Wireless Telecommunications Antenna. The physical device through which electromagnetic, wireless telecommunications signals authorized by the Federal Communications Commission are transmitted or received. Antennas used by amateur radio operators are excluded from this definition.
   (g)   Wireless Telecommunications Equipment Shelter. The structure in which the electronic receiving and relay equipment for a wireless telecommunications facility is housed.
   (h)   Wireless Telecommunications Facility. A facility consisting of the equipment and structures involved in receiving telecommunications or radio signals from a mobile radio communications source and transmitting those signals to a central switching computer which connects the mobile unit with the land- based telephone lines.
   (i)   Wireless Telecommunications Tower. A structure intended to support equipment used to transmit and/or receive telecommunications signals, including monopoles and guyed and lattice construction steel structures.
(Ord. 399-96. Passed 4-14-97.)

1198.02 GENERAL REQUIREMENTS.

   The following requirements apply to all wireless telecommunications facilities regardless of the zoning district in which they are to be located. These general standards are to be supplemented with the specific regulations for nonresidential and residential districts as set forth in Sections 1198.03 and 1198.04.
   (a)   When the proposed wireless telecommunications facility is to include a new tower, a plot plan at a scale of not less than one inch is equal to 100 feet shall be submitted. This plot plan shall indicate all building uses within 300 feet of the proposed facility. Aerial photos and/or renderings may augment the plot plan.
   (b)   The location of the tower and equipment shelter shall comply with all natural resource protection standards established in this Zoning Code, including those for floodplain, wetlands, and steep slopes.
   (c)   Security fencing eight feet in height shall surround the tower, equipment shelter, and any guy wires, either completely or individually as determined by the Planning Commission.
   (d)   A landscaped buffer area of not less than ten feet in depth shall be placed between the wireless telecommunications facilities, the public rights-of-way, residential zoning districts, and any adjacent residential uses. The ten-foot landscape buffer shall consist of a tight screen fence of hardy evergreen shrubbery not less than six feet in height.
   (e)   Existing vegetation (trees and shrubs) shall be preserved to the maximum extent possible.
   (f)   Any applicant requesting permission to install a new tower shall provide evidence of written contact with all wireless telecommunications service providers who supply service within a quarter mile of the proposed facility. The applicant shall be required to collocate at all technically feasible locations. The existing providers shall be required to respond in writing to the inquiry within thirty days. The applicant's letter(s) as well as responses shall be presented to the Planning Commission as a means of demonstrating the need for a new tower.
    (g)   Any application to locate an antenna on a building or structure that is listed on an historic register or is in an historic district shall be subject to review by the municipality's Architectural Review Board or Building Commissioner if there is no such review board.
    (h)   The tower shall be painted a noncontrasting gray or similar color minimizing its visibility, unless otherwise required by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) or the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA).
    (i)   No advertising is permitted anywhere on the facility, with the exception of identification signage.
   (j)   All providers utilizing towers shall present a report to the Building Commissioner notifying the Building Commissioner of any tower facility located in the Municipality whose use will be discontinued and the date this use will cease. If at any time the use of the facility is discontinued for 180 days, the Building Commissioner may declare the facility abandoned. (This excludes any dormancy period between construction and the initial use of the facility.) The facility's owner/operator will receive written notice from the Building Commissioner and instructed to either reactivate the facility's use within 180 days, or dismantle and remove the facility. If reactivation or dismantling does not occur, the Municipality will remove or will contract to have removed the facility and assess the owner/operator the costs.
    (k)   No tower under 150 feet shall be artificially lighted except to assure safety or as required by the FAA. Any tower between 150 and 200 feet in height shall follow safety marking and obstruction lighting as prescribed by the FAA. Security lighting around the equipment shelter is permitted.
   (l)   Towers and antennas shall be designed to withstand sustained winds of at least 100 miles per hour.
   (m)   "No Trespassing" signs shall be posted around the facility with a telephone number of who to contact in the event of an emergency.
   (n)   Applicants will provide evidence of legal access to the tower site, thereby maintaining this access regardless of other developments that may take place on the site.
   (o)   A conditional use permit must be approved by City Council with a subsequent building permit issued by the Building Commissioner for construction of new towers in nonindustrial districts. Collocation of antennas on a single tower, antennas attached to existing structures/buildings, towers located in industrial districts, or replacement towers to be constructed at the site of a current tower, are permitted uses and will not be subject to the conditional use permitting process.
   (p)   Any decision to deny a request to place, construct, or modify a wireless telecommunications antenna and/or tower shall be in writing and supported by evidence contained in a written record of the proceedings of the Planning Commission.
   (q)   Underground equipment shelters are encouraged, especially in nonindustrial districts, and may be requested by the Planning Commission.
    (r)   The applicant must provide written certification from a registered engineer that the antenna and/or tower are to be constructed in compliance with all applicable Federal, State, and local regulations pertaining to the construction.
   (s)   A proposed new tower in a nonresidential district shall not be located within 1,000 feet from any residential zoning district or from any residentially used property.
   (t)   There shall be a separation of at least one quarter mile between new wireless telecommunications towers. The Planning Commission may waive this requirement for wireless telecommunications towers associated with or within existing structures, such as electrical high-tension towers.
(Ord. 399-96. Passed 4-14-97.)

