Subsection A of this section provides procedures and requirements for tree preservation and tree removal permits related to rezoning, subdivision, site plan approval and/or building permits. Because the Village finds it is in the best interests of the community to preserve and protect all trees from unnecessary or unreasonable damage and destruction, procedures and requirements have also been developed to regulate trees on private property when rezoning, subdivision, site plan approval or building permits are not required. These regulations are presented in subsection B of this section.
A. Rezoning, Subdivision, Site Plan Approval And/Or Building Permit: Every effort shall be made to retain existing trees by integrating them into site and landscape plans for rezoning, subdivisions, planned developments, and proposals for individual lot development. Trees shall not be removed without first obtaining a tree removal permit according to the following procedures and criteria: (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code)
1. Tree Removal Permit Application And Fee:
a. Applications for tree removal permits subject to this subsection may be obtained from the Building Department, and, upon completion, submitted to the Building Commissioner. The Building Commissioner, or appointed designee, shall be responsible for reviewing applications and issuing permits. No building or site development permits shall be issued until such time as there is compliance with the terms and conditions of this chapter, and a tree removal permit has been issued according to procedures set forth in this subsection. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code; Ord. 2017-42, 11-13-2017)
b. The application for a tree removal permit shall be accompanied by the following:
(2) Commonly known address of the lot or property where the tree(s) sought to be removed is located.
(3) A written statement indicating the reasons for removal of the tree(s).
(4) A tree identification plan, according to subsection A2 of this section.
(5) A tree preservation plan, as required under subsection A5 of this section.
(6) Name and address of contractor or other person who is proposed as having responsibility for tree removal.
c. A fee as established by the Village Board of Trustees shall be charged for each tree removal permit to cover the cost of staff review
. A single permit may authorize the removal of more than one tree but shall only apply to a single parcel of land. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code) 2. Tree Identification Plan:
(1) A plan which identifies existing trees shall be submitted to the Building Commissioner as a part of the site plan review or plat approval process for subdivisions, planned developments, and the construction of residential, commercial, manufacturing and institutional buildings on individual lots; and
(2) Where site plan or plat approval is not required by this title or the Village subdivision control ordinance, the tree identification plan shall be submitted with drawings presented to the Building Commissioner for site development and building permits. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code; Ord. 2017-42, 11-13-2017)
b. Plan Requirements: The tree identification plan shall:
(1) Be superimposed on the proposed grading plan and shall identify the location, size, condition and species of all trees on the property and existing trees that are twenty five feet (25') beyond all property lines which have a diameter at breast height (dbh) that is six (6) or more inches;
(2) Identify all trees with a dbh six (6) or more inches in size that are proposed to be removed; and
(3) Identify all groups (2 or more) of trees with an aggregate trunk size of twelve inches (12") in diameter or larger, as measured four and one-half feet (41/2') above grade, which are proposed to be removed.
3. Tree Preservation Requirements:
a. Every effort shall be made to preserve trees with a dbh that is six (6) or more inches, or groups (2 or more) of trees with an aggregate trunk size of twelve inches (12") in diameter or larger, as measured four and one-half feet (41/2') above grade, that are illustrated on the tree identification plan. The Village has the right to require an individual lot owner or developer to modify the proposed development as may be necessary to preserve existing, mature trees that substantially contribute to the aesthetics of the area or provide screening, shade, slope stabilization or wildlife habitat. Development modifications that may be required include, but are not limited to:
(1) Reconfiguring the proposed site plan including building location(s), street network and/or parking layout;
(2) Reducing the intensity of development; or (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code)
(3) Increasing the intensity of development on that portion of a property that does not include trees identified for preservation. Exceptions that may be required from the bulk regulations of the underlying zoning and/or subdivision control ordinances to accommodate the development shall, however, be presented to the Planning and Zoning Commission and Village Board for review and approval at a public hearing. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code; Ord. 2014-48, 10-27-2014)
b. The Building Commissioner, or appointed designee, shall evaluate existing trees and proposed site development and shall, in conjunction with the individual lot owner or developer, determine which trees shall be preserved. All trees identified for preservation shall be preserved and protected according to procedures and requirements set forth in subsection A5 of this section.
c. The Building Commissioner, or appointed designee, shall also determine which trees may be removed and replaced, due to one or more of the following conditions: (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code; Ord. 2017-42, 11-13-2017)
(1) Necessity to remove trees in order to:
(A) Provide for essential grade changes;
(B) Provide for surface water drainage and utility installations;
(C) Reasonably maximize the property development potential while remaining consistent with the goals and objectives of the Village Comprehensive Land Use Plan and this chapter;
(D) Locate proposed building(s), structure(s), required parking, or access drive(s) without causing unreasonable economic hardship; and
(E) Observe reasonable forestry practices regarding the number, species and location of healthy trees the parcel will support.
