Restoration. Any lawful building or structure or portion of such building or structure rendered nonconforming by the enactment of this code or by reason of any subsequent amendment to this code or to the Zoning Map, which is damaged or destroyed by fire, flood, high winds or other accident or natural causes, may be repaired or rebuilt on the same building footprint and to the same dimensions, including height, provided such repair or rebuilding is completed within 12 months of the date of damage or destruction. However, a building or structure which is not conforming as to front setback and which is destroyed shall be rebuilt to meet the front yard setback for the district in which it is located, if the dimensions of the lot would permit doing so without causing any new or greater setback violation elsewhere on the lot. The total square footage of such rebuilt structure shall not exceed the total square footage of the structure that was damaged or destroyed.