1198.03 NONRESIDENTIAL DISTRICTS.

    Wireless telecommunications facilities proposed for industrial, commercial, and institutional zoning districts are subject to the following conditions:
   (a)   Sole Use on a Lot. A wireless telecommunications facility is permitted as a sole use on a lot subject to the following:
      (1)   Minimum lot size - 30,000 square feet
      (2)   Minimum yard requirements
         New Tower: The minimum distance to any single-family or two-family residential use or district lot line shall be 1,000 feet.
          Equipment Shelter: Right-of-way - 50 feet Front/Rear/Side - 15 feet
       (3)   Maximum height:
          Tower: 200 feet (includes antenna)
         Equipment Shelter: 15 feet
      (4)   Maximum size of equipment shelter - 300 square feet for a single shelter, or, if there is more than one, 750 total square feet
    (b)   Combined With Another Use. A wireless telecommunications facility is permitted on a property with an existing use subject to the following conditions:
      (1)   The existing use on the property may be any permitted use in the district or any lawful nonconforming use, and need not be affiliated with the wireless telecommunications provider. The wireless telecommunications facility will not be considered an addition to the structure or value of a nonconforming use.
      (2)   The wireless telecommunications facility shall be fully automated and unattended on a daily basis and shall be visited only for periodic and necessary maintenance (except during construction or an emergency).
       (3)   Minimum lot area - The minimum lot area shall be the area needed to accommodate the tower (and guy wires, if used), the equipment shelter, security fencing, and buffer planting.
       (4)   Minimum yard requirements -
         New Tower: The minimum distance to any single-family or two-family residential use or district lot line shall be 1,000 feet.
         Equipment Shelter: shall comply with the minimum setback requirements for the primary lot.
       (5)   Access - The service access to the equipment shelter shall, whenever feasible, be provided along the circulation driveways of the existing use.
       (6)   Maximum height
         Tower: 200 feet (includes antenna)
         Equipment Shelter: 15 feet
      (7)   Maximum size of equipment shelter-300 square feet for a single shelter, or, if there is more than one, 750 square feet
   (c)   Combined With an Existing Structure. Where possible, an antenna for a wireless telecommunications facility shall be attached to an existing structure or building subject to the following conditions:
      (1)   Maximum height - 10 feet or 10% of the building height above the existing building or structure, whichever is greater.
      (2)   If the applicant proposes to locate the telecommunications equipment in a separate shelter (not located on or attached to the building), the shelter shall comply with the following:
         A.   The minimum setback requirements for the subject zoning district.
         B.   A buffer yard may be planted in accordance with Section 1198.02(d).
         C.   Vehicular access to the shelter shall not interfere with the parking or vehicular circulation on the site for the principle use.
         D.   The maximum size of the equipment shelter shall not exceed 300 square feet, or, if there is more than one, 750 total square feet.
(Ord. 399-96. Passed 4-14-97.)

