Zoneomics Logo
search icon

Wellsville City Zoning Code

ARTICLE V

SUPPLEMENTAL REGULATIONS

The purpose of this Chapter is to provide for safe, orderly and beneficial development of areas characterized by development hazards and valuable natural conditions shown on the Official Critical Lands Maps; to limit alteration and to reduce encroachment upon such areas. Critical Land conditions include, but are not limited to the following:
   A.   Floodplain Corridor Lands.
   B.   Riparian Preservation Lands.
   C.   Erosive and Slope Failure Lands.
   D.   Wildfire Threats.
   E.   Severe Constraint Lands.
   F.   Agricultural lands.
   G.   Essential Views.
   H.   Wetlands.
   I.   Wildlife Habitat.
   J.   Development proximate to canals.
   K.   Valuable Physical Characteristics of Wellsville as defined in the Wellsville General Plan. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-34-2: REGULATIONS:

The type of regulation applicable to the land depends upon the classification in which the land is placed, as provided in Section 10-34-4. If those regulations conflict with other regulations of Title 10 of the City Code - Land Use Regulations, the more stringent of the regulations shall govern. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-34-3: REVIEW AND APPROVAL REQUIRED:

   A.   A Critical Lands Review is required for any development, proposed on a site within or including lands defined in Section 10-34-4 as Critical Lands, and identified as Floodplain Corridor Land, Riparian Preserve, Erosive and Slope Failure land, or Severe Constraint land.
   B.   If the proposed development is required to obtain a Design Review Permit, Conditional Use Permit, subdivision, or other regulatory process, the review shall be conducted simultaneously with the regulatory process and no additional fee shall be charged.
   C.   If a development is exclusive of any other regulatory process, as noted in Section 10-34-3 B, then the Critical Lands Review shall be processed by the Planning Commission.
   D.   Information Required: The following information shall be required for any development requiring a Critical Lands Review:
      1.   A site plan containing the following:
         a.   Project name, and name of the developer.
         b.   Vicinity map.
         c.   Scale 1"=50' or larger (the scale shall be at least one inch equals fifty feet).
         d.   North arrow.
         e.   Date of submittal.
         f.   Street names and locations of all existing and proposed streets within or on the boundary of the proposed development.
         g.   Lot layout with dimensions for all lot lines.
         h.   Location and use of all proposed and existing buildings, fences and structures within the proposed development. Indicate which buildings are to remain and which are to be removed.
         i.   Location and size of all public utilities within the proposed development.
         j.   Location of drainage ways or public utility easements in and adjacent to the proposed development.
         k.   A topographic map of the site at a contour interval of two feet or less.
         l.   Location of all parking areas and spaces, ingress and egress on the site, and onsite circulation.
         m.   Locations of all existing natural features including, but not limited to, all trees of a caliper greater than six inches (6"); natural drainages or creeks on the site, and outcroppings of rocks, boulders, etc. In forested areas, it is necessary to identify only those trees which will be affected or removed by the proposed development. Indicate any contemplated modifications to a natural feature.
         n.   The proposed method of erosion control, water runoff control, and tree protection for the development.
         o.   Building envelopes for all existing and proposed new parcels that contain only buildable area, as defined by this Chapter.
         p.   If the applicant desires to challenge the extent or classification of any critical lands within the applicant's property a technical report may be submitted with the application that is prepared by an appropriately qualified professional providing technical data to justify a modification to critical lands.
      2.   Additional plans and studies as required in Sections 10-34-6, 10-34-7, 10-34-8 and 10-34-10 of this Chapter.
   E.   Criteria For Approval: A Critical Lands Review shall be permitted when the Applicant demonstrates the following:
      1.   That the development will not cause damage or hazard to persons or property upon or adjacent to the area of development.
      2.   That the development is in compliance with the requirements of this chapter and all other applicable requirement of the City Code.
   F.   The Planning Commission has the authority to require amendment of the plans to include any or all of the following conditions if it is deemed necessary to mitigate any potential negative impact caused by the development:
      1.   Require the retention of trees, rocks, ponds, watercourses, highly productive agricultural lands, and other natural features.
      2.   Require plan revision or modification to mitigate possible negative or irreversible effect upon the topography, or natural features that the proposed development may cause.
      3.   Avoid land possessing hazardous conditions adverse to public health, welfare and safety.
   G.   The Planning Commission may deny the Critical Lands Permit if, in its opinion:
      1.   The proposed development will have a detrimental effect on the lands regulated and protected by this Chapter.
      2.   Where it appears that the proposal is part of a more extensive development that would require a master site plan, or other action and/or approval, the Planning Commission may decide to post-poned any action until a complete application has been submitted. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-34-4: LAND CLASSIFICATIONS:

The following factors shall be used to determine the classifications of various lands and their constraints to building and development of certain lands:
   A.   Floodplain Corridor Lands: Lands with potential stream flow and flood hazards. The following lands are classified as Floodplain Corridor lands:
      1.   All land contained within the one hundred (100)-year floodplain as defined by the Federal Emergency Management Agency.
      2.   All land within the area defined as Floodplain Corridor land in maps adopted by the City as provided for in Section 10-34-5.
      3.   All lands which have physical or historical evidence of flooding in the historical past.
      4.   All areas within thirty feet (horizontal distance) of any river, creek, or stream as required by the State of Utah, Division of Water Quality.
   B.   Riparian Preservation Areas: The lands shown on the official maps as Riparian Areas are identified as seventy five feet (75') from the stream centerline for streams draining a basin of greater than one (1) square mile, and twenty five feet (25') from streams that drain areas of one square mile or less. It also includes any areas identified as wetlands or riparian in a Federal 404 Permit Process.
   C.   Erosive And Slope Failure Lands: Lands with potential erosion hazards, erosive lands, slope failure potential, and debris flow hazards are lands that are subject to damage from erosion and slope failure or defined as erosion and slope failure lands on the Critical Lands map and have a slope of fifteen percent (15%) or greater. Areas above and below canals on slopes greater that ten percent (10%) are also considered to have high erosive and slope failure potential.
   D.   Wildfire Lands: Lands with potential of wildfire, as defined on the Critical Lands map.
   E.   Severe Constraint Lands: Lands with severe development limitations which generally limit normal development. The following lands are classified as Severe Constraint Lands:
      1.   All areas which are within the floodway channels.
      2.   All lands with a slope greater than twenty percent (20%).
      3.   All lands within drainage ways with a watershed large enough to produce flooding conditions with potential to create property damage or threat to life.
   F.   Agricultural Land: Land as mapped by the State of Utah as Agricultural land of National or State Importance and as mapped and shown on the Critical Lands maps.
   G.   Essential Views: View corridors, view foregrounds, and view backdrops that are a value to the citizens of Wellsville and as define on the Essential Views map.
   H.   Classifications Cumulative: The above classifications are cumulative in their effect and, if a parcel of land falls under two (2) or more classifications, it shall be subject to the regulations of each classification. Those restrictions applied shall pertain only to those portions of the land being developed and not necessarily to the whole parcel. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019; amd. Ord. 2021-04, 5-19-2021)

10-34-5: OFFICIAL MAPS:

   A.   The City shall adopt official critical lands maps denoting the above identified areas. The source of data will be available and current GIS data from federal and state agencies. Any mapping not available from these sources will be produced by the City from the best technical data available. Property owners may submit additional engineered data to modify city mapping if approved by the City. Substantial amendments of these maps shall require amendment procedures as required herein.
   B.   The city will endeavor to complete the critical lands maps as resources become available. Basic critical lands maps are provided in the General Plan as a guide to the City and to Developers. Until new maps are produced and adopted the method used to identify critical lands shall be as specified in Section 10-34-5 item 4. Developers shall use these maps and other publicly available resource maps to determine which critical lands are affected by the proposed development. The Planning Commission may require additional studies by the developer if it judges that additional critical lands are involved.
   C.   Minor amendments of the maps to correct mapping errors when the amendments are intended to reflect more accurately the mapping criteria contained in this chapter or in the findings of the Council in adopting an official map may be processed following the minor map amendment procedure contained in this ordinance.
   D.   Map As Reference To Text:
      1.   The text provisions of this ordinance shall be used to determine whether applications to allow development in Critical Lands are subject to the requirements of this chapter.
      2.   Applicants are required to provide the decision makers with a delineation of the Critical Lands on the subject property as part of the application. An application shall not be considered complete until this delineation is submitted.
      3.   An applicant may identify and delineate Critical Lands by gathering and reviewing information other than the Critical Lands Map, such as FEMA maps, aerial photographs, Section 10-34-3 permit delineation, field investigations, and other significant evidence.
      4.   The specific delineation of the Critical Lands will be determined as part of the permit by the Planning Commission based on the best available data. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-34-6: DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS FOR FLOODPLAIN CORRIDOR LANDS:

For all land use actions which could result in development of the Floodplain Corridor as defined by FEMA, the following is required:
   A.   Standards For Filling In Floodplain Corridor Lands:
      1.   Fill shall be designed as required by the building code, where applicable.
      2.   The toe of the fill shall be kept at least ten (10) feet outside of floodway channels, as defined in this chapter.
      3.   The amount of fill in the Floodplain Corridor shall be kept to a minimum. Fill and other material imported from off the lot that could displace floodwater shall be limited to the following:
         a.   Poured concrete and other materials necessary to build permitted structures on the lot.
         b.   Aggregate base and paving materials.
         c.   Plants and other landscaping material.
         d.   A total of fifty cubic yards of other imported fill material, or three hundred cubic yards per acre, whichever is greater. These amounts are the maximum cumulative fill that can be imported onto the site, regardless of the number of permits issued.
         e.   The above limits on fill shall be measured from the elevation that existed at the location as shown on the latest FEMA flood maps and shall not exceed the above amounts.
      4.   If additional fill is necessary beyond the permitted amounts in (3) above, then fill materials must be obtained on the lot from cutting or excavation only to the extent necessary to create an elevated site for permitted development. All additional fill material shall be obtained from the portion of the lot in the Floodplain Corridor.
      5.   Adequate drainage shall be provided for the stability of the fill.
      6.   Fill to raise elevations for a building site shall be located as close to the outside edge of the Floodplain Corridor as feasible.
      7.   Development of floodways is not permitted except for bridges and road crossings. Such crossings shall be designed to pass a one hundred (100) year flood without raising the upstream flood height more than six inches (6").
   B.   Culverting or bridging of any waterway or creek identified on the official maps adopted pursuant to Section 10-34-5 must be designed by an engineer for a one hundred year flood event. Stream crossings shall be designed to the standards currently accepted by the City Engineer and shall comply with all requirements of the City Engineer. Where no floodway has been identified, culverts must be capable of handling a one hundred (100)-year flood without any increase in the upstream flood height elevation. The engineer shall consider in the design the probability that the culvert will be blocked by debris in a severe flood and accommodate expected overflow. Fill for culverting and bridging shall be kept to the minimum necessary but is exempt from the limitations in section (A) above. Culverting or bridging of streams identified as Riparian Preservation is subject to the requirements of Section 10-34-7.
   C.   Non-residential structures shall be flood-proofed to one foot above the elevation flood elevation contained in the official maps adopted by Section 10-34-5 at the finished floor elevation. Where no specific elevations exist on maps, buildings shall be elevated to three feet above the stream channel on all drainage ways identified on the official maps.
   D.   No new residential structures are permitted in the Floodplain Corridor, except as permitted in E and F below. All residential structures shall be elevated so that the lowest habitable floor shall be raised to one foot above the elevation contained in the official maps adopted by Section 10-34-5. Where no specific elevations exist, buildings shall be elevated to three feet above the stream channel on all drainage ways identified on the official maps.
   E.   The elevation of the finished lowest habitable floor shall be certified to the City by an engineer or surveyor prior to issuance of a certificate of occupancy for the structure.
   F.   All lots modified by lot line adjustments, or new lots created from lots which contain Floodplain Corridor land must contain a building envelope on all lot(s) which contain(s) buildable area of a sufficient size to accommodate the uses permitted in the underling zone, unless the action is for open space or conservation purposes. This section shall apply even if the effect is to prohibit further division of lots that are larger than the minimum size permitted in the zoning ordinance.
   G.   No new habitable space shall be permitted lower than the highest floodplain corridor elevation.
   H.   Storage of petroleum products, pesticides, or other hazardous or toxic chemicals is not permitted in Floodplain Corridor lands.
   I.   Fences constructed within twenty feet (20') of any riparian area shall be limited to wire or electric fence, or similar fence that would not collect debris or obstruct flood waters, but not including wire mesh or chain link fencing.
   J.   Decks and structures other than buildings, if constructed on Floodplain Corridor Lands and at or below the levels specified in Paragraphs (C) and (D) of the section, shall be capable withstanding flooding and must meet FEMA standards.
   K.   Local streets and utility connections to developments in and adjacent to the Floodplain Corridor shall be located outside of the Floodplain Corridor, except for crossing the Corridor in the shortest possible distance. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-34-7: DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS FOR RIPARIAN PRESERVATION LANDS:

All development in areas identified for Riparian Preservation, as defined in Section 10-34-4, shall comply with the following standards:
   A.   Development shall be subject to all Development Standards for Floodplain Corridor Lands (Section 10-34-6).
   B.   Within these areas in addition to the standards for Undeveloped Floodplains, no land disturbing activity is allowed except as permitted in this section.
   C.   Permitted Uses:
      1.   Up to ten percent (10%) of the area may be disturbed for private yard structures including but not limited to: storage sheds, gardens, yards, trails, and clearings, except that no disturbance is permitted for 404 identified areas. Treatment of wetlands for land use and development proposals shall follow those mandated by Utah State Code. Wellsville City may act upon a land use and/or development proposal containing wetlands without prior mitigation of those wetlands, but in no case shall structures, infrastructure, improvements, utilities and the like be developed, constructed, built and/or occupied in areas containing wetlands without prior approval, including mitigation measures, from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.
      2.   Repair, replacement or improvement of utility facilities where:
         a.   The disturbed portion of the Riparian Preservation lands is restored; and
         b.   Non-native vegetation is removed from the riparian preservation lands and replaced with native riparian vegetation as approved by the Planning Commission.
      3.   Additions, alterations, rehabilitation, or replacement of existing structures that do not increase existing structural footprint in the Riparian Preserve lands where the disturbed portion of the area is restored using native vegetative cover.
      4.   Stream, wetland, riparian and upland enhancement or restoration projects;
      5.   Farming practices and farm uses, excluding buildings and structures, and the pasturing of livestock within twenty-five feet (25') of the stream.
      6.   Routine repair and maintenance of existing structures, roadways, driveways, utility facilities, accessory uses and other development.
      7.   Measures to remove or abate nuisances, or any other violation of State statute, administrative agency rule or City ordinance. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-34-8: DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS FOR EROSIVE AND SLOPE FAILURE LANDS:

   A.   All development that removes vegetation or disturbs topsoil and leaves the disturbed soil at a slope of twenty percent (20%) or more shall comply with the following standards:
      1.   Any exposed soil shall be revegetated in a manner to reestablish a vegetative community within a one year period from issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy. If irrigation is not provided, then the exposed soil must be planted with species that can survive without irrigation.
      2.   Vegetative cover, rock, dry or conventional masonry, or other permanent cover must be maintained on areas that have been disturbed.
      3.   These restrictions shall not apply to areas of exposed bedrock which exhibit no erosion potential.
   B.   Cuts And Fills:
      1.   In addition, any cuts and/or fills greater than two hundred fifty (250) cubic yards must be designed by an engineer to comply with building code and requirements of this chapter. Such cuts and/or fills shall be designed in such a manner that they will be stable for the use intended.
      2.   If the excavation is not a dedicated street or a public right-of-way, the engineer shall declare to the City, after the cut and/or fill is completed, that it was constructed to plans and meets all standards set forth in the plans approved.
      3.   Nothing in this section shall abridge the City's right to inspect work in progress or in its completed state, to make appropriate measurements and tests to determine if the cut and fill was made according to plan, and to require alterations prior to final approval of the cut and/or fill.
   C.   Any development that is proposed in Erosive and Slope Failure Lands must be shown on a master site plan at the time the final plan or plat is filed. All development must comply with the master site plan. Any improvements necessary for the implementation of the master plan (e.g., storm drains, gutters, etc.), which involve two (2) or more parcels of land must be constructed by the applicant prior to any development occurring on the parcels.
   D.   All structures in Erosive and Slope Failure Lands shall have foundations that have been designed by an engineer or architect.
   E.   All newly created lots or lots modified by a boundary line adjustment must include a building envelope on all lots that contains a buildable area of sufficient size to accommodate the uses permitted in the underlying zone without including erosive and slope failure land, unless the division or lot line adjustment is for open space or conservation purposes. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019; amd. Ord. 2021-04, 5-19-2021)

10-34-9: DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS FOR LANDS WITH WILDFIRE THREATS:

   A.   Requirements For Subdivisions, Or Planned Developments (see also Chapter 10-28):
      1.   A Fire Prevention and Control Plan shall be required with the submission of any application for plan approval of a development or preliminary plat of a subdivision, which contain areas designated as Wildfire threats areas in the Wildland/Urban Interface Fire Safety Overlay Zone, Chapter 10-28.
      2.   The Planning Commission shall forward the Fire Prevention and Control Plan to the Fire Chief. The Fire Chief shall review the Fire Prevention and Control Plan and submit a written report to the Planning Commission no less than seven (7) days before the scheduled hearing. The Fire Chiefs report shall be a part of the record of permits.
      3.   Criterion for Approval. The hearing authority shall approve the Fire Prevention and Control Plan when, in addition to the findings required by this chapter, the additional finding is made that the wildfire hazards present on the property have been reduced to a reasonable degree, balanced with the need to preserve and/or plant a sufficient number of trees and plants for erosion prevention, wildlife habitat, and aesthetics.
      4.   The hearing authority may require, through the imposition of conditions attached to the approval, the following requirements as deemed appropriate for the development of the property:
         a.   Delineation of areas of heavy vegetation to be thinned and a formal plan for such thinning.
         b.   Clearing of sufficient vegetation to reduce fuel load.
         c.   Removal of all dead and dying trees.
         d.   Relocation of structures and roads to reduce the risks of wildfire and improve the chances of successful fire suppression.
      5.   The Fire Prevention and Control Plan shall be implemented during the public improvements required of a subdivision or Performance Standards Development and shall be considered part of the subdivider's obligations for land development. The Plan shall be implemented prior to the issuance of any building permit for structures to be located on lots created by partitions and for subdivisions or Performance Standards developments not requiring public improvements. The Fire Chief, or designee, shall inspect and approve the implementation of the Fire Prevention and Control Plan, and the Plan shall not be considered fully implemented until the Fire Chief has given written notice to the Planning Commission that the Plan was completed as approved by the hearing authority.
      6.   In all new residential developments, provisions for the maintenance of the Fire Prevention and Control Plan shall be included in the covenants, conditions and restrictions for the development and the City shall be named as a beneficiary of such covenants, conditions and restrictions.
   B.   Requirements For Construction Of All Structures:
      1.   All new construction and any construction expanding the size of an existing structure shall have a "fuel break" as defined below.
         a.   A "fuel break" is defined as an area which is free of dead or dying vegetation, and has native, fast-burning species sufficiently thinned so that there is no interlocking canopy of this type of vegetation. Where necessary for erosion control or aesthetic purposes, the fuel break may be planted in slow burning species. Fuel breaks do not involve stripping the ground of all native vegetation.
         b.   Primary Fuel Break - A primary fuel break will be installed, maintained and shall extend a minimum of thirty feet (30') in all directions around structures, excluding fences, on the property. The goal within this area is to remove ground cover that wilt produce flame lengths in excess of one foot (1‘). Such a fuel break shall be increased by five feet (5') for each ten percent (10%) increase in slope over ten percent (10%).
         c.   Secondary Fuel Break - A secondary fuel break will be installed, maintained and shall extend a minimum of one hundred feet (100') beyond the primary fuel break where surrounding landscape is owned and under the control of the property owner during construction. The goal of the secondary fuel break is to reduce fuels so that the overall intensity of any wildfire is reduced through fuels control.
      2.   All structures shall be constructed or re-roofed with Class B or better non-wood roofing materials, as determined by the Building Ordinance. All re-roofing of existing structures in the Wildfire Lands area shall be done under approval of a zoning permit. No structure shall be constructed or re-roofed with wooden shingles, shakes, wood-product material or other combustible roofing material, as defined in the building ordinance.
         a.   Fuel breaks in areas which are also erosive or slope failure lands shall be included in the erosion control measures outlined in Section 10-34-8. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-34-10: DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS FOR SEVERE CONSTRAINT LANDS:

   A.   Severe Constraint Lands are extremely sensitive to development, surface disturbance such as grading, filling, or vegetation removal has high potential to threaten life or property, whenever possible, alternative development should be considered.
   B.   New structures are not allowed on Severe Constraints Lands.
   C.   Other development of land or approval for a Planning Commission action shall be allowed only when the following study has been accomplished. An engineering geologic study approved by the Wellsville City Engineer establishes that the site is stable for the proposed use and development. The study shall include the following:
      1.   Index map.
      2.   Project description to include location, topography, drainage, vegetation, and discussion of previous work and discussion of field exploration methods.
      3.   Site geology, based on a surficial survey, to include site geologic maps, description of bedrock and surficial materials, including artificial fill, locations of any faults, folds, etc., and structural data including bedding, jointing and shear zones, soil depth and soil structure.
      4.   Discussion of any off-site geologic conditions that may pose a potential hazard to the site, or that may be affected by on-site development.
      5.   Suitability of site for proposed development from a geologic standpoint.
      6.   Specific recommendations for cut slope stability, seepage and drainage control or other design criteria to mitigate geologic hazards.
      7.   If deemed necessary by the engineer or geologist to establish whether an area to be affected by the proposed development is stable, additional studies and supportive data shall include cross-sections showing subsurface structure, graphic logs with subsurface exploration, results of laboratory test and references.
      8.   Signature and registration number of the engineer and/or geologist licensed as professional engineer in the State of Utah.
      9.   Additional information or analyses as necessary to evaluate the site.
   D.   Prohibited Actions: Notwithstanding any other provision of these Ordinances it shall be unlawful to clear, "grub," grade, fill, or excavate any land in any manner which presents an unreasonable risk of erosion, flooding, landslide, or any other unsafe condition; and it shall be unlawful to erect any structure which will not be reasonably safe for use as a human habitation because of:
      1.   Proximity to a high water table (water close to the ground surface);
      2.   Surface water;
      3.   Expansive soils;
      4.   Collapsible soils;
      5.   Proximity to a potential landslide area;
      6.   Proximity to a secondary fault;
      7.   Proximity to an alluvial fan;
      8.   Proximity to an active landslide;
      9.   Proximity to a primary Wasatch Fault zone;
      10.   Any other unsafe condition, as determined by the City. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-34-11: HIGHLY PRODUCTIVE AGRICULTURAL LANDS:

   A.   Agricultural lands support a locally important and nationally unique agricultural industry that includes; dairy, livestock, food from grains, vegetables, fruit, forestry, and greenhouse crops. Wellsville's climate, topography and accessibility make it uniquely suited to the production, processing and distribution of agricultural products on a regional and national scale. The natural resources, productive farmland and rural character, has made Wellsville and Cache Valley a desirable place to live and work. Farm land is an irreplaceable natural resource with soil and topographic characteristics that have been enhanced by generations of agricultural use. Loss of this resource to development is a permanent reduction of a critical resource. The economic base of the City is also supported by a variety of agriculturally related businesses including: farm equipment and supply, dairy products processing, grain dealers, packaging plants and other professional services. Critical agricultural lands shall be governed by the following:
      1.   All lands identified as critical agricultural lands shall be designated and mapped by the City. The City may utilize existing mapped agricultural lands from other sources to satisfy this requirement.
      2.   Any proposed development within identified critical agricultural lands shall be governed by the uses allowed in the respective zones in which the highly productive agriculture exists.
      3.   Critical agricultural lands should be preserved through means of one or more tools including, but not limited to:
         a.   Limitations placed on development on highly productive agricultural lands;
         b.   Land set aside requirements as in Chapter 10-35;
         c.   Substitutions for Open Space, Section 10-35-5;
         d.   Use of conservation easements;
         e.   Purchase of Development Rights (PDRs);
         f.   Private land trusts. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-34-12: ESSENTIAL VIEWS:

   A.   Essential Views are a critical visual and quality of life resource and are protected as provided herein. The purpose and intent is to protect the public health, safety, and welfare and to protect the scenic quality of Wellsville City both for visitors to the city as well as for its residents by ensuring that future development improvements are compatible with existing land forms, including city ridgelines and views of Wellsville's many unique geologic and agricultural features and the existing landscape fabric of the city's hillside areas. The regulations contained in this chapter are consistent with the goals and policies of the Wellsville City General Plan. It is intended that this chapter accomplish the following:
      1.   Provide hillside development standards to minimize the impact of man-made structures and grading on views of existing landforms, unique geologic features, existing landscape features and open space as seen from designated public roads within the city;
      2.   Protect and preserve views of major and minor ridgelines from designated public roads;
      3.   Create a development review process by the Planning Commission.
      4.   Minimize cut and fill, earthmoving, grading operations and other such man-made effects on the natural terrain to ensure that finished slopes are compatible with existing land character; and
      5.   Promote architecture and designs that are compatible with hillside terrain and minimize visual impacts.
   B.   General Requirements For Essential Views:
      1.   All final grades, including all cut and fill slopes, visible from any designated public road shall be:
         a.   Consistent with the existing landscape to the greatest extent possible, avoiding uninterrupted slope surfaces that stand out against existing topographic contours;
         b.   Contoured to resemble existing terrain by varying slope increments and breaking the visual surface of banks and inclines both vertically and horizontally as naturally as possible;
         c.   Constructed to allow for the creation of berms or mounding at the top of slopes and in other locations for the screening of structures and assurance proper site drainage.
      2.   Design, height and massing of hillside development shall:
         a.   Maintain a balance of scale and proportion using design components that are harmonious with natural landforms and landscaping;
         b.   Be small scale and low in height, conforming with hillside topography by stepping or staggering the mass of the proposed building up or down slope, avoiding flat pad construction and vertical massing;
         c.   Utilize structural elements, building materials and color tones which blend artificial surfaces with surrounding native elements;
         d.   Utilize construction materials, glass, roofing and other surfaces that are of a non-reflective nature;
         e.   Utilize articulated wails that use reveals, cornice detailing, alcoves or other features which are appropriate to the scale of the building and building projections, trellises, landscaping or other devices, which serve to break up continuous building wails which are visible from designated public roads; and
         f.   Ensure that the proposed structure does not break the skyline of a primary ridge when viewed from any designated public road.
      3.   Roadways, driveways and utility alignments shall be:
         a.   Located to minimize grading, by following existing contours and positioned upon gradual slopes;
         b.   Constructed to blend with the existing landscape, through alignment with the natural curving contour of the land instead of using straight lines or geometric patterns which create excessive cuts and fills;
         c.   Concealed from view through preservation and maintenance of existing vegetation or through planned landscaping that is constant with the natural character of the area.
      4.   Landscape planting and vegetation preservation shall:
         a.   Incorporate trees where appropriate, planted in random groupings or clusters that mimic or maintain natural assemblages rather than in systematic rows;
         b.   Maintain vegetation lines which convey the existing slope of the hillside;
         c.   Preserve native vegetation, including grasses and open space whenever possible;
         d.   Use native materials to the greatest extent possible and/or non-natives that are compatible with indigenous vegetation and confined to the adjacent vicinity of the proposed structure;
         e.   Include a sufficient irrigation, maintenance and monitoring program designed to provide species requirements as well as protect against sedimentation, soil loss and land sliding;
         f.   Be landscaped in such a manner so as to reduce fire hazard and create a minimum defensible space for fire suppression.
      5.   Exterior and landscape lighting applications shall be:
         a.   Designed to minimize nighttime disruption and visual glare by shielding lamp sources downward and away from view of designated public roads;
         b.   Controlled by timers and/or motion sensors, to limit the duration of use and reduce prolonged glare;
         c.   Sized with the minimum wattage possible to meet desired application. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

The purpose of this Article is to promote and provide incentives for the setting aside of lands, whether publicly or privately owned, that are accessible to and designed for the use and enjoyment of the citizens of Wellsville within all existing boundaries and future annexation areas of the City. Furthermore, it is generally intended that open space set asides remain in private ownership and maintenance. However, where there is a demonstrated public interest in open space set asides being dedicated to public ownership and responsibility for maintenance and where sufficient funding exists to meet this maintenance responsibility, public dedication of open space may occur under the terms of this Article.
This article establishes minimum standards for providing open and outdoor space set asides in developments and subdivisions. It is intended to ensure that all development including residential, commercial, and industrial projects are designed with functional open space to promote the health, safety, enjoyment, and livability of residents, visitors, shoppers, and workers. Furthermore, Wellsville and its future annexation areas possess critical lands with qualities that shall remain in permanent open space for the future health, safety, and welfare of all residents, workers, and visitors of the City. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-35-2: LAND SET ASIDE REQUIRED:

All development or redevelopment required to obtain a Design Review Permit as specified in Land Use Regulations shall provide a required set aside of land as open space as a condition of approval. The following types of set asides are required and further specified in Table 10-35-3:
   A.   Open Space: Open space is an area of land or water that may be used for passive or active recreation, agriculture, conservation, landscaped areas, preserves of the natural environment, scenic land, and/or other use that is of a suitable size, topography, location, and shape to permit the activities for which it is intended as determined by the Planning Commission, but shall not include critical lands as defined in Chapter 10-62 "Critical Lands" and Chapter 10-34.
   B.   Useable Outdoor Space: A land area within a lot or parcel that is used in conjunction with a primary use designed and intended for the use or enjoyment of the residents and their guests of the development and shall include improvements as necessary and appropriate for use as useable outdoor space. Useable outdoor space may include accessory structures that enhance its use and enjoyment. Useable outdoor space shall be generally landscaped and may include patios, decks, shade structures, play equipment, play courts, walkways, and landscaped plazas. Useable outdoor space shall not include required setbacks, parking, and/or driveways. Storm water facilities qualify as useable outdoor space if the physical characteristics are functional as useable areas for the intended purpose of useable outdoor space. Except that storm water facilities for useable outdoor space shall not be used for parking lots. Storm water facilities may be used for useable outdoor space when located in the setback require on U.S. Highway 89/91.
   C.   Exemption: An Open Space set-aside shall not be required for legal lots within the Residential Open Space One Acre (ROS1) and Residential Open Space One Half Acre (ROS 1/2) zoning districts for one (1) and two (2) lot subdivisions. Subdivisions that are proposed with two (2) lots and a remainder lot shall be considered a three (3) lot subdivision and are not eligible for this exemption.
   D.   General requirements in all zoning districts. Open space shall be required if any lot or subdivision is part of a larger parcel and/or part of multiple, contiguous, parcels that are in the same ownership where it is possible for the land to be developed in the future. The provision to waive an open space set-aside shall not be used to circumvent open space requirements when it is apparent that lot(s) can be added in the future or when attempts are being made to split-off lot(s), in smaller increments, to avoid setting aside open space. Existing open space, in all zoning districts, that has been set-aside, as required by ordinance, shall not be waived, removed, recorded, or modified in any way that is contrary to the original recording of the open space.
(Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019; amd. Ord. 2022-11, 12-7-2022)

