7.2. - Considerations in reviewing site plans.
The Planning and Zoning Board shall not approve a site plan unless a finding is made that such site plan conforms to all applicable provisions of the land development regulations.
A.
Site Location and Character of Use. The Comprehensive Plan together with the land development regulations, including size and dimension regulations, general provisions, performance standards, and the list of permitted and conditional uses, off-street parking, landscaping, required open spaces, yards and building setbacks shall collectively be the principal guides in determining the suitability of the location of the proposed use.
B.
Appearance of Site and Structures. The appearance of site and structures shall be coordinated for the purpose of creating a pleasing and harmonious overall environment. The choice of building materials, plant materials, lighting and other building and site improvements shall be commensurate with the objectives of the subject use without generating adverse visual impact on surrounding properties or transportation corridors. Architectural style or design is not restricted. Evaluation of the appearance of a project shall be based on the quality of its overall design and relationship to the impacted area considering the following factors:
1.
Harmonious Overall Design. The exterior of buildings and structures including mass, facade and materials shall be in harmony with the site and the general character of the impacted area and shall not be gaudy or garish. Awnings or ornamental features shall be designed in a manner harmonious with the building design and shall be of appropriate scale, shape, and pattern in order to reinforce good design principles. Similarly, awnings or ornamental features shall not use incompatible or extraordinary scale, shapes, color schemes, patterns or other extraordinary features for purposes of attracting attention. The appearance of buildings and structures shall be disapproved under Section 1-7.2(B) in extreme cases only and reasonable doubt shall be resolved in favor of the applicant.
2.
Location and Screening of Mechanical Equipment, Utility Hardware and Waste Storage Areas. Mechanical equipment or other utility hardware other than antennas and stacks on roofs shall be harmonious with the building or they shall be located and/or screened so as not to be visible from any public ways within the impacted area. Similarly, refuse and waste storage areas shall be screened from adjacent properties and public ways by appropriate fences, walls or hedges. In cases where dumpsters must be located in areas highly visible from any public right-of-way, the Town Planning and Zoning Board shall be authorized to require appropriate vegetative or structural screening to shield an unsightly condition.
3.
Commercial and Industrial Activities Conducted in Enclosed Buildings. All businesses, services or manufacturing or processing shall be conducted within completely enclosed buildings. If the Town Council determines that a demonstrated necessity exists for outside storage or display due to the impracticality and unreasonableness of enclosure of such services, storage and display areas, in such case such service, storage and display areas or yards shall be screened by a continuous fence or wall or by landscaping and berm system so as to provide a ninety (90) percent opaque screen with a minimum height of five (5) to eight (8) feet, unless the same is demonstrated by the applicant to the Town Council's satisfaction to be impractical and unreasonable.
4.
Exterior Lighting. Exterior lighting shall be provided and shall be so arranged as to shield or deflect the light from adjoining properties and public streets.
C.
Access, Internal Circulation, Off-Street Parking and Other Traffic Impacts. The Town Building Official and/or designated staff shall advise on matters related to this subsection 1-7.2(C):
1.
Internal Circulation System Design and Access/Egress Considerations. Driveways, curb cuts, and areas for the parking and internal circulation of vehicles shall be located, designed and controlled so as to provide for safe and convenient circulation within the site and safe and convenient access from and onto adjoining streets. The Town Staff shall review such design considerations based on standard traffic engineering principals and practices and such specifications as may be adopted by resolution of the Town Council. Requirements of Article IX of this Chapter [Code] shall be applied for off-street parking. Among factors to be considered shall be need for acceleration and deceleration lanes; the number, location and size of curb cuts and access drives from adjacent streets; the location and design of driveways and access aisles to parking spaces, the arrangement, delineation and marking for parked areas; and the means of access to buildings for fire-fighting apparatus and other emergency vehicles.
2.
Separation of Vehicular and Pedestrian Areas. Parking areas and driveways shall be clearly identified and separated from principal pedestrian routes and recreation areas by curbs, pavement markings, planting areas, fences or similar features designed to promote pedestrian safety.
D.
Traffic Impacts. A traffic impact analysis shall be required for site plan reviews pursuant to standards, procedures and criteria defined herein. The traffic impact analysis is designed to achieve objectives stipulated in the transportation element of the Comprehensive Plan.
1.