(2) Necessity to remove trees which:
(A) Pose a safety hazard to pedestrian or vehicular traffic or threaten to cause disruption of public services;
(B) Pose a safety hazard to buildings, both existing and proposed;
(C) Are diseased or weakened by age, storm, fire or other injury; and
(D) Are fast growing, short lived, softwood trees. These include:
(Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code)
4. Required Tree Replacement: Unless otherwise approved by the Building Commissioner, appointed designee, or the Village Board, trees which have been specified for removal for one or more reasons set forth in subsection A3 of this section shall be replaced according to the following: (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code; Ord. 2017-42, 11-13-2017)
a. Replacement trees shall either:
(1) Equal or exceed the size of the tree(s) removed; or
(2) Consist of smaller trees, not less than three inches (3") in caliper, as measured six inches (6") above grade, which, in combination, equal the size of the original tree(s); and
b. In no instance shall more than three (3) 3-inch caliper trees be required to replace any single tree, of any size, that will be removed. The Village finds this necessary to avoid unreasonable crowding of trees on the property that could otherwise occur if trees were replaced according to the formula specified in subsection A4a of this section. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code)
c. Species selected for replacement trees shall be limited to the following, unless written approval from the Building Commissioner, or appointed designee, is obtained: (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code; Ord. 2017-42, 11-13-2017)
1. Excluding silver maple and box elder.
d. Species selection shall be submitted for approval. Each species shall constitute only fifteen percent (15%) of the total site tree replacement requirements.
e. The location, size and species of all required replacement trees shall be depicted on both the final landscape and grading plans. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code)
f. Replacement trees may, at the discretion of the Building Commissioner, appointed designee, Planning and Zoning Commission and/or Village Board, be used for perimeter yard landscaping and screening on the subject property that may otherwise be required by other ordinances of the Village. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code; Ord. 2014-48, 10-27-2014; Ord. 2017-42, 11-13-2017)
5. Tree Preservation Plan:
a. A tree preservation plan, establishing the methods to be used for protecting and preserving trees, shall be submitted once trees have been identified for preservation according to the process and criteria specified in subsections A3 and A4 of this section. This plan shall be submitted simultaneously with other documents prepared for final plan or final plat approval and/or building and site development permits, according to procedures set forth in applicable sections of this title and the Village subdivision control ordinance. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code)
b. The tree preservation plan shall be subject to review and approval by the Building Commissioner, or appointed designee. The plan shall also be approved by the Village Board if it is part of a rezoning or development proposal that is reviewed by the Planning and Zoning Commission and Village Board according to established procedures for site plan review. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code; Ord. 2014-48, 10-27-2014; Ord. 2017-42, 11-13-2017)
c. The preservation plan shall be superimposed on the proposed grading plan and shall show, at a minimum, the following:
(1) Size, species, condition and location of each tree approved for preservation;
(2) Protective fencing at the critical root zone of a tree or trees identified for preservation, or to the edge of disturbance, to protect trees from grading, and from root compaction by construction equipment. If construction is allowed to occur within the critical root zone of one side of a tree proposed for preservation, protective fencing shall be extended beyond the critical root zone of the other side of the tree in order to maximize protection of the root system. The area of the root system protected by protective fencing shall, in no case, be less than the total area of the critical root zone of the tree; (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code)
(3) Trees which are to be preserved, but which could be negatively affected during the construction process. The crowns and roots of all such trees shall, unless otherwise determined by the Building Commissioner, or appointed designee, be pruned by a qualified arborist, according to the tree pruning standards set by ANSI 2100 Code, to: (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code; Ord. 2017-42, 11-13-2017)
(A) Compensate for root loss due to construction; and
(B) Minimize damage to root systems;
(4) Areas where crushed limestone or other materials detrimental to the health of trees would be stored. Placement of these materials within a tree's drip line or at higher elevations where drainage would be routed toward a tree or stand of trees proposed for preservation shall be prohibited; and
(5) Areas proposed for washing concrete trucks. These areas should be designed and located such that wash water is directed into a silt trap and not allowed to be routed toward trees approved for preservation.
d. Approval of a development proposal, final plan or final plat of subdivision shall be withheld until all of the information required by this chapter has been submitted, and the evaluation of existing trees on the subject property has been completed by the Village. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code)
e. The Village shall, at its discretion, have the right to retain a professional tree consultant/forester to review tree preservation plans and to submit a written report to the Building Commissioner. All expenses incurred by the Village for the use of the tree consultant shall be reimbursed by the developer.
a. After completion of the applicable public hearing or public meeting process, the Building Commissioner, or appointed designee, shall, within approximately three (3) weeks of the receipt of all final plans and support documentation set forth in subsections A1 through A5 of this section, either: (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code; Ord. 2017-42, 11-13-2017)
(1) Issue a tree removal permit; or
(2) Provide written documentation to the applicant which fully indicates why the request for a tree removal permit has been denied. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code)
b. Additional time, however, may be required if the tree identification and tree preservation plans are being reviewed and evaluated by the Planning and Zoning Commission and Village Board as part of a rezoning, subdivision, or site plan approval process. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code; Ord. 2014-48, 10-27-2014)
a. Site grading and other development shall not occur until such time as the Building Commissioner, or appointed designee, inspects the site to verify that tree protection measures are in place according to the approved plan. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code; Ord. 2017-42, 11-13-2017)
b. The Village shall have the right to inspect the subject property at any time during the construction process in order to verify that the developer and contractor have protected trees according to the approved tree preservation plan.