10-35-3: APPLICABILITY:

   A.   All development or redevelopment required to obtain a Design Review Permit and which is specified in Table 10-35-3, shall set aside land as "open space", as defined in section Chapter 10-62 "Open Space." For mixed use development, the "type" of development in Table 10-35-3 is determined according to the proportion of mix of uses proposed. All "critical lands" as defined in Chapter 10-62 "Critical Lands" of this title shall be set aside as permanent open space and shall not be included in determining open space as required herein.
Table 10-35-3: Developments requiring Land Set Asides (open space)
Type of Development
Minimum Area Required for Open Space (gross land area)
Type of Development
Minimum Area Required for Open Space (gross land area)
Residential RCA
50%
Residential RAC5
50%
Residential ROS1
40%
Residential ROS1/2
35%
Residential RSF*
30%
Commercial
0%
Industrial
0%
Redevelopment
5%
Recreational Planned Development RPD
70%
Forest Recreation
95%
Agriculture
95%
Open Space Conservation OSC
95%
 
*   Development within the Residential Single Family zone (RSF) shall be required to set aside open space for developments of ten (10) lots or more. The developer may choose to pay in-lieu fees for open space allowing all of the developable property to be subdivided excluding all critical lands,
   B.   Exclusions: The following shall be excluded from open space requirements:
      1.   Development on public land including land dedicated as public rights-of-way or dedicated as other public land. The land area of public rights-of-way dedicated for pubic roadways within a development or subdivision may be deducted from the total land area required for open space.
      2.   Development on land of private utility companies which provides distribution of electrical power, or natural gas which existed prior to adoption of this chapter.
      3.   Development within the RSF zone shall not be required to set-a-side open space for development of nine (9) lots or less. However, if it is apparent that the development is a subdivision from a larger parcel that will be developed in later phases, the Planning Commission shall recommend to the City Council that open space shall be required of the smaller development. A subdivider may not circumvent the requirement for open space by subdividing and developing small parcels split off from a larger mother parcel.
      4.   Development or redevelopment on existing legal lots within legal subdivisions which do not require a Design Review Permit. However, useable outdoor space is required as specified in Table 10-35-3.
      5.   Remodeling, renovation, redevelopment and/or change of use of commercial and industrial uses within the same parcel(s) of land existing at the time of this ordinance. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019; amd. Ord. 2021-02, 4-21-2021)

10-35-4: CALCULATION OF REQUIRED OPEN SPACE:

Calculation to determine the land area required for set-aside of open space shall be based on the total land area of the development parcel(s) excluding the land area of critical lands and future public lands and/or road rights-of-way to be dedicated to the public as part of the development plan. Example: If the total land area of a development parcel is ten (10) acres and one (1) acre is critical lands and an additional two (2) acres are to be dedicated for public roads within project, then seven (7) acres of land would be used to calculated the amount of land required for open space set-aside. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-35-5: OPEN SPACE STANDARDS:

   A.   General Standards: The standards for the establishment, maintenance, and ownership of open space are set forth. In addition to any standards or requirements stipulated elsewhere in this Ordinance for open space located in a specific district, the following general standards shall apply to all open space:
      1.   To the greatest extent practical, open space shall be of a configuration suited to its specific site context and the purpose for which it is specifically proposed to be used (e.g. preserve, active or passive park, playground, walkway/bikeway, agriculture, etc.);
      2.   Where practical, open space shall be contiguous with existing or imminent future open space. As a rule, the contiguous interconnection shall be a minimum of twenty (20) feet in linear measure. In its discretion, the Planning Commission may reduce or waive the contiguous interconnection requirement when a lesser interconnection is deemed functional, such as for pedestrian walkways, or where the open space, though non-contiguous with other open space, is of sufficient size and design to function well and serve as a public asset;
      3.   A permanent restrictive covenant in the form of a perpetual conservation easement shall be placed upon open space land requiring its maintenance as open space, in form and content as approved by the Planning Commission.
      4.   The minimum land area that shall be designated as open space is specified in Table 10-35-3. The minimum land area shall be in addition to any critical lands within the property.
      5.   All land possessing the constraints of critical lands shall also be set aside as permanent open space but shall not be included in the determination of required open space.
      6.   The determination of open space does not include storm water handling facilities, except as may be useable outdoor space per Section 10-35-2 B.
      7.   The developer may locate and design open space wherever desirable for the efficient and advantageous use of the property. However, the City may specify the location and configuration of open space on the property as deemed necessary to connect adjacent, existing or future open space.
      8.   At no time shall any open space be reduced in size, subdivided, used, or modified beyond its original intent unless the following actions occur:
         a.   Amendment to the subdivision plat as prescribed in the Utah Code Annotated.
         b.   Notification for this action is required for all owners of property included in the plat when the open space was created. A recommendation to modify the open space shall be received by the City Council representing at least sixty six percent (66%) of the property owners.
         c.   Public hearings held as required.
         d.   Recommendation of the Planning Commission.
         e.   Majority vote of the City Council.
      9.   Land outside the proposed property shall not be used in determining the allowed density of a project.
      10.   Uses Within Open Space: All uses and facilities within open space developed under the provisions of this title shall be considered conditional uses and subject to the requirements of conditional uses as described in this code. Conditional uses are subject to approval and conditions as required by the Planning Commission and may include:
         a.   Recreation active use - play fields, parks, trails, play grounds, related parking and accessory uses to the above listed uses, such as, the preparing and serving of food and beverages, and the sale or rental of equipment, supplies and facilities in connection with and in support of the recreational activities engaged in upon the premises.
         b.   Agricultural crop production compatible with adjacent residential development.
         c.   Conservation areas, including, but not limited to, wilderness areas, watersheds, wildlife refuges, wetlands, riverways, drainageways and riparian zones.
         d.   Equestrian facilities;
         e.   Swimming pools;
         f.   Lakes, ponds, and streams;
         g.   Natural landscapes;
         h.   Agricultural crop lands and pasture/grazing lands;
         i.   Conservation easements held by a recognized conservation organization or other type of ownership as permitted by Section 10-35-4.
         j.   Visual amenities or expanded development setbacks.
         k.   Equestrian facilities.
         l.   Forests and forest experimentation.
         m.   Historic preservation and monument sites.
         n.   Open air theaters and meeting places.
         o.   Public facilities.
         p.   Publicly dedicated open space.
      11.   The following uses are not allowed in open space:
         a.   Motorized vehicles, except farm equipment supporting approved agricultural uses and maintenance vehicles for open space.
         b.   Signs other than incidental signs for allowed uses;
         c.   Buildings and structures, except those incidental to the use of the open space as approved by the Planning Commission.
         d.   Rubbish, trash, or storage of vehicles or equipment.
      12.   A land area not exceeding ten percent may be acquired by the City through open space to facilitate public trail connections.
      13.   All developments with common areas or common facilities shall be owned and managed by a "homeowner association" as defined in U.C.A § 57-8a.
      14.   The following notation shall be fulfilled and shall be recorded on the face of the final plat;
"Open Space designated on this ptat shall be maintained in perpetuity and shall remain in the condition that it was originally intended and shall not be modified or used for buildings. The City of Wellsville shall have the right, but not the duty, to require, and if necessary, perform, at the organization's orowner(s) expense, landscaping, maintenance and snow removal, as applicable, within the open space areas if the organization or owner(s) fail to adequately perform such. The City may take this action when asked to take over improvements or maintenance tasks by the home owner's association or the property owner(s). The City may also take such action when it determines the need based on a historical pattern of lack of care and maintenance, in the event Wellsvilie City exercises this right, the City shall be entitled to recover any associated costs and attorney fees. This notation shall not be amended or deleted without the written approval of Wellsville City".
      15.   Leasing, renting or use by any entity or person other than the homeowners' association of any portion of the open space shall be reviewed and approved by the Planning Commission for use compatibility.
   B.   Ownership Of Open Space: Open space shall be protected through a perpetual conservation easement held by the City or by a recognized land trust, conservancy, or homeowners' association. Ownership shall exist as specified in Section 10-35-4 . The ownership document shall be reviewed and approved by the City and recorded at the office of the county recorder. Open space within a development shall be owned, administered and maintained by any of the following methods, either individually or in combination, and subject to approval by the City:
      1.   Type 1 - Offer of Dedication: The city shall have the first and last offer of dedication of open space in the event said land is to be conveyed. Dedication shall take the form of fee simple ownership. The City may, but shall not be required to, accept open space; provided, that the Planning Commission shall consider and make determinations and findings as to the following in its review of public dedication of open space:
         a.   Such land is accessible to the city and adjacent to a public right-of-way or legal easement;
         b.   There is no cost of acquisition other than any cost incidental to the transfer of ownership and
         c.   The city agrees to and has the funds and ability to maintain such lands. Where the city accepts dedication of open space that contains improvements, the city may require the posting of financial security to ensure satisfactory functioning and structural integrity of improvements for a term not to exceed one (1) year from the date of acceptance of dedication. The amount of financial security shall not exceed fifteen percent (15%) of the actual cost of installation of said improvements.
         d.   There shall be documentation of a clear plan for the conveyance of the open space to the accepting public entity, with a written agreement of acceptance from said entity. Copies of all documents related to conveyance shall be filed with the City Attorney.
         e.   There shall be documentation of an agreement as to the condition of the open space necessary for acceptance and conveyance. This shall include stipulations as to what improvements, if any, are expected, and whether the developer or the City is responsible for installation of said improvements. If the public dedication is part of a request for any bonus under this chapter, the Planning Commission may require of the developer a reasonable contribution towards improvement of the open space. The developer may have the option of actually constructing the improvements or making a monetary contribution to the City based on the cost estimate of a certified civil engineer, landscape architect or guaranteed contractor proposal acceptable to the Planning Commission.
      2.   Type 2 - Homeowners’ Association (HOA): The open space and associated facilities may be held in common ownership by a homeowners' association. The HOA shall be formed and operated as prescribed in Section 10-35-4 with the additional provisions:
         a.   The developer shall provide covenants, conditions and restrictions (CC&Rs) of the association, including its bylaws, articles of incorporation and methods for maintaining the open space. The CC&Rs shall be reviewed and approved in content and form by the city. Acceptance of the CC&Rs by the city will be contingent upon meeting the intent and conditions required by this code. The CC&Rs will be approved by the City prior to filing the CC&Rs with the final plat.
         b.   The association shall be organized by the developer and be operated with financial subsidy by the developer, before the sale of any lots within the development. The association shall continued to be operated by the developer for a minimum of two (2) years after sixty percent (60%) of the development is occupied.
         c.   A narrative describing ownership, use, and maintenance responsibilities shall be submitted for all common and public improvements, utilities and open space within critical lands and open space. There shall be documentation of legally enforceable mechanisms for responsibility of maintenance of the open space as specified herein.
         d.   Membership in the association is automatic and mandatory for all purchasers of homes or lots therein and their successors. The conditions and timing of transferring control of the association from developer to homeowners shall be identified in the CC&Rs.
         e.   The association shall be responsible for maintenance of insurance and taxes on open space, enforceable by liens placed by the City.
         f.   The members of the association shall share equitably the costs of maintaining and developing open space. Fees shall be determined by the association and assessed and deposited in an escrow account. Shares shall be defined within the association bylaws.
         g.   The developer of the subdivision shall endow the newly formed homeowners' association with funds equivalent to ten percent (10%) of the development cost for all common improvements plus an amount equal to one years operating expenses to maintain and insure the open space. These funds shall be used exclusively by the HOA to operate, maintain and insure the HOA for the first year that the association begins to operate independently of the developer. Remainder funds, if any, shall be used in for subsequent years. Funds shall be deposited in a checking account in the name of the HOA within ten (10) days after the day which the HOA begins to operate independently of the developer.
         h.   In the event of a proposed transfer, within the methods herein permitted, of open space by the homeowners' association, or of the assumption of maintenance of the open space by the City, notice of such action shaii be given to all property owners within the development.
         i.   All improvements to the open space held in common or intended to be held in common by the HOA shall be installed, completed and accepted prior to the beginning of the second phase of construction, or if the project is not phased, prior to sale of 20% of the total lots in the project. If phasing of the improvements to the open space is required by the developer, all incomplete improvements for the open space shall be secured through a bond (Section 10-56-3 ) equal to one hundred fifty (150%) of the estimated value of the improvements, posted by the developer.
         j.   The association shall have or hire adequate staff to administer common facilities and properly and continually maintain the open space.
         k.   The homeowners' association may lease open space to any other qualified person, or corporation, for operation and maintenance of open space by lease agreement, which shall provide that:
            (1)   The residents of the development shall at all times have access to the open space contained therein, except that agricultural crops may not be accessed unless the grower specifically allows;
            (2)   The open space to be leased shall be maintained for the purposes set forth in this title; and
            (3)   The operation of facilities within the open space may be for the benefit of the residents only, or may be open to the residents of the City, at the election of the developer and/or homeowners' association, as the case may be;
            (4)   The lease shall be subject to the approval of the Planning Commission specific to the compatibility of use of open space intended by the lessee.
         l.   A conservation easement shall be established to provide a permanent preservation of the open space. The easement shall be indicated on the recorded plat and state the ownership of the easement and reference the maintenance agreement also recorded with the final plat stating the standards of upkeep as defined in these subdivision regulations.
      3.   Type 3 - Transfer of Easements to Private Conservation Organization: With the approval of the Planning Commission, an owner may transfer easements or ownership to a private nonprofit organization, among whose purposes it is to conserve land; provided, that:
         a.   The organization is acceptable to the Planning Commission and is a bona fide conservation organization recognized by the Internal Revenue Service as a 501c3 organization with perpetual existence;
         b.   The conveyance contains appropriate provision for proper reversion or retransfer in event that the organization becomes unwilling or unable to continue carrying out its functions; and
         c.   A maintenance agreement acceptable to the Planning Commission is entered into by the developer/owner, the City, and the organization.
   C.   Maintenance Standards: The following standards for maintenance shall be fulfilled for all opens space:
      1.   The owner of the open space shall be responsible for maintenance and the raising of all monies required for operations, maintenance or physical improvements to the open space through annua! dues, special assessments, etc. The maintenance organization shall be authorized, under its bylaws, to place liens on the property of residents who fall delinquent in payment of such dues, assessments, etc.
      2.   In the event that the maintenance organization, or any successor organization, shall, at any time after establishment of a development containing open space, fail to maintain the open space in reasonable order and condition, the City may serve written notice upon the owner of record, setting forth the manner in which the owner of record has failed to maintain the open space in reasonable condition.
      3.   Failure to adequately maintain the open space in reasonable order and condition constitutes a violation of this title. The City is hereby authorized to give notice, by personal delivery or by United States Postal Service, to the owner or occupant, as the case may be, of any violation, directing the owner to remedy the same within thirty (30) days. Further, the City shall be authorized to assume maintenance of the open space in such a manner as it deems appropriate.
      4.   Should any bill or bills for maintenance of the open space by the City be unpaid by January 1 of each year, a lien shall be filed against the premises in the same manner as other municipal claims. The City shall be entitled to recover any costs and attorney fees incurred in collecting or recovering any such amounts due to the City.
      5.   Access by Public Upon Completion Of Improvements Within Open Space. The public shall have access, when mutually agreed by all parties, including the City. Lots designed with rear facing open space shall be accessible at all times and all locations. At no time shall public access be denied unless unsafe conditions exist or unless approved by the City. Public access within open space shall be allowed only where identified and allowed within the approval documents. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019; amd. Ord. 2021-03, 5-19-2021)

10-35-6: IN LIEU SUBSTITUTIONS FOR OPEN SPACE REQUIREMENTS:

   A.   Purpose: The City finds that land in other locations may be substituted for open space requirements where it is advantageous to preserve important and critical land within the limits or in locations outside city limits that are included in the future annexation area of the City. For this purpose, developers may choose to receive additional incentives in lieu of developing the land required for open space if equivalent or greater land is identified and substituted in another location(s) and acceptable to the City. A method called "in lieu substitution" or "in lieu open space substitutions", hereafter.) The following conditions shall apply to in lieu open space substitutions:
      1.   As an incentive or bonus for providing open space, the Planning Commission may grant density, coverage, or height bonuses to developments providing additional open space where ever open space set asides are required in Sections 10-11-20 and 10-11-21.
      2.   Recordation of a final plat for a subdivision utilizing an approved density bonus and an in-lieu substitution may not occur until in lieu substitutions are approved, finalized, and effective.
      3.   An in-lieu substitution may be approved, for open space land in another location, only when such proposed in lieu substitution of open space land is absent hazards to development such as, but not limited to, steep slopes, geologic hazards, unstable soils, flood plains, wetlands, riparian areas, water source protection areas. In no case shall hazardous lands be used for the original development density or the bonus density. Where agricultural land is being substituted, equally productive or more productive agricultural land must be substituted.
      4.   For in lieu substitutions, use of the open space land shall be limited to the uses allowed in open spaces in Section 10-35-4 .
      5.   In lieu substitutions of land intended to fulfill the requirements for open space may be allowed when it is factually established, by a qualified land appraiser, that the substituted land is at least equal to or greater than the value of land compared with the development property as if developed fully as proposed. The City must agree to and approve the land area to be appraised both from the original site and the proposed substituted site prior to the appraisal. The appraiser will be selected by and contract with the City. The fees for the appraisals will be reimbursed to the City at cost by the developer.
      6.   Any land which has been dedicated, set-aside, platted, or otherwise approved as open space may not be substituted or used for any purpose other than those allowed in Section 10-35-5 .
   B.   Land for in-lieu open space substitutions shall not be eligible for substitution outside of the corporate boundaries of Wellsville City. Except, the Planning Commission may approve land inside the future annexation area as defined in the Annexation Plan which is outside of the current corporate limits. Such land must contribute to the purposes of open space as defined herein.
   C.   Types of Open Space Substitutions Available; The following options are available to developers to propose to the City for in lieu substitutions for bonus and open space requirements:
      1.   Cash in lieu: The City may, at its sole discretion, accept cash in lieu of open space requirements where such funds can be more effectively used to acquire land at a more appropriate or significant location consistent with the General Plan, the Parks and Recreation Master Plan, the Annexation Plan and other adopted documents identifying substitute sites for open space. Cash in lieu payments shall not be accepted until a qualified appraisal, authorized by the City and at the cost of the applicant, identifying the value of the original land for which the in-lieu substitution is proposed, based on the use that will be permitted if the open space requirement is removed, and for which cash in lieu shall be offered. The City shall be obligated to use in lieu funds for uses identified in Section 10-35-5, above, and shall diligently pursue purchase of the land for this purpose to prevent erosion of purchasing power.
      2.   Land in lieu: The City may, at its sole discretion, accept land in lieu of open space requirements under the following conditions:
         a.   The proposed land to be substituted is consistent with the General Plan, the Parks and Recreation Master Plan, the Annexation Plan and other adopted documents identifying substitute sites for open space.
         b.   Other land is acceptable to and approved by the City as open space in a location determined by the City to be a substitute site;
         c.   Acceptable and approved land is dedicated to the City with unencumbered title; and
         d.   in lieu substitution for open space is retained in use and ownership consistent with other acceptable forms of open space ownership in this chapter.
      3.   Purchase of Development Rights: The City may, at its sole discretion, accept the purchase of development rights by the developer to meet in lieu of open space requirements under the following conditions:
         a.   Other land of sufficient size and value is acceptable to and approved by the City as open space in a location determined by the City to be an in-lieu substitute site for the purchase of development rights by the applicant;
         b.   The proposed land to be substituted is consistent with the General Plan, the Parks and Recreation Master Plan,, the Annexation Plan and other adopted documents identifying substitute sites for open space.
         c.   Land where development rights are purchased by the applicant shall be subject to a recorded conservation easement that runs with the land and exists in perpetuity. The conservation easement shall be held by a recognized conservation organization acceptable to the City, and subject to the requirements for such ownership as stated in Section 10-35-4 B.3 of this Chapter. All documentation shall be reviewed and approved by the City;
      d.   Cost of the purchase of development rights by the applicant is equivalent to the value of the original land for which the in-lieu substitution for open space is proposed, based on the use that will be permitted if the open space requirement is removed, and for which purchase of development rights shall be offered; and
      e.   Uses of the land within the conservation easement are consistent with other acceptable forms of open space ownership and uses in this chapter.
      f.   The recordation of the final plat shall not occur until the documents evidencing the purchase of development rights and all conservation easements are ready to be recorded simultaneously with the final plat and not until the purchase prices for all development rights and all conservation easements are paid in full, in order to provide marketable title to the City, without encumbrances not accepted by the City
   D.   In lieu substitution applications shall first be reviewed by the Planning Commission as a part of the initial application for Design Review Permit. Approval of the in lieu substitution shall be obtained from the City Council before recordation of the Final Plat or issuance of a building permit, which ever occurs first.
   E.   The provisions of Chapter 10-35 shall be effective for all applications for Design Review Permit filed on or after the effective date of this ordinance; provided, however, the Planning Commission and the Mayor shall have the authority to approve an in lieu substitution for open space for an existing subdivision or development containing approved open space, subject to such application first being submitted to the Planning Commission for its consideration and recommendation to the Mayor. If the in-lieu substitution application is approved, the applicant shall comply with all applicable land use laws of the City and State.
   F.   Nothing contained in this Chapter 10-35 shall be construed as restricting the use of the Utah Open and Public Meetings Act, Utah Code Sections 52-4-101, et seq., and as they might be amended, by the City Council, Planning Commission, and other City Officials, to hold closed meetings, as reasonably determined necessary, for all purposes therein allowed, including strategy sessions to discuss the purchase, exchange, lease or sale of real property, as contemplated herein. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-35-7: REZONING OF OPEN SPACE:

Upon approval of a development application that provides for open space under the terms of this Chapter, the Planning Commission shall consider the potential rezoning of the open space as part of the Open Space Conservation (OSC) Zone set forth herein, and shall make a recommendation to the City Council using the following criteria:
   A.   Upon acceptance of any public dedicated open space, said open space shall be included as part of the Open Space Conservation (OSC) Zone of this Title.
   B.   Where open space is retained in private ownership and is provided in response to the open space requirements, said open space shall be rezoned as part of the Open Space Conservation (OSC) Zone upon the recommendation of the Planning Commission and its finding that the open space complies with all requirements of the Open Space Conservation (OSC) Zone.
   C.   In all cases, the rezoning of open space shall be in accordance with the amendment procedure set forth herein. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-1: PURPOSE:

The purpose of this chapter is to provide for uniform application of development standards and specifications as a condition of project approval and permit issuance for all development permits, subdivisions, building permits, conditional use permits, design review permits, or other permit issued by the City. The standards of this chapter are in addition to other provisions of the Wellsville City Code and the Design Standards and Construction Specifications as approved by the City. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-2: OPEN SPACE:

The standards for open space development are specific to conditions of approval for open space set aside (See Chapter 10-35, Open Space Requirements). (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-3: PRIVATE STREETS:

All privately owned streets shall be designed, built, and maintained to the same standard as public streets (see adopted Design Standards and Construction Specifications, and Design Criteria). (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-4: PRIVATE DRIVES:

Reserved. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-5: STREET TREES:

Street trees shall be required as a condition of all project approvals (Section 10-39-6) The tree species and locations of plantings shall be as specified in City Trees and Beautification plan. Street trees shall be planted at the time of issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy or construction of sidewalks, whichever occurs first. For subdivisions, the Planning Commission may require posting of improvement security to guarantee the availability of funds adequate to cover the cost of purchasing and installing street trees. All streets within the public right-of-way shall be maintained in a safe and healthy condition by the adjacent property own. Street trees shall not be planted in the site distance triangle (Chapter 10-61 Site Distance Triangle). Street trees are the property of the city and shall not be removed without a permit. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-6: WASTE MANAGEMENT FACILITIES ONSITE:

Solid waste receptacles, recycling bins, and refuse storage shall be sited in locations approved by the provider of Waste Management Collection. All waste disposal areas shall be screened with solid fencing, such as masonry, wood, or vinyl. No waste disposal facilities shall be located between the structure and a public right-of-way, unless specifically approved by the decision-makers with a finding that no screened site exists. Publicly accessible recycling facilities may be located between the structure and the right-of-way, provided that the facility is kept in a neat appearance with regular collection and cleanup in the general area. All waste management facilities shall be screened with landscaping. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-7: PUBLIC FACILITIES:

   A.   Public Facilities, Road Rights-of-Way, and Public Utility Easements:
      1.   The City may require a project proponent to reserve lands within a project site for a public facility. Such request shall be made in conformance with the laws related to municipal property acquisition.
      2.   The City may require dedication of lands for public utility easements, road right-of-way, and for other public purposes without compensation in conformance with the requirements of Utah law and this Title. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-8: WARRANTY:

Public improvements performed by or on behalf of private development shall be guaranteed for a period of two (2) years after the date of acceptance. The improvements shall be guaranteed against settlement, break up, failure or inability to satisfactorily function as required, lack of adequate drainage. The City may require or retain security to assure performance of improvements during the guarantee period. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-9: COMMON AREA DEVELOPMENT REQUIREMENTS:

   A.   All developments with common areas or common facilities shall be owned and managed by a "homeowner association" as defined in U.C.A. § 57-8a-102.
   B.   The homeowner association shall adopt City approved covenants, conditions and restrictions (CC&Rs), bylaws and rules for the association. The bylaws and rues for the association shall provide for enforcement of the CC&Rs, including the assessing of fines for violations.
   C.   Prior to the issuance of any permits, the developer shall file a lien in favor of the homeowner association against each residential lot equal to the pro rata share of ten percent of the total cost of the common area and facility improvements. Upon payment of the liens, the homeowner association shall place the proceeds in a restricted fund to be used solely for the maintenance, repair and replacement of the common area and facility improvements. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-10: EXTERIOR LIGHTING:

   A.   Purpose: It is the purpose of the exterior lighting code to ensure the rights of all property owners to light their own properties. Individual property owners have a right to light their own properties. Property owners do not have the right to adversely illuminated other properties. Exterior lighting by one property owner can adversely affect the right of privacy and enjoyment of another property owner. A property owner who is adversely illuminating another's property is not protected by the "legally existing non-conforming" provisions of this title because compliance can be achieved with simple, economical methods. Lighting compliance is expected of all property owners.
      a.   If the luminaires are less than eight hundred (800) lumens per fixture or if the fixture uses one sixty (60) watt incandescent lamp, provided the light fixture has an opaque top or is completely recessed in a soffit.
      b.   Building soffit lighting that is recessed beyond the surface of the soffit material and does not exceed luminary limits of 2a above.
      c.   Floodlights with external shielding of the light source and angled downward at least thirty (30) degrees, or sufficiently, to prevent lighting of adjacent properties.
      d.   Lights used only to light athletic courts when all reasonable measures have been taken to minimize lighting of surrounding properties. Such lighting shall not operate later than ten o’clock (10:00) p.m. All adjacent luminaires surrounding an athletic complex are not exempt.
   E.   Existing lighting on all properties: Properties that have installed exterior lighting prior to the adoption date of this code shall be considered non-conforming with lighting requirement of this title. When existing lights adversely affect the privacy of adjacent property owners and are deemed to be a nuisance, the following process shall be used to resolve the concerns of adjacent property owners:
      1.   Written complaints will be accepted from property owners and/or occupants adversely affected by lights from other properties. Photographs depicting the detrimental lighting shall be included with the complaint. Complaints shall not be anonymous.
If it is determined that a complaint is valid and subject lights do not comply with these requirements, the city shall send a letter to require relief for adjacent property owners by voluntary compliance. A complaint shall be determined valid if an unshielded source of the light can be seen from adjacent properties and if it is determined that it is reasonable to take enforcement action. The compliance letter shall suggest economical ways to conform, such as, changing luminaries to reduce lighting, shielding the light source at the light fixture with paint or tape, or removing lights, dimming lights, and/or turning lights off during normal sleeping hours. The letter shall include a date for the property owner to comply.
      2.   If compliance is not achieved by the date to comply, the City shall process a Notice of Violation beginning the Administrative Enforcement procedures prescribed in Chapter 10.60.
   D.   Height and Placement of Exterior Luminaires: Parking area luminaires shall not emit light beyond the property lines of the development. The light source within the luminary must be concealed and not visible from adjacent properties. Freestanding luminaires on private property in residential zones shall be no taller than twelve (12) feet. Luminaires for public street lights and public athletic fields are exempt from height regulations. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019; amd. Ord. 2021-05, 6-2-2021)

10-36-11: SHARED ACCESS:

Shared access between adjoining parcels is strongly encouraged. It may be required by the Planning Commission as condition of project approval. Shared access may be required if the property owner owns or controls adjoining property and/or it is feasible for separate property owners to enter into an agreement. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-12: ACCESS ADJOINING MAJOR STREETS:

   A.   On Arterial and Major Collector Streets, whenever a project proposes access to an arterial street or major collector street, whether the streets are existing or proposed, limited access to the street shall be required:
      1.   The determination shall be consistent with the City of Wellsville 2009 Transportation Plan and General Plan.
      2.   The determination shall be based upon the recommendation of the City Engineer.
      3.   When frontage roads or alternative access are used, "no access easements" may be required between the project and the road to which access is limited.
         a.   No new driveway access shall be permitted to directly access streets whenever officially designated as limited access streets:
         b.   If there are no alternatives for access utilizing existing side streets or rights-of-way, the decision-makers may approve access to a limited access street as follows:
            (1)   Frontage roads may be required to create a shared access between the subject property and adjoining properties to limit the number of points of access;
            (2)   Driveways, if permitted, shall be required to be aligned on the City's grid system by either:
               A.   Aligning with existing driveways across from the proposed new driveway location;
               B.   Aligning the driveways in locations approved by the Planning Commission to create safe driveway separations and accommodate other potential driveways within the project area.
            (3)   If the project is a subdivision, the decision-makers may reduce the number of lots within a subdivision to accommodate a frontage road; or
            (4)   The decision-makers may approve an access to a street if it is designed to be or become a shared access;
         c.   The decision-makers shall require that the access be developed to serve as an interior project street to provide access to multiple properties.
         d.   No new residential driveways shall be permitted to access the excluded streets if there is any other location for access. If a legally existing lot is proposed for development and there are no alternative points of access, the Planning Commission may approve one residential driveway with a maximum width of twenty two feet (22') at the right-of-way.
         e.   If a lot has been created in violation of subdivision regulations, the Planning Commission may require driveways for illegally created lots to conform to the provisions of this chapter.
         f.   Other access limitations as defined in the General Plan.
   B.   Alternate Access Required: The Planning Commission shall consider the long-term needs of the City in maintaining local and regional transportation corridors in the approval of any subdivisions pursuant to this Title. The Planning Commission may reduce density, reduce the number of driveways or change driveway locations, or impose other design considerations in order to avoid or prohibit access to arterials and major collectors and to preserve future transportation corridors. The Planning Commission may require road right-of-way stubs or connections to adjoining properties for purposes of future road development whether or not the adjoining properties are proposed for development at the present time, The Planning Commission may require the dedication of the extended right-of-way if adjoining zoning or site development potential results in the need for a logical future connections or a future roadway on the city block grid. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-13: DRIVEWAY SPECIFICATIONS:

   A.   Residential Driveways:
      1.   Driveways shall lead to a garage or parking area located outside of the front, side and rear setbacks. Driveways serving residential developments shall be not less than twelve feet (12') in width for single lane driveways. Driveways in this classification shall not exceed twenty feet (20') in width.
      2.   Only one driveway is permitted on a single family residential lot, except as specified in section 10-36-13(B) for circular driveways.
      3.   More than one (1) driveway may be permitted for multi-dwelling structures, if approved as a part of the design review permit for new construction or with a right-of-way access permit.
   Figure 10-36-13A: Driveway Standards
 
Single Frontage Lots (min. lot width)
Number of Driveways allowed
Width Between Circular Drives
82.5' - 100'
1
NA
More than 100'
2
6'
Corner Lots
(min. lot width both frontages)
82.5' - 100'
1
NA
More than 100'
2
6'
 
On corner lots new drives shall be located adjacent to the property line as far away from the intersection of the street as possible. Circular drives are not allowed on the corner lots if both frontages have a drive.
   B.   Circular Driveways: Circular driveways may be permitted by the Planning Commission and City Engineer for residential development on minor collector or residential streets. Maximum driveway width of a circular drive shall be ten feet within the property and twelve feet (12') at the street. Circular driveways shall only be permitted if the lot frontage is greater than one hundred feet (100') in width or a corner iot with at least one hundred feet (100') of clearance from edge of pavement on the intersection for each driveway. A right-of-way access permit shall be required.
   C.   Non Residential Driveways:
      1.   Entry (ingress) lanes shall be limited to a maximum width of sixteen feet (16'), except as noted in this subsection.
      2.   Exit (egress) lanes shall be at least twelve feet wide with one lane for each turning movement. If there is a lateral (straight across) alignment approved by the decision-makers, there shall be a third twelve-foot (12') lane for straight traffic.
      3.   Typical non-residential driveway width shall be forty feet (40') (one sixteen foot (16') ingress lane and two twelve foot (12') egress lanes) with a maximum established at fifty-two feet (52') when approved by the Planning Commission.
      4.   The Planning Commission may approve varied widths based on site specific and project specific conditions and traffic safety. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-14: DRIVEWAY LOCATION AND SPACING:

   A.   Commercial Zoning Districts: The following standards apply to all development in the CC, CG, HT, PUB, REC zoning districts.
      1.   Number of Driveways: One driveway is allowed per lot or one driveway per three hundred feet of street frontage, whichever is greater, unless a greater number is approved by the City Engineer.
      2.   Driveway Width: The maximum width of a driveway providing access to public right-of-way is forty feet (40'). The Planning Commission may require that driveways wider than twenty four feet (24') be constructed with a landscape island or divider median to separate ingress and egress traffic.
      3.   Driveway Spacing: Driveways shall be spaced at least one hundred feet (100') from other driveways and street intersections, unless otherwise approved by the City Engineer. Spacing is measured from nearest edge to edge.
   B.   Industrial Zoning Districts: The following standards apply to all development in the IND zoning district.
      1.   Number of Driveways: One driveway is allowed per lot or per three hundred feet (300') of street frontage, whichever is greater, unless otherwise approved by the City Engineer.
      2.   Driveway Width: The maximum width of a driveway providing access to public right-of-way is fifty-two feet (52'). The Planning Commission may require that driveways wider than twenty-four feet (24') be constructed with a landscape island or divider median to separate ingress and egress traffic.
      3.   Driveway Spacing: Driveways shall be spaced at least one hundred feet (100') from other driveways and street intersections, unless otherwise approved by the City Engineer. Spacing is measured from nearest edge to edge. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-15: FENCES AND WALLS:

   A.   Purpose and intent: Fences and walls are part of the built environment and visual make-up of the City. This section is intended to provide development standards for fencing specific within the City.
   B.   Applicability: The standards of the chapter apply to all public and private development, unless otherwise specifically stated in this chapter.
   C.   Exemption: Government incarceration facilities, impound lots, and agricultural operations or similar land uses.
   D.   Fence Height: Fence or wall height shall be measured from the highest existing grade within a ten foot (10') radius of the proposed fence location. It is prohibited to build grade up to a higher level in order to increase the allowed fence height. Fence and wall heights shall be as follows;
      1.   For all Residential zoning districts, fences, and walls shall be a maximum of three feet (3') tall within the front setback. Fences and walls shall be a maximum of six feet (6') tall within the rear and side setbacks behind the front plane of the primary structure. Lots with multiple street frontages may install a six foot (6') tall fence or wall at a twelve foot (12') setback from the property line on the side(s) yard other than the declared front yard.
      2.   For all non-residential zoning districts, fences, and walls shall be a maximum of three feet (3') tall within the front setback and a maximum of eight feet (8') tall in the rear and side setbacks behind the front plane of the primary structure. Lots with multiple street frontages may install a six foot (6') tall fence or wall at a twelve foot (12') setback from the property line on the side(s) yard other than the declared front yard.
   E.   Fence Standards:
      1.   Location: Fences and walls shall be installed outside of the Site Distance Triangle. All fence and wall sections shall be installed outside of Public Rights-of-Way.
      2.   Replacement and Repair: The property owner is responsible to repair, replace or remove any unsafe or structurally unsound sections of fencing or walls. If a fence or wall is more than twenty (20) degrees beyond plumb it shall be considered structurally unsafe and correction or removal will be required.
   F.   Prohibited Fences: The following fences shall be prohibited in all zoning districts unless otherwise specifically authorized:
      1.   Razor Wire.
      2.   Barbed Wire (unless associated with agricultural operations).
      3.   Electrically Charged Fencing (unless associated with agricultural operations).
      4.   Chain Link Fence within the front setback.
      5.   Highly reflective or metallic fencing or wall materials.
   G.   Fence Permits:
      1.   All fences and walls shall have a permit issued by the Planning Commission prior to installation. Failure to obtain a fence permit may result in enforcement actions pursuant to Chapter 10-60;
      2.   Permit applications shall require dimensioned drawings showing the layout and location of all proposed fences and walls;
      3.   Permit applications shall indicate fence height and materials for all proposed fence sections;
      4.   Some fences or walls may require an additional approval from the Planning Commission, the Historic Preservation Committee, or both.
      5.   Inspections: Inspections may be required upon receiving a citizen complaint, or if determined to be unsafe by the Chief Building Official.
 
(Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-16: TRAILS:

   A.   Purpose And Intent: Trails are an essential part of the infrastructure of Wellsville City. They provide transportation options, improve pedestrian and cycling circulation, decrease vehicle congestion, promote healthy recreational activity and connect people to nature. Trails shall be integrated into existing roadway corridors, along existing waterways and through undeveloped natural areas of the City to create an efficient trail network connecting neighborhoods, schools, churches, commercial areas, industrial parks and adjacent regional recreational lands.
   B.   Applicability: These standards apply to all public and private development, new construction, subdivisions and major remodeling unless otherwise specifically stated in this chapter.
   C.   Exemption: Minor improvements to existing development that do not result in more than a ten percent (10%) increase in a building floor area are exempt from the standards of this chapter.
   D.   Trail Standards:
      1.   Urban Trails: Urban Trail design shall conform to the adopted road/walk/trail cross sections within the Design Standards and Construction Specifications.
      2.   Primitive Trails: Primitive Trail Design shall conform to the Design Standards and Construction Specifications. Primitive Trail networks should follow natural systems and corridors and make connections to adjacent regional trail systems. Trail layout shall minimize impacts on significant environmental features.
   E.   Trails Master Plan shall identify existing and proposed trail locations. The Plan shall identify Urban and Primitive Trail designations and shall assign priority rankings to all proposed trails sections based on contiguous length created, ease of construction and overall network connectivity. See figure 10-36-16.
   F.   Implementation Of Trails:
      1.   Dedicated trail projects independent of new developments, subdivisions and major remodeling determined eligible by the Planning Commission shall have trails sections constructed as per priority ranking and as funding and resources become available to the Park Recreation.
      2.   New public and private development, subdivisions and major remodeling projects increasing the finished floor area by more than ten percent (10%) and determined eligible by the Planning Commission shall follow locations and connections shown on the Trails Master Plan. Private trails shall connect to nearby or adjacent trails systems as may and/or exist or as shown on the trials master plan.
Figure 10-36-16F2: Trails Master Plan
 
(Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-17: SELF-STORAGE:

   A.   Purpose: The additional requirements for Self-Storage uses are intended to ensure that this form of storage unit project is developed to reduce adverse consequences on surrounding properties and require that the long-term appearance of storage units is maintained.
   B.   Standards: The following standards are required for Self-Storage development:
      1.   All other development standards as required in Title 10.
      2.   Specific requirements of the zone where proposed to be located and where allowed.
      3.   Standard screening and setback requirements shall be increased by one hundred percent (100%). Storage of any kind is prohibited in required setbacks.
      4.   All outside storage shall be located at the rear of the property, completely screened from public view by a solid screen fence approved through a design review permit.
      5.   Storage units adjacent to any public roadway shall be single loaded with the back of the units facing the street and doorways of the units facing inward toward other storage units.
      6.   Front yard setbacks shall be landscaped and screened with a combination of deciduous and coniferous trees and shrubs to cause at least a fifty percent (50%) screen within five (5) years. Trees must be planted at two and one-half inch (2-1/2") caliper. Shrubs must be planted at least five (5) gallon nursery stock.
      7.   All side yard and rear yard setbacks shall be landscaped and screened with a combination of deciduous and coniferous trees and shrubs to cause at least a twenty five percent (25%) screen within five (5) years. Trees must be planted at one and one-half inch (1-1/2") caliper. Shrubs must be planted at least one (1) gallon nursery stock.
      8.   Building design and must meet all requirements of sections 10-18-1 and 10-18-8.
      9.   All setbacks are required to be irrigated by an automatic sprinkler irrigation system.
      10.   The developer shall landscape and grade the street facing frontage using one of the following options:
   Figure 10-36-40 Options for Design of Self Storage
 
(Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-18: ADULT-ORIENTED BUSINESSES:

   A.   Purpose: The purpose of this section is to establish reasonable and uniform regulations to prevent the concentration of adult-oriented businesses or their location in areas deleterious to the City, regulate the signage of such businesses, control the adverse effects of such signage, and prevent inappropriate exposure of such Chapter 10-36 Development Standards businesses to the community. The chapter is to be construed as a regulation of time, place, and manner of the operation of these businesses, consistent with the United States and Utah Constitutions.
   B.   Location of Businesses - Restrictions:
      1.   Adult oriented business shall be conditionally permitted in the Industrial (IND) district subject to the provisions of this chapter.
      2.   No adult-oriented business shall be located:
         a.   Within one thousand feet (1,000') of any school, public park, library, or religious institution;
         b.   Within one thousand feet (1,000') of any residential use (no matter which zoning district) or residential zoning boundary;
         c.   Within six hundred feet (600') of any other adult-oriented business;
         d.   Within six hundred feet (600') of any gateway or gateway corridor as identified in this Title and the General Plan. The distance shall be measured from the edge of the right-of-way.
      3.   Distance requirements between structures and uses specified in this section shall be measured in a straight line, without regard to intervening structures or zoning districts, from the perimeter property boundaries of the school, public park, religious or cultural activity, residential use, or other adult-oriented business, or from the edge of right-of-way of a gateway to the structure of the adult-oriented business.
      4.   Distance requirements from zoning districts for this section shall be measured in a straight line, without regard to intervening structures or zoning districts, from the closest zoning boundary of a residential or agricultural district to the adult-oriented business structure.
   C.   Effect on Non-Conforming Businesses: All lawfully established, legally existing, non-conforming adult-oriented businesses, shall comply with the provisions of this chapter by December 31, 2014, except in the case in which a business is required to be relocated. In such cases where relocation is required for conformance with this section, the business shall have complied by December 31, 2015.
   D.   Signs: Signs for adult-oriented businesses shall be subject to the limitations of this section regardless of standards within Chapter 10-40 of the Wellsville Municipal Code.
      1.   No more than one exterior building-mounted sign shall be permitted;
      2.   No sign shall exceed eighteen (18) square feet in total sign area;
      3.   No animation shall be permitted on or around any sign or on the exterior walls or roof of such premises;
      4.   No descriptive art or designs depicting any activity related to or inferring the nature of the business shall be permitted on any sign. Signs shall contain alphanumeric copy only.
      5.   Only flat wall signs shall be permitted; awnings shall be permitted only to display the street number in letters or numbers no greater than eight inches (8") in height;
      6.   Painted wall advertising shall not be allowed
      7.   Other than the signs specifically allowed by this chapter, the adult-oriented business shall not attach, construct, or allow to be attached or constructed any temporary sign, banner, light, or other device designed to draw attention to the business location. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-36-19: CLUSTER MAILBOXES REQUIRED:

   A.   General: In all new residential subdivisions, mailboxes shall be installed by the subdivider in clusters of locked mailboxes (groupings of multiple mailboxes) as approved by the United States Postal Service and the City.
   B.   Location: Mail boxes shall be located as required by the U.S. Postal Service as specified in current regulations of the Salt Lake District. The mailboxes shall not reduce the intended width of the public sidewalk. The developer shall show the location of the clusters of locked mailboxes on the preliminary plat and on the final plat of all subdivisions. The clusters of locked mailboxes may be in the City right-of-way, but they shall not be dedicated to the City. The placement of the Cluster Mailbox shall avoid underground utilities to the greatest extent possible.
   C.   Maintain Plan Required: The subdivider shall submit a maintenance plan for the cluster of locked mailboxes along with his application for the approval of the final plat for the subdivision. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-38-1: PURPOSE:

The purpose of this chapter is to establish standards for the development of parking facilities, access to private and public property, and ensure public health and safety with facilities which safely accommodate vehicles, bicycles, and pedestrians. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-38-2: GENERAL:

   A.   Applicability:
      1.   New Development: The off-street parking standards of this chapter apply to any new development and to any new use established.
      2.   Expansions and Alterations: The off-street parking standards of this chapter apply when an existing structure or use is expanded or enlarged. Additional off-street parking spaces shall be required only to serve the enlarged or expanded area, not the entire building or use. The decisionmaking body may require increases in parking for non-conforming parking areas when found necessary to ensure adequate off-street parking.
Example: Implementation of Parking Requirements When A Business Changes Use In An Existing Building
         1.   A business which was required to provide 10 parking spaces vacates its site. A new business or use which then occupies the site requires 15 parking spaces. The new business is required to provide 5 more parking spaces.
         2.   A business has 8 parking spaces. The current code requires 10 spaces. The business vacates and a new business opens requiring 15 spaces. The new business only needs to provide 5 additional parking spaces. It is not required to resolve the deficiency of legally existing non-conforming parking spaces. Only a total of 13 parking spaces need be provided.
      3.   Change of Use: Off-street parking shall be required for any change of use or change of operation that would result in a requirement for more parking than the existing use. Additional parking shall be required only in proportion to the extent of the change, not for the entire building or use.
      4.   Areas for deliveries and loading shall be required, as a part of any required permit, to ensure that loading and deliveries do not constrain fire access, street safety, or use public streets for deliveries.
   B.   No Reduction Below Minimums: Existing parking spaces shall not be reduced below the minimum requirements in this chapter. Any change in use that increases applicable off-street parking requirements will be deemed a violation of the Land Use Regulations unless parking is provided in accordance with the provisions of this chapter. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-38-3: OFF-STREET PARKING SCHEDULES:

   A.   Off-Street Parking Requirements: The "Off-Street Parking Schedule" Table 10-38-4 lists the minimum off-street parking requirement for each use category defined in the Land Use Regulations. These requirements apply unless an Alternative Parking Plan is reviewed and approved in accordance with Section 10-38-6. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-38-4: RULES FOR COMPUTING REQUIREMENTS:

The following rules apply when computing off-street parking and loading requirements:
   A.   Multiple Uses Lots containing more than one use shall provide parking in an amount equal to the total of the requirements for all uses. The decision-makers may award a reduction of not more than fifteen percent (15%) when it can be found that the uses within the business or development share general customer traffic.
   B.   Fractions When measurements of the number of required spaces result in fractions, any fraction of one-half or less will be disregarded and any fraction of more than one-half will be rounded upward to the next highest whole number.
   C.   Area Measurements Unless otherwise specifically noted, all square footage-based parking and loading standards are to be computed on the basis of gross floor area.
   D.   Occupancy-Based Standards For the purpose of computing parking requirements based on employees, students, residents or occupants, calculations shall be based on the largest number of persons working on any single shift, the maximum enrollment or the maximum fire-rated capacity, whichever is applicable and whichever results in the greater number of spaces.
   E.   Unlisted Uses Upon receiving a development application for a use not specifically listed in an off-street parking schedule, the Planning Commission shall apply the off-street parking standard specified for the listed use that is deemed most similar to the proposed use or require a parking study in accordance with this chapter.
   Table 10-38-4: Parking by Land Use Category
Unless otherwise states, calculations using square footage shall mean Gross Leasable Area.
Land uses with unique parking characteristics refer to the subsection following this table.
The number of parking spaces specified in this chapter shall not be exceeded or reduced by an amount of more than twenty-five percent of the minimum (or maximum is applicable).
Bicycle parking standards refer to the subsection 10-38-10 .
Category
Specific Uses
   Number of Spaces Required
 
 
Minimum
Maximum
Bike
Residential Uses
Group Living
Assisted Living Center
Alternative
N/A
Nursing Home, Convalescent Home
1 per occupant plus 1 guest per 6 required spaces
N/A
N/A
Caregiver, Certified NA or CA
Alternative
N/A
Care, training, or treatment IS provided on site where other types of occupancy exceeds the maximum occupancy allowed by the base zoning district.
1 per occupant plus 1 guest space per 6 required spaces
N/A
N/A
Care, training, or treatment is NOT provided on site where other types of occupancy of a structure where the occupancy exceeds the maximum occupancy allowed by the base zoning district.
2.25 per dwelling unit (min. 1 guest space).
N/A
1 per 2 occupants
Dormitories, Fraternities, Sororities
1.5 per bedroom
N/A
0.5 per bedroom
Household Living
Multi-dwelling structures
2 per dwelling unit
N/A
0.5 per bedroom
Single family dwelling
2 per dwelling unit
N/A
N/A
Category
Specific Uses
   Number of Spaces Required
 
 
Minimum
Maximum
Bike
Institutional Uses
College
Colleges and other institutions of higher learning that offer courses of general or specialized study leading to a degree
Alternative
1 per 5 spaces
Trade, vocational, or commercial schools
Alternative
1 per 10 spaces
Community Services
 
Alternative
1 per 20 spaces
Family Group Daycare/
Preschool (1-8 clients)
Excluding daycare in a residence
1 per 500 s.f.
N/A
N/A
Family Group Daycare/
Preschool (9-16 clients)
 
1 per 500 s.f.
N/A
N/A
Commercial Daycare
 
1 per 500 s.f.
N/A
N/A
Hospital
 
1 per two beds
NA
1 per 20 spaces
Parks & Open Areas
 
Alternative
- -
Religious Institutions
 
1 per 4 persons of max. capacity49
N/A
1 per 30 spaces
Safety Service
 
Alternative
N/A
Schools
Public schools at the elementary, middle, junior high, or high school level that provide state- mandated basic education
Alternative
1 per 10 students
Private schools at the elementary, middle, junior high, or high school level that provide state- mandated basic education
Alternative
1 per 10 students
Telecommunicat ion Facilities
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
Utilities, Basic
Excluding park’n’ride facilities50
None
None
None
Utilities, Distribution
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
Utilities, Facilities
None
N/A
N/A
N/A
Office
Activities conducted in an office setting and generally focusing on business, government, professional, medical, or financial services
1 per 300 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
 
Bank, savings and loans, or credit union (0-4 drive up lanes)51
1 per 250 s.f., plus stacking per Table 10-38-4
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
 
Clinic, medical, dental, or optical
1 per 200 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
 
Laboratory, scientific or research
 
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
 
Wholesale office
1 per 300 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Accommodation s Lodging, Bed and Breakfast
Bed and breakfast: ten or fewer rooms and meal service limited to guests. Sleeping accommodations for transient occupancy
2 plus 1 per room
N/A
N/A
Hotel, Motel
1 per guest room, plus associated uses
N/A
N/A
Parking, Commercial
Facilities providing parking that is not accessory to a specific use; public or private
N/A
N/A
N/A
Parking, Commercial (cont.)
Recreational vehicle and vehicle storage parking
Alternative
N/A
N/A
Truck storage, outdoor
Alternative
N/A
N/A
Recreation & Entertainment, Outdoor Facility
Generally commercial uses that provide recreation or entertainment-oriente d activities, primarily takes place outdoors
Alternative
N/A
N/A
Golf Course (not incl. clubhouse)
4 per green
N/A
N/A
Parks short term occupancy (less than 30 calendar days)
2 plus 1 per RV pad
N/A
N/A
RV Parks long term occupancy (more than 30 calendar days)
2 plus 1 per RV pad
N/A
N/A
Non-vehicle camping (tents) in RV Park
2 plus 1 per tent pad
N/A
N/A
Tent campground
2 plus 1 per tent pad
N/A
N/A
Sales & Service
 
Firms involved in the sale, lease or rent of new or used products to the general public…they may also provide personal services or entertainment, or provide product repair or services for consumer and business goods
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Sales and service, large, footprint greater than 100,000 sq. ft.
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Adult oriented business
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Sales & Service (cont.)
Amusement, commercial indoor
1 per 1,200 s.f.
N/A
1 per 20 spaces
Animal clinic or pet hospital, no outdoor pens
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Animal clinic or pet hospital, with outdoor pens
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Antique or collectible shop
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Art supply store
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Barber or beauty shop
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Bakery or confectionery shop, retail sales
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Camera shop
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Camping supply store in RV Park
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
N/A
Car Wash
Stacking per Table 10-38-7
N/A
N/A
Clothing
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Club, private
1 per 50 s.f. of usable area52
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Convenience Market (no gasoline)
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Dairy products or ice cream
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Dancehall or nightclub
1 per 100 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Department or discount store
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Drug store or pharmacy
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Sales & Service (cont.)
Dry cleaner
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Florist shop
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Furniture or appliance store
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Garden shop, plant sales, nursery
2 per 1,000 s.f. of storage area plus office area
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Grocery store
10 per 1,000 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Handicraft and art object sale
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Hardware store
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Hobby Shop
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Kennel
1 per 400 s.f.
N/A
1 per 20 spaces
Laundromat
1 per 3 machines
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Copy Center
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Locksmith or key shop
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Maintenance or repair service for buildings
Alternative
N/A
1 per 20 spaces
Medical appliance fitting or sales
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 20 spaces
Mortuary
1 per 75 s.f. of slumber room
N/A
1 per 20 spaces
Music store
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Package liquor store
State law preempts local zoning
Paint sales
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Sales & Service (cont.)
Pawn shop
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Personal custom services such as milliner, tailor, etc.
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
Pet shop small animals, birds & fish
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Plumbing shop
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Provisioning and recreational sporting goods sales
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Radio or television transmitting stations, commercial
Alternative
N/A
N/A
Railroad or bus passenger station
Alternative
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Repair of appliances, TV, radios
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Restaurant, General
1 per 150 s.f. of dining area
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Restaurant, Fast-Food
1 per 75 s.f. of customer service and dining area or 1 per 150 s.f., whichever is greater, plus stacking per Table 10-38-7
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Shoe, boot, or other leather goods sale and repair
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Storage warehouse
1 per 2,500 s.f.
N/A
Studio, health, exercise, massage, reducing or similar service
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Studio, photographer, artist, music, dance, and drama
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Sales & Service (cont.)
Tavern
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Tennis or swim club, private Indoor
1 per 300 s.f.
N/A
N/A
Trailer and mobile home sales
Alternative
N/A
N/A
Vehicle parts sales, new or reconditioned, indoor
1 per 1,000 s.f.
N/A
N/A
Vehicle parts sales, used or reconditioned, outdoor
1 per 3,000 s.f.
N/A
N/A
Vehicle and Equipment sales
Sum of components
N/A
N/A
Welding or machine shop
N/A
N/A
Self-Service Storage
Uses providing storage areas for individual or business uses
1 per 250 s.f.
N/A
N/A
Commercial storage unit
1 per 6 units or 1 per 12 units with 20' wide aisle
N/A
N/A
Storage, Outdoor
 
Alternative
N/A
N/A
Vehicle Repair
 
5 per service bay
N/A
N/A
Vehicle Service
Services to motor vehicles where the driver or passengers generally wait in the car or nearby while the service is performed
6 per service bay
N/A
N/A
Vehicle Service (cont.)
Gasoline service stations
1 per employee (based on maximum number of employees working at peak hours) plus 1.5 per service station bay, plus any retail component
N/A
5 per station
Gasoline, petroleum products storage (home heating exempt) (See Uniform Fire Code Section 7902)
Alternative
N/A
N/A
Electric fueling facilities for vehicles (no petroleum) in conjunction with a primary use
Alternative
N/A
N/A
Truck Stop
Alternative
N/A
N/A
Industrial Uses
Industrial Services
Firms engaged in the repair or servicing of business or consumer machinery, equipment, products or by-products
Sum of components
N/A
1 per 20 spaces
Industrial machinery storage, sales, repair
1 per 2,500 s.f.
N/A
1 per 40 spaces
Contractor supply store
1 per 500 s.f.
N/A
1 per 40 spaces
Contractor supply store with outdoor storage
Sum of components
N/A
1 per 40 spaces
Manufacturing, Assembly or Production
Firms involved in the manufacturing, processing, fabrication, packaging, or assembly of goods
Sum of components
N/A
1 per 40 spaces
Manufacturing, Assembly or Production (cont.)
Light manufacturing processes which do not emit detectable dust, odor, fumes, or gas beyond the boundary of the property of noises above the ambient level
Sum of components
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Warehouse and Freight Movement
Firms involved in the storage, or movement of goods for themselves of other firms
Sum of components
N/A
N/A
Contractors storage yard of heavy equipment
None
N/A
N/A
Lumberyard
1 per 1,000 s.f. plus retail sales area
N/A
N/A
Storage of sand, gravel, earth or stone
2 per every 3 employees
N/A
N/A
Waste-Related Use
Uses that receive solid or liquid wastes from others for disposal on the site or for transfer to another location, uses that collect sanitary wastes, or uses that manufacture or produce goods or energy from the composting of organic material
Alternative
N/A
N/A
Enclosed Wrecking or Salvage Facilities
1 per 500 s.f.
N/A
N/A
Open Wrecking or Salvage Facilities
1 per 2,500 s.f.
N/A
N/A
Wholesale Sales
Firms involved in the sale, lease, or rent of products primarily intended for industrial, institutional, or commercial businesses
Alternative
N/A
1 per 10 spaces
Other Uses
Agriculture
Activities that primarily involve raising, producing or keeping crops or animals
None
N/A
N/A
Aviation, Surface Passenger Terminals
Facilities for the landing and takeoff of flying equipment, arrival and departure of vehicles, including loading and unloading areas for passengers, cargo, or freight
Alternative
N/A
N/A
Detention Facilities
Facilities for the judicially required detention or incarceration of people
Alternative
N/A
N/A
Home Occupations
 
None
As specified in permit
N/A
Mining
Mining or extraction of mineral or aggregate resources from the ground for off-site use
Alternative
N/A
N/A
Telecommunicat ions Facilities
Offices and studios
1 per 300 s.f.
N/A
N/A
Transmission facilities
 
1 space or as specified in permit
N/A
N/A
Rail Lines and Utility Corridors
 
Alternative
N/A
N/A
 
(Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-38-5: ALTERNATIVE PARKING PLAN:

An Alternative Parking Plan is a proposal to meet vehicle parking needs by means other than providing parking spaces on-site in accordance with the ratios established in this chapter. Proponents who wish to provide a greater amount (up to a maximum of one hundred and twenty five percent (125%) of the required parking stalls), or a reduced amount (to a minimum of seventy five percent (75%) of the required parking stalls) of off-street parking spaces than required shall secure approval of an Alternative Parking Plan, in accordance with the standards of this section.
   A.   Procedures:
      1.   Plan Contents. Alternative Parking Plans shall be submitted in a form established by the Planning Commission. At a minimum, such plans shall detail the type of alternative proposed and the rationale for such a proposal. Plans shall be prepared by a professional appropriately licensed by the State of Utah.
      2.   Review and Approval:
         a.   Small Facilities: The Planning Commission is authorized to review and act on Alternative Parking Plans if the plan proposes a reduction or decrease of ten percent (10%) or fewer off-street parking spaces.
         b.   Large Facilities: Alternative Parking Plans that propose a reduction or increase of six (6) or more off-street parking spaces from the required amount require review and action by the decision-maker.
      3.   A parking study shall include estimates of parking demand based on recommendations of the Institute of Traffic Engineers (ITE) Parking Generation Manual, or other acceptable estimates as approved by the Department of Public Works, and should include other reliable data collected from uses or combinations of uses that are the same as or comparable with the proposed use. Comparability wilt be determined by density, scale, bulk, area, type of activity, location, or parameters of the use that may be estimated to parking requirements.
      4.   The study shall document the source of data used, and methods used to develop the recommendations. After reviewing the parking study, the Planning Commission and City Engineer shall establish a minimum off-street parking standard for the proposed use.
      5.   Recordation of Approved Plans: A copy of an approved Alternative Parking Plan shall be submitted to the County Recorder's office for recordation. An Alternative Parking Plan may be amended by following the same procedure required for the original approval.
      6.   Appeals of the administrative decision may be made to the Board of Adjustment in accordance with the procedures of Chapter 10-57.
   B.   Transportation Management Program: The Planning Commission may authorize an alternative to the number of required off-street parking spaces for developments or uses that institute and commit to maintaining a Transportation Management Program, in accordance with the standards of this section.
      1.   Required Study: The applicant shall submit a study that clearly indicates the types of transportation management activities and measures proposed.
      2.   Posting and Distribution of Information: The distribution and posting of information from transit agencies and other sources of alternative transportation shall be a minimum requirement of this subsection.
      3.   Transportation Management Activities: There is no limitation on the types of transportation management activities for which reductions may be granted from otherwise required off-street parking ratios. The following measures will serve as a guide to eligible transportation management activities:
         a.   Transportation Coordinator: The appointment of a Transportation Coordinator with responsibility for disseminating information on ride-sharing and other transportation options may be cause for a reduction in otherwise applicable off-street parking requirements. In addition to acting as liaisons, Transportation Coordinators shall be available to attend meetings and training sessions with the City or transit providers.
         b.   Off-Peak Work Hours: Employers that institute off-peak work schedules, allowing employees to arrive at times other than the peak commute periods as defined by the City Engineer, may be eligible for a reduction in otherwise applicable off-street parking requirements.
         c.   Preferential Parking: The provision of specially marked spaces for each registered car pool and van pool may be cause for a reduction in otherwise applicable off-street parking requirements.
         d.   Financial Incentives: The provision of cash or in-kind financial incentives for employees commuting by car pool, van pool and alternative transit may be cause for a reduction in otherwise applicable parking requirements.
   C.   Off-Site Parking: Required parking may be located off-site, if approved as a part of an Alternative Parking Plan and in compliance with all of the following standards:
      1.   Ineligible Activities: Off-site parking may not be used to satisfy the off-street parking standards for residential uses (except for guest parking), restaurants, convenience stores or other convenience-oriented uses. Required parking spaces reserved for persons with disabilities may not be located off-site.
      2.   Location: Off-site parking may be located within a six hundred (600)-foot radius from the use served. Off-site parking spaces may not be separated from the use served by a street right-of-way with a width of more than one hundred twenty feet (120'), unless a grade-separated pedestrian walkway or other traffic control or safety device is provided.
   D.   Agreement For Off-Site Parking: Off-site parking requires a written agreement that shall run with the land and which shall be recorded. A signed, notarized copy of the agreement between the owners of record shall be submitted to the Planning Commission for review and approval. Recordation of the agreement shall take place prior to the issuance of a building permit for any use to be served by the off-site parking area. An off-site parking agreement may be revoked only if required off-street parking spaces are provided in conformance with the provisions of this chapter.
   E.   Shared Parking: Developments or uses with different operating hours or peak business periods may share off-street parking spaces if approved as part of an Alternative Parking Plan and if the shared parking complies with all of the following standards.
      1.   Location: Shared parking spaces shall be located within a 600-foot radius of all uses served.
      2.   Shared Parking Study: A parking study prepared by a professional appropriately licensed by the State of Utah shall be submitted to the Planning Commission that clearly demonstrates the feasibility of shared parking. At a minimum, the study shall address the size and type of the proposed development, the composition of tenants, the anticipated rate of parking turnover and the anticipated peak parking and traffic loads for all uses that will be sharing off-street parking spaces.
      3.   Agreement for Shared Parking: A shared parking agreement shall be enforced through written agreement among all owners of record. A signed, notarized copy of the agreement between the owners of record shall be submitted to the Planning Commission for approval prior to recordation. Recordation of the agreement shall take place prior to the issuance of a building permit for any use to be served by the off-site parking area. A shared parking agreement may be revoked only if required off-street parking spaces can be otherwise provided, in conformance with the provisions of this chapter. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-38-6: FINDINGS:

The decision-making body may approve or conditionally approve as part of a design review permit parking in excess of the maximum allowable stalls per this Section upon substantiating all of the following findings:
   A.   Demand for excess parking is ongoing and not based on a peak day, holiday or seasonal event.
   B.   Unique parking needs do not allow necessary parking to be reasonably provided based on the requirements of this Section.
   C.   A Performance Landscape Plan has been submitted which demonstrates that the site can accommodate additional landscaping to compensate for and mitigate the impact from additional stalls. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-38-7: VEHICLE STACKING CAPACITY IN DRIVE-THROUGH LANES:

   A.   Based on specific site requirements and business operations, the following table shall be used as a guide for the recommended stacking capacity:
   Table 10-38-7: Minimum Stacking Lanes, Number of Vehicles
Activity Type
Minimum Stack
Measured From
Activity Type
Minimum Stack
Measured From
Bank teller lane
3 per lane
Teller or Window
Automated teller machine
3 per machine
Teller
Restaurant drive-through
8
Order Box54
Car wash stall, automatic
6
Entrance
Car wash stall, self-service
1
Entrance
Other
Determined by City Engineer based on Traffic Study
Convenience store drive-thru
Prohibited
Gasoline pump island
30 feet from each end of pump island
 
   B.   Standards for Design and Layout apply to all drive-through facilities. Required stacking spaces are subject to the following design and layout standards:
      1.   Stacking space shall be a minimum of eight feet (8') by sixteen feet (16') in size.
      2.   Stacking spaces shall not impede on- or off-site traffic movements or movements into or out of off-street parking spaces.
      3.   Stacking spaces shall be separated from other internal driveways with raised medians, as deemed necessary by the City Engineer for traffic movement and safety. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-38-8: RESIDENTIAL PARKING:

   A.   Onsite: Except as specifically stated in this chapter, required off-street parking spaces shall be located on the same lot as the primary use.
   B.   Residential Zoning Districts:
      1.   Parking shall not be located within the front setbacks.
      2.   For attached dwelling units, parking {not located within an attached garage) shall be separated from the dwellings by a landscape area. No parking shall be located between the street and the structure.
      3.   If there are no conforming locations on a lot for parking in residential districts, a parking pad may be situated in the side setback, provided that it is no closer than two (2) feet to the adjoining property line. No carport, canopy, or cover shall be permitted (see additional requirements Section 10-44-7J).
   C.   No Heavy Vehicle Storage in Residential Districts: The parking or storage of any commercial truck or truck trailer is prohibited in Residential Districts except when located outside of front yards, setbacks and public rights-of way, or located within a residential garage. This prohibition does not apply to vehicles making deliveries or pick-ups.
   D.   Parking of Recreational Vehicles: No recreational vehicle shall be parked within the public right-of-way, or if there is an adjoining driveway, no recreational vehicle shall be parked in a sight distance triangle of fifteen (15) feet from the front property line.
   E.   Outside storage or parking of more than two (2) unregistered vehicles or trailers is prohibited in all residential zoning districts.
Figure 10-38-8D: Recreation Vehicle Sight Distance Triangle Established
 
(Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-38-9: COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL PARKING:

   A.   Onsite Parking Required: A commercial and industrial development shall be required to provide adequate parking onsite except as noted:
      1.   Within the Town Center district in Downtown Wellsville where there is no physical location for onsite parking, businesses may provide parking at offsite locations in conformance with this chapter, or businesses may contribute a proportional share of the cost of developing offsite parking, if approved.
      2.   Businesses in any zone may contract or lease offsite parking or obtain parking easements at locations conforming to the requirements of this chapter.
      3.   If a right-of-way parking permit has been obtained in conformance with the Wellsville City Code, the parking identified in the permit shall count or be part of the parking requirements of this chapter.
   B.   Location of Parking:
      1.   On-site parking must be located in the side or rear yard areas.
      2.   Legally existing non-conforming parking lots must meet current landscaping standards upon a change of use or significant change or alteration. See Sections 10-39-2 through 10-39-4.
Figure 10-38-9: Parking Lot Specifications and Dimensions
   C.   Driveway Widths: Maximum driveway width in commercial and industrial zones shall be fifty-two feet (52').
   D.   Parking Lot Design: Parking lots and parking spaces shall be designed and maintained in conformance with the standards shown in Figure 10-38-9. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-38-10: BICYCLE PARKING:

All new development or change of use shall install parking for bicycles as required in Table 10-38-4 of the Code. Required bicycle parking areas are subject to the following design and layout standards:
   A.   Bicycle parking shall be provided with racks that allow the frame and one wheel to be locked to the rack with a high security, U-shaped lock.
   B.   Racks shall be clearly visible and accessible, but should not interfere with pedestrian traffic or other site furnishings.
   C.   Parking areas shall be well-lit for theft protection, personal security and accident prevention. Exterior lighting shall meet the standards in Section 10-36-10 of the Land Use Regulations.
   D.   Location of bicycle parking shall be separated from vehicle parking and roads with space and physical barriers in order to prevent potential damage to parked bikes and/or vehicles. Bicycle parking shall not be located on sidewalks or in areas that obstruct pedestrian traffic flow.
   E.   Use existing overhangs or covered areas to provide weather protection for parking areas.
   F.   Bicycle parking spaces shall be calculated based on their manufacturer's recommended use of the product. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-38-11: PARKING FOR PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES:

Off-street parking for persons with disabilities shall be provided in accordance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and the Uniform Federal Accessibility Standards. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-38-12: USE OF REQUIRED PARKING SPACES:

   A.   Use Of Parking Areas: Required off-street parking areas shall be used solely for the parking of licensed, motor vehicles in operating condition. Required spaces may not be used for the storage of vehicles, boats, motor homes, campers, mobile homes, or building materials.
   B.   Use Of Parking Areas For Temporary Events And Sales:
      1.   A portion of a parking lot that allows at least seventy-five percent (75%) of the remaining legal parking spaces to be used for parking in conformance with the standards of this chapter may be set aside for purposes of a temporary event, such as a "tent sale," "sidewalk/parking lot sate," or other permitted activity. These events may not exceed seven consecutive days in length while not occurring more than once each calendar quarter, or may not exceed two consecutive days while not occurring more than three times each calendar quarter,
      2.   The property owner and operator of the licensed business at the location are jointly responsible for ensuring that events blocking parking lots do not result in unsafe traffic or circulation conditions and ensures that there is adequate fire and emergency vehicle access. The Police Chief, Fire Chief or their designee may order the event cancelled and removed without hearing or notice if found that the arrangement of the temporary event or sale interferes with safe flow of traffic or emergency vehicle access to a site.
      3.   The property owner, business licensed at the site, and entity responsible for the event are jointly responsible for ensuring there is adequate parking at the event site. The use of public right-of-way for event parking is prohibited. Parking arrangements may be made for use of adjoining or nearby parking areas within a six hundred foot (600') radius, but a copy of the agreements shall be in writing and filed with the Planning Commission at least two (2) working days prior to the event.
   C.   Long-Term Vendors Located In Parking Lots:
      1.   A business license for the temporary long-term use of a parking lot for a vendor (example and not limited to: Christmas trees, fireworks, snow cone sales, ice cream sales, seasonal food sales) that will be located in the parking lot for more than seven consecutive days may be permitted by the Planning Commission provided that a copy of a written agreement for use of the parking area is submitted to the Planning Commission prior to the establishment of the use.
      2.   A site plan showing the location of the facility and an indication of the total number of existing spaces in the parking lot and parking to be removed by the vendor shall be submitted to the Director.
      3.   Depending on the design of the parking area and location of the long-term vendor, the Planning Commission may require parking spaces in the area of the vendor to be re-striped for purposes of providing parking or accommodating safe traffic flows.
      4.   A portion of a parking lot that allows at least ninety-five percent (95%) of the required parking spaces, for general usage, in conformance with current zoning standards may be used by long-term vendors.
   D.   Temporary Vendors on Undeveloped Sites: The use of undeveloped sites for parking or sales by temporary vendors shall be prohibited. Temporary vendors may utilize undeveloped portions of appropriately zoned properties provided that the property owner creates an approved right-of-way access, a paved surface for the area as approved by the Planning Commission and the City Engineer, parking needed by the vendor, and landscaping. The Planning Commission may approve the design and landscaping for temporary vending.
   E.   Shopping Cart Corrals: Cart corrals or similar facilities shall not be permitted to replace required parking. New development shall identify cart corral or collection areas on the site plan. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-38-13: ACCESS AND DRIVEWAYS:

Access and driveways shall conform to the standards as outlined in Chapter 10-37 of the Land Use Regulations. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-38-14: LANDSCAPING:

Landscaping for parking lots shall conform to the standards as outlined in Chapter 10-39 of the Land Use Regulations. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-38-15: SETBACKS FOR PARKING:

Setbacks for parking shall conform to the standards as outlined in Chapter 10-39, Table 10-15-1, Table 10-18-1 or Table 10-21-1 of the Land Use Regulations. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-39-1: PURPOSE AND INTENT:

This chapter provides standards for landscaping of all new or redeveloped projects within the City. These standards do not apply to single family detached homes, except where new residential development abuts U.S Highway 89/91 or as may be otherwise required in Title 10 or Title 11. It is intended to ensure that the policies of the General Plan related to increasing the attractiveness of the City and enhancing neighborhood character includes appropriate landscaping.
The General Plan sets forth general requirements for the maintenance of community character and further establishes general requirements for growth and development that is consistent with the character of the City. The Land Use Regulations, of which this chapter is apart, establishes specific and detailed regulations that implement the purposes of the General Plan. Specifically, the General Plan states the following which guide the detailed regulations of this Chapter 10-39 Landscaping:
"Measures should be taken to preserve the open space that exists along the highway and in no case should commercial growth be allowed to continuously line the roadside... The land adjacent to entrance roadways to the city and Highway 89/91 should remain as scenic approaches... The views and vistas of Wellsville are critical to the quality image of the City... The gateways to Wellsviile are vital to the quality of the City. Efforts must continue to place priorities on city entrances that invite and that maintain rural qualities of the community. Large setbacks should be required along these roadways. The Planning Commission should require additional landscaping and other visual controls to ensure quality entrances to the City of Wellsville.”
The City recognizes the aesthetic, ecological, and economic value of landscaping and requires its use to:
   A.   Improve landscaping for the visual quality of the City.
   B.   Reduce the rate and volume of storm water runoff.
   C.   Promote compatibility between land uses and create buffer areas by reducing the visual, noise, and lighting impacts from adjoining properties.
   D.   Unify development within the Zoning Districts throughout the City.
   E.   Promote the retention of existing vegetation and restore natural communities through re-establishment of native plants.
   F.   Reduce the visual and audio impacts of automobile related infrastructure (parking lots, driveways and roads).
   G.   Promote healthy outdoor recreational activities.
   H.   Reduce greenhouse gases and the negative environmental impacts created from automobiles and development.
   I.   Use the landscape to compliment the built environment and achieve the principals and goals set forth in the General Plan and Land Use Regulations.
   J.   Promote water efficient landscaping that reduces the demand on City's water resources.
   K.   Reduces heat island effect.
 
(Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-39-2: APPLICABILITY:

The standards of this chapter apply to all public and private development, new construction, exterior remodeling, enlargement or change of use, unless otherwise specifically stated in this chapter. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-39-3: EXEMPTION:

The following are exempt from the standards of this chapter:
   A.   Agriculture structures and agricultural uses;
   B.   Minor improvements or repairs to existing development that do not result in an increase in floor area.
   C.   Detached single family dwellings on individual lots for a period of one (1) year for the front yard area and a period of two (2) years for the rear yard area beginning at the time the final certificate of occupancy is issued. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-39-4: LANDSCAPING:

   A.   Required Landscaping:
      1.   Required landscaping shall be installed in all yard areas, along the perimeter of the lot, around buildings, and all other portions of the property not specifically utilized for walkways, driveways, parking, loading, or other functions for which landscaping may not be practical as determined by the decision-makers.
      2.   Lawn areas in new commercial, industrial, institutional, and multi-family development common area landscapes shall not exceed twenty percent (20%) of the total landscaped area, except for lawn areas required for active recreation.
   B.   Use Of Sterilants, Weed Killers, Or Herbicides: The use of these products shall not be used as a permanent landscape solution. No sterilants, weed killers, or herbicides that result in soil conditions that preclude plant material to grow shall be permitted without the prior written approval of the Planning Commission. Such products shall be applied in conformance with Federal and State regulations.
   C.   Landscaping For Lots Which Are Partially Developed: At the discretion of the decision-makers, projects with substantial portions of the parcel area left for future development may be exempt from landscaping the undeveloped portion of the property. If any portion of the undeveloped area of the lot fronts a public right-of-way, standard improvements such as curb, gutter, sidewalk and installation of street trees and other appropriate landscaping shall be required at the time of the development.
   D.   Landscaping When Expansion Or Additional Development Occurs: If a parcel with existing development is proposed for additional development, and the expansion results in more than a ten percent (10%) increase in gross square footage the decision-makers have the discretion to review the landscaping installed on the entire property and may require conformance to the requirements of Section 10-39-5 . If the expansion or redevelopment results in less than a ten percent (10%) gross increase in square footage the Planning Commission shall require conformance with the landscape requirements of Section 10-39-5 for the new portion of the project only.
   E.   Landscaping Required For Interior Remodeling That Results in a change of use, where practicable, full compliance with this chapter shall be required when a change of use occurs that results in any modifications to the site and exterior of the structures. The Planning Commission, upon review of existing landscaping, may require partial compliance. Compliance is not required when a structure is changed in use and there is no change in exterior appearance and there are no Planning Commission or Design Review approvals required.
   F.   Landscaping and setback requirements for all new development, other than residential development, abutting U.S. Highway 89/91. The requirements set forth in the General Plan (see Standards for Development Projects) pertaining to highways require large setbacks from the highway and landscaping to maintain rural character and a quality image of the City. Landscaped setbacks from the highway right-of-way shall be a minimum of one hundred fifty feet (150'). Setbacks may vary, but the average along the entire highway must be a minimum of the required one hundred fifty feet (150'). When average setback is used, the setback shall not be less than sixty feet (60') at any location. Berming is not required, but is allowed, where buildings abut the front yard setback. Berming shall be required where parking lots, interior roads, drives, utilities, and/or service areas are adjacent to the setback (see Section 10-39-7 B Type "E" Separation). Earthen berming is required to be at least six feet (6') high with a base of at least forty feet (40'). Berms shall be continuous along the frontage except where driveway approaches access the main highway or in those areas of the setback where buildings are located. The highway setback may be used to meet stormwater storage requirements, but all berming and screening requirements shall be fulfilled. Stormwater detention and retention basins shall be landscaped as required for all other landscaped areas and shall conform to the Stormwater Code in Titles 8 Chapters 4 and 5.
Certain incentives for development are provided to allow the Planning Commission to modify the setback requirements. These incentives intend to encourage Highway development that is compatible with the goals of the city.
   1.   Landscaping setbacks may be reduced to seventy five feet (75') if determined by the Planning Commission that increased berming, screening, and landscaping ensures the purposes set forth in this Chapter. Specially, the height of berming, and the plant materials shall be increased sufficiently to compensate for the reduction in setback.
   2.   Landscaping setbacks may be reduced further by the voluntary development of a public trail running parallel to and within the front setback. The setback may be reduced equal to the width of the trail and is subject to the Planning Commission finding that the purposes of this Chapter shall prevail.
   3.   In order to encourage development at major lighted intersection, setbacks may be reduced to forty feet (40') adjacent to U.S. Highway 89/91 on land parcels which are located at future intersections where traffic lights will be allowed by agreement with the City of Wellsville and the Utah Department of Transportation. Specific parcels where reduced setbacks are allowed are as follows and as included in the CGC zoning district:
      11-090-0007
      11-089-0007
      11-087-0008
      11-087-0007
      11-088-0022
      11-091-0012
      11-091-0011
      11-091-00
   G.   Landscaping and setback requirements for new residential development abutting U.S Highway 89/91. The requirements set forth in the General Plan (see Standards for Development Projects) pertaining to highways require large setbacks and landscaping to maintain a quality image of the City. The landscaped highway setback shall be a minimum of one hundred fifty feet (150'). If the front of the home is facing the Highway no earthen berming is required, but setback area shall be fully landscaped. Where the side or the rear of homes face the highway, a two hundred foot (200') highway setback is required with berming (see Section 10-39-7 B Type "F" Separation) Berms shall be at least six feet (6') high with a base of at least forty feet (40'). Berms shall be continuous along the frontage. The highway setback may be used to meet stormwater storage requirements, but all berming and screening requirements shall be fulfilled. Stormwater detention and retention basins shall be landscaped as required for all other landscaped areas and shall conform to the Stormwater Code in Titles 8 Chapters 4 and 5.
Figure 10-39-5A: All new Development, except when abutting Highway 89/91, to be landscaped with buildings placed to screen parking and fronting on the primary street.
 
Figure 10-39-5B: All new development along Highway 89/91 required to provide a berm with a landscaped setback for parking, drives, and service areas.
 
Figure 10-39-5C: All new commercial/industrial development along Highway 89/91 where access is allowed is required to provide a berm with a 150' landscaped setback for parking, drives, and services areas.
 
Figure 10-39-5D: Residential Development along Highway 89/91 required to provide a berm with a landscaped setback. Residential dwellings are required to front on a single loaded roadway. The rear year of dwellings shall not be adjacent to the highway right-of-way. (see 10-39-4 G)
 
(Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019; amd. Ord. 2023-04, 4-19-2023)

10-39-5: LANDSCAPING PERFORMANCE (MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS):

Landscaping requirements are intended to establish a minimum standard by which a property owner may use to design a set of landscape drawings that can be approved and constructed through the City’s development process.
   A.   For commercial, industrial, mixed-use, and multi-family projects located within the any zone.
      1.   At least fifty percent (50%) of the required landscape area of the project shall be living, planted landscape.
      2.   Twenty (20) trees shall be required for every acre of land. For parcels of land where fractions of acres occur, the requirement for trees shall be proportionate to the fractional acreage.
      3.   Fifty (50) shrubs shall be required per one (1) acre of gross land.
      4.   Plant material shall be placed around the perimeter of the building footprint in a three foot (3') minimum planting strip with the exception of entrances, utilities and where setbacks are less than three feet (3').
      5.   When abutting Highway 89/91 the required setback area shall be fully landscaped with at least one (1) tree for every twenty feet (20') of frontage, planted in a naturalistic pattern.
      6.   Street trees required 10-39-6 A. and F.
   B.   For multi-family, mixed use, and projects located within a future Mixed Residential zone excluding single family homes.
      1.   At least seventy-five percent (75%) of the required useable open space of the project shall be planted landscape area.
      2.   Twenty-four (24) trees shall be required per one (1) acre of gross land.
      3.   Fifty (50) shrubs shall be required per one (1) acre of gross land.
      4.   Plant material shall be placed around the perimeter of the building footprint in a three (3) foot minimum planting strip with the exception of entrances, utilities and where setbacks are less than three feet.
      5.   When abutting Highway 89/91 the required setback area shall be fully landscaped with at least one (1) tree for every twenty (20) feet of frontage, planted in a naturalistic pattern.
   C.   Plant Selection: Plants selected for landscape areas shall be well suited for Wellsville's climate and soil conditions at the project site. Plants with similar water needs shall be grouped together as much as possible. On slopes greater than thirty percent (30%), plant material shall be selected to reduce the risk of soil erosion. Native and drought tolerant plant material are encouraged and should be used whenever possible. Projects should have a diverse mix of plant species for disease resistance and visual interest.
   D.   Mulch: Mulch is encouraged in non-turf areas to retain water, discourage weed growth and moderate soil temperatures. Weed barrier fabrics shall be a porous material to allow water and air to infiltrate the soils below.
   E.   Use of Evergreen Trees and Shrubs: A minimum of twenty-five (25%) percent of the plant material used for the project shall be evergreen trees and shrubs to provide visual interest year-round and for dense landscape screening.
   Table 10-39-5E.: Species Diversity Requirements
 
Required Number of Trees
Minimum Number of Species
11-20
2
21-30
3
31-40
4
41+
5
 
   F.   Screening Of Service Areas: Landscape shall be used to provide visual and audio buffers between pedestrian and service areas. Use multiple planting layers and stager plants to provide screening from various viewpoints. Loading docks, storage of material or vehicles, and other service areas shall be screened from public view as specified in the design review process. Acceptable screening may include plant material, fencing, walls, earth berm or a combination as approved by the decision-makers.
      1.   Solid waste receptacles, recycling bins, refuse storage shall be screened from view on three (3) sides by a fence or wall with a minimum height of six feet (6') or one foot (1') taller than the receptacle, whichever is greater. Waste disposal receptacles shall be located out of the public view insofar as is practical. See Section 10-11-16 .
      2.   The enclosure shall be compatible in material and color with the primary structure on the lot if located within twenty feet (20') of the building, if located beyond twenty feet (20') from the structure the enclosure should be designed to minimize the visual impact and blend in with surrounding landscaping.
      3.   Waste disposal and recycling receptacles shall be consolidated to reasonably minimize the number of collection sites and to equalize the distance from the buildings they serve.
   G.   Enhance Or Develop Pedestrian-Oriented Spaces Within A Project: Such as Walkway Landscaping and Creation of Usable Outdoor Spaces.
      1.   Use vertical landscaping to break up long stretches of linear wall planes and to soften the hard edges of the built environment.
      2.   Provide a balance between the overall appearance of the landscaping as a part of a planned site and the buildings on the site. The City's objective is to ensure that the site has dense landscaping in terms of the land area dedicated to landscaping and in vertical elevation of landscaping.
      3.   Any flexibility to be applied by the decision-makers shall be based on achieving an attractive site with installations of landscaping that are designed to complement and enhance the site development.
      4.   A variety of tree species shall be provided in conformance with Table 10-39-5E.
   H.   Submission Of Landscape Plans:
      1.   All commercial, industrial, mixed-use and multi-family landscape plans shall be prepared and stamped by a Licensed Landscape Architect registered with the State of Utah.
      2.   Landscape plans shall be submitted prior to or included with submittal for Building Permit.
      3.   Landscape plans shall be of adequate size and detail so the decisionmakers can see the land area to be planted and the appearance of plantings at seventy-five percent (75%) of mature growth.
      4.   Landscape plans and details shall be drawn in a professional manner with credible representations of plant sizes and site features. The Planning Commission or staff may reject plans which do not accurately depict the site landscaping.
      5.   Landscape plans shall be accompanied by a planting schedule that identifies both the common and scientific name of each species. The schedule shall include the size and type of plant material to be installed.
      6.   Landscape plans shall be drawn to scale and have a north arrow. Site features including buildings, parking lots, streets, existing vegetation, utilities should be shown for reference and orientation. Planting details and Irrigation specifications will generally not be including with the submitted Performance Landscape plan unless unique situations are associated with the project requiring further detail.
      7.   Show on the landscape plans the location and connection type of backflow prevention.
   I.   Review Of Landscape Plans: Landscape plans may be approved upon a finding that the plan meets or exceeds the purposes and objectives of this chapter through either:
      1.   Natural land characteristics or existing vegetation on the proposed development site; or
      2.   Innovative landscaping or architectural design.
   Figure 10-39-5: Example of a Landscape Plan
 
(Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-39-6: LANDSCAPING IN PUBLIC RIGHTS-OF-WAY:

   Landscaping in public rights-of-way should be designed to conserve water, use drip irrigation systems and use plants that conserve water._ All streets, either public or private, shall provide a planted landscaped park strip to City specifications, and be perpetually maintained by the adjacent property owner. Plantings within the right-of-way or park strip will not count towards meeting the performance landscape requirements of Section 10-39-5 .
   A.   Street trees shall be planted within the entire parkstrip adjacent or abutting the development frontage at a uniform spacing of thirty feet (30') on center. If no parkstrip exists, trees shall be planted adjacent to the roadway edge located as required in Standards and Specifications of the City of Wellsville. Tree size, species, and locations shall be approved by the Planning Commission and shall be included in the Landscape Plan (Section 10-39-5).
   B.   Landscaping in park strips shall be installed and maintained as follows:
      1.   In all park strips, street trees are required as 10-39-6-A.
      2.   Plants, including trees, shall be irrigated with water conserving irrigation systems.
      3.   Parks strips shall be planted with live plantings of shrubs and ground cover which will grow to cover at least fifty (50) percent of the total area of the park strip when the plants mature. Shrubs and other plant material located within all park strips shall not exceed three feet (31) in height at maturity. Potential hazardous plant material containing thorns or spikes shall be prohibited in the park strip. When calculating park strip coverage percentage areas, plants may be measured at mature spread excluding street trees.
      4.   In new residential development the follow is required:
         a.   No lawn shall be planted in park strips less than eight (8) feet in width.
         b.   No more than fifty (50) percent of the front and side yard landscaping may be lawn. Lawn limitations do not apply to small residential lots with less than two hundred-fifty (250) square feet of landscaped area in the front yard.
   C.   Stone, gravel, mulch, or other decorative hardscape materials shall not exceed fifty percent (50%) of the park strip area ground cover. Decorative boulders and similar features shall be less than eighteen inches (18") in height. Poured concrete, asphalt or other similar solid surface paving is prohibited within the park strip, except for driveway approaches and adjacent commercial uses.
   D.   Landscaping and any other surface material located within the right-of-way between the edge of traveled way and the property shall not be used for the storage, sale, and/or display of merchandise.
   E.   Where Utah Department of Transportation (UDOT) rights-of-way are involved in the development of landscaping, state permits shall be obtained and landscaping with UDOT rights-of-way shall conform to state standards.
   F.   Anyone installing materials for paving, landscaping or storing within the public right-of-way shall be responsible to pay for removal or restoration of such materials in the event that the Public Works Department is required, by its duty of maintenance and use of streets, culverts, drains, ditches, waterways, curbs, gutters, sidewalks, street trees, public utilities and any other service provided by the city or utility providers located within the right-of-way.(Title 7.1.1 A-C). The cost of removal and/or restoration necessary for the Public Works Department to do its duty shall be reimbursed to the City by the responsible property owner(s) for the amount required to perform the work.
(Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019; amd. Ord. 2023-04, 4-19-2023)

10-39-7: PARKING LOT LANDSCAPING:

Parking lot landscaping standards of this section establish minimum landscaping requirements for the perimeter and interior of off-street parking areas, access driveways, and drives to and from drive-up windows. The general purpose of such landscaping is to reduce the visual impact of parking and pavement. See Chapter 10-38 Parking Section and the project's zone Development Specification Standards page for parking lot locations and setbacks. Parking lot landscaping may count towards meeting the Landscaping Performance Minimum Requirements.
   A.   Applicability to All Off-Street Parking Lots: Parking lot landscaping shall be approved through the Design Review process and shall not be less than the minimum standards of this chapter.
   B.   Perimeter Parking Lot Landscaping: The parking lot perimeter landscaping requirements apply to all off-street parking lots that are not otherwise fully screened from view of adjacent public rights-of-way. Landscape borders shall be used for open space and landscaping. No structures or paving shall be located within the border area, with the exception of walls, walkways or other features incorporated into the landscaping. If adjoining properties share or abut parking lots, the perimeter landscape requirements are waived for the two (2) adjoining sides of each parking lot and the two adjoining parking lots will be calculated as one.
      1.   If the parking lot's front setback is twenty-five feet (25') or more, the border landscape shall conform to the Type "A" Separation in figure 10-38-7 B. Border trees shall be planted at an average of twenty feet (30') on center.
      2.   For Type "B" and "C", separation shrubs must be planted at an average of three feet (3') on center and small trees at fifteen feet (15') on center along the entire border.
      3.   For Type "C" separations, the earth berm or wall combination shall be a minimum three feet (3') in height measured from the nearest street's top back of curb and in combination with plant material to achieve a minimum four foot (4') tall solid screen at installation.
      4.   For Type "D" separations, when a wall is constructed it must be four feet (4') in height and in combination with plant material placed at six feet (6') on center.
      5.   For parking lots containing twenty-five (25) stalls or fewer, five feet (5') shall be the minimum perimeter border width for the rear and side borders of the parking lot.
      6.   For parking lots containing more than twenty-five (25) stalls, eight feet (8') shall be the minimum perimeter border width for the rear and side borders of the parking lot.
      7.   Side and rear parking lot perimeter borders shall be landscaped with plant material covering a minimum of fifty percent (50%) of the total border surface area measured at the plant maturity.
      8.   For Type "E" separation requirements when new development is abutting Highway 89/91.
      9.   No longer needed.
 