Applicability. A transportation impact study shall be required if:
(a)
A proposed development generates more than one thousand (1,000) trips per day. Such development shall maintain a level of service C, daily condition and level of service D for peak hour conditions on collector and arterial street segments as noted below. The trip generation shall be based on the Institute of Transportation Engineers, Trip Generation Manual (1988) unless the applicant can demonstrate that unique development characteristics will result in substantially different rates.
2.
Impact Study Areas. The transportation impact study area shall include all arterial and collector streets within one half (½) mile of the site entrance and/or shall include the nearest arterial roads that will be impacted by the development. For developments which generate between five hundred (500) and one thousand (1,000) trips during the peak hour or over one thousand (1,000) trips during the peak hour, the study area shall be one (1) and three (3) miles respectively. Estimates of peak hour trip generation shall be determined by the applicant's Florida Registered Traffic Engineer and shall be approved by the Town Engineer. Peak hour traffic impact shall be assessed, with and without the development, for all collector and arterial road segments and their respective intersections with other collector and arterial roadways within the designated service area. If additional traffic counts are warranted, they shall be the applicant's responsibility.
3.
Contents. The transportation impact analysis shall contain the following:
(a)
A detailed description of the collector and arterial road network, including existing and proposed roadway widths and right-of-way widths; existing and proposed traffic signals and traffic control devices; existing and proposed ingress and egress locations, including existing or proposed acceleration or deceleration lanes or turning lane improvements.
(b)
A detailed description of the existing and proposed land uses within the impacted study area including stages of construction and anticipated completion dates.
(c)
A detailed description of the existing traffic conditions, including the Average Annual Daily Traffic (AADT) and the highest average peak hour volume for all collector and arterial roads within the study area. The AADT shall be based on a current twenty-four (24) hour traffic count provided by the applicant. The current twenty-four (24) hour traffic count shall be adjusted to compensate for seasonal variations. This adjustment shall be determined by utilizing Florida Department of Transportation (DOT) or traffic counts calculated quarterly at traffic count stations in the Town of Malabar. The methodology and assumptions underlying the annual adjustment shall be clearly stated. The average peak hour traffic volume shall be the highest average peak hour volume for any weekday twenty-four (24) hour period.
(d)
A detailed Service Level C condition analysis of all collector and arterial roadways and intersections within the study area based on procedures outlined in the 1965 Highway Capacity Manual (including the Northwestern Monographs) and in the Transportation Research Circular No. 212, "Interim Material on Highway Capacity," Transportation Research Board, January, 1980.
(e)
A description of all the existing collector and arterial roadways and intersections that are at or below the Service Level C condition (Service Levels C, D, E, or F).
(f)
A detailed analysis of traffic impact of the development, including trip generations (average 24-hour weekday and highest average weekday hour), internal and external trips, trip absorptions and trip distributions over all collector and arterial roads within the study area. The trip generation shall be based on the latest edition of the Institute of Traffic Engineers Trip Generation Manual, unless a qualified traffic engineer demonstrates that unique qualities of the development will result in different rates. All methodology and assumptions must be clearly stated.
(g)
A detailed cumulative transportation impact of the existing traffic conditions including traffic from the development, normal increases in traffic and increases from allocation of road capacity to already approved projects. This analysis must identify projected AADT and peak hour volumes for all the collector and arterial roads and must describe all the roadways and intersections that will be at or below the Service Level C daily condition or Service Level D peak hour condition.
4.
Traffic Study and Traffic Data Inventory and File. The Town Engineer shall keep a file on all traffic studies including the future capacity allocated for each project. In determining the projected demand in subsection 1-7.2(D)(3)(g) above, the impact analysis shall include trips already allocated in previous development approvals. The Town shall provide information when available and where appropriate data already exists in order to prevent duplication of efforts and unnecessary costs.
5.
Improvements to Roadways and/or Traffic Control Devices. Transportation improvements such as intersection improvements; additional turning, acceleration or deceleration lanes; modified land delineations; new or improved traffic control devices; or other such improvements may be required in order to maintain a level of service C daily condition and/or a level of service D peak hour condition. In such case, the applicant for a development permit may be required to fund and/or install the necessary improvements or provide a legal assurance, such as a performance bond or other surety approved by the Town Attorney, prior to the issuance of a building permit. Where the traffic impact does not generate traffic volume that substantiates the total improvement needs, the Town Council shall determine an equitable participation in the required improvement. The participation by the applicant may, at the discretion of the Town Council, consist of a pro-rata dollar share of improvement costs.
