A. Purpose: The purpose of the design review process is to protect, preserve, and enhance the natural and architectural environment of the Village, property values, and to promote the health, safety, and welfare of the Village and its residents.
B. Regulated Activities: No person may engage in the following activities without first obtaining design approval in accordance with the procedures of this Section:
1. Constructing, altering, enlarging, or remodeling the exterior appearance of any building or structure (such as, without limitation, any wall, fence, paved driveway, paved parking or loading area, sidewalk, sign, or light pole);
2. Altering the access, circulation, or parking of vehicles, bicycles, or pedestrians, such as by changing the number or designation of parking stalls or the designated use or direction of access drives;
3. Substantially changing outdoor lighting fixtures, such as by adding or removing light fixtures or by increasing or decreasing the intensity, color temperature, distribution pattern, or shielding of a light fixture. The changing of light bulbs shall not constitute a substantial change to an outdoor lighting fixture;
4. Removing any landscape furniture, such as benches, waste receptacles, or bicycle racks; and
5. With respect to any site or use for which design approval has been previously granted, doing anything materially different from or in addition to what is shown, described, required and/or approved as part of the prior approval, including any conditions of such design approval.
C. Exempt Activities: Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in Section
10-2C-6.B, the following activities are exempt from this requirements of this Section:
1. Any activity wholly concerning a single-family residential use, provided that this exemption does not apply to improvements that benefit a residential development, such as, for example, common areas and amenities maintained by a homeowners or condominium association;
2. The painting or refinishing of existing surfaces to restore the previously approved color;
3. Changes to signage subject to review by the Architectural Board of Review pursuant to Chapter 10 of the Zoning Regulations;
4. The total demolition of the principal structure upon a site; or
5. Emergency work as authorized (i) elsewhere in the Zoning Regulations or (ii) in Title 9 of this Code. In the event that the Building Commissioner permits emergency work that exempts a property owner or occupant from the provisions of this Section, the Building Commissioner may condition its approval of the emergency work on the owner's or occupant's compliance with conditions related to the design of any improvements or alterations made during such emergency work so as to preserve the purposes and protect the objectives of the design review process while also providing flexibility due to the exigent needs related to the emergency work.
D. Who May Apply: An application for design approval may be initiated only by the owner of a subject property.
E. Application: In addition to the general requirements of Article B of Chapter 2 of this Title concerning applications, the applicant must provide:
1. A site plan for the subject property showing proposed building location(s), land use areas, sidewalks, pedestrian walks, parking lot and walkway lighting, signage, site amenities, the location of garbage and refuse collection points, mail pick up points, and loading areas;
2. A vehicle traffic and parking plan for the subject property detailing the access locations, access geometry, on-site traffic circulation and parking areas;
3. Preliminary drawings for buildings to be constructed on the subject property, including floor plans, exterior elevations and sections, and building materials. A color, three-dimensional rendering where warranted by the complexity of the design;
4. Preliminary landscaping plans for the subject property, including site grading, irrigation, and landscaping design; and
5. For property in the CBD or R-5 Districts, streetscape elevation plans showing elevations for the buildings and structures on the immediately adjacent properties.
F. Authority and Procedure:
1. Types of Design Approvals: For purposes of this Section, the following terms have the following meanings:
a. Level 1 Design Approval (Administrative Review): The approval of a regulated activity that, in the judgement of the Building Commissioner, consist entirely of regulated activities that are either or both:
(1) Not highly visible and will not have a significant impact on the character or welfare of the surrounding area; or
(2) Minor alterations to plans previously approved as Level 2 or Level 3 alterations, which do not substantially alter the appearance or function of the approved design from that of the previous approval.
b. Level 2 Design Approval: The approval of any regulated activity which is not subject to Level 1 or Level 3 review.
c. Level 3 Design Approval (Major): The approval of:
(1) Construction of a new principal building;
(2) Enlargement of an existing building or structure by 400 square feet or more;
(3) Any development or construction work that also requires other land use approvals by the Village Board, such as the approval or amendments to a special use permit, variation, or a planned development.