   C.   Parking Lot Interior Landscaping Requirements: The parking lot interior landscaping requirements apply to all off-street parking lots that contain five or more parking spaces. Only areas specified in figure Section 10-39-7 C can be counted towards a project's interior parking lot landscaping requirements. Interior planting areas are required within all parking lots as specified in this subsection.
      1.   At least eighteen (18) square feet of interior landscape planting area shall be provided within the interior of an off-street parking area for each parking stall contained with the parking area.
      2.   Landscaping located within the interior of a parking area shall be evenly dispersed throughout the area. All planting areas shall be protected to prevent damage by vehicles and vehicle overhang.
      3.   When the number of stalls in a parking area exceeds the number of required parking stalls defined in Chapter 10-39 by one hundred twenty five percent (125%), the minimum interior parking lot landscaping requirements shall be increased to thirty-six (36) square feet of interior landscaping for each parking space contained within the parking stall.
      4.   All aisles shall have landscaped areas at each end of the aisle.
      5.   One (1) tree shall be planted within the interior of a parking area per every ten (10) stalls contained within the area. Interior parking area landscapes shall have a minimum of fifty percent (50%) plant material coverage measured at plants maturity.
   Figure 10-39-7C: Interior Parking Lot Measurement Area
 
      6.   For all commercial and industrial zones, parking lot landscaping for tractor/trailer truck service areas, loading, docking, staging, and truck parking lots, the Planning Commission shall review and determine landscape requirements. The Planning Commission may reduce or eliminate the requirement on the interior of parking lots and paved areas. However, the Planning Commission shall require, at least, the quantity of plant material required for interior landscaping to be located at the periphery of parking lots to screen vehicles and services from public view and to provide buffer landscaping between adjacent properties. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-39-8: INSTALLATION, REPLACEMENT, OCCUPANCY:

   A.   Accepted Practices Required: All landscaping shall be installed according to sound nursery practices in a manner designed to encourage vigorous and healthy growth. All landscape material, living and non-living, shall be in place prior to the issuance of the final Certificate of Occupancy plant material shall be in a healthy condition.
   B.   Protection of Existing Trees During Construction: Any trees identified or approved for preservation by the Planning Commission shall be protected utilizing accepted techniques for protection. All trees and other vegetation identified for protection must be watered regularly to maintain vigorous growth during construction until new irrigation systems are operational at the time of occupancy.
   C.   Replacement of Dead, Diseased, Or Dying Vegetation: The Beautification Committee or Planning Commission may require that landscaping be replaced in kind if vegetation becomes dead, diseased, or dying. In the event of blight or species-specific diseases, substitution of plants shall be approved by the Planning Commission or the Beautification Committee.
   D.   Temporary Occupancy Requirements: A Certificate of Occupancy may be issued prior to the installation of required landscaping upon execution of an agreement with the City and acceptance by the City of appropriate surety.
      1.   Land development that does not require or is normally utilized without obtaining a certificate of occupancy shall have landscaping installed per this chapter prior to the initiation of any use or any occupancy of the facility, structure, or grounds.
      2.   An agreement for temporary occupancy shall be used only under extenuating circumstances which prohibit the physical installation of landscaping at the time the Certificate of Occupancy is issued. Financial or similar issues shall not constitute extenuating circumstances for the purpose of this section.
      3.   Financial surety shall be equal to one hundred ten percent (110%) of the estimated cost of the plant material, irrigation, labor, and materials.
         a.   The amount of the surety shall be calculated from a written cost estimate prepared by an appropriately licensed professional and provided to the City by the developer. If the Planning Commission finds that the cost estimates are not generally within accepted standards for estimating the costs of landscaping installation, the Planning Commission shall require that surety be based on accepted estimating practices.
         b.   Each estimate shall be guaranteed valid at the maturity of the surety instrument.
         c.   An irrevocable letter of credit, cash deposit, cashier's check, certificate of deposit endorsed in favor of the City, performance bond issued by a bonding company with an investment grade rating by Moodys or Standard and Poors, or savings account passbook issued in favor of the City shall be acceptable forms of surety.
      4.   The expiration date of the surety bond shall be determined by the Planning Commission at the time the agreement is made. The expiration date shall be appropriate to the project circumstances. If the Surety bond expires, the City shall have the authority to seize the surety and install the landscaping. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-39-9: XERISCAPING:

   A.   Qualifications: Xeriscaping or Water-Wise Landscaping is encouraged, as is, the use and development of secondary irrigation water systems. Xeriscaping consists of native and drought tolerant plant material placed in conjunction with groundcover or mulch. Xeriscaping is encouraged throughout the city as a way to reduce water consumption. The selection of plant material shall be based on microclimate, exposure and slope of the site. At mature growth plant material should cover a minimum of fifty percent (50%) of the ground. Rocks, hardscape and mulches alone without native and drought tolerant plantings are not considered xeriscaping and do not meet these minimum requirements. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-39-10: IRRIGATION:

   A.   Automatic Irrigation Required: All new landscaping installations shall be required to incorporate an automatic underground irrigation system. Irrigation systems should be designed to conserve water and avoid erosion of soils. Irrigation heads should have a matched precipitation rates for each valve. The irrigation system, when connected to culinary water supplies, shall have backflow prevention assembly(s) installed to prevent contamination of culinary water system. Backflow preventer and installation shall meet current City codes and policies. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-39-11: MAINTENANCE AND UPKEEP OF LANDSCAPING:

   A.   Landscaping To Be Maintained in a Vigorous and Healthy Condition:
      1.   Regular maintenance of all landscaping to present a healthy, neat and orderly appearance shall be required.
      2.   All landscaping shall be maintained free from disease, pests, weeds and litter.
      3.   Maintenance shall include weeding, watering, fertilizing, pruning, mowing, edging, mulching and other maintenance as needed and in accordance with acceptable horticultural practices.
   B.   Repair And Replacement Of Landscaping:
      1.   Required landscape structures (examples include and are not limited to walls, fences, curbs, planters) shall be maintained in a structurally sound and aesthetically pleasing condition.
      2.   The regular maintenance, repair, or replacement of any landscaping irrigation systems as required by this chapter.
      3.   Continuous maintenance of the site as a whole.
   C.   Aquifer Protection Areas 10-39 Landscaping Requirements: Areas of the City are designated by Code as "Aquifer Protection Areas." Landscaping within designated areas may have restrictions as to the types of plants, use of chemicals, and other standards imposed for purposes of protecting municipal groundwater quality. See this code and the Utah Division of Drinking Water R309-600 "Source Protection Regulations". (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-39-12: LANDSCAPING FEATURES ARE A PART OF THE OVERALL APPROVAL:

Trees, shrubs, fences, walls and other landscape features depicted on plans approved by the City shall be considered as elements of the project in the same manner as parking, building materials and other details are elements of the plan. The landowner, heirs, successors in interest, lessees, or agent, shall be jointly and inseverably responsible for installation, maintenance, and upkeep as specified in this Title. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-39-13: COMPLIANCE:

Landscaping compliance when it is found not to be physically possible to achieve compliance with the objectives of this chapter.
   A.   If the Planning Commission finds that site development, location of existing landscaping, or other physical factors make it physically impossible to achieve compliance with the provisions of this section, the Planning Commission may require alternative compliance that conforms to the purpose of this chapter.
   B.   Alternative compliance may include any or a combination of the following and is not limited to the alternatives specified in this subsection:
      1.   Planting of street trees and public right-of-way landscaping in the general vicinity of the subject property.
      2.   Financial contributions related to the approximate value of onsite landscaping materials and labor into a trust fund to be established for public landscaping in the neighborhood in which the subject property is located.
      3.   City approved purchase and installation of other landscape or streetscape amenities, such as and not limited to benches, lighting, public art, access paths or sidewalks.
      4.   Modification of setbacks and landscape requirements to meet the purpose of this chapter to the greatest extent possible as determined by the Planning Commission. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-40-1: PURPOSE:

The purposes of these sign regulations are to encourage the effective use of signs as a means of communication in the City; to fulfill a community-wide goal to protect the aesthetic quality of the community; to minimize the possible adverse effect of signs on nearby public and private property; and to enable the fair and consistent enforcement of these sign regulations. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-40-2: APPLICABILITY:

The provisions of this section apply to all types of signs, except:
   A.   Official public notice, traffic control, warning, or safety signs as required by law;
   B.   Appropriately displayed official flags of any country, federal agency, state, county, or City government;
   C.   Any sign located within a building and not visible from a public street;
   D.   Display of actual merchandise within display windows in commercial buildings;
   E.   Identification sign(s) or logo(s) applied to the outside surface of a vehicle, provided, only if the vehicle or trailer is not used as a sign as defined in Section 10-40-10 Prohibited Signs. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-40-3: PERMANENT SIGNS:

   A.   Residential Zoning Districts and Residential Uses in Nonresidential Zones The following standards apply to all permanent residential signs without regard to the base zoning district. Churches, schools, parks, government facilities, and community services within residential zoning districts (RCA, RAC5, ROS1, ROS1/2, RSF, REC, A, FR ) are also regulated by this section and table 10-40-3A.
      1.   Sign types not listed in the following table are not permitted;
      2.   Only one reader board or message center is allowed per project;
      3.   All electronic message centers require a Design Review Permit prior to installation.
      4.   See also Sections 10-40-4 through 10-40-7 regarding sign measurement, placement, illumination, and permitting.
      5.   All new projects shall have signage areas and locations designated and approved as part of the Design Review Permit. Individual sign permits may be applied for as the tenant space fills up.
Table 10-40-3A.: Residential Signs
Use/ Structure type
Sign Type
Number
Area (s.f.)
Height (ft.)
Setback (ft.)55
Approval Type
Use/ Structure type
Sign Type
Number
Area (s.f.)
Height (ft.)
Setback (ft.)55
Approval Type
Multi Family Complex
Building
1 per facade
24
na
na
DR
 
Monument
1 per street
24
6
0, not in SDT
DR
 
Directional
One per access point to a vehicular use area within the property or project
3
4
0, not in SDT
DR
Home Occupation Churches, Schools, Parks, Government Facilities, community services
Building
1 permitted
2
na
na
DR
 
Building
1 per facade
24
na
na
DR
Home Occupation
Monument
1 per street
24
6
0, not in SDT
DR
Churches, Schools, Parks, Government Facilities, community services
Directory
1 per street frontage
24
6
2056, not in SDT, within 15 ft. of primary building
DR
 
Directional
One per access point to a vehicular use area within the property or project
3
4
0
DR
 
SDT - Site distance triangle, clear area forty (40) feet from corner intersection of property line (see Definitions, Chapter 10-62).
DR - Design Review Permit required (Chapter 10-50).
   B.   Nonresidential Zoning Districts: The following standards apply to all permanent signs in the commercial, industrial, public, and recreational zoning districts (CC, CGC, CG, CGC, HT, IND, RPD, PUB, REC) with the exception of residential uses (see Section 10-40-30A).
      1.   Sign types not listed in the following tables are not permitted;
      2.   Total facade signage is limited to ten percent (10%) of the first story facade area. Any number of separate building signs are allowable with the exception of reader boards and electronic message centers;
      3.   Only one reader board or electronic message display is allowed per project;
      4.   All electronic message displays require a Design Review Permit.
      5.   See also sections 10-40-4 through 10-40-8 regarding sign measurement, placement, illumination, permitting, and master signage plans.
      6.   All new projects shall have signage areas and locations designated and approved as part of the Design Review Permit. Individual sign permits may be applied for as the tenant space fills up.
Table 10-40-3B1: Building Signs in Nonresidential Zoning Districts
Sign Type
Zones
Area
Approval Type
Sign Type
Zones
Area
Approval Type
Individual letters
All
10%
DR
Sign board
All
10%
DR
Painted advertising copy
All
10%
DR
Wall art (non-advertising copy)
All
10%
DR
Cabinet
All but CC
10%
DR
Awning with signage
All
10%
DR
Reader board with changeable letters
All
10%
DR
Electronic message display
CGC, CG, IND, HT only
5% (24 sf max)
DR
Perpendicular within right-of-way (non- electrical)
CC only
10 sq. ft. each
DR
Perpendicular not within right-of-way
All
10 sq. ft. each
DR
Permanent Window signs (more than 90 days)
All
10%
DR
 
SDT - Site distance triangle, clear area forty (40) feet from corner intersection of property line (see Definitions, Chapter 10-62).
DR - Design Review Permit required (Chapter 10-50).
Table 10-40-3B.2.: Freestanding Signs for Projects in Non-Residential Zoning Districts
 
Sign Type
Zones
Area (s.f.)
Maximum Height (ft.)
Number
Setback (ft.)
Approval Type
Monument
All
60 for CG, CGC, IND, and HT, 36 for all other non-res. zones
6 for all other zones, 8 for CG, CGC, HT and IND zones
1 sign per street frontage.
1 additional sign per street when frontage exceeds 450'.
0', not in SDT
Staff
Menu Board
All
72
6 for CC zones, 8 for all other zones
2 per drive through lane
20
Staff
Directional
All
3
4
One per access point to a vehicular use area within the lot
0'
Staff
Directory
All
24
6 (text on sign shall not exceed two (2) inches in height)
one per street frontage
0', not in SDT, must be within 15 ft. of primary building
Staff
Archway
CC, CG, CGC, HT, IND
48
25 (14 foot min. clearance)
one per street or sidewalk entrance, two (2) max. per project
10
DR
 
SDT - Site distance triangle, clear area forty (40) feet from corner intersection of property line (see Definitions, Chapter 10-62).
DR - Design Review Permit required (Chapter 10-50).
(Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-40-4: SIGN MEASUREMENT:

   A.   Sign Face Area Shall be Computed by Means of:
      1.   The area of the sign shall encompass the outer limits of the sign cabinet frame for signs within a cabinet;
      2.   For signs with individual components, the measurement shall be based on the letters, emblem, or other display, together with any material or color forming an integral part of the background of the area used to differentiate the sign from its backdrop. When there is no background color differentiation; letters, emblems or logos will be measured from the tallest and widest portions (see figure 10-40-45).
   B.   Height: The height of a freestanding sign shall be measured from the top of the nearest City curb, or if no curb the crown of the nearest road to the highest portion of the freestanding sign, it is prohibited to build grade to a higher level to increase the allowed sign height. See 'Height, Sign' Chapter 10-62 for details on height measurement.
   C.   Clearance: All permitted other than monument signs must have a minimum clearance of eight and one-half feet (8.5') from the finished grade to the bottom of the sign. Monument signs shall have a base no more than twenty-four inches (24") between the bottom of the sign and finished grade and base shall be solid.
Figure 10-40-45: Sign Measurement
 
(Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-40-5: LOCATION:

   A.   All signs and sign structures shall be located completely within the boundaries of the lot on which the principal building or use is located;
   B.   No part of a permitted sign shall be placed within the required sight distance triangle;
   C.   No portion of a freestanding sign may extend into the public right-of-way;
   D.   All monument signs shall be setback at least eighteen inches (18") from any adjoining or adjacent sidewalk.
   E.   Building signs shall not project beyond the corner of a building; and shall not be attached to or extend above the parapet or roof of a building. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-40-6: ILLUMINATION:

   A.   For non-residential zones, no signs within three hundred feet (300') of a residential zoning district shall be illuminated between the hours of eleven o’clock p.m. and five o’clock a.m.;
   B.   For residential districts, no sign shall be illuminated between the hours of ten o’clock p.m. and six o’clock a.m.
   C.   Signs that are externally illuminated shall have a shielded, stationary, steady light source that is down lit and directed solely at the sign face;
   D.   Light sources used to illuminate signs shall not be visible from adjacent rights-of-way or properties. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-40-7: PERMITS:

   A.   Permanent Signs:
      1.   All permanent signs shall have a permit issued by the City prior to installation. Failure to obtain a sign permit may result in enforcement actions pursuant to Chapter 10-60;
      2.   Permit applications shall require scale drawings showing the design of the sign(s) including size, materials, illumination, colors and other items as determined necessary by staff;
      3.   Permit applications shall require scale drawings showing the placement of the sign(s) and its location on the building;
      4.   Permit applications for freestanding signs shall require scale site plans showing the location of the sign(s) on the property, streets, property lines, buildings, driveways, landscaping, parking areas and other items as determined necessary by staff;
      5.   The permit number plaque provided by the City shall be affixed to the lower right hand side of the sign cabinet or to a location identified by a Department official when the permit is issued;
      6.   Freestanding and perpendicular signs require plans prepared and stamped by or under the supervision of a professional engineer licensed to practice in the State of Utah as required by the International Building Code;
      7.   All signs require plans meeting the requirements of the International Building Code for installation and mounting of signs;
      8.   All permanent signs for which a permit was issued will be considered legally existing signs. If legally existing signs no longer conform to current code regulations they will be considered legally existing non-conforming. For all legal, existing signs that only need to have the graphics or face of the sign replaced without modifications to the cabinet or frame, a permit is required but will be issued at no charge.
      9.   All permanent signs that are valued at one thousand dollars ($1,000) or more are required to be installed by a licensed sign contractor.
      10.   All signs shall comply with applicable provisions of the International Building Code (IBC) and Article 600 of the National Electrical Code (NEC) (UL or approved listing required).
   B.   Inspections:
      1.   Inspection of all mounting brackets, electrical work, and freestanding sign bases shall be required as specified in the International Building Code;
      2.   Freestanding signs require an inspection of the forms and size of hole prior to the pouring of concrete;
      3.   Failure to obtain the inspection may result in a prohibition against using the freestanding sign base without further code compliance;
      4.   Inspections are not required for refaceing of legally existing signs, painted building signs, wall art, window signs or other types of signs as determined by the City. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-40-8: WINDOW SIGNS:

   A.   Window displays and signage within stores not attached to windows are not regulated by the City, even if visible from outside the store;
   B.   Window signs that are displayed without change for a period of less than sixty (60) days per calendar year shall be defined as "temporary" for purposes of this chapter. Window signs that are displayed without change for a period of sixty (60) days or more per calendar year shall be defined as "permanent" for purposes of this chapter and shall obtain sign permits prior to installation. (See Table 10-40-3B1). (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-40-9: REAL ESTATE SIGNS:

Real estate signs shall be permitted for all uses, provided that signs are located outside the sight distance triangle and:
   A.   One such sign shall be allowed per parcel per street frontage;
   B.   Real estate signs shall be non-illuminated;
   C.   Real estate signs on nonresidential sites shall not exceed thirty-two (32) square feet in area and six feet (6') in height;
   D.   Real estate signs on residential lots shall not exceed four (4) square feet in area or be more than four feet (4') in height;
   E.   Such signs shall be removed within five (5) days from the date of closing or full occupancy, if leasing;
   F.   Signs shall not be placed on public property or within the public right-of-way except for open house signs detailed in subsection H. below; such off-premise signs may be removed by the City;
   G.   Real Estate Signs shall only be located on the subject property for sale. Signs which serve as a directional sign to a sale property shall be prohibited, except as provided in subsection H. of this section. Such off-premise signs may be removed by the City;
   H.   Open House Signs: In addition to a Real Estate Sign located on the subject property open house signs shall be permitted as follows:
      1.   Signs are limited to a maximum size of four (4) square feet in area and four feet (4') in height;
      2.   One open house sign may be permitted within the public right-of-way within the landscape strip at the nearest corner to direct traffic to the open house. The sign shall be placed no earlier than thirty (30) minutes before the start of the open house and shall be removed within one hour of the end of the open house; and never more than fifteen (15) consecutive hours.
      3.   Associated balloons, streamers, or attention-getting devices shall be placed on the subject property for sale only and may not cause a safety hazard;
      4.   Signs shall be on posts that are placed into the ground, sandwich board or freestanding open house signs shall not be permitted due to the potential of winds blowing the signs into the traveled way;
      5.   Not more than one open house sign may be placed on a corner;
      6.   No individual open house shall be identified by more than three signs located within the public right-of-way. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-40-10: CONSTRUCTION SIGNS:

   A.   Construction signs may not be located within the sight distance triangle;
   B.   Such signs may identify the project name and major participants, such as and not limited to: owner, developer, planner, architect, engineer, builder, financier, unions, or skilled trades;
   C.   One sign may be permitted per project per street frontage. One (1) additional sign is allowed per street per every four hundred fifty feet (450') of street frontage. No more than four (4) construction signs will be allowed per project;
   D.   Signs shall not be placed on public property, on utility poles, light poles, or within the public right of way; such off-premise signs may be removed by the City;
   E.   For construction of individual single family residences, such signs shall not exceed four (4) square feet in area and four feet (4') in height above the ground;
   F.   For non-residential development, residential subdivisions and multi-family residential construction, signs shall not exceed thirty-two (32) square feet in area and feet (6') in height;
   G.   Such signs shall be removed within five (5) days of the date of the issuance of the last certificate of occupancy or sale of all lots; whichever occurs first. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-40-11: TEMPORARY SIGNS:

Temporary signs shall only be allowed as follows: (see also 10-61 Signs - Temporary).
   A.   Signs shall not exceed twelve (12) square feet per facing and a maximum height of four feet (4') above the ground;
   B.   Signs shall be located on private property with the owner's permission;
   C.   Signs shall not be stacked;
   D.   Signs shall not be placed in the public right of way or on public property;
   E.   Signs shall not be placed in the sight distance triangle;
   F.   Signs shall not be illuminated.
   G.   A maximum of five (5) different temporary signs may be placed on any one property per calendar year;
   H.   Signs shall be maintained in a safe condition. Signs that are damaged, broken or displayed in a manner to be a safety hazard shall be subject to immediate removal;
   I.   Sign shall not be displayed for longer than a cumulative amount of sixty (60) days in a calendar year;
   J.   Signs shall include a notation or certificate on the back of the sign listing a responsible person to contact regarding the sign including the name address and phone number and the dates or date range the sign is displayed.
   K.   Political election signs are temporary signs. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-40-12: BANNERS:

Banners shall only be allowed as follows:
   A.   Banners shall not exceed forty eight (48) square feet in area;
   B.   Banners shall be located on private property with the owner's permission;
   C.   Banners shall not be placed in the public right of way or on public property;
   D.   Banners shall not be placed in the sight distance triangle;
   E.   Banners shall be securely attached to the wall of primary buildings;
   F.   Commercial banners shall be maintained in safe condition. Banners that are damaged, faded, torn, broken, or displayed in such a manner to be a safety hazard shall be subject to immediate removal;
   G.   Banners shall not hang below the bottom of awnings, canopies, or other overhangs or between columns or pillars;
   H.   Banners shall not be mounted on freestanding signs;
   I.   A maximum of two banners may be placed on any one property;
   J.   Banners are only permitted in the CC, CG, CGC, HT, IND zoning districts;
   K.   Banners shall not be displayed for longer than thirty (30) consecutive days and no more than four times in any calendar year. All attachment apparatus shall be removed with banner;
   L.   Banners shall include a notation or certificate on the back of the banner listing a responsible person to contact regarding the banner including the name address and phone number and the dates or date range the sign is displayed.
   M.   City sponsored event banners shall be allowed in the CC, CG, CGC, HT, IND zoning districts and shall meet all requirement for other banners. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-40-13: PROHIBITED SIGNS:

The following signs shall be prohibited in all zoning districts unless otherwise authorized:
   A.   Signs that do not comply with the provisions of this section or sign types not specified within this section, except for legally existing nonconforming signs;
   B.   Off-premise signs, except where specifically allowed by this chapter.
   C.   Signs above or within the public rights-of-way except for signs per section.
   D.   Permanent signs on lots without a principal use;
   E.   Building signs that extend above the parapet or roof;
   F.   Signs attached to the roof of a building;
   G.   Pole Signs;
   H.   Portable "reader boards" and other portable signs that are not attached to a building or the ground except as otherwise defined in this chapter;
   I.   Signs that rotate, flash, move or give the appearance of motion; not including barber poles;
   J.   Signs that are attached to or towed behind a vehicle, except for business identification signs or logos that are permanently affixed to the vehicle or a magnetic sign that serves the purpose of being affixed to the vehicle;
   K.   Signs that emit sound, odor or visible matter such as smoke or vapor;
   L.   Signs painted on or attached to utility poles, trees or natural features (signs painted or engraved onto boulders or natural materials as a part of the sign permit may be permitted in conformance with this chapter);
   M.   Signs that are abandoned, dilapidated, or advertise businesses that are no longer licensed or situated on the location;
   N.   Sign structures, poles, pylons, and other supports not maintained or kept in good aesthetic and physical condition;
   O.   Signs with visible frames unless part of the approved sign design;
   P.   Signs that exhibit words or pictures of an obscene nature;
   Q.   Signs that are inflatable except as otherwise identified in Section 10-40-10;
   R.   Parking of vehicles or trailers off-premise or within landscaped areas or outside of designated parking stalls or in other areas in a manner primarily oriented to the adjacent street(s) with signs either attached to or placed upon that result in the vehicle or trailer serving as a sign or billboard. Unhitched trailers parked in a parking stall adjacent to street(s) with signage attached or placed upon. Large vehicles with signage attached or placed upon that are parked in a manner that consumes more than one parking stall adjacent to street(s).
   S.   Signage that includes a visible or direct light source with the exception of neon or other lighting that has been approved as a part of the sign design (see also Section 10-40-6 on illumination);
   T.   Signs that would cause a violation of the building code;
   U.   "Sandwich boards" or "A frame" signs.
   V.   Attention getting devices, inflatable objects and inflatable signs.
   X.   Signs that are placed, held or worn as part of a costume in the public right-of-way or off-premise with the intent of advertisement directed to vehicle and pedestrian traffic.
   Y.   Signs using wood, trees, or other materials that do not have a foundation or structurally sound anchoring system and present unsafe conditions. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-40-14: SIGNS IN THE PUBLIC RIGHT-OF-WAY:

   A.   No Signs Shall be Allowed in the Public Right-of-Way, Except:
      1.   Emergency warning signs erected by a governmental agency, public utility or contractor authorized to work within the right-of-way;
      2.   Public signs erected by or on behalf of a governmental entity to post legal notices, convey public information, and direct or regulate pedestrian or vehicular traffic;
      3.   Community or public events may have signs within the public right-of-way as approved by the City and the City Administration;
      4.   Informational signs of a public utility regarding its poles, lines, pipes or other facilities;
      5.   Temporary signs identified elsewhere in this chapter as being permitted in the right-of-way are not subject to the prohibition of this section.
      6.   Perpendicular signs as permitted in this chapter are not subject to the prohibition of this section.
      7.   Cache Valley Transit District (CVTD or Utah Transportation Authority (UTA)) bus stop shelter advertisements as defined in Section 10-40-14.
      8.   Political election signs are not allowed in the public right-of-way.
   B.   Removal: Any sign installed or placed on public property, except in conformance with the provisions above, shall be forfeited to the public and subject to confiscation. In addition to other remedies, the City shall have the right to recover from the owner or person placing such a sign the full costs of its removal and disposal. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-40-15: ELECTRONIC MESSAGE DISPLAY (EMD):

   A.   Permit Required:
      1.   All signs within this section, pursuant to Table 10-40-4 (B)(1), shall require a Design Review Permit. Exceptions exist pursuant to Section 10-40-2. Public Service Announcements are also exempt from this title.
      2.   No off premise advertising permitted. Advertising copy may only advertise business on the same property or within the same project, as outlined in an approved Design Review Permit, as the sign itself.
   B.   Permitted Zones:
      1.   EMDs shall only be permitted in the CC, CG, HT and IND zoning districts.
      2.   No EMDs shall be permitted within any other zoning districts.
   C.   Transitions:
      1.   Prohibited Transitions.
         a.   Scrolling or Travel.
         b.   Any text or graphic that "moves" or "has the appearance of movement" not specified in this section.
      2.   Permitted Transitions.
         a.   Dissolve, to require four (4) seconds of dissolve time between spots.
         b.   Fade, to require four (4) seconds of fade time between spots.
   D.   Frame Effects:
      1.   Prohibited Effects:
         a.   Flashing and Blinking.
         b.   Starburst.
         c.   Animation and Video.
         d.   New frame effects not identified herein.
         e.   No sign shall utilize a white background for greater than or equal to fifty percent (50%) of the sign area.
      2.   Permitted Effect(s):
         a.   Static image.
   E.   Dwell Time:
      1.   Each message/advertisement (spot) displayed on an EMD shall remain "on" and static for a minimum of twenty (20) seconds;
   F.   Operational Characteristics:
      1.   Level One (static) and Level Two (fade or dissolve) operational modes (as defined by the United States Sign Council) shall be permitted. Where Level Two is required to use transitions shall that last four (4) seconds from start of the transition to end of the transition.
   G.   Sign Brightness/Intensity: All EMDs are required to comply with the following standards:
      1.   EMD Sign Illumination Standards;
Photocell technology is required to be properly installed for all EMDs to allow for automatic dimming of the intensity of the sign illumination and accommodate varying light conditions.
      2.   LED and EMD Sign Illumination levels shall never exceed the following levels:
 
Intensity Level (NITS)
Color
Daytime 15 min after sunrise
Nighttime 15 min. after sunset
Red Only
3,000 nits
500 nits
Amber Only
3,000 nits
500 nits
Full Color
5,000 nits
500 nits
 
      3.   Prior to the issuance of a Sign Permit, the manufacturer shall be required to submit written certification that the EMD has been manufactured to regulate the light intensity and photocell dimming to prevent the system from exceeding the maximum levels specified in the above table.
   H.   Sign Area:
      1.   Building Signs.
         a.   EMD sign area shall be included as part of the total allowable sign area for the building and never to exceed twenty-four (24) square feet.
      2.   Monument Signs: Permitted EMD's shall never solely consist of the entire sign area and the permitted size of an EMD shall not be more than 50% of the permitted freestanding sign area of a monument sign; and shall never exceed thirty (30) square feet in area.
   I.   Compliance:
      1.   New Signs: Any sign applied for or permitted under this chapter shall comply with Section 10-40-13.
      2.   Existing EMDs. All legally existing non-conforming EMDs shall comply with Section 10-40-12 (including operational characteristics) and otherwise be regulated by Section 10-59-8. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-40-16: PUBLIC BUS STOP SHELTER SIGNAGE:

   A.   Location:
      1.   One (1) twenty-four (24) square foot maximum sign advertisement may be permitted on one of the two walls of the bus shelter that are perpendicular to the street. Only one perpendicular wall on the shelter can be used for signage.
      2.   Signage is permitted only at public transportation bus stop shelters located within the Commercial and Industrial zones and outside of the Historic District boundaries.
      3.   No signage is allowed on bus stop benches.
   B.   Sign Area:
      1.   Signs shall be a maximum of twenty-four (24) square feet per shelter.
      2.   Route maps and other transit-oriented information will not be counted as part of the sign area.
   C.   Sign Illumination:
      1.   Sign lighting or sign illumination is prohibited for this type of signage.
      2.   No Electronic Message Display (EMD) signs allowed at any bus stop location.
   D.   Sign Type:
      1.   Sign material shall be attached to bus shelter glass and have a 50/50 visual opacity ratio that allows bus passenger inside the shelter and bus driver to see one another.
Figure 10-40-14: Bus Shelter Signage
 
(Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-40-17: ARCHWAY SIGNS:

Archway signs are signs that span either between two buildings or independent supports structures and only have individual lettering located in front of an open horizontal cross-support. Archway signs shall only act as a project identification sign. EMD's are prohibited on archway signs. They may be located at the vehicle or pedestrian entrances to a project. They shall never be located above or within the public right-of-way. Illumination shall be minimal and accomplished with concealed source lighting. If attached to a building, an archway sign may extend no more than four feet (4') above the highest adjacent rooflines. Archway signs require design review approval. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-41-1: PURPOSE:

The purpose of this chapter is to avoid concentration of large numbers of multi-family dwellings in any one area, and to allow a diverse mix of residential uses the following requirements must be fulfilled. "Multi-family "shall have the same meaning and definition as contained in Chapter 10.62 of this title.
(Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-41-2: GENERAL REQUIREMENTS:

   A.   Units Allowed: One (1) multiple-family dwelling unit may be allowed for each city block or future city block. In areas of the city where existing roads do not define a city block, multi-family dwelling units may be allowed by using the general plan which defines the ten (10) acre grid of the city. The Planning Commission will determine where future roads would establish a grid of standard size city blocks.
   B.   Multifamily dwellings are allowed by Conditional Use Permit.
   C.   Building Configurations: A multiple-family dwelling unit may be in any one of the following building configurations:
Table 10-41-2 Multifamily Dwellings in the Residential Single Family (RSF) Zone
 
Type
Number Dwelling Units
Lot Size (s.f. min.)
Lot Frontage (feet min.)
Two-family dwelling
2
13,000
100
Three-family dwelling
3
14,000
110
Four-family dwelling
4
15,000
120
 
   D.   Lot Area: The minimum size lot for the first dwelling unit of a multifamily project shall be, at least, the size of the minimum lot required in the respective residential zone. Each additional dwelling unit shall require an additional one thousand (1,000) s.f. not to exceed a total of four (4) dwelling units.
   Figure 10-41-2D Multifamily Dwellings
 
   E.   Street Frontage: The street frontage for multifamily dwells shall be the same as shown in Table 10-41-2. Multifamily dwellings shall not be located facing the same street on two (2) city blocks.
   Figure 10-41-2E: Multifamily Dwellings Dispersed on Blocks
 
(Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-41-3: MULTIFAMILY DWELLINGS ALLOWED IN THE TOWN CENTER:

The Residential Single Family (RSF) zoning district is the older portion of the city referred to in the General Plan as the Town Center. This zone allows multifamily dwellings to promote more compact residential uses where utilities, roads and services can be provided at the lowest cost to residents. The Town Center possesses vacant land and is an appropriate location for a judicious mix of housing types and densities. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-41-4: LEGALLY EXISTING MULTIFAMILY USES:

The following specific parcels are recognized as legally existing multifamily uses because they existed prior to zoning regulations:
   A.   Tax ID no. 11-082-0048.
   B.   Tax ID no. 11-082-0022. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-41-5: STANDARDS AND REQUIREMENTS:

All multi-family dwellings, except single-family dwellings intended for conversion, shall meet the following requirements:
   A.   The building shall be designed by a licensed architect in the state of Utah. Review plans shall be drawn and submitted in architect's or engineer's scale and must show utilities, property lines (including adjacent properties), direction of drainages, existing surface features, topography at five foot (5') intervals minimum, parking, roads, curbs, walks, landscaping, building floor plans and building elevations.
   B.   The building shall be designed to appear from the street as a single-family dwelling with the following characteristics (see General Plan page 5, item 1.2, multiple family homes):
      1.   No more than two (2) entry doors visible from the street on which the unit fronts;
      2.   No architectural distinction between individual dwelling units;
      3.   Roof gables and diversity in roof forms;
      4.   No more than three (3) types of exterior building facade materials.
   Figure 10-41-5B
   Design of multifamily dwellings
 
   C.   Parking must be located in the rear of the building with no more than two (2) access roads. Access roads may be no wider than twelve feet (12') when not adjacent to parking. Parking stalls shall have painted lines and shall be nine feet (9') wide and twenty feet (20') in depth. Drive lanes adjacent to parking stalls shall be twenty four feet (24') wide. Parking shall be located with same setbacks as required for structures. No more than one fully enclosed double car garage will be allowed for each dwelling unit; provided, that a minimum of two and one-half (2-1/2) parking stalls shall be provided for each dwelling unit. All driveways and parking shall have six inch (6") curb and two foot (2') gutters. The Planning Commission may approve parking in the front for no more than two (2) single car garages which are attached and intergrated into the design of the dwellings. Access to both garages shall be by a twenty foot (20') wide shared driveway. Two (2) additional parking spaces may occur in tandem in front of the garage doors, as occurs in single family homes.
   D.   Complete landscaping shall be provided throughout the entire required lot area. Underground sprinkler irrigation systems shall be installed and maintained operational. Street trees shall be planted along the entire road frontage and spaced no less than thirty feet (30') apart (Sections 10-39-5 and 10-39-6A. Establish in front yard, a minimum of three (3) shade trees, and the rear yard, a minimum of five (5) shade trees. Trees shall be installed at two and one-half inch (2-1/2") diameter trunk size. All surface areas shall be landscaped with lawns, ground covers and shrubs. All landscapes shall be maintained to keep plants healthy and in vigorous growth. Reference also Section 10-39-6A and F.
   E.   Storage units, storage areas, and refuge containers must be enclosed and screened from view from the frontage street. Storage shall only be available to the residents.
   F.   Care must be taken in the design of the units to minimize window glass on outside walls adjacent to existing residents.
   G.   Yard lights and security lights must have a concealed light source.
   H.   Open space set-aside requirements for multifamily dwellings shall be the same as the zone in which permitted. In addition, the development of the site shall include twenty percent (20%) of the total site, less open space set-asides, for landscaping and open area for family and occupant enjoyment. The twenty percent (20%) requirement may include, setbacks, but shall not include parking areas, driveways, nor building footprint(s) of any main or accessory structures. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-41-6: ACCESSORY DWELLING UNITS (ADU) INTERNAL TO AN EXISTING SINGLE-FAMILY DWELLING:

   A.   Eligibility.
      1.   The purpose of these requirements is to permit accessory dwelling units internal to a primary dwelling in certain areas while minimizing adverse impacts to surrounding properties.
      2.   ADUs are permitted in all residential zoning districts.
      3.   An accessory dwelling unit shall only be established in conjunction with a detached, owner occupied, single family residential dwelling. The residence shall be the owner’s primary place of residence (primary dwelling). Non-owner occupied single family dwellings are not eligible for an ADU.
      4.   A primary single-family residential unit is only eligible for one ADU.
      5.   An accessory dwelling unit shall only be established within the footprint (internal) of the primary dwelling at the time the accessory dwelling unit is created. No accessory buildings or detached structures can be used as an ADU.
      6.   An accessory dwelling unit is prohibited in any other housing type (townhome, duplex, apartment, etc.).
      7.   In addition to meeting the minimum parking off street parking requirement of 2 parking spaces for a single-family dwelling, an additional off-street parking space shall be provided for an ADU. The additional parking stall comply with Wellsville Land Use Regulations, and shall not be located within the front setback.
      8.   ADU Design-ADUs shall be designed in a manner that does not change the appearance of the primary dwelling as a single-family residence. Entrances for an ADU cannot be placed on the street facing facade.
      9.   The minimum lot size for the creation of an ADU is 6,000 sq. ft.
      10.   A property owner is prohibited from installing a separate utility meter for an ADU.
      11.   A building permit is required for ADU which shall conform to all building, health, and fire codes.
      12.   An ADU Landlord License is required prior to creating an accessory dwelling unit. An ADU Landlord License is not transferable. Following a change in ownership, a new ADU Landlord License is required.
      13.   Accessory dwelling units in mobile or manufactured homes are prohibited.
      14.   An accessory dwelling unit shall not be rented or offered for rent for a period of less than 30 consecutive days. An accessory dwelling unit shall not be used as a vacation rental or for short term occupancy.
      15.   An ADU becomes abandoned under any of the following conditions:
         a.   If an ADU Landlord License lapses for twelve (12) months,
         b.   If the ADU is not occupied for twelve (12) months,
         c.   Or if the property is no longer owner-occupied.
   B.   ADU Building Requirements.
      1.   Building Permits are required for all new, remodel and finish work. If construction has occurred without a permit, a building permit shall be obtained. The project shall be inspected prior to approval of an ADU. In addition to the minimal building requirements listed below, construction documents may be required for framing/construction, electrical, plumbing, and mechanical alterations and remodels. Additional building requirements may apply as determined by the building inspector.
      2.   Minimum building requirements for establishment of an ADU include:
         a.   Every dwelling unit is required to have a living space/bedroom, kitchen, bathroom, and shower area.
         b.   Doors in the common walls shall be 20-minute fire-rated and self-closing.
         c.   Egress windows must be provided per code* (one for each bedroom) with a minimum opening of 5.7 square feet, when window sill is 44" or more below finish grade. Grade floor openings shall have a minimum net clear opening of 5 square feet. Opening shall measure a minimum of 20" wide and 24" high.
         d.   Window wells for egress windows shall have all minimum dimensions of 36 inches or 24" minimum when installed to earlier code.
         e.   Handrails must be built per code and provided as needed.
         f.   A smoke detector must be provided in each bedroom and in a hallway or room leading to each bedroom, with a minimum of one on each floor.
         g.   A carbon monoxide detector must be provided on each level of each dwelling unit.
         h.   All gas-fueled appliances must be provided with the proper amount of air for efficient combustion.
         i.   All clothes dryers must be vented to the exterior of the building.
         j.   All outlets in bathrooms, outside, garage, unfinished parts of basement, and all outlets on the kitchen countertops need to be protected with a ground-fault-circuit-interrupter receptacle or GFCI breaker.
         k.   Electrical outlets must be tamper-resistant type.
         l.   Minimum ceiling height must be 7'0".
         m.   Bedrooms must be a minimum of 70 square feet for a single occupant. Bedrooms for more than a single occupant must be 50 square feet for each occupant, except, if the bedroom was existing and complies to the building code in effect at the time the bedroom was finished.
   C.   Application Requirements. The following materials are required for an ADU License:
      1.   Complete ADU Landlord License Application.
      2.   Declaration of Owner Occupancy.
      3.   Two documents to verify owner address (copy of driver’s license, property tax receipt, utility bill, or mortgage statement).
      4.   Site Plan drawn to scale (including property lines, setbacks, structures, entrances, walkways, and parking areas).
      5.   Street facing elevations drawn to scale (if exterior changes are proposed).
      6.   Interior Floor Plan for the ADU drawn to scale (including rooms, doors, windows, ceiling height, new and existing construction, and location of smoke detectors and carbon monoxide detectors).
      7.   Building Permit Application, copy of Building Permit or copy of the Certificate of Occupancy for the ADU if already obtained.
      8.   Fees - ADU Landlord License Application Fee ($75), Building Permit Fees, and impact fees, if established.
   D.   Application Processing. The Mayor shall designate a person employed by the city to perform ADU reviews. The Mayor’s designee shall perform the following:
      1.   Determine conformance with eligibility and design, including location, lot size, structure type, parking requirements, and alterations or modifications to the exterior of the home.
      2.   Assess conformance with building code, including interior and exterior alterations.
      3.   Verify building permit requirements.
      4.   Review and issue ADU Landlord License.
      5.   Verify owner-occupancy of the dwelling unit.
      6.   Process annual renewal of license.
(Ord. 2023-03, 4-19-2023)

10-41-7: CONVERSION OF EXISTING DWELLING OR DWELLINGS TO 3 OR 4 DWELLING UNITS:

   A.   A site plan and an application for a Conditional Use Permit shall be submitted for consideration by the Planning Commission. Site plan shall show the entire lot with accurate location of existing dwelling, other structures, driveways, doorways, walks,
   B.   Trees, fences, buildings on adjoining properties, property lines, building setbacks and other site features. Plans must be drawn to engineer’s by a licensed surveyor.
   C.   Required parking for the additional dwelling units may not be located in the front yard, on existing driveway to garage, or where other parking is required for the existing dwelling.
   D.   New parking spaces required for the proposed multi-family dwelling must be designated on the plan. Parking must be easily accessible based on standard parking conventions (nine foot (9') by twenty foot (20') stalls and twenty four foot (24') wide drive lane adjacent to parking). The access driveway to new parking shall be a minimum often feet (10') wide.
   E.   Two (2) parking spaces must be provided for each dwelling unit, plus one additional space is required for each unrelated person who occupies each dwelling unit. Parking shall include the required parking for existing dwelling(s).
   F.   Drawings of exterior modifications to the existing dwelling shall be submitted with the application. Architectural elevation drawing shall be drawn to scale and show proposed colors and material.
   G.   The building inspector must issue a certificate of occupancy prior to occupancy of the dwelling units.
   H.   Other conditions such as landscaping, screening, fencing, etc, as deemed necessary by the Planning Commission, particularly the multifamily use must be allowed in the zone in which the existing residence is located. Emphasis for additional requirements shall be to protect the adjacent single family residences, and the public image from the public way.
   I.   Any violation of the requirements of the Conditional Use Permit may result in revocation of the permit and toss of the use as a multiple family dwelling.
(Ord. 2019-04,10-16-2019; amd. Ord. 2023-03, 4-19-2023)

10-42-1: DEFINITIONS:

The following definitions shall apply to all sections of this title, and except as provided herein, shall supersede any other definitions contained in this title:
ADULT DAYCARE FACILITY:
Any building or structure furnishing care, supervision and guidance for three (3) or more adults unaccompanied by a guardian for periods of less than twenty four (24) hours per day.
ASSISTED LIVING FACILITY:
A residential facility, licensed by the state of Utah, with a homelike setting that provides an array of coordinated support personnel and healthcare services, available twenty-four (24) hours per day, to residents who have been assessed under the Utah department of health or the Utah department of human services rules to need any of these services. Each resident shall have a service plan based on the assessment, which may include:
A.   Specified services of intermediate nursing care;
B.   Administration of medication; and
C.   Support services promoting residence independence and self-sufficiency. Such a facility does not include adult daycare provided in conjunction with a residential facility for elderly persons or a residential facility for persons with a disability.
BOARDER:
A person living in a rented room in a boarding house. The boarding house operator or member of his or her immediate family who resides on the premises with the operator, shall not be considered to be a boarder.
BOARDING HOUSE:
A building, or a portion thereof, where, for compensation, rooms are rented, together with meals for not more than fifteen (15) boarders who generally do not directly utilize kitchen facilities. The operator of a boarding house must reside on the premises of the boarding house. The work shall include compensation in money, services or other things of value. A "boarding house" does not include a residential facility for disabled persons or a residential facility for the elderly. A boarding house does not include a nonresidential facility, such as a rehabilitation/treatment facility, where the primary purpose of the facility is to deliver rehabilitation, treatment, counseling, medical, protective or other similar services to the occupants.
BUILDING, PUBLIC:
For purposes of this chapter only, a public building is a building owned and operated, or owned and intended to be operated, by the city, a public agency of the United States of America, the state of Utah, or any of its political subdivisions. The use of a public building, with immunity, is nontransferable and terminates if the structure is devoted to a use other than as a public building with immunity. A public building referred to as with immunity under the provisions of this title includes:
A.   Properties owned by the state of Utah or the United States government which are outside of the jurisdiction of the city zoning authority as provided under Utah Code Annotated section 10-9a-304, as amended; and
B.   The ownership or use of a building which is immune from the city zoning authority under the supremacy clause of the United States constitution.
COMMUNITY CORRECTIONAL FACILITY:
A facility licensed or contracted by the state of Utah to provide temporary occupancy for previously incarcerated persons which assists such persons in making a transition from a correctional institution environment to independent living.
CORRECTIONAL INSTITUTION:
A prison, jail, juvenile detention facility or juvenile secure facility.
DISABILITY:
A physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more of a persons major life activities, including a person having a record of such a problem or being regarded as having such an impairment. The following is incorporated into the definition of disability: Disability does not include current illegal use of, or addiction to, any federally controlled substance as defined in section 102 of the controlled substances act, 21 USC 802, or as defined under Utah Code Annotated title 58, chapter 37, as amended.
DOMESTIC STAFF:
Persons employed or residing on the premises of a dwelling or other residential facility to perform domestic services or to assist residents in performing major life activities.
EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTION:
Any elementary or secondary school, seminary, parochial school or private educational institution having a curriculum similar to that ordinarily given in grades 1 through 12 in public school systems. The term educational institution, for the purpose of this title, does not include posthigh school educational facilities or educational facilities which include residential facilities for its students.
EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTION WITH HOUSING:
A public or private educational institution with residential facilities or housing for its students and/or staff.
ELDERLY PERSON:
A person who is sixty (60) years or older, who desires or needs to live with other elderly persons in a group setting, but who is capable of living independently.
FAMILY:
An individual, or two (2) or more persons related by blood, marriage or legal adoption according to the laws of the state; also any individual or persons, not more than three (3), associated by guardianship, conservatorship or a foster care relationship, or a group of not more than three (3) persons not so related or associated, living together in a dwelling unit as a single housekeeping unit.
HOSPITAL:
An institution licensed by the state of Utah which provides diagnostic, therapeutic and rehabilitative services to individuals on both an inpatient and outpatient basis by or under the supervision of one or more physicians. A medical clinic or professional office which offers any inpatient overnight care, or operates on a twenty four (24) hour basis, shall be considered to be a hospital. A hospital may include necessary support service facilities such as laboratories, outpatient units and training and central services, together with staff offices necessary to operate the hospital.
JAIL:
A place of incarceration owned and operated by the county.
JUVENILE DETENTION FACILITY:
A place of temporary detention for delinquent juveniles, which either is owned or operated by the state of Utah or is under contract with the state of Utah.
JUVENILE SECURE FACILITY:
A place of incarceration for delinquent juveniles which is either owned or operated by the state of Utah or is under contract with the state of Utah.
MAJOR LIFE ACTIVITIES:
Functions such as caring for oneself, performing manual tasks, walking, seeing, hearing, speaking, breathing, learning and working.
NONRESIDENTIAL TREATMENT FACILITY:
A facility wherein no persons will be housed on an overnight basis, and provides services, including rehabilitation, treatment, counseling or assessment and evaluation services related to delinquent behavior, alcohol abuse, drug abuse, sexual offenders, sexual abuse or mental health. Associated educational services may also be provided to juvenile occupants.
NURSING HOME:
An intermediate care/nursing facility or a skilled nursing facility licensed by the state of Utah, for the care of individuals who, due to illness, advanced age, disability or impairment, require assistance and/or supervision on a twenty four (24) hour per day basis. Such a facility does not include an adult daycare facility or adult daycare provider in conjunction with residential facilities for elderly persons or a residential facility for persons with a disability.
PRISON:
A place of incarceration owned or operated by the state of Utah.
PRIVATE JAIL:
A place of incarceration established or operated under a contract with the county.
PRIVATE PRISON:
A correctional facility established or operated under a contract with the state of Utah under the provisions of the private correctional facilities act, Utah Code Annotated title 64, chapter 13c, as amended.
PROTECTIVE HOUSING FACILITY:
A facility either;
A.   Operated, licensed or contracted by a governmental entity; or
B.   Operated by a charitable, nonprofit organization where, for no compensation, temporary, protective housing is provided to:
   1.   Abused or neglected children waiting placement in foster care;
   2.   Pregnant or parenting teens;
   3.   Victims of sexual abuse; or
   4.   Victims of domestic abuse.
REASONABLE ACCOMMODATION:
A change in any rule, policy, practice or service necessary to afford a person with a disability equal opportunity to use and enjoy a dwelling. The following words have the following definitions:
A.   Equal Opportunity: Achieving equal results as between a person with a disability and a nondisabled person.
B.   Necessary: The applicant must show that, but for the accommodation, one or more persons with a disability likely will be denied an equal opportunity to enjoy the housing of their choice.
C.   Reasonable: A requested accommodation that will not undermine the legitimate purpose of existing zoning regulations notwithstanding the benefit that the accommodation will provide to a person with a disability.
RECORD OF IMPAIRMENT:
Having a record of impairment means having a history of, or having been classified as having, a mental or physical impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities.
REGARDED AS HAVING AN IMPAIRMENT:
A person is regarded as having an impairment when:
A.   The person has a physical or mental impairment that does not substantially limit one or more major life activities, but is treated by another person as having such a limitation;
B.   Has a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities only as a result of the attitudes of others towards such an impairment; or
C.   Has none of the impairments defined in this section, but is treated by another person as having such an impairment.
REHABILITATION/T REATMENT FACILITY:
A facility licensed or contracted by the state of Utah to provide temporary occupancy and supervision of individuals (adults and/or juveniles) in order to provide rehabilitation, treatment or counseling services. Without limitation, such services may include rehabilitation, treatment, counseling or assessment and evaluation services related to delinquent behavior, alcohol abuse, drug abuse, sex offenders, sexual abuse or mental health. Associated educational services may also be provided to juvenile occupants.
RELATED:
Related by blood, marriage or adoption within the definition of "family" means a father, mother, husband, wife, son, daughter, sister, brother, uncle, aunt, nephew, niece, first cousin, mother-in-law, father-in-law, brother-in-law, sister-in-law, son-in-law, daughter-in-law, grandparent or grandchild, to include the half as well as the whole blood.
RESIDENTIAL FACILITY FOR ELDERLY PERSONS:
A dwelling unit that is occupied on a twenty four (24) hour per day basis by eight (8) or fewer elderly persons in a family type arrangement. A residential facility for elderly persons shall not include any of the following:
A.   A facility which is operated as a business; provided, that such facility may not be considered to be operated as a business solely because a fee is charged for food or for actual and necessary costs of preparation and maintenance of the facility;
B.   A facility where persons being treated for alcoholism or drug abuse are placed; a facility where placement is not on a strictly voluntary basis or where placement is part of, or in lieu of, confinement, rehabilitation, or treatment in a correctional institution; or a facility which is a healthcare facility as defined by Utah Code Annotated section 26-2-21, as amended; or a facility which is a residential facility for persons with a disability.
RESIDENTIAL FACILITY FOR PERSONS WITH A DISABILITY:
A residence in which more than one person with a disability resides and which is:
A.   Licensed or certified by the department of human services under Utah Code Annotated title 62A, chapter 2, licensure of programs and facilities; or
B.   Licensed or certified by the department of human health under Utah Code Annotated title 26, chapter 21, healthcare facilities licensing and inspection act.
RESIDENTS, RESIDENTIAL FACILITY:
Any building, or portion thereof, where an individual is actually living at a given point and time and intends to remain, and not a place of temporary sojourn or transient visit.
RETIREMENT HOME:
A residential facility designated, occupied and intending for residents fifty (50) years of age or older where common facilities for cooking and dining are available to all residents and independent facilities are provided for living, sleeping and sanitation.
SHELTER FOR THE HOMELESS:
Charitable lodging or sleeping rooms provided on a temporary basis (usually on a daily basis) to those members of society lacking other safe, sanitary or affordable shelter. A shelter for the homeless may also include kitchen and cafeteria facilities.
SHELTERED WORKSHOP:
An on site supervised educational or vocational training facility for persons with a disability and does not provide any residential facilities.
TRADE OR VOCATIONAL SCHOOL:
A post high school educational or vocational training facility.
TRANSITIONAL HOUSING FACILITY:
A facility owned, operated or contracted by a governmental entity or a charitable, not for profit organization, where, for no compensation, temporary housing (usually three (3) to twenty four (24) months, but in no event less than thirty (30) days) is provided to homeless persons, while they obtain work, job skills, or otherwise take steps to stabilize their circumstances. A transitional housing facility shall not include a shelter for the homeless, and a dwelling unit provided to a family for the exclusive use as part of a transitional housing program, for more than thirty (30) days, shall not be considered to be a transitional housing facility. (Ord. 2006-08, 12-6-2006; amd. Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)
 

10-42-2: RESIDENTIAL FACILITIES FOR PERSONS WITH A DISABILITY:

   A.   Applicability: This section shall be deemed to govern any facility, residence or other circumstance that meets the definition of a "residential facility for persons with a disability", as set forth in section 10-17-1 of this chapter, and the definition of "disability", as set forth in section 10-17-1 of this chapter. The requirements of this section shall govern notwithstanding any other provisions of city ordinances. (Ord. 2006-08, 12-6-2006; and. 2009 Code)
   B.   Purpose: The purposes of this section are:
      1.   To comply with Utah Code Annotated section 10-9a-520, as amended; and
      2.   To avoid discrimination in housing against persons with disabilities as provided in the Utah fair housing act and the federal fair housing amendments act, as interpreted by the courts having jurisdiction over the city.
   C.   Permitted Use; Requirements: A residential facility for persons with a disability shall be a permitted use in any zoning district where a dwelling is allowed. Each such facility shall conform to the following requirements:
      1.   Code Compliance: The facility shall comply with all applicable building, safety and health regulations, the Americans with disabilities act, fire regulations, and all applicable state code standards and licensing requirements, and any standards set forth in any contract with a state agency. The facility shall also comply with the city land use zoning provisions applicable to single-family dwellings for the zone in which it is to be located, except as may be modified by the provisions of this chapter.
      2.   Site Development; Parking and Open Space: The following site development standards and parking standards shall be applicable:
         a.   Each facility shall be subject to minimum site development standards applicable to a dwelling unit in the zone in which the facility is located; and
         b.   The minimum number of parking spaces required shall be the same as the number required for a dwelling with similar occupancy density in the same zone.
         c.   Open Space requirements shall be the same as required within the respective zoning district.
      3.   Prohibited Persons: No facility shall be made available to an individual who has demonstrated, by prior behavior, actions and/or criminal convictions, or as a resident, that he or she:
         a.   May be determined to be or does constitute a direct threat to the health or safety of other individuals; or
         b.   Has or may engage in conduct resulting in substantial physical damage to the property of others.
      4.   Licensing: Prior to occupancy of the facility, the person or entity licensed or certified by the department of human services or the department of health to establish and operate the facility shall:
         a.   Provide a certified copy of such license to the city recorder and maintain said license in full force and effect at all times;
         b.   Certify, in a sworn affidavit submitted with the application for a business license, compliance with the Americans with disabilities act;
         c.   Certify, in a sworn affidavit submitted with the application for a business license, that no person will be placed or remain in the facility whose prior or current behavior, actions and/or criminal incidents or convictions, has demonstrated that such person is or may be a direct threat to the health or safety of other individuals, or whose said behavior, actions and/or incidents or convictions have resulted in or may result in substantial physical damage to the property of others; and such a sworn statement shall be resubmitted to the city recorder on each sixth month anniversary after the issuance of the city business license required to operate said facility, the intent being that there be such a sworn affidavit on file with the city recorder that is no older than six (6) months;
         d.   Apply for, obtain and maintain a city business license in accordance with the procedures stated in title 3 of this code, as amended, on forms to be supplied by the city;
         e.   Any license issued in accordance with the provisions of title 3 of this code, as amended, may be revoked and any application denied, by reason of the failure of the applicant or licensee to comply with the provisions of this chapter, said title 3 of this code, or any other applicable statute, ordinance, rule or regulation, by following the procedures set forth in section 3-1-14 of this code, as amended;
         f.   Obtain and maintain the liability insurance required by the department of human services, the department of health, or as is standard in the industry in the event neither state agency requires that such insurance be obtained and maintained.
      5.   Nontransferable Use: The use permitted by this section is nontransferable and shall terminate if:
         a.   A facility is devoted to or used as other than a residential facility for persons with a disability; or
         b.   The license or certification issued by the department of human services, department of health or any other applicable agency, including the city, terminates or is revoked; or
         c.   The facility fails to comply with the conditions set forth in this section.
      6.   Number Of Residents Limited:
         a.   In the RCA, RA, R-1, R-2 and RM-4 zones, no residential facility for persons with a disability shall exceed six (6) residents, not including staff, or the family that owns the residence.
         b.   In the A and RPD zones, no residential facility for persons with a disability shall exceed twelve (12) residents, not including staff, or the family that owns the residence.
         c.   In the C-2 zone, no residential facility for persons with a disability shall exceed twelve (12) residents, not including staff, or the family that owns the residence.
      7.   Zones Prohibited: No residential facilities for persons with a disability shall be permitted in the FR, M-1, CN, C-1, C-3 and CH zones.
      8.   Appeal: Any decision made in connection with the process of establishing a residential facility for persons with a disability, except as provided herein, may be appealed to the city appeal authority (board of adjustment) if notice of such appeal is filed in writing, clearly stating the grounds for such appeal, within thirty (30) days after the final decision is made or within thirty (30) days after the meeting at which the final decision being appealed is decided. The appeal process shall be handled in the manner set forth in section 2-2-5 of this code, as amended.
   D.   Reasonable Accommodations: None of the foregoing conditions shall be interpreted to limit reasonable accommodations necessary to allow the establishment or occupancy of a residential facility for persons with a disability.
      1.   Application: Any person or entity who wishes to request a reasonable accommodation shall make application to the City Council. Said application shall specifically articulate, in writing, the following:
         a.   The name, mailing address and phone number of the applicant;
         b.   The nature and extent of the disability;
         c.   An exact statement of the ordinance or policy from which the applicant needs a reasonable accommodation;
         d.   The applicant's proposed reasonable accommodation;
         e.   A statement detailing why a reasonable accommodation is necessary; and
         f.   The physical address of the property where the applicant intends on living.
      2.   Considerations for Granting: When considering whether or not to grant a reasonable accommodation, the City Council shall consider the following factors, among others deemed appropriate and applicable:
         a.   The zoning ordinance applicable to the property;
         b.   The parking, traffic and noise impact on the neighborhood if the reasonable accommodation is granted;
         c.   Whether or not the accommodation will be an undue burden or expense to the city;
         d.   The extent to which the accommodation will or will not benefit the applicant;
         e.   The extent to which the accommodation will or will not benefit the community;
         f.   Whether or not the accommodation fundamentally alters the citywide zoning ordinance and whether or not the accommodation would likely create a fundamental change in the character of a residential neighborhood;
         g.   Whether or not the applicant has demonstrated that the accommodation will affirmatively enhance the applicant's life, or ameliorate the effects of the applicant's disability, or the lives or disabilities on whose behalf the entity is applying;
         h.   Whether or not, without the accommodation, similar housing is available in the city for the applicant or group of applicants;
         i.   Given the scope of the accommodation requested, what is the impact on the immediate neighborhood; and
         j.   The requirements of applicable federal and state laws and regulations.
      3.   Findings and Conclusions: Written findings and conclusions of the City Council shall be sent to the applicant within thirty (30) days after the decision by the City Council.
      4.   Denial; Appeal: In the event a request for a reasonable accommodation is denied, such decision may be appealed to the first district court for Cache County for review, if the petition of review/appeal is filed with the district court within thirty-five (35) days after the written findings and conclusions supporting and stating the City Council's decision have been sent to the applicant. The review/appeal process shall be handled in the manner set forth in Utah Code Annotated section 10-9a-801, as amended. (Ord. 2006-08,12-6-2006) (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-42-3: RESIDENTIAL FACILITIES FOR ELDERLY PERSONS:

   A.   Purpose: The purpose of this section is to comply with Utah Code Annotated sections 10-9a-516 through 10-9a-519, as amended.
   B.   Requirements: Residential facilities for elderly persons shall comply with all requirements of Utah Code Annotated sections 10-9a-516 through 10-9-519, and also the following requirements:
      1.   Code Compliance: The facility shall meet all applicable building codes, safety codes, zoning regulations, the Americans with disabilities act, and health ordinances applicable to single-family or similar dwellings, except as may be modified by the provisions of this chapter.
      2.   Prohibited Persons: No facility shall be made available to an individual who has demonstrated, by prior behavior, actions and/or criminal convictions, or as a resident, that he or she:
         a.   May be determined to be or does constitute a direct threat to the health or safety of other individuals; or
         b.   Has or may engage in conduct resulting in substantial physical damage to the property of others.
      3.   Site Development: Minimum site development standards shall be the same as those for a dwelling unit in the zone in which the facility is located.
      4.   Residential Character Maintained: The facility shall be capable of being used as a residential facility for elderly persons without structural or landscaping alterations that would change the structure's residential character.
      5.   Nontransferable Use: The use granted and permitted by this section is nontransferable and terminates if the structure is devoted to any use other than as a residential facility for the elderly, or if the structure fails to comply with the applicable health, safety, zoning and building codes.
      6.   Distance To Similar Facilities: No residential facility for elderly persons, which facility has more than five (5) elderly persons in residence, shall be established or maintained within seven hundred feet (700'), measured in a straight line between the closest property lines of the lots or parcels of similar facilities, residential facilities for persons with disabilities, protective housing facilities, transitional housing facilities, assisted living facilities, rehabilitation/treatment facilities, or a nonresidential treatment facility.
      7.   Appeal: Any decision made in connection with the process of establishing a residential facility for elderly persons, except as provided herein, may be appealed to the city appeal authority (board of adjustment), if notice of such appeal is filed in writing, clearly stating the grounds for such appeal, within thirty (30) days after the final decision is made or within thirty (30) days after the meeting at which the final decision being appealed is decided. The appeal process shall be handled in the manner set forth in section 2-2-5 of this code, as amended.
      8.   Licensing; Insurance: Prior to occupancy of the facility, the person or entity licensed or certified by the department of human services or the department of health to establish and operate the facility, shall:
         a.   Provide a certified copy of such license to the city recorder and maintain said license in full force and effect at all times;
         b.   Certify, in a sworn affidavit submitted with the application for a business license, compliance with the Americans with disabilities act;
         c.   Certify, in a sworn affidavit submitted with the application for a business license, that no person will be placed or remain in the facility whose prior or current behavior, actions and/or criminal incidents or convictions, have demonstrated that such person is or may be a direct threat to the health or safety of other individuals, or whose said behavior, actions and/or incidents or convictions has resulted in or may result in substantial physical damage to the property of others; and such a sworn statement shall be resubmitted to the city recorder on each sixth month anniversary after the issuance of the city business license required to operate said facility, the intent being that there be such a sworn affidavit on file with the city recorder that is no older than six (6) months;
         d.   Apply for, obtain and maintain a city business license in accordance with the procedures stated in title 3 of this code, as amended, on forms to be supplied by the city;
         e.   Any license issued in accordance with the provisions of title 3 of this code, as amended, may be revoked and any application denied, by reason of the failure of the applicant or licensee to comply with the provisions of this chapter, said title 3 of this code, or any other applicable statute, ordinance, rule or regulation, by following the procedures set forth in section 3-1-14 of this code, as amended; f. Obtain and maintain the liability insurance required by the department of human services, the department of health, or as is standard in the industry in the event neither state agency requires that such insurance be obtained and maintained. (Ord. 2006-08,12-6-2006; amd. Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-42-4: DESIGN STANDARDS FOR PROTECTIVE HOUSING, REHABILITATION/TREATMENT FACILITIES (BOTH RESIDENTIAL AND NONRESIDENTIAL), TRANSITIONAL HOUSING AND ASSISTED LIVING FACILITIES, WHEN ALLOWED AS PERMITTED OR CONDITIONAL USE:

Any newly constructed or remodeled facility in a residential zone, or immediately abutting a residential zone, shall comply with the following design standards:
   A.   Setbacks: All setbacks shall be according to the requirements of the residential zone in which the facility sits, or if the facility is in a commercial zone abutting a residential zone, the setbacks shall be those of the abutting residential zone.
   B.   Parking Areas: All required or accessory parking areas shall be located either in the rear yard area of the lot, or behind the main building or garage.
   C.   Height: Notwithstanding the maximum height restrictions of the individual residential zone, new buildings or additional buildings shall not exceed one hundred ten percent (110%) of the average height of the closest dwellings on both sides of the proposed structure.
   D.   Design and Character Standards: In order for new construction to reflect the design and character of the existing neighborhood, the following standards shall be met:
      1.   The roof design of the proposed structure or remodel roof shall be a pitched roof of the same slope as the most common roof slope of the homes on the side of the block on which the building is proposed; and
      2.   The type of exterior materials shall be of traditional home finish materials of brick, siding or stucco. The use of these materials shall be applied in such a manner as to blend in with the neighborhood where the building is located and not draw undue attention to the building because of the materials, their color and combination being uncharacteristic of the other buildings in the neighborhood.
      3.   Open space set-aside requirements for Group dwellings shall be the same as the zone in which permitted. In addition, the development of the site shall include twenty percent (20%) of the total site, less open space set-asides, for landscaping and open area for family and occupant enjoyment. The twenty percent (20%) requirement may include, setbacks, but shall not include parking areas, driveways, nor building footprint(s) of any main or accessory structures.
   E.   Prohibited Persons: No facility shall be made available to an individual who has demonstrated, by prior behavior, actions and/or criminal convictions, or as a resident, that he or she:
      1.   May be determined to be or does constitute a direct threat to the health or safety of other individuals; or
      2.   Has or may engage in conduct resulting in substantial physical damage to the property of others.
   F.   More Restrictive Provisions Prevail: To the extent similar requirements to any contained in this section are contained in the specific zone in which any facility referred to herein may be located, the more restrictive provisions shall apply, and the requirements stated herein shall be considered to be in addition to presently existing zoning regulations, subject to the conflict resolution provisions of this subsection. (Ord. 2006-08, 12-6-2006; amd. Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-42-5: NONRESIDENTIAL TREATMENT FACILITIES:

Nonresidential treatment facilities shall not be built within the city, except as specifically allowed as a permitted or conditional use by proper designation in a zone or zones in this title. Each permitted facility, or facility allowed as a conditional use, shall conform to the following requirements:
   A.   Code Compliance: The facility shall comply with all building, safety, zoning and health regulations, the Americans with disabilities act, fire regulations, and all applicable state code standards and licensing requirements, and any standards set forth in any contract with a state agency.
   B.   Site Development; Parking: The following site development standards and parking standards shall be applicable:
      1.   Each facility shall be subject to minimum site development standards applicable to a business in the zone in which the facility may be located; and
      2.   The minimum number of parking spaces required shall be the same as the number required for an office building with similar size, occupancy and density in the same zone.
   C.   Licensing: Prior to occupancy of the facility, the person or entity licensed or certified by the department of human services or the department of health to establish and operate the facility shall:
      1.   Provide a certified copy of such license with the city recorder;
      2.   Certify, in a sworn affidavit submitted with the application for a business license, compliance with the Americans with disabilities act;
   D.   Nontransferable Use: The use permitted by this section is nontransferable and shall terminate if:
      1.   A facility is devoted to or used as other than a nonresidential facility; or
      2.   The license or certification issued by the department of human services, department of health, or any other applicable agency, terminates or is revoked, or the facility fails to comply with the conditions set forth in this section.
   E.   Distance To Similar Facilities: No nonresidential treatment facility shall be established or maintained within seven hundred feet (700'), measured in a straight line between the closest property lines of the lots or parcels, of the following facilities:
      1.   A residential facility for persons with a disability;
      2.   A residential facility for elderly with more than five (5) elderly persons in a residence; or
      3.   Any of the following facilities: protective housing facility, transitional housing facility, assisted living facility or rehabilitation/treatment facility, a nonresidential treatment facility, and elementary schools.
   F.   Prohibited Persons: No facility shall be made available to an individual who has demonstrated, by prior behavior, actions and/or criminal convictions, or as a resident, that he or she:
      1.   May be determined to be or does constitute a direct threat to the health or safety of other individuals; or
      2.   Has or may engage in conduct resulting in substantial physical damage to the property of others.
   G.   More Restrictive Provisions: To the extent similar requirements to any contained in this section are contained in the specific zone in which any facility referred to herein may be located, the more restrictive provisions shall apply, and the requirements stated herein shall be considered to be in addition to presently existing zoning regulations, subject to the conflict resolution provisions of this subsection. (Ord. 2006-08, 12-6-2006; amd. Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-42-6: LIMITATIONS:

Only such uses and facilities as are specifically authorized in this chapter and title as permitted or conditional uses shall be allowed. All other uses and facilities are prohibited. (Ord. 2006-08,12-6-2006; amd. Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-42-7: APPLICATIONS AND OTHER FORMS:

Certain applications and other forms are referred to in this chapter. It is hereby provided that such applications and other forms shall be prepared by the city and adopted for use by the city in connection with this chapter, by resolution duly adopted by the City Council. In addition, the forms may be amended or otherwise changed, or replaced, also by resolution duly adopted by the City Council. (Ord. 2006-08, 12-6-2006; amd. Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-43-1: PURPOSE:

In order to accommodate entrepreneurial desires of citizens and to respect the purpose of residential areas of the City, the City Council finds and declares a need to accommodate home occupations as uses accessory to residences. Many types of businesses can be conducted at home with little or no effect on the surrounding neighborhood. Businesses in the home are intended to be nonintrusive in the neighborhood. Traffic is to be generally the same as conventional homes. The businesses are to be of a compact nature that does not require accessory buildings or additions to the home. The customer traffic that may occur is to be limited and low intensity, similar to the visitors who come to homes without businesses. The regulations of this chapter are intended to permit residents to engage in home occupations while enduring that the businesses will not be a detriment to the character and livability of the surrounding neighborhood. It is the City Council's purpose that home occupations remain accessory and subordinate to the permitted residential uses and that the residential viability of the dwelling unit is maintained. Home occupations are intended to be businesses that function within the residence and not business sites within which residential use becomes subordinate. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-43-2: CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT AND BUSINESS LICENSE REQUIRED:

All home occupations shall only be allowed as a conditional use in the zones in this title where they are so designated. All conditional uses shall not commence until the applicant has obtained a conditional use permit from the Planning Commission and a business license from the City Council.
Approvals by conditional use shall be administered as follows:
   A.   Level One Home Occupation shall be administered by review by staff and approval shall be granted upon the applicant meeting requirements herein for Level One Home Occupations. If staff determines that approval of an application is complicated and cannot be fairly determined by staff the application may be referred to the Planning Commission. Applicants may appeal staff decisions about Level One Home Occupations to the Planning Commission. Conditions of approval may not be imposed by staff unless reviewed and approved by the Planning Commission. Level Two Home Occupation shall be administered by the Planning Commission at their regularly scheduled meetings. Approval shall be granted upon the applicant meeting requirements for the conditions for approval and as also required herein for Level Two Home Occupations. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-43-3: DEFINITIONS:

 
LEVEL ONE HOME OCCUPATION:
A home occupation included on the approved list set forth in Section 10-43-4A.of this section, which is conducted inside the primary residence and meets the requirements of Section 10-43-4B of this section.
LEVEL TWO HOME OCCUPATION:
A home occupation not meeting the requirements of level one home occupation that uses property, garages, carports and/or accessory buildings for offices, storage or shelter for equipment, materials, and goods associated with the home occupation, subject to the restrictions herein provided. (1991 Code § 17.12.200, as amended; amd. Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)
 

10-43-4: LEVEL ONE HOME OCCUPATION REQUIREMENTS:

   A.   Allowed Uses: The following home occupations, as a general rule, have been determined to meet the stated required standards described in Section 10-43-4B of this section for a level one home occupation. The applicant for such a home occupation is not required to obtain a conditional use permit from the Planning Commission and a business license from the City Council. However, the applicant shall appear before the Planning Commission to clarify that the applicant will comply with the requirements for a Level One Home Occupation and to ensure that the use is permitted. Compliance with Section 10-43-4B of this section is required. The holder is subject to the revocation of either or both the permitted use in the event of a failure to maintain compliance with the stated standards. (Ord. 2003-05, 12-17-2003)
      1.   Doctors for consultation or treatment on an occasional basis, not for full time practice;
      2.   Lawyers for consultation;
      3.   Writers, editors;
      4.   Computer programmers, data processing;
      5.   Telephone solicitors;
      6.   Seamstresses, tailors and related occupations;
      7.   Order processing where the stock of goods is stored elsewhere;
      8.   Artists, artisans, craftsman, photographers, sculptors and related artistic work (not for teaching classes or maintenance of a public gallery);
      9.   Architects;
      10.   Insurance agents;
      11.   Engineers;
      12.   Real estate licensees;
      13.   Clerical, secretarial, notary publics, accounting, drafting and similar office work;
      14.   individual private instructors/tutors;
      15.   Cosmetology; and
      16.   Other home occupations similar to those in this subsection judged by the Planning Commission to be in harmony with the character and intent of the zone in which it is proposed to be located.
   B.   Conditions and Requirements: Level one home occupations shall be allowed as conditional uses, subject to the following conditions:
      1.   All home occupations shall have a business license renewed each year by the city;
      2.   Required state and city professional licenses shall be shown prior to receiving a business license, and shall be maintained in a valid, nonsuspended or unrevoked status;
      3.   The home occupation must be clearly incidental and secondary to the primary use of the dwelling for residential purposes;
      4.   The home occupation shall be conducted such that the neighbors, under normal conditions, would not be aware of its existence;
      5.   The residence must be the principal residence of those conducting the home occupation;
      6.   The home occupation work conducted at the residence shall only involve those persons lawfully living in the residence;
      7.   No more than twenty five percent (25%) of the residence may be used for home occupation and this area shall remain in character with the rest of the home;
      8.   Inventory or other materials used in conjunction with the home occupation shall be kept within the residence;
      9.   The home occupation shall not generate any additional vehicular traffic or parking in the city right of way beyond that normally seen in a residential neighborhood;
      10.   A maximum of one additional vehicle associated with the home occupation, other than those used for the residents of the home, may be stored at the residence. This vehicle shall be parked on the property where the home occupation is located. Any vehicle with a rating over one ton shall be parked to the side or rear of the residence;
      11.   Long term parking (in excess of one half (1/2) hour) required for the home occupation shall be provided off the city right of way;
      12.   No noise, odor, light, vibrations, dust, gas or magnetic interference in excess of that normally experienced in a residential neighborhood shall be permitted beyond the premises on which the home occupation is located;
      13.   There shall be complete conformity with fire, building, plumbing, electrical and health codes, and all state and city ordinances;
      14.   A nonilluminated sign will be permitted on the property, which must be in compliance with Chapter 10-40 of this title. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-43-5: LEVEL TWO HOME OCCUPATION REQUIREMENTS:

Level two home occupations shall be allowed as conditional uses, subject to the following:
   A.   All requirements for level one home occupations shall apply unless otherwise noted in this section;
   B.   The conditional use permit shall be obtained from the Planning Commission and approved by the City Council, as a part of issuing the business license required;
   C.   The home occupation shall be conducted in a manner such that impact to neighbors and the surrounding area is minimized;
   D.   The home occupation work conducted at the residence shall involve a maximum of two (2) additional employees other than those persons lawfully living in the residence;
   E.   No more than twenty five percent (25%) of the property, including parking, where the home occupation is located, may be used for business purposes. This area shall remain in character with the rest of the neighborhood;
   F.   Inventory or other materials used in conjunction with the home occupation shall be kept within a garage, accessory building or home occupation property and shall not be noticeable from adjacent properties or rights of way;
   G.   The Planning Commission shall approve any parking of home occupation vehicles not meeting level one requirements
   H.   The Planning Commission shall hold a public hearing in connection with each application for a level two conditional use permit. (1991 Code § 17.12.200, as amended; amd. Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-43-6: APPLICATION FORM:

The city shall be required to provide all necessary forms for making an application for a conditional use permit and a business license for level one and level two home occupations. It is not uncommon for such forms to evolve with time and use, which results in city officials coming to understand that new or different information is needed in connection with such applications. The City Council is specifically allowed hereby to modify such applications as deemed necessary by the City Council, based on its own judgment and recommendations from the Planning Commission and other interested parties. In the event such changes are determined to be necessary, the changes may be made to the form, and once made, the application form, as revised, shall become the official application form for a level one or a level two home occupation application, whether it be for a conditional use permit or a business license. When such changes are made, it shall not be necessary to amend this section as authority for such ministerial duties is hereby granted to the appropriate city officials. The currently approved application forms for a business license for both a level one and a level two home occupation business are on file in the city office. These forms are hereby adopted as the official home occupation business license applications for level one and level two home occupations, until modified by the City Council at some future date. {1991 Code § 17.12.200, as amended; amd. 2009 Code; Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-43-7: REVIEW OF HOME OCCUPATION CONDITIONAL USE PERMITS:

   A.   The Planning Commission, as often as it deems necessary, upon the filing of a complaint from a citizen or other interested party of the community, which includes members of the elected and appointed officers and employees of the city, or upon the proposed expansion of the home occupation, will review a home occupation conditional use permit for compliance.
   B.   Level two conditional uses will be reviewed every three (3) years by the Planning Commission, or more often if deemed by the Planning Commission to be necessary. These reviews will occur prior to renewal of a business license.
   C.   Home occupation applicants shall permit reasonable inspection of the premises by a member of the Planning Commission to determine compliance with applicable laws and any conditional use permit and/or business license. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-43-8: LOSS OF HOME OCCUPATION USE; REVOCATION:

   A.   To maintain a conditional use, it is necessary to have a conditional use permit issued by the Planning Commission as provided in Chapters 10-49, 10-55 and 10-56 of this title, and a business license issued by the City Council as provided by City Code. If either or both of the permit and/or business license is revoked, suspended or otherwise terminated, the conditional use shall cease.
   B.   In conjunction with the provisions of Section 10-43-7 of this section, and as provided in Chapters 10-49, 10-55 and 10-56 of this title, a home occupation conditional use permit may be revoked in accordance with said Chapters 10-49, 10-55 and 10-56 of this title.
   C.   The review, suspension, refusal to renew and/or revocation of the conditional use permit holder's business license is governed by title 3 of this code, and specifically section 3-1-14 of this code. Pursuant to said section 3-1-14 of this code and any others which are applicable, the City Council has the authority to review and revoke, suspend or refuse to renew a business license; and if such action is taken by the City Council, the business conducted as a home occupation shall immediately cease until the required conditional use permit and/or business license is reinstated. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-43-9: APPEALS:

Any appeals in connection with the revocation of a home occupation conditional use permit or a revocation, suspension or refusal to renew a business license related to a home occupation conditional use are governed by the appeals process as outlined in Chapters 10-49, 10-55 and 10-56 of this title, together with any other applicable laws and regulations as contained in this code. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-43-10: EXISTING HOME OCCUPATIONS:

Existing home occupation activities and uses, which are in legal existence as of February 20, 2002, with their legality to be determined under the provisions of ordinance 98-04, in effect at the time this amendment is adopted and effective, but which are no longer legally allowed within the zone in which they are located by reason of the adoption of this amendment, may be maintained for subsequent years, subject to the following conditions:
   A.   The home occupation must comply with all conditions and provisions imposed by the prior ordinance;
   B.   Any changes or enlargements made to the existing home occupation will impose the provisions of this section, and the existing home occupation must then be brought into compliance with the provisions of this section immediately. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-43-11: NONTRANSFERABILITY:

Home occupation uses, permits and business licenses under this and related sections of the law, are personal to the applicant or home occupation owner, are nontransferable and do not run with the land. In the event the property on which an existing home occupation is located should be sold or otherwise transferred, it will result in the immediate termination of the right to continue the home occupation and the conditional use permit and business license. If it is the intent of the new owner to continue the home occupation, it will be necessary for the new owner to obtain a new conditional use permit and a new business license before continuing the existing home occupation on the premises involved. (1991 Code § 17.12.200, as amended; amd. Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-44-1: PURPOSE:

   This chapter is intended to provide development standards for specific categories of land uses for which conventional development standards of this Title need to be supplemented.
(Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-44-2: FENCES AND WALLS:

   A.   All fence walls and retaining walls shall conform to the provisions of this chapter. All references to fences are inclusive to walls, and retaining walls.
      1.   Fences, Walls, And Retaining Walls, Fence, walls, and retaining walls requirements on the property line(s) facing a single street (lots with only one street frontage.
         a.   The height of fences located within the front yard setback:
            (1)   Solid fences or fences that are less than 50 % open shall be have a height of no more than three (3) feet.
            (2)   Fences that have openings that are 50% or greater shall not exceed four (4) feet.
         b.   Fences may be located on the property line but not within the public right- of-way.
         c.   Chain link fencing is prohibited in the front yard between the front property line and the front of the dwelling or building.
      2.   Fence requirements on the side and rear property lines:
         a.   Fences along the rear property line (unless the rear property line fronts a street) shall be a maximum of six feet (6') in height, except for the portion of the rear property line that due to lot configuration may be within a front setback,
         b.   Fences along the side property line (unless the side property line fronts a street) shall be a maximum of six feet (61) in height, except for the portion of the side property line within a front setback,
         c.   No fence located within the site distance triangle (see 10.62 and 10.38.8D) shall have a height greater than a fence allowed in the front yard.
      3.   Fence requirements, for lots with more than one. street frontage:
         a.   No fence shall be higher than fences allowed in the front yard on the property line or at any point within the front setback except as follows:
            (1)   The property owner shall declare one frontage of the lot as the “front,” and a fence allowed in the front yard may be located within the front setback,
            (2)   The property lines fronting any other street or streets that are not declared as the “front” site may be fenced with the following options:
               (A)   A fence allowed in the front yard may be constructed along the property line, or
               (B)   A six-foot high fence may be constructed on the property line provided that any portion of the fence located within the site distance triangle (see 10.62 and 10.38.8D) is reduced in height as allowed within the front yard.
      4.   Measurement of fence height
         a.   The height of a fence shall me measured at any point along the run of the fence from the finished grade to the top of the highest component of the fence.
         b.   Where there is a difference in the ground level between two adjacent parcels, the height of a fence or wall constructed along the property line shall be determined by using the finish grade of the lowest contiguous parcel.
   Height Measurement of Fences and Walls in Front Yard
   Height Measurement of Fences and Walls on Slopes
   Height Measurement at Property Line when Grades are Different
(Ord. 2022-02, 3-2-2022)

10-44-4: ADULT-ORIENTED BUSINESSES:

   A.   Purpose: The purpose of this section is to establish reasonable and uniform regulations to prevent the concentration of adult-oriented businesses or their location in areas deleterious to the City, regulate the signage of such businesses, control the adverse effects of such signage, and prevent inappropriate exposure of such businesses to the community. The chapter is to be construed as a regulation of time, place, and manner of the operation of these businesses, consistent with the United States and Utah Constitutions.
   B.   Location Of Businesses - Restrictions:
      1.   Adult oriented business shall be conditionally permitted in the Industrial (IND) district subject to the provisions of this chapter.
      2.   No adult-oriented business shall be located:
         a.   Within one thousand feet (1,000') of any school, public park, library, or religious institution,
         b.   Within one thousand feet (1,000') of any residential use (no matter which zoning district) or residential zoning boundary,
         c.   Within six hundred feet (600') of any other adult-oriented business,
         d.   Within six hundred feet (600') of any gateway or gateway corridor as identified in this Title and the General Plan. The distance shall be measured from the edge of the right-of-way.
      3.   Distance requirements between structures and uses specified in this section shall be measured in a straight line, without regard to intervening structures or zoning districts, from the perimeter property boundaries of the school, public park, religious or cultural activity, residential use, or other adult-oriented business, or from the edge of right-of-way of a gateway to the structure of the adult-oriented business.
      4.   Distance requirements from zoning districts for this section shall be measured in a straight line, without regard to intervening structures or zoning districts, from the closest zoning boundary of a residential or agricultural district to the adult-oriented business structure.
   C.   Effect on Non-Conforming Businesses: All lawfully established, legally existing, non-conforming adult-oriented businesses, shall comply with the provisions of this chapter by ninety (90) days after adoption of the Chapter, except in the case in which a business is required to be relocated. In such cases where relocation is required for conformance with this section, the business shall comply within one (1) year after adoption of this Chapter.
   D.   Signs: Signs for adult-oriented businesses shall be subject to the limitations of this section regardless of standards within Chapter 10-40 of the Wellsville City Code.
      1.   No more than one exterior building-mounted sign shall be permitted,
      2.   No sign shall exceed eighteen (18) square feet in total sign area,
      3.   No animation shall be permitted on or around any sign or on the exterior walls or roof of such premises,
      4.   No descriptive art or designs depicting any activity related to or inferring the nature of the business shall be permitted on any sign. Signs shall contain alphanumeric copy only.
      5.   Only flat wall signs shall be permitted; awnings shall be permitted only to display the street number in letters or numbers no greater than eight inches in height,
      6.   Painted wall advertising shall not be allowed,
      7.   Other than the signs specifically allowed by this chapter, the adult-oriented business shall not attach, construct, or allow to be attached or constructed any temporary sign, banner, light, or other device designed to draw attention to the business location. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-44-5: THE RIGHT TO FARM:

   A.   Findings:
      1.   As Wellsville grows, the City will begin to annex land area that is currently in agricultural production.
      2.   The City still has agricultural uses within its existing boundaries.
      3.   The City recognizes that the owners of these farms have certain rights for the agricultural uses to continue.
      4.   Protecting the rights of agricultural uses to continue is important in order to avoid the conflict between long-standing agribusinesses and newly settled homeowners.
   B.   Right To Farm Standards:
      1.   The right of a farm may continue using standard agricultural practices for purposes of commercial farming, ranching, or crop production. These agricultural uses are permitted uses.
      2.   To be protected with the "right to farm," agricultural uses shall operate within the provisions of the law related to the use of pesticides and operations of equipment.
      3.   When the City approves urban development adjoining agricultural uses, the urban project shall be required to ensure that its future buyers, tenants, or occupants recognize that the right of a farm to continue is a City policy.
   C.   Protective Standards: When urban development is considered adjoining existing agricultural uses, the City shall not impose regulations that will interfere with accepted farm operations, including:
      1.   Hours of operations: The City shall not limit the hours of operations or days of use;
      2.   Noise standards: Noise abatement or modification requirements shall be conditions of the urban land use and not preexisting agricultural uses.
      3.   Storage of working equipment: No limitations shall be imposed on equipment that is used in the operations of an existing farm or ranch, except that equipment that is abandoned or stored shall be kept in a safe and orderly manner.
   D.   Mediation And Assistance In Determining Compliance: In the event that any person forwards an argument that an agricultural operation protected by the provisions of this section is not utilizing accepted agricultural practices in its operations, the City shall utilize the resources available from the Utah State University College of Agriculture in determining the acceptable standards for the practices. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-44-6: KEEPING OF ANIMALS AND FOWL:

The keeping of animals and fowl is permitted on lots by a point count system and is based on the size of a lot.
   A.   Lots one-half (1/2) acre or larger a total of not more than ten (10) points is allowed.
   B.   Lots less than one-half (1/2) acre a total of not more than seven (7) points is allowed.
Figure 10-44-7 ANIMAL POINT EQUIVALENTS
1 cow or bison
3 points
1 sheep or goat
1 points
5 rabbits
2 points
10 pigeons
2 points
5 chickens or guinea fowl
1 point
1 duck or 1 goose
1 point
1 turkey
1 point
1 ostrich
3 points
1 fallow deer
2 points
 
   C.   General Requirements:
      1.   Offspring of mammals shall not be considered in the point count until they are weaned.
      2.   Animals must have free access to a minimum of forty percent (40%) of the lot.
      3.   Pigs of any kind and peacocks are not allowed.
      4.   Where permitted under the provisions of this title, animals and fowl are to be fed and corralled at least fifty feet (50') from any dwelling on the same or adjacent lot, as measured from the closest point of the corral or enclosure to the closest point of the dwelling. These distance restrictions apply to permanent corrals, stables, sheds, barns or other protected or restricted areas.
      5.   For purposes of grazing down a pasture, animals may be brought in for a period not to exceed one hundred eighty (180) days per year per piece of property, and the number of animals permitted to graze may be up to twice the number allowed on a permanent basis. Grazing includes only the vegetation native to the pasture and does not permit the supplemental feeding of hay or grain.
      6.   The keeping of animals and fowl are allowed only by conditions that they do not constitute a violation of the nuisance or health code.
      7.   If any keeping of animals become a nuisance or cause frequent complaints, these regulation shall require abatement and removal as prescribed in Chapter 10-60 Administrative Enforcement.
   D.   Keeping of Pigs for youth project of the 4-H or FFA:
      1.   The keeping of pigs of any species, including pigs, is not permitted within the corporate limits of Wellsville City, except, pigs may be kept by youth ages eight (8) - eighteen (18) who are raising such as members of the 4-H or FFA, Youth must be Wellsville City residents. Pigs may be kept on a temporary basis on a parcel that is one-half (1/2) acre or larger. For this purpose, the keeping of pigs shall be limited to the period of March 1st to August 31st.
      2.   To facilitate compliance with 4-H and FFA rules and protocols a Pig Oversight Committee of three (3) persons will be formed. Committee members will be appointed by the Mayor annually. The committee will be responsible to ensure participant compliance. Non-compliance will be reported to the City Manager.
      3.   The keeping of pigs, for this purpose, is subject to the following criteria:
         a.   Two (2) pigs allowed on one-half (1/2) acre, three (3) pigs allowed on % acre and maximum of four (4) pigs are allowed on one (1) acre.
         b.   Pigs must be registered, tagged, and monitored in accordance with 4-H and FFA rules and protocols.
         c.   Proposed owners of pigs must discuss said ownership with all neighbors sharing property lines. If neighbors do not support the raising of pigs for this purpose they are to be referred to the City Council for arbitration.
         d.   Pens, sheds, and shelters containing pigs shall not be kept within the front yard setback, nor within the side yard setback on corner lots.
         e.   Shade must be provided.
         f.   Clean, fresh water and fresh feed must be readily available.
         g.   Sheltered inside space shall be provided as follows:
            (1)   Up to forty (40) pounds: three (3) square feet per pig.
            (2)   Forty (40) pounds to one hundred (100) pounds: four (4) square feet per pig.
            (3)   One hundred (100) pounds to one hundred fifty (150) pounds: six (6) square feet per pig.
            (4)   Exceeding one hundred fifty (150) pounds to market weight: eight (8) square per pig.
   E.   Adequate outside space must be provided: six (6) square feet to fifteen (15) square feet per pig determined by size of pig. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-44-7: STRUCTURE RELOCATION, TRAILER CONTAINERS, AND PORTABLE CARPORTS:

   A.   General: No building or structure shall be moved into nor relocated in the City unless such building or structure and proposed foundation are in compliance with current building codes, Land Use Regulations, and all other pertinent City ordinances. The relocation of mobile homes, demountable structures, manufactured buildings, shipping trailer containers, portable carports and similar movable structures shall also be subject to the requirements of this section, except the requirements of this provision shall not apply to the moving of mobile homes within a mobile home park.
   B.   Permits Required:
      1.   No person, firm or corporation shall move into or relocate within the City any building or structure without first obtaining a building permit and a conditional use permit Permits shall be required prior to relocation. A site investigation will be required whenever the Chief Building Official deems appropriate.
      2.   Failure to comply with the requirements of this chapter shall require that the relocated structure or building be relocated to a site allowed and intended for storage of building materials or it shall be moved outside of City jurisdiction. In addition, failure to comply with any of the requirements of this chapter shall be subject to the enforcement provisions of the Municipal code.
   C.   Investigation:
      1.   Prior to the issuance of a Conditional Use Permit for the relocation of a building or structure, the Chief Building Official shall investigate any buildings or structures to be relocated and the property for relocation in order to determine whether a permit shall be granted. The Planning Commission shall specify conditions that shall accompany the permit. Conditions may apply to the vacated site, the moving operation, and the permanent lot.
      2.   Investigation of the building or structure to be relocated shall include the review of complete site and building plans showing compliance with all current codes regulating construction. The plans must include complete structural, electrical, plumbing, and mechanical drawings with a detailed scope of work to be performed with the relocation. The approved plans shall be included in the conditions of the building permit.
   D.   Standard Conditions Of Relocation:
      1.   No building or structure shall be moved into nor relocated within the City that is dangerous or unsafe, or which is infested, dilapidated, defective, or in such a condition of deterioration or disrepair that its relocation at the proposed site would be materially detrimental to the property in the district or area surrounding the proposed site. The Chief Building Official may place such conditions as deemed necessary to protect the public health, safety or welfare on any proposed relocation of a building or structure;
      2.   All footings and foundations on the site to which the building or structure is to be relocated shall be inspected, approved, and installed prior to removal of the building or structure from its original site;
      3.   All relocated structures shall be permanently affixed to a new foundation within forty five (45) days of approval of the foundation. Prior to the release of the permit, the applicant may request, in writing, an extension of the 45-day time, subject to approval by the Planning Commission. Ail relocated structures shall comply with all applicable regulations and conditions within six months of the date of the permit issuance unless otherwise approved and extended in writing by the Planning Commission;
      4.   All relocated buildings or structures, whether permanently affixed to a new foundation or not, and all buildings or structures to be relocated, shall be maintained in a safe, secure condition. This will require certification by a licensed structural engineer that the structure is sound enough to be moved and relocated. The structural engineer must include drawings and specifications to support structural analysis for moving and relocation at the proposed site. The chief building Official may require a structural peer review to substantiate findings of the structural engineer.
      5.   At the proposed site, all landscaping, walkways, masonry work, or required dedications and improvements for streets and facilities and building shall be provided in conformity with the standards of the City. At the vacated site, restoration and improvements shall be required as deemed necessary by the Chief Building Official.
      6.   A bond or other assurance shall be posted as a guarantee that the building and grounds will be improved, as stipulated, before the building is occupied. The bond or other assurance shall include costs for the vacated site to be restored to a safe and sightly condition. The amount of the bond or other assurance shall be at least equal to the cost of employing a contractor to make the improvements to the buildings and premises as required.
      7.   The applicant shall pay all cost incurred by the City for materials, labor, equipment and machinery, and other incidental costs directly related to the move. The permit holder shall also be responsible for the cost to repair all damages caused by the move to streets, bridges, sidewalks, trees and landscape, utilities, and other property.
   E.   Storage of Relocated Structures or Buildings: Storage of a relocated structure or at a location other than the vacated or permanent site shall only occur at a site allowed and intended for storage of building materials. When a building or structure is relocated at a site allowed and intended for storage of building materials, the following requirements shall apply:
      1.   Application for, fees for, and construction of any foundation work or any improvements is not required until such time as the building is ready to be relocated from the yard. The foundation permit must be released and the foundation inspected, approved, and installed prior to removal of the building from the yard; and
      2.   If relocated structures are to be stored for a period exceeding thirty (30) days, they shall be in compliance with setback requirements as set forth in the Land Use Regulations.
      3.   All structures shall be securely blocked to maintain structural integrity and to resist wind forces. In addition, any stored structure shall be located in a secure fenced yard in compliance with Chapter 10-36.
   F.   Findings Of Fact: A building permit for the relocation of a building or structure granted to the applicant shall be substantiated by the finding of Section 10-49-5. The following additional findings shall be determined:
      1.   The building or structure will have no appreciable detrimental effect on the living environment and property values in the area into which the structure is to be moved;
      2.   The building or structure is in conformity with the quality of buildings existing in the area of the proposed site.
   G.   Existing Relocated Structures: Buildings or structures that have been removed from the original location and that have not been relocated to a permanent site on a permanent foundation prior to the adoption of this ordinance shall comply with the regulations of this chapter within forty five (45) days. Failure to comply with the requirements of this section may result in additional fees being levied or initiation of enforcement procedures provided in the Municipal Code. Once application has been made for a conditional use permit, the Planning Commission may grant a one-time, six (6) month extension of time when the following findings can be substantiated:
      1.   The proponent's initiation of relocation and permitting activities is limited by the City or other public agency which has not taken place or was delayed, resulting in a time delay beyond the permit holder's control.
      2.   The proponent has made a good faith effort to initiate the project by systematically completing pre-relocation conditions to the satisfaction of the responsible agency or department.
      3.   Circumstances, other than approval of financing, beyond the control of the permit holder has prevented initiation of the project.
   H.   License - Required: It is unlawful to engage in the business of house moving, raising, or shoring without first having obtained a business license therefore.
   I.   Requirements For Shipping Containers And Trailers: Steel shipping containers, ocean shipping containers and trailers designed to be towed by combination vehicles or a truck shall not be located within the City unless they meet the following standards:
      1.   All Zoning Districts: In all zoning districts within the City, shipping containers and trailers shall meet the following requirements:
         a.   Not to exceed two hundred (200) square feet;
         b.   Meet all requirements for accessory uses and structures;
         c.   Review and approval by the Planning Commission. The Planning Commission may require a public hearing;
         d.   Obtain a building permit if electrical or other city services are required;
         e.   Not allowed as a dwelling.
      2.   Commercial and Industrial Zones: In commercial and industrial zones shipping containers and trailers that exceed two hundred (200) square feet, shall meet the following requirements:
         a.   Obtain a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) from the Planning Commission requiring a public hearing and notification of property owners within three hundred (300) feet.
         b.   Meet requirements as an accessory use and structure;
         c.   Obtain a building permit if electrical or other city services are required;
         d.   Not allowed as a dwelling.
   J.   Portable Carports: Moveable carports that are purchased in kits and composed of a metal frame and fabric or metal cover shall meet the following requirements;
      1.   If the structure is less than two hundred (200) square feet a carport permit must be obtained from the Planning Commission.
      2.   located behind the rear plane of the residential structure. Not allowed within the front yard or side yard of the primary residential structure;
      3.   Anchored to meet manufacturer's instructions;
      4.   The roof and structure shall be maintained in a safe and aesthetic condition;
      5.   Carport larger than two hundred (200) square feet must meet requirements of the currently adopted building code and obtain a building permit and required inspections. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-44-8: MANUFACTURED HOMES:

A manufactured home may be approved as a permanent dwelling; provided, that:
   A.   Minimum Width: The manufactured home shall be a minimum of twenty feet (20') wide.
   B.   Date Of Manufacture: The manufactured home was manufactured after June 1976, and is stamped by HUD (S-5402-6) and contains the state insignia of approval.
   C.   Permits Obtained: A Conditional Use Permit and a building permits is required to assure that site preparation, foundations, installation, roof loads, etc., meet the appropriate codes.
   D.   Recorded As Real Estate: The manufactured home is recorded with the county recorder as being "permanently affixed" to real estate.
   E.   Development Standards: The manufactured home meets the following development standards:
      1.   It has exterior siding which extends to a permanent continuous foundation. The siding shall consist of a conventional exterior material and shall be finished before occupancy.
      2.   It has a shingled, pitched gable roof.
      3.   It has improved permanent entrances and exits which are installed according to the adopted building codes.
      4.   It does not violate any deed restrictions in the area where the unit is to be located.
   F.   Board Of Health Requirements: The manufactured home meets the requirements of the state board of health.
   G.   Zoning Requirements: The manufactured home meets the appropriate zoning requirements.
   H.   Changes Require Building Permit: Any additions, enlargements or remodels must receive building permits to assure that all minimum adopted standards are being met.
   I.   Manufactured homes must meet all requirements of the currently adopted International Building Code and state building code amendments.
(Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-44-9-1: PURPOSE:

   A.   Purpose. The purpose of Ag-Tourism is to support agriculture within the City of Wellsville. The city desires to foster economically feasible land use alternatives for local, enterprising agriculture operators committed to providing local agricultural products, artisan goods, education, and rural experiences for the public.
   B.   Wellsville seeks, primarily, to promote the preservation of agriculture by aiding operations in generating supplementary farm income through innovation and entrepreneurship. Keeping agriculture viable is a high priority. Agricultural production shall be the primary use of the land and shall not become secondary to Ag-Tourism. This ordinance seeks to:
      1.   Support a sustainable agricultural environment.
      2.   Develop agri-business, ag-tourism, farm-to-market, farm-to-table, and related strategies and objectives.
      3.   Allow an environment for agricultural, and artisan goods that benefit both community and commerce, including agricultural involved experience, education, and outreach.
      4.   Protect the health, safety, and welfare of those who operate and those who attended ag-tourism venues.
   C.   This section is not intended to regulate a farmer for the production and sale of farm products as traditionally practiced by growing, harvesting, taking the product to market, feeding what is produced, or storing the product for future use or sale.
   D.   The City has authority and obligation to regulate safety whenever a farm attracts groups of people, vehicles, or whenever events concentrate people requiring sanitary facilities, access to public roads, exiting safety, emergency access, avoidance of hazards, and fire safety.
(Ord. 2023-08, 11-1-2023)

10-44-9-2: DEFINITIONS:

The following definitions apply to this Chapter:
AGRICULTURE: The tilling of soil, growing of produce or crops, or raising or keeping of domestic animals that is consistent with the R0S1, RAC5, CG, or OSC zoning districts where the property is located.
AGRI-BUSINESS: The use of land to generate revenue as an agricultural operation, the production of food and artisan goods for retail, wholesale, or commercial use, and is inclusive of ag-tourism, farm-to-market, and farm-to-table.
AG-TOURISM: The public visiting a working farm, agricultural and/or horticultural operation for enjoyment, education, or involvement in the activities of the farm or operation.
ARTISAN: A worker in a skilled trade, especially one that involves making food, drinks, crafts, or consumer products made by hand in a traditional way using high quality ingredients that are produced on the premises or locally.
ARTISAN GOODS: Products that are produced by artisans, either completely by hand or with the help of hand-tools or even mechanical means, as long as the direct manual contribution of the artisan remains the most substantial component of the finished product.
ENTERTAINMENT USES: Activities and structures that attract people to events or shows seasonally or periodically that are generally of a spectator nature. Entertainment uses can be outdoors and/or indoors.
RECREATIONAL USES: Activities and structures that are participatory in nature where guests are involved or may be observers. Recreational uses are in indoors and/or outdoors and correspond to the farming season.
(Ord. 2023-08, 11-1-2023)

10-44-9-3: APPLICABILITY:

   A.   This Chapter applies to properties in the R0S1, RAC5, CG, or OSC, Zones. The uses and standards in this chapter supplement and are in addition to those of the ROS1, RAC5, CG, OSC, Zones. It shall be the responsibility of the property owner and/or operator to understand and comply with all applicable codes. If a conditional use permit is required, per the permitted use table in 10-44-9-060, the conditional use permit application must be completed and submitted to the city for review and receive approval by the Planning Commission before engaging in any Ag-tourism.
   B.   All Ag-tourism and agri-business operations, whether the use is permitted or conditional shall require a business license. All operations shall obtain a business license approved and issued by the City before engaging in business.
   C.   This Chapter shall not apply to agriculture producers who use or sell farm, livestock, hay, seedling plants, garden, or other agricultural produce, if sold during the harvest season by the producer, an employee of the producer, or by a member of the producers immediate family. In addition, this chapter shall not apply to agriculture producers who store farm products for sale after the harvest season.
   D.   Any Ag-Tourism business selling admission, products, or services that are defined by the Utah Tax Commission, as taxable for sale or use tax, shall collect and pay sales taxes or use taxes, unless the business obtains a Sales Tax Exception Certificate from the Utah Tax Commission.
(Ord. 2023-08, 11-1-2023)

10-44-9-4: REQUIRED STANDARDS:

   A.   Applicability. Any parcel of land that is a viable and active farm may be eligible as an Ag-tourism business if the primary use of the parcel is agriculture within the ROS1, RAC5, CG, or OSC Zones.
   B.   Agriculture Primary. When agriculture is the primary use in an ROS1, RAC5, CG or OSC Zone, Ag-tourism uses are complementary and accessory to the primary agriculture use. Whenever there is an occupied residential dwelling on the property, agriculture shall not be considered the primary use, except where the size of the parcel exceeds 1 acre and the majority of the land area is in active agricultural production.
   C.   Application. All Ag-tourism applications shall be accompanied by a concise narrative describing the farm, agriculture operation, and the overall vision for the proposed Ag-tourism business. The narrative shall include:
      1.   Agriculture and farm history.
      2.   A description or plan for the general maintenance of its agricultural product(s) and proposals for the following:
         a.   Proposed Ag-tourism uses, including any non-agriculturally related products, uses, or activities.
         b.   Agriculturally related and non-agriculturally related types of facilities and equipment.
         c.   Anticipated number of daily patrons and employees showing peak times and numbers attending.
         d.   Written evidence from the Fire Marshal that fire safety, EMS issues have been evaluated and concerns have been addressed. If additional concerns are described by the fire marshal those issues shall become conditions of approval. Any structures or uses that have not been approved previously, shall be reviewed and approved by the Fire Marshal, including any entertainment or recreational uses that are new or that are proposed to be modified from previous approvals.
         e.   Written evidence shall be provided showing that access, from any state highway, will be permitted for the proposed ag-tourism operations.
         f.   Maximum number of vehicles to be parked on the property at peaks times and during average attendance, Parking areas shall be shown on the site plan.
         g.   The proposed season of use.
         h.   A statement explaining the desired operation hours.
         i.   A detailed description of the nature of entertainment or recreational uses, facilities, and structures. Sufficient details shall be shown in the form of plans, narratives, and visual representations that allow the Planning Commission to understand how the proposal is built, maintained, and used by guests.
   D.   Site Plan. A site plan review is required for newly permitted large farms (5 acres & larger) for ag-tourism uses, conditional uses, and new construction. The site plan shall be drawn to engineer’s scale. The site plan shall contain the following:
      1.   Existing buildings, structures and proposed new construction of buildings and facilities intended for Ag-tourism purposes.
      2.   New construction shall comply with requirements of the City Code for accessory buildings. Required setbacks shall be shown on the site plan.
      3.   Front yard setbacks for permanent ag-tourism facilities and uses fronting on Highway 89/91 are required to be one hundred and fifty (150) feet. Front yard setbacks in all other locations shall be thirty (30) feet. Agi-tourism permanent structures and parking shall not be located within the front yard setback.
      4.   Proximity of ag-tourism operations to adjacent properties, existing buildings, and uses shall be considered in approving the site plan.
      5.   All sewage disposal facility location(s).
      6.   An Ag-tourism operation may consist of multiple adjacent properties. All properties shall be considered in aggregate.
      7.   Existing parking, proposed new parking, and over-flow parking shall be shown on the site plan explaining the type of surface material for interior roads or proposed parking.
   E.   Production. An Ag-tourism use shall, with exception of the winter season, actively produce an agricultural product for sale or use by the farmer. In the event, that the Ag-tourism use and facilities become unsafe or unsightly, the right to operate an Ag-tourism use under this Chapter may be revoked, by the Planning Commission.
   F.   Access. Access to the property from a city street shall be approved by the City Engineer. Access from any state highway shall be permitted by the Utah Department of Transportation.
   G.   Parking. All uses shall have adequate off-street parking. The owner shall obtain an alternative parking permit (10-38-5) which shall become a condition of approval. No on-street parking shall be allowed. Parking surfaces shall be well maintained to allow emergency access.
   H.   Permanent Buildings. Permanent buildings and structures that are used exclusively for agricultural purposes are allowed visitors to be educated about or to participate in the activities that occur within the farm building. New farm buildings shall be permitted for the purposes of farming operations. Whenever permanent buildings or portions of buildings are used for group gatherings, the building shall meet the requirements for Group Occupancy A as defined by the most current adopted building code. Group A occupancy includes the use of a building or structure, or a portion thereof, for the gathering of persons for purposes such as civic, social, religious functions, recreation, food or drink consumption, or awaiting transportation. Group occupancy limits shall be established by the fire marshall and shall be clearly posted by the owner/operator.
   I.   Sanitary Sewer Disposal. Permanent sanitary sewer facilities are required if located within three hundred (300) feet of an existing city sewer line unless specifically waived by the City Council. On-site sewage disposal may be approved at the discretion of the City Council. On-site sewage disposal shall conform to requirements of the Bear River Health Department. If temporary sanitary facilities are found necessary, they shall be incorporated into the design of the Ag-tourism operation and completely screened from view from public streets and adjacent property.
   J.   Uses. Agriculture shall be is maintained as the primary use of the property, unless a residential use is permitted and has been established as the primary use.
   K.   Access. Access for fire and EMS vehicles shall be provided to all venues of the ag-tourism operation and shall be independent of parking lot(s). The Fire Marshall shall inspect and provide a letter that emergency access is adequate.
   L.   Entertainment And Recreational Uses. Proposed new or proposed modified entertainment and/or recreational uses, facilities, or structures shall be reviewed as specified in 10-49 for a Conditional Use Permit which shall be processed in parallel with these Ag-Tourism procedures. The Planning Commission shall base conditions on the standards of 10-49 and may require recommendations from the Fire Marshal, the City Engineer, the Building Inspector, or other expert analysis.
   M.   Signs. Signs shall obtain one sign permit to Include all signs for the season prior to the beginning of each season as provided in 10-40, Sign permits require administrative staff approval.
   N.   Signs - Safety. Signage stating the safe and unsafe uses of farm property shall be posted at entrances to the site, buildings accessible to visitors, and ag-tourism venues.
   O.   Secure Site. Site facilities and grounds shall be secured, and temporary signs removed at the end of the operational season.
   P.   Hours Of Operation. Ag-tourism uses are limited to 6:00 A.M. and 10:00 P.M., except where hours may be extended as permitted as a condition of approval by the Planning Commission.
   Q.   Development Agreement. Property owners and the city have the option to enter into a development agreement but shall not be required. Participation in a development agreement is voluntary for all parties. The development agreement may be annual or continual as agreed upon. A development agreement is a voluntary contract between the City of Wellsville and a person who owns or controls property within the city, detailing the obligations of both parties and specifying the standards and conditions that will govern development of the property. A development agreement can benefit all parties and can foster compromise or contributions to improve a development.
(Ord. 2023-08, 11-1-2023)

10-44-9-5: FARM CLASSIFICATION:

   The following establishes the classification for farm operations based on acreage:
   A.   Small Farm. Includes an agriculturally productive property consisting of lot sizes one (1) to five (5) acres.
   B.   Large Farm. Includes an agriculturally productive property consisting of lot sizes greater than (5) acres.
(Ord. 2023-08, 11-1-2023)

10-44-9-6: PERMITTED USE TABLE:

   The following uses are determined desirable in conjunction with primary agriculture operation. The uses in this Section may be subject to other requirements beyond those imposed by this Chapter. “P” denotes a permitted use, “C” denotes a conditional use in the ROS1, RAC5, CG, OSC, Zones.
Use / Activity
Small Farm
Large Farm
Use / Activity
Small Farm
Large Farm
Agricultural Demonstrations or Educational Classes
P
P
Artisan Goods Production
P
P
Festival Related to Agribusiness
C
C
Community Garden / Rent-a-row
P
P
Corn Maze
NONE
C
Herb Garden
P
P
Market for On-site Produce
P
P
Market for Multi Farmers / Off-site Products
None
C
Nursery or Greenhouse
P
P
Passenger Rides (tractor, sleigh, wagon, etc.)
None
P
Petting Farm or Zoo
none
C
Photography
P
P
Pumpkin Patch or U-Pick Operation
P
P
Entertainment or Recreational Uses
C
C
Any Other Approved Agribusiness Use
C
C
 
(Ord. 2023-08, 11-1-2023)

10-44-9-7: PERMITTING PROCEDURES:

   The process to obtain clearance to apply for a business license shall be as follows:
 
 
Small Farm
(Less than 5 ac.)
Large Farm
(5 acres +)
Permitted Uses (P) (from table 10-44-9-060)
Application Reviewed by Staff
Reviewed by Planning Commission - no public hearing
Conditional Uses (C). (from table 10-44-9-060)
Conditional Use Permit (10-49) Public Hearing
Conditional Use Permit (10-49) Public Hearing
 
(Ord. 2023-08, 11-1-2023)

10-44-9-8: AG-VENDORS:

   A.   Ag-Vendors Defined: An Ag-Vendor is an invited guest of a property owner holding a valid business license for Ag-Tourism. An Ag-Vendor(s) may provide for sale to the public, local agricultural products, food, entertainment, and recreation services that support education, and rural experiences for the public and as otherwise specified in 10-44-9.
   B.   License Required: It shall be unlawful to operate as an ag- vendor without first obtaining a valid city business license or a temporary ag-vendor license.
   C.   License Required; Display: It shall be unlawful for any person to conduct business as an ag-vendor, except as exempted in this article, without first securing a license for such business. The license shall be displayed in a visible location with the vendor operations.
   D.   Exemptions: Agricultural producers who sell only fruits and vegetables produced from their own property, and sold on the producer’s property are exempt from licensing or the payment of license fees under this article.
   E.   Procedure: A registry shall be posted at the city offices. Applicants may register and obtain a temporary ag-vendor license upon completing necessary paperwork. If the ag- vendor plans to operate in the city, for the season, a business license shall be required.
   F.   Unlawful Acts: It shall be unlawful for an exempt vendor to sell, produce, or grow other than on the exempt vendor’s property, or to sell any merchandise other than fruits and vegetables at an exempt location.
(Ord. 2023-08, 11-1-2023)

10-45-1: PURPOSE:

The purpose of this chapter is to protect Wellsville's aesthetic resources and community character by establishing development regulations for wireless telecommunication facilities (hereafter "facilities") to assure their compatibility with adjoining uses. The location and design of telecommunications facilities have the potential to have long-term negative effects on surrounding properties and neighborhoods.
The intent of the following regulations is to reduce those effects by locating wireless telecommunications facilities where they are least visible from public streets and public areas and to the best extent possible, provide screening from adjacent property owners. Antennas mounted on existing structures are preferred over new monopoles because they are more easily hidden or are generally less conspicuous when not completely hidden. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-45-2: APPLICABILITY:

This chapter applies to both commercial and private wireless telecommunication facilities, such as, but not limited to, "cellular" or PCS (personal communications system) communications and paging facilities or others as defined in Chapter 10-62. This chapter does not apply to public safety, amateur radio, satellite, or cable television communications facilities, although they may be regulated by other city ordinances and policies. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-45-3: PERMITS REQUIRED:

   A.   A design review permit is required for alt new or expanding wireless telecommunications facilities. The design review permit shall be issued in accordance with the City's standard design review permit approval process described in Chapter 10-50. The City shall process all applications within a reasonable time and shall not unreasonably discriminate among providers of functionally equivalent services.
   B.   A design review permit may not be required if the Planning Commission finds that the proposed changes will not result in a significant character change in the appearance of a structure from what currently exists. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-45-4: APPLICATIONS:

In addition to the standard items to be included with the design review application, the applicant shall submit the following;
   A.   Certification of compliance with FCC Parts 24 and 27 regarding RF (radio frequency) hazards and safety, and other FCC provisions as applicable.
   B.   A visual analysis, to include photo simulations, field mock up, computer enhanced graphics or other techniques, which identify the negative visual effects of the proposed facility on surrounding properties. The analysis shall include the following as required by the Design Review Committee:
      1.   Show views of the facility from public areas (streets, parks, etc.); and
      2.   Show views from private residences; and
      3.   Show the appearance of the facility from at least three locations within a three-block radius. One view shall be from a point on the nearest public right-of-way from which the facility is most visible. Other views shall be from locations where the facility would be most visible.
The Design Review Committee or the Planning Commission may ask for additional simulations if it feels that they are necessary to better understand the proposed facility's effect on the surrounding neighborhood. All costs associated with this requirement are to be borne by the applicant. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-45-5: DESIGN REQUIREMENTS:

In order to approve a design review permit, the Design Review Committee shall find that the proposed facility employs stealth design. In making the decision, the Design Review Committee shall consider the criteria below and any special circumstances that may apply to the proposed site. Because of differing circumstances specific to each site, a facility that is considered to be stealth in one location may not be considered to be stealth in a different location.
   A.   "Stealth design" is required for all facilities regulated by this chapter. To the extent reasonably feasible, the applicant shall employ stealth design so as to mitigate and/or camouflage negative visual effects. Stealth design ensures that facilities will be compatible with the natural or built setting and that the facilities will be concealed or camouflaged. Methods of stealth designs include:
      1.   Blending the facility with the architecture of the existing structure upon which the facility will be mounted;
      2.   Blending the facility with and/or take advantage of existing vegetation and/or site features;
      3.   Using color schemes that make the facility less noticeable;
      4.   Using church steeples, clock towers, bell towers, false penthouses or other similar "mimic" structures to conceal antennas and associated structures and equipment. Such "mimic" structures shall have a contextual relationship to the adjacent area. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-45-6: LOCATION ON EXISTING TOWERS AND POLES:

Location on existing towers is both permitted and encouraged in order to discourage the proliferation of wireless telecommunications facilities.
   A.   Location On Existing Towers And Poles:
      1.   The width of antennas and antenna mounting structures placed on the top of an existing tower or pole shall not exceed the width of the pole at its highest point.
      2.   Antennas and their supporting structure mounted to the sides of an existing tower or pole shall be as slim in profile as possible. In no case shall the antennas and supporting structures extend more than one foot beyond the tower or pole.
      3.   The height of the antenna and its supporting structures may not exceed five feet (5') above the height of the tower or pole.
      4.   In addition to the above standards, facilities shall comply with Section 10-45-5.
   B.   Co-location On Existing Monopoles:
      1.   The maximum height of a monopole with antennas and antenna support structures may be increased for co-location of a second antenna on an existing monopole if the new height of the monopole and antenna will not exceed twenty feet (20') above the maximum height for structures for the zone in which it is placed,
      2.   Antennas and supporting structures mounted to the sides of a monopole shall be as slim in profile as possible. In no case shall the antennas and supporting structures extend more than one foot (1') beyond the pole in any direction.
      3.   In addition to the above standards, facilities shall comply with Section 10-45-5.
   C.   Private radio antennas shall be limited to one antenna per lot in all residential zones when occupied by a dwelling. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-45-7: ROOF-MOUNTED ANTENNAS:

   A.   Roof-mounted antennas, placed on a flat roof, may extend up to ten feet above the roof line of the existing structure or up to ten feet (10') above existing equipment structures or penthouses, provided that the antenna is set back from the edge(s) of the roof a minimum distance equal to or greater than double the height of the antenna from the roof line to the top of the antenna. The Design Review Committee may reduce the requird setback if practical difficulties are demonstrated by the proponent and upon a finding by the Design Review Committee that a reduced setback would preserve the character of the neighborhood.
   B.   Roof-mounted facilities, placed on a pitched roof, may extend a maximum of five feet above the roofline of the existing structure only upon a finding by the Design Review Committee that the proposed facility preserves the character of the neighborhood by meeting the highest standard of stealth design.
   C.   In addition to the above standards, roof mounted facilities shall comply with Section 10-45-5. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-45-8: WALL MOUNTED FACILITIES:

   A.   Wall mounted facilities shall not extend above the roofline of the building.
   B.   Wall mounted facilities shall not extend more than two feet (2') horizontally from the face of the building.
   C.   The total area for all wall mounted facilities on any one facade of a building shall not exceed five percent (5%) of that facade's area.
   D.   In addition to the above standards, wall mounted facilities shall comply with Section 10-45-5. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-45-9: MONOPOLES WITH ANTENNAS:

   A.   Design:
      1.   The height of a monopole with antennas and antenna support structures shall be limited to ten feet (10') above the maximum height for structures stated in Section 10-18-1, for the zone in which it is placed or ten feet (10') above the highest building within three hundred feet (300') of the monopole, whichever is higher.
      2.   The height of a monopole shall be measured from the average finished grade of the site within a fifty-foot (50') radius.
      3.   The width of antennas and antenna mounting structures placed on the top of a monopole shall not exceed the width of the monopole at its highest point.
      4.   In addition to the above standards, monopoles shall comply with Section 10-45-5.
   B.   Siting:
      1.   Monopoles are permitted only in the Commercial Service (CS) and Industrial Park (IP) zones.
      2.   Monopoles shall be set back from property lines adjacent to all public rights-of-way at least two feet (2') for every one foot (1') of pole and antenna height. The Design Review Committee may reduce the required setback in the design review process if practical difficulties are demonstrated by the proponent and upon a finding by the Design Review Committee that a reduced setback would adequately preserve the character of the neighborhood.
      3.   Monopoles shall be set back a minimum of two feet (2') for every one foot (1‘) of pole height from the nearest property line of any property in an adjacent residential zone.
      4.   Any associated mechanical or electrical equipment shall be completely screened from view from public rights-of-way and adjacent properties, with a solid screen and landscaping.
      5.   Antennas mounted to the sides of a monopole may only be allowed in the case of a co-location in accordance with Section 10-45-6. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-45-10: HISTORIC DISTRICT:

Prior to considering a design review permit application for any facility within a Historic District, the application shall be reviewed by the Historic Preservation Committee for a Certificate of Appropriateness. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-45-11: LEGALLY EXISTING NONCONFORMITIES:

Legally existing nonconforming wireless telecommunications facilities, equipment, and antennas are governed by Chapter 10-59. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-45-12: ABANDONMENT:

   A.   The applicant, or the applicant's successor(s) and/or assign(s) shall be responsible for the removal of unused wireless telecommunications facilities within ninety (90) days of abandonment of use. If such facility is not removed by the property owner, then the City may employ all legal measures to remove the facility. See Section 10-60-28 through 10-60-38.
   B.   In the event of co-location on a monopole, if a secondary facility is abandoned the owner of the primary facility shall have thirty (30) days, from the date the owner of the secondary facility files with the FCC the required "Notice to Abandon" its facility, to reduce the height of the monopole to its previous or originally approved height. The City shall receive a copy of the "Notice to Abandon" filed with the FCC. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)

10-45-13: PROHIBITED FACILITIES:

No telecommunication antennas or facilities other than those specifically allowed in this chapter shall be permitted within the City except as otherwise required by applicable state or federal law. (Ord. 2019-04, 10-16-2019)