E.
Open Space and Landscape. Open space shall be comprised of permeable open surfaces, excluding principal structures and impermeable surfaces. No parking areas shall be included as open area. Active recreation areas may be counted as open area.
1.
Residential Open Space Requirement. All residential development shall preserve a minimum of fifty (50) percent of the upland area as open space. Uplands shall be defined as those areas which are not permanent water bodies or wetlands as defined in Section 1-7.2(G)(2) at the time of application. A maximum of thirty (30) percent of any totally landlocked water body may be credited as open space. At no time shall water bodies comprise more than twenty (20) percent of the total upland open space requirements.
2.
Non-Residential Open Space Requirement. Non-residential development shall provide a minimum of twenty (20) percent open space.
3.
Mixed Use Open Space Requirement. Where residential and non-residential development is permitted pursuant to the Town of Malabar Land Development Regulations, the following pro rata open space requirement shall be enforced.
OS = NRA / TA × .2 TA + RA / TA × .5 TA
OS = Open Space
NRA
= Non-Residential Acreage
RA = Residential Acreage
TA = Total Area
4.
Use of Open Space. Open space and spaces between buildings required by this Chapter [Code] shall be located and improved so as to reasonably serve the purposes for which the requirements are intended. These purposes include provisions of adequate light and air, appropriate separation between buildings and uses, enhancement of privacy, sufficient area for recreation and leisure pursuits (in residential areas) and to facilitate surface water drainage.
5.
Preserve Natural Landscape. The natural landscape of the site shall be preserved as much as possible for purposes of enhancing the general appearance of the site as well as to prevent excessive storm water run-off, erosion, siltation and dust.
F.
Required Screening of Abutting Residential and Non-Residential Uses. In order to maintain stability of residential areas, non-residential development within or abutting residential districts and multiple family development abutting single family residential districts, shall provide a fence or a wall or a combination of a berm and landscaping so as to provide a continuous ninety (90) percent opaque solid screen not less than eight (8) feet in height to form a continuous screen along such abutting property lines. In addition, one tree shall be provided for each thirty-five (35) lineal feet or fraction thereof of such landscape barrier. Notwithstanding, all developments shall comply with the landscape requirements of Article XIV. Where a conflict exists with the standards of this paragraph, the more restrictive requirement shall prevail.
Credit may be given for existing plant material against the requirements of this section. Adjustments may be rendered by the Town Council to the requirements of this paragraph based on demonstrated need by the applicant and recommendations of Town Staff and the Planning and Zoning Board. The site plan applicant and successors in ownership shall maintain the continuous screen in perpetuity.
G.
Flood Prone Land and Wetland Preservation. In order to promote and preserve natural hydrological conditions and to preserve water recharge areas, water supply and water quality, and natural habitats, the following regulations shall be applied to wetland areas.
1.
Flood Prone Land. Construction in flood prone areas shall comply with the Town's flood plain management policies.
2.
Wetland Defined. Wetland areas shall include hydric soils and wetland species identified by the DER pursuant to § 17-4.022, F.A.C. Site specific investigations shall confirm the existence of wetland systems based on on-site soil and vegetative analysis with assistance of appropriate representatives of the State Department of Environmental Regulation, the St. John's River Water Management District, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, and the U. S. Soil Conservation Service.
3.
Wetland Development Restrictions and Interpretations. No development other than approved passive recreation, open space, restricted accessway, bird sanctuary, natural stormwater retention/detention, or natural preserve shall be allowed in a wetland area unless "competent evidence" indicates that:
(a)
Dominant vegetation is no longer comprised of wetland types normally found in the specified soil; and
(b)
The water regime has been permanently altered artificially or naturally in a manner to preclude its associated watershed areas from functioning as wetlands. Applicants for site plan review shall have an opportunity to so demonstrate that any wetland designations within the confines of their property no longer function as wetlands as defined above. The County urban forester, the soil conservationist as well as representatives of the State Department of Environmental Regulation, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the St. John's River Water Management District may be made a part of the site plan review process to assist in identifying and delineating wetlands. The applicant may request that a waiver of the provisions of this section be granted by the Planning and Zoning Board for small isolated marginal wetlands for which the developer shall provide viable compensatory preserve areas which mitigate against a loss of viable wetland systems. The Planning and Zoning Board shall consider the recommendation of the Town Engineer prior to taking action on such a request and shall grant the same only in the case of an overriding public interest. Finally, this section shall not prevent the construction of one single family home on existing lots of record.