2. Level 1 Design Approval: Upon receipt of a complete application for a Level 1 Design Approval, the Building Commissioner shall approve the application administratively if, in the sole judgment of the Building Commissioner, the application:
a. Qualifies for a Level 1 Design Approval pursuant to Section
10-2C-6.F.1 of this Code; and
b. Satisfies the standards set forth in Section
10-2C-6.G of this Code.
3. Level 2 Design Approval: Upon receipt by the Building Commissioner of a complete application for a Level 2 Design Approval, the Building Commissioner shall schedule the matter for a meeting before the Architectural Board of Review, which meeting shall occur not more than 60 days after the filing of a complete application, unless otherwise agreed to by the applicant. The Architectural Board of Review shall approve the application if the application satisfies the standards set forth in Section
10-2C-6.G of this Code.
4. Level 3 Design Approval:
a. Action by the Architectural Board of Review: Upon receipt by the Building Commissioner of a complete application for a Level 3 Design Approval, the Building Commissioner shall schedule the matter for a meeting before the Architectural Board of Review, which meeting shall occur not more than 60 days after the filing of a complete application, unless otherwise agreed to by the applicant. The Architectural Board of Review shall make a recommendation to the Board of Trustees on the application for a Level 3 Design Approval, which recommendation shall be forwarded to the Board of Trustees, within 60 days after the adoption of the recommendation. The failure of the Architectural Board of Review to provide a recommendation within such 60 day period, or such further time to which the applicant may, in writing, agree, shall be deemed a recommendation against the approval of a Level 3 Design Approval.
b. Action by the Board of Trustees: Following the receipt of the recommendation from the Architectural Board of Review on applications for Level 3 Design Approvals, the Board of Trustees shall commence consideration of the application and shall grant approval upon finding that the application satisfies the standards set forth in Section
10-2C-6.G of this Code.
G. Standard of Review: No application for design approval may be recommended for approval, or approved, unless findings are made that the application protects, preserves, and enhances the natural and architectural environment of the Village, property values, and the health, safety, and welfare of the Village and its residents. In evaluating whether this standard has been satisfied, the following factors shall be considered:
1. The quality of architectural design, including the quality and selection of materials; the use of materials or design elements that are visually compatible within the site and in comparison to the site's surroundings; consistency of treatments throughout a design; and the avoidance of materials or design elements that are duplicative or monotonous in comparison to their surroundings;
2. The design's compatibility with natural and man-made features in the surrounding area, especially as to height, scale, and the protection of features with significant natural, cultural, or historic value;
3. The design's effect upon adjacent properties and benefit to the public health, safety, and general welfare;
4. The quantity, quality, utility, size and type of open spaces and landscape improvements, including the provision of open spaces between a use and adjacent uses and rights of way and the reasonable preservation of existing trees and natural landscaping;
5. The suitability of a project's provisions for convenient and safe vehicular access, circulation, and parking;
6. The suitability of a project's provisions for access and circulation by bicyclists and pedestrians in a manner that is convenient, safe, and integrative of adjacent public and private amenities for these users;
7. The location and screening of a project's waste disposal areas, loading areas, air-conditioning units, and other mechanical and service facilities; and
8. Conformance with any additional criteria for design review located elsewhere in this Title;
9. Conformance with all requirements of this Code and other applicable laws.
H. Protective Conditions: Any recommending body may recommend, and any approving body or the Building Commissioner (if a Level 1 Design Approval) may impose conditions or restrictions upon the construction, location, and operation of any development authorized by design review as shall be deemed necessary to ensure compliance with its findings and to satisfy the applicable standards found in this Section. Conditions must have a rational nexus to the potential impacts of the proposed design, and must be roughly proportional, both in nature and extent, to the impacts of the proposed development. (Ord. 2022-38, 12-12-2022)