1198.04 RESIDENTIAL DISTRICTS.

   Wireless telecommunications facilities that include towers are not permitted in single-family or two- family residential districts; with the exception of placement on any property with an institutional use (e.g., church, park, library, municipal/government, hospital, school, utility) located in either of these two districts. However, antennas attached to existing buildings or structures are permitted. In applying for a permit in any residential district, the applicant must present substantial evidence as to why it is not technically feasible to locate in a more appropriate nonresidential zone. Once those efforts have been exhausted, a wireless telecommunications facility may be located in a residential district subject to the following conditions:
   (a)   Fully Automated; Unattended. The wireless telecommunications facility shall be fully automated and unattended on a daily basis and shall be visited only for periodic and necessary maintenance. This shall also apply to subsections (b) to (e) hereof.
   (b)   Combined With Nonresidential Use. An antenna may be attached to a nonresidential building or a structure that is a permitted use in the district; including, but not limited to a church, a municipal or governmental building or facility, agricultural building, and a building or structure owned by a utility.
      The following conditions shall be met:
      (1)   Maximum height: ten feet above the existing building or structure.
      (2)   If the applicant proposes to locate the telecommunications equipment in a separate shelter, the shelter shall comply with the following:
         A.   The shelter shall comply with the minimum setback requirements for the subject zoning district.
         B.   The maximum size of the equipment shelter shall be 300 square feet, or, if there is more than one, 750 total square feet.
         C.   A buffer yard shall be planted in accordance with Section 1198.02.
         D.   Vehicular access to the shelter shall not interfere with the parking or vehicular circulation on the site for the principal use.
   (c)   Located on a Nonresidential Use Property. A tower to support an antenna may be constructed on a property with a nonresidential use that is a permitted use within the district, including, but not limited to, a church, hospital, school, municipal or government building, facility or structure, agricultural use and utility use, subject to the following conditions:
      (1)   The new tower shall be set back from any property line abutting a single-family or two-family residential lot by 1,000 feet.
      (2)   The maximum height of the tower shall be 200 feet (includes antenna) The maximum height of the equipment shelter shall be fifteen feet.
      (3)   The maximum size of the equipment shelter shall be 300 square feet, or, if there is more than one, 750 total square feet.
      (4)   Vehicular access to the tower and equipment shelter shall, whenever feasible, be provided along the circulation driveways of the existing use.
      (5)   In order to locate a telecommunications facility on a property that is vacant or with an agricultural use, the tract shall be at least 2.5 acres.
   (d)   Located on a Residential Building. An antenna for a wireless telecommunications facility may be attached to a mid-rise or high-rise apartment building subject to the following conditions:
      (1)   Maximum height: ten feet above the existing building.
      (2)   If the applicant proposes to locate the telecommunications equipment in a separate shelter (not located in or attached to the building), the shelter shall comply with the following:
         A.   The shelter shall comply with the maximum setback requirements for the subject zoning district.
         B.   The maximum size of the equipment shelter shall be 300 square feet, or, if there is more than one, 750 total square feet.
         C.   A buffer yard shall be planted in accordance with Section 1198.02(d).
         D.   Vehicular access to the shelter shall, if at all possible, use the existing circulation system.
   (e)   Located in Open Space. A wireless telecommunications facility is permitted on land that has been established as permanent open space or a park subject to the following conditions:
      (1)   The open space shall be owned by the municipality, county, or state government, a homeowners association, charitable organization, or a private, non-profit conservation organization.
       (2)   The maximum height of a new tower shall be 200 feet (includes antenna). The maximum height of the equipment shelter shall be fifteen feet.
       (3)   The maximum size of the equipment shelter shall be 300 square feet, or, if there is more than one, 750 total square feet.
      (4)   The tower shall be set back from any single-family or two-family property line 1,000 feet.
(Ord. 399-96. Passed 4-14-97.)