The provisions of Article VIII: Surface Water Management are hereby incorporated into this subsection by reference.
H.
Available Potable Water. All future applications for new development shall be required to connect to a central water system except as herein provided.
1.
Exceptions for Limited Scale Development. When connection to a central water system is not feasible, applicants for limited scale development adaptive to service by an interim water system, may be allowed if approved by the County Director of Public Health subject to the following conditions:
a.
Assurance in writing from a central water utility that extension of lines to the development is not part of its master plan for expansion; and,
b.
Agreement by the applicant that the system shall be connected to the central utility system at no cost to the Town when service becomes available. The applicant shall be required to post a performance bond or other surety approved by the Town Council after considering recommendation of the Town Engineer and the Town Attorney. The performance bond shall be for the express purpose of constructing water system improvements required as a condition of subdivision approval.
2.
Intent of Regulating Procedure. The intent of this permitting procedure is: (1) to maintain a comprehensive data base concerning water supply and quality; (2) to discourage unregulated proliferation of private water systems; and (3) to achieve a subsystem design which can be effectively and economically integrated into a central public system certified and regulated by an approved local public service entity at a later point in time and to encourage a compact urban development pattern by managing the location, timing and scale of land development to assure that new development can be efficiently served by public facilities without adversely impacting the City's fiscal capacity; and (4) to discourage all new subdivision of land unless served by a central water utility and to similarly discourage nonresidential development on existing lots of record when such sites are not serviced by a central water utility.
3.
Testing of Private Wells. In addition, the Town may undertake any necessary action to prevent or remedy water supply and water quality problems. To this the Town may request analysis of water quality and supply of all permitted private wells based on evolving problems and issues associated with water resources. The private well owner may be assessed by the Town after due public hearings for needed water quality, supply problems, requisite testing, laboratory analysis, and improvements, deemed necessary and fiscally equitable.
I.
Wastewater Service. All applicants for development shall be required to connect to a public wastewater utility regulated by the Public Service Commission, the Department of Environmental Regulation (DER) and/or the County Environmental Health Department. Where a system for wastewater is unavailable, the applicant shall provide an interim wastewater system approved by the DER and/or the County Environmental Health Department and shall agree in writing that the system will be connected to a public wastewater utility at no cost to the Town when service becomes available.
1.
Intent and Purpose of Regulating Wastewater Disposal Systems. The intent of this provision is: (1) to discourage unregulated proliferation of private package treatment plants; (2) to achieve a subsystem design which can be effectively and economically integrated into a major central public wastewater system at a future point in time which would be certified and regulated by a local public entity; and (3) to encourage a compact urban development pattern by managing the location, timing, and scale of land development to assure that new development can be efficiently served by public facilities without adversely impacting the City's fiscal capacity.
2.
Design Standards and Required Guarantee. The system shall be designed to satisfy performance standards of the Department of Environmental Regulation (DER), other applicable regional, state, or federal standards, or standards which may be hereafter adopted by the Town. The applicant shall be required to post a performance bond or other surety approved by the Town Council after considering recommendations of the Town Engineer and the Town Attorney. The performance bond shall be for the express purpose of constructing waste water system improvements required as a condition of subdivision approval.
3.
Regulating Use of Septic Tanks and Wastewater Disposal Fields. Notwithstanding any other provisions of this Code, when septic tank and waste disposal field is the only means of individual sewage disposal, the County Environmental Health Department shall enforce State law regulating use of septic tanks and wastewater disposal fields.
J.
Soil Erosion, Sedimentation Control, and Estuary Water Resource Protection.
1.
Applicability. In order to prevent both soil erosion and sedimentation, and to protect both ground and surface water resources, a soil erosion and sedimentation control plan shall be required as a part of an application for site plan review whenever a development will involve any clearing, grading, or other form of disturbing land by the movement of earth, provided that any one of the following descriptions applies to said movement:
(a)
Excavation, fill, or any combination thereof will exceed five hundred (500) cubic yards.
(b)
Fill will exceed three (3) feet in vertical depth at its deepest point as measured from the natural ground surface.