c. In the event that a tree identified for preservation is destroyed or damaged during construction, such tree shall be replaced according to criteria set forth in subsection A4 of this section. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code)
8. Development Ordinances: On sites designated for tree protection or tree preservation, the following standard provision will be included in the development ordinance regulating the site:
Should any trees specifically designated to be preserved, maintained and protected on the subject property be removed, destroyed or injured in such a fashion that its death is imminent, the owner or other party in interest of the subject property shall be required to replace the removed, destroyed or injured tree(s) with additional trees of like kind that have the same monetary value as the tree removed, destroyed or injured. The value of the tree removed, destroyed or injured shall be determined by the Trunk Formula Method equation below as published in the Guide for Plant Appraisal as published by the International Society of Arboriculture Council Of Tree and Landscape Appraisers.
V = B x S x C x L, where:
This formula may be updated from time to time by the Building Commissioner based on information from the International Society of Arboriculture.
Replacement trees shall be in addition to any trees required to be planted pursuant to the approved landscape plan. The number and placement of replacement trees shall be approved by Village staff, prior to installation.
(Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code; Ord. 2017-42, 11-13-2017)
B. Unrelated To Rezoning, Subdivision, Site Plan Approval And/Or Building Permits: The Village finds that it is in the best interests of the community to preserve existing trees on private property. Therefore, any live tree with a diameter at breast height (dbh) that is six (6) or more inches in size, or two (2) or more live trees with an aggregate trunk size of twelve inches (12") in diameter or larger, as measured four and one-half feet (41/2') above grade, shall not be removed from: nonresidential planned developments; common areas or landscape easements in residential planned developments that are visible from an adjoining street; residentially zoned properties which are one or more acres in area; or any nonresidential property, regardless of size, without first obtaining a tree removal permit according to the following procedures and criteria: (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996)
1. Tree Removal Permit Application And Fee:
a. Applications for tree removal permits subject to this subsection may be obtained from the Building Department, and, upon completion, submitted to the Building Commissioner. The Building Commissioner, or appointed designee, shall be responsible for reviewing applications and issuing a tree removal permit. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. Ord. 2017-42, 11-13-2017)
b. The application for a tree removal permit shall be accompanied by the following:
(2) Commonly known address of lot or property where the tree(s) sought to be removed is located;
(3) A written statement indicating the reason for removal of the tree(s);
(4) A drawing of the site, drawn to scale, which shows:
(A) The location, size, species and condition of the tree(s) for which a tree removal permit is sought; and
(B) The location, size and species of all required replacement trees;
(5) A written description of other trees on the lot, including size, condition, number and species; and
(6) Name and address of the contractor or other person who is proposed as having responsibility for tree removal. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996)
c. A fee as established by the Village Board of Trustees shall be charged for each tree removal permit to cover the cost of staff review
. A single permit may authorize the removal of more than one tree but shall only apply to a single parcel of land. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. 2012 Code) 2. Justification For Permit:
a. The Building Commissioner, or appointed designee, shall determine which trees may be removed and replaced based on, but not limited to, one of the following reasons: (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. Ord. 2017-42, 11-13-2017)
(2) The tree poses a safety hazard to pedestrian or vehicular traffic or threatens to cause disruption of public services;
(3) The tree poses a safety hazard to buildings, both existing and proposed;
(4) The tree is diseased or weakened by age, storm, fire or other injury;
(5) The tree is a willow, silver maple, or other fast growing, short lived, softwood tree (see subsection A3c(2) of this section);
(6) Removal of the tree is consistent with reasonable forestry practices regarding the number, species and location of healthy trees the parcel will support;
(7) Removal of the tree will avoid or alleviate an economic hardship or hardship of another nature on either the lot or the residence located on the lot. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996)
b. A tree removal permit shall also be required for the removal and transplanting of a tree with a dbh six (6) or more inches to another location. The Building Commissioner, or appointed designee, shall have the authority to deny the application if it is determined that the tree cannot reasonably be expected to survive the transplant procedure unless suitable replacement is provided according to subsection A4 of this section.
3. Required Tree Replacement:
a. Unless otherwise approved by the Building Commissioner, or appointed designee, or the Village Board, trees which have been specified for removal for one or more reasons set forth in subsection B2 of this section, shall be replaced according to subsection A4 of this section.
b. The Village encourages the replacement of trees for which a tree removal permit has been issued, even though the Building Commissioner, or appointed designee, may not require such replacement.
4. Review Period: The Building Commissioner, or appointed designee, shall, within approximately three (3) weeks of the receipt of all plans and support documentation set forth in subsection B1 of this section either: (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996; amd. Ord. 2017-42, 11-13-2017)
a. Issue a tree removal permit; or
b. Provide written documentation to the applicant which fully indicates why the request for a tree removal permit has been denied. (Ord. 96-12, 3-25-1996)