1198.05 CRITERIA FOR REVIEW.

   A wireless telecommunications facility which includes a tower may be permitted as a conditional use in a multifamily residential or commercial district. In order to be considered for review, the applicant must prove that a newly-constructed tower is necessary in that collocation on an existing tower is not feasible. The following steps must also be taken for the application to be considered for review in this category:
   (a)   The applicant shall present a landscaping plan that indicates how the wireless telecommunications facility will be screened from adjoining uses.
   (b)   The applicant shall demonstrate that the telecommunications tower must be located where it is proposed in order to service the applicant's service area. There shall be an explanation of why a tower and this proposed site is technically necessary.
   (c)   Where the telecommunications facility is located on a property with another principal use, the applicant shall present documentation that the owner of the property has granted an easement or entered into a lease for the proposed facility and that vehicular access is provided to the facility.
   (d)   Any applicant requesting permission to install a new tower shall provide evidence of written contact with all wireless service providers who supply service within a quarter mile of the proposed facility. The applicant shall inquire about potential collocation opportunities at all technically feasible locations. The contacted providers shall be requested to respond in writing to the inquiry within thirty days. The applicant's letter(s), as well as response(s), shall be presented to the Planning Commission as a means of demonstrating the need for a new tower.
   (e)   After issuance of a permit to construct a wireless telecommunications facility, the permittee shall begin construction within 180 days and shall complete construction within 360 days or the permit and approval shall expire. As a condition of the permit, the Planning Commission shall require the applicant and the site owner to certify that if construction is not commenced within 180 days or completed within 360 days that the site shall be available for another wireless telecommunications facility.
(Ord. 399-96. Passed 4-14-97.)

1198.06 REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES.

   The applicant shall be responsible for all expenses incurred by the City for any legal planning and/or technical engineering services deemed necessary by the Building Commissioner, the Planning Commission, the Architectural Board of Review or City Council to perform the reviews required by this chapter.
(Ord. 399-96. Passed 4-14-97.)

1198.07 PERMIT FEES.

   Wireless communications fees shall be as set forth in Section 185.04(e) of the Administrative Code. (Ord. 177-97. Passed 1-20-98.)

1198.99 PENALTY.

   Whoever violates any of the provisions of this chapter is subject to the penalty provision of the Planning and Zoning Code found in Section 1123.99 unless otherwise specified in this chapter.
(Ord. 399-96. Passed 4-14-97; Ord. 239-08. Passed 12-15-08.)

1199.01 INTENT.

   The intent of this chapter is to:
   (a)   Extend space or screen undesirable views to reduce the impact of one land use upon another;
   (b)   Increase soil and water retention through landscape requirements;
   (c)   Protect and preserve the appearance and property values of residential uses from the adverse effects of adjoining nonresidential uses and certain multifamily uses;
   (d)   Establish attractive visual landscapes along public roads and promote pedestrian and motor vehicle safety; and
   (e)   Supplement proper land use planning practices.
(Ord. 138-90. Passed 12-16-91.)

1199.02 PURPOSE.

   The purpose of this chapter is to promote the health, safety and general welfare of the residents of the City by providing for space requirements and visual screen landscape buffers to remove, reduce, lessen or absorb the shock of impact of incompatible uses of real properties between one use or zone district and another, and to separate motor vehicle traffic from pedestrian traffic.
(Ord. 138-90. Passed 12-16-91.)

1199.03 CONFLICTS.

   If any of the requirements or standards of this chapter are found to be inconsistent with the standards and requirements found in other chapters of this Zoning Code, the more restrictive or greater requirements shall be deemed in each case to be applicable.
(Ord. 138-90. Passed 12-16-91.)

1199.04 DEFINITIONS.

   As used in this chapter:
   (a)   "Landscaping" means living materials, including, but not limited to, grass, ground covers, shrubs, vines, hedges, trees and nonliving durable material commonly used in landscape development.
   (b)   "Screening" means plant material or other nonliving durable material, including, but not limited to, walls, berms or fencing.
   (c)   "Opacity" means the state of being impervious to rays of light measured by observation of any two square yard area lying between two feet and ten feet from the ground.
   (d)   "Shrub" means a self-supporting, deciduous and/or evergreen species, normally branched near the base, bushy and less than fifteen feet in height, as normally grown in Cuyahoga County.
   (e)   "Tree" means a self-supporting, woody, deciduous and/or evergreen plant with a well-defined central stem, or a species of such plant that normally grows to a height of fifteen feet or more in Cuyahoga County.
   (f)   "Vine" means a plant that normally requires physical support to reach mature form.
   (g)   "Buffer" means an open, unoccupied land area used to visibly separate one use from another or to shield or block noise, lights or other nuisances.
   (h)   "Landscaped buffer" means a buffer that contains landscaping and/or screening materials.
(Ord. 138-90. Passed 12-16-91; Ord. 289-96. Passed 1-21-97.)