(c)
Excavation will exceed four (4) feet in vertical depth at its deepest point as measured from the natural ground surface.
(d)
Excavation, fill or any combination thereof will exceed an area of one thousand (1,000) square feet.
(e)
Plant and/or tree cover is to be removed from an area exceeding one thousand (1,000) square feet on any parcel of land.
(f)
Whenever excavation or fill is proposed within one hundred feet of a stream, stream channel, or body of water, a soil erosion and sedimentation control plan shall be provided.
2.
Definitions. For the purposes of this subsection 1-7.2(J) the following definitions are provided:
(a)
Soil erosion shall mean any removal and/or loss of soil by the action of water, gravity, or wind. Erosion includes both the detachment and transport of soil particles.
(b)
Sedimentation shall mean the settling out of the soil particles which are transported by water or wind. Sedimentation occurs when the velocity of water or wind in which soil particles are suspended is slowed to a sufficient degree and for a sufficient period of time to allow the particles to settle out of suspension or when the degree of slope is lessened to achieve the same result.
(c)
Erodible slope shall mean all slopes with inclines in excess of four (4) percent unless modified by the Town Engineer based on consideration of specific soil conditions.
(d)
Large flat surface area (unpaved) shall mean an area which is flat or whose slope is less than four (4) percent and which consists of more than one thousand (1,000) square feet of exposed soil.
3.
Erosion Water Quality Control Measures. All measures necessary to minimize water quality degradation soil erosion and to control sedimentation in the disturbed land area shall be implemented. The following protection shall be provided for all disturbed areas: minimize velocities of water runoff, maximize protection of disturbed areas from stormwater runoff, and retain sedimentation within the development site as early as possible following disturbances. A list of major problem areas for erosion and sedimentation water control degradation control follows. For each one, the purpose(s) of requiring control is described. Soil erosion and sedimentation control measures for all such areas shall be provided with a view toward achieving the specific purpose listed below for which a control plan is required:
(a)
Erodible slopes: Prevent detachment and transportation of soil particles from slope.
(b)
Streams, streambeds, streambanks, bodies of water, lake shorelines: Prevent detachment and transportation of soil particles.
(c)
Drainageways: Prevent detachment and transportation of soil particles (which would otherwise deposit in streams, bodies of water, or wetlands); promote deposit or sediment loads (traversing these areas) before these reach bodies of water.
(d)
Land adjacent to streams, ponds, lakes, and wetlands: Prevent detachment and transportation of soil particles. The applicant shall not adversely impact aquatic vegetation within the sensitive transition zone located between the upland and the mean high water line (ordinary high water line for non-tidal waters). No such vegetation shall be disturbed without approval of the Town. Any such approval shall be based on a demonstrated necessity which promotes the overall public health, safety and welfare. Furthermore, any such disturbance of aquatic vegetation shall be compensated by revegetation based on a plan approved by the Town as stipulated herein. The applicant shall coordinate plans for development along the riverfront or tidal waters with the Florida Department of Environmental Regulation as well as the U.S. Army Corp of Engineers where tidal waters might be impacted. Where deemed appropriate by the Town, the site plan shall include the planting of native indigenous aquatic plant vegetation to promote stability of the shoreline and to enhance water quality.
(e)
Enclosed drainage structure: Prevent sedimentation in structure, erosion at outfall of system, and deposit of sediment loads within system or beyond it.
(f)
Large flat surface areas (unpaved): Prevent detachment of soil particles and their off-site transportation.
(g)
Impervious surfaces: Prevent the detachment and transportation of soil (in response to an increase in the rate and/or volume of runoff of the site or its concentration caused by impervious surfaces).
(h)
Borrow and stockpile areas: Divert runoff from face of slopes which are exposed in the excavation process; convey runoff in stabilized channels to stable disposal points; leave borrow areas and stockpiles in stable condition. Creation of water bodies by excavation and/or impoundment shall comply with applicable provisions of Article VIII.
(i)
Adjacent properties: Prevent their erosion and/or being deposited with sediment.
K.
Additional Considerations. The Planning and Zoning Board or the Town Council may require additional information be provided by the petitioner for site plan review in order to carry out a review process which is necessary to fulfill the purpose, intent and spirit of this Chapter [Code].
(Ord. No. 91-1, 3-19-91)