1199.05 GENERAL PROVISIONS.

   (a)   Materials. A landscaped buffer may include, but shall not be limited to, trees, shrubs, bushes, grass cover, earth berms or a combination thereof.
   (b)   Fences and Walls. Fences may be required as part of a landscaped buffer where a fence is necessary to protect the public health, safety, comfort and quiet enjoyment of those in the affected districts from such nuisances as traffic, noise and light. The Planning Commission shall determine the style, type and size of the fence upon consideration of the circumstances creating the need for the fence. Walls and berms shall be used only in the most unusual cases as one of several options to the developer to fulfill the buffering requirement.
   (c)   Natural Plantings Requirement. Where natural plantings are used to provide a landscaped buffer contiguous to side and rear property lines, such plantings shall provide eighty percent summer opacity and sixty percent winter opacity when viewed from two to ten feet above ground level.
   (d)   Buffering Effect. The desired buffering effect shall be achieved not later than twelve months after the initial installation. The Planning Commission may extend this period of time when a hardship would be created because of expected growth or material shortages, but the Commission shall not extend such period beyond two growing seasons from the time the initial installation was to have been or has been installed.
   (e)   Modification of Requirements. The Commission may modify or change the location of a landscaped buffer area contiguous to side and rear property lines where topographical problems prevent the installation of buffer materials or plantings, if confirmed by the City Engineer.
(Ord. 138-90. Passed 12-16-91; Ord. 289-96. Passed 1-21-97.)

1199.06 LANDSCAPED BUFFER AREAS FOR REAR AND SIDE YARDS.

   (a)   When Required. Landscaped buffer areas for rear and side yards shall be mandatory between the Single-Family House District or Two-Family House District and the Multifamily Residential District, and between any existing residential uses or zones and new nonresidential development in an abutting Shopping Center, Retail Business, Office Building, Commercial-Manufacturing, Industrial and Research Manufacturing or Automobile Parking District, nursing homes, and public facilities.
(Ord. 12-93. Passed 4-5-93.)
   (b)   Location. Landscaped buffer areas shall be located on the lot containing the more intensive (higher density) residential land use or, in the case of a residential lot or district abutting a nonresidential use or district, the lot that proposes to contain the nonresidential use or district. In either case, a landscaped buffer shall be placed on the portion of the lot's land area that abuts the less intensive lot or zoning district.
   (c)   Minimum Width. The minimum width of a landscaped buffer shall be as per the following schedule:
Lot Size (sq. ft.)
Side Yard(s) (ft.)
Rear Yard (ft.)
Up to 90,000
12
12
90,001 - 130,000
16
16
130,001 - 170,000
20
20
170,001 - 250,000
24
24
250,001 - 370,000
30
30
370,001 - 550,000
36
36
550,001 - 730,000
42
42
730,001 - 910,000
48
48
910,001 - 1,150,000
54
54
1,150,001 and over
60
60
 
(Ord. 138-90. Passed 12-16-91.)

1199.07 BUFFER AREAS FOR YARDS ABUTTING PUBLIC STREETS AND PARKING LOTS.

   (a)   When Required. This section applies to all uses developed in the City, excluding single-family and two-family dwelling units.
   (b)   Street Buffer Strips. A street buffer strip shall be provided and maintained on each developed property in a location between the sidewalk (where one exists or is proposed) and the curb or pavement edge of an adjacent public road. The entire area between the sidewalk and the curb shall be landscaped with grass and trees or an equivalent landscaping.
   (c)   Perimeter Parking Buffer Strips. In addition to the above requirements, a minimum grass- covered buffer strip of six feet in width with a six-inch high cement curbing is required from the sidewalk (where one exists or is proposed) to any parking area or driveway aisle that is located in a required yard abutting a public road. In addition to grass cover, the perimeter parking buffer strip shall contain a continuous line of evergreen shrubs planted at intervals of no more than five feet on center at an initial height of at least two feet, and a continuous row of trees spaced at intervals of no more than twenty feet on center at an initial height of at least eight feet. Such tree or shrub that covers over three feet in height shall be so located within the perimeter parking strip so as not to obstruct proper sight distance at intersecting parking aisles or where walkways intersect with vehicular driveway aisles.
   (d)   Length of Buffer Strips. Both the street buffer strip and the six-foot wide perimeter parking buffer strip shall be continuous and extend along the entire length of the front lot line that abuts a public right-of-way, except for areas pierced by walkway or driveway aisles to the extent necessary to provide safe ingress to and egress from the property.
(Ord. 138-90. Passed 12-16-91.)

1199.08 DETERMINATION OF REQUIREMENTS BY BUILDING COMMISSIONER; REVIEW BY PLANNING COMMISSION; PERFORMANCE BONDS.

   (a)   When an application for a building permit is made, the Building Commissioner shall determine if any of the landscaping or buffering requirements of Sections 1199.06 and 1199.07, or of any other section of this Zoning Code, must be applied. If he determines that the request comes under a specific landscaping or buffering requirement, the Building Commissioner shall so advise the applicant and shall submit a request to the Planning Commission that the matter be reviewed once the applicant has furnished the Commission with the following material:
      (1)   A copy of the site plan;
      (2)   The topography of the building site and surrounding area; and
      (3)   A complete description of the area and structure to be constructed or modified.
   (b)   The applicant shall provide the Planning Commission with a detailed description and sketch of all proposed buffering and landscaped buffers, preferably prepared by a landscaping expert, which visually and verbally outlines the nature and the effect of the proposed landscaped buffer.
   (c)   The Planning Commission may request photographs or other descriptive data if the Commission deems such data necessary.
   (d)   The Planning Commission shall notify all owners immediately adjacent to the property in question, by regular mail, prior to any meeting at which the landscaped buffer requirements, as set forth in Section 1199.06, will appear on the agenda.
   (e)   Where buffering is required, a building permit shall not be issued by the Building Commissioner until an agreement has been reached between the applicant and the City as to the buffering requirement. The agreement between the City and the owner and/or developer shall include, among other requirements, provisions for the following:
      (1)   Maintenance of the landscaped buffer on the part of the applicant;
      (2)   Replacement procedures for any portion of the landscaped buffer that is, for any reason, no longer viable;
      (3)   Replacement of the landscaped buffer involving plant material that does not extend beyond the next growing season;
      (4)   Replacement of landscape material, such as fences; and
      (5)   Replacement of landscape material within sixty days from the date of notification by the Building Commissioner of noncompliance.
(Ord. 138-90. Passed 12-16-91.)
   (f)   A certificate of occupancy shall not be granted until landscaped buffer requirements have been completed or until the posting of a cash equivalent or a performance bond in an amount determined by an estimate by a landscape contractor and confirmed by the City Engineer and the Building Commissioner.
   If compliance with landscaped buffer requirements is delayed because of the growth season, the bond shall be retained to ensure compliance by the next growing season. Such delay shall not extend beyond the next growing season following the date upon which the certificate of occupancy is requested.
(Ord. 194-92. Passed 9-8-92.)

1199.09 APPEALS.

   Any decision or determination by the Building Commissioner or the Planning Commission pertaining to the requirements of this chapter may be appealed to the Board of Zoning Appeals.
(Ord. 138-90. Passed 12-16-91.)

1199.10 VIOLATIONS.

   Whoever has control of any land or structure whereon or wherein a violation of any of the provisions of this chapter occurs, and any other person who assists in the commission of any such violation, shall be guilty of a separate offense and shall be liable to the penalty provided in Section 1123.99.
(Ord. 138-90. Passed 12-16-91.)