Zoneomics Logo
search icon

Durham City Zoning Code

Article

3 Applications and Permits

3.1.1. Applicability

A. When uncertainty exists, the director of the appropriate department, or designee, as identified below, shall be authorized to make all interpretations concerning the provisions of this Ordinance. In making these interpretations, all provisions shall be:

1. Considered as minimum requirements;

2. Liberally construed in favor of the governing body;

3. Deemed neither to limit nor repeal any powers granted under State statutes; and

4. Require application of the more stringent provisions wherever the provisions of this ordinance appear to impose conflicting provisions that cannot otherwise be reconciled.

B. Interpretation Authority

The Planning Director, or Assistant Director in matters involving a conflict of interest, shall make all interpretations of this Ordinance, but shall not make interpretations regarding the following sections:

1. Sec. 3.8, Sedimentation and Erosion Control, Sec. 12.10, Sedimentation and Erosion Control, and Sec. 15.5, Sedimentation and Erosion Control Enforcement and Penalties, the County Engineer, or designee, shall be authorized to make all interpretations concerning the provisions of these sections.

2. Sec. 8.4, Floodplain and Flood Damage Protection Standards, the Inspections Director, acting as the Floodplain AdministratorClosed, or designee, in consultation with the Planning Director, shall be authorized to make all interpretations related to this section.

3. Paragraph 12.3.1, Street Layout, the Public Works Director or City Transportation Director or designee, as applicable, shall be authorized to make all interpretations concerning the provisions of this section.

4. Sec. 12.8, Stormwater Management, the Public Works Director or County Engineer or designees, as appropriate, shall be authorized to make all interpretations concerning the provisions of this section.

5. All interpretations of matters relating to the North Carolina BuildingClosed Code shall be made by the Inspections Director or designee.

6. The Planning Director may defer interpretations of this Ordinance to appropriate City and/or County officials.

C. Other than official interpretations of this Ordinance issued by the authority indicated in paragraph 3.1.1B, Interpretation Authority, and permit and application approvals, the Planning Department does not issue interlocutory determinations or interpretations.

3.1.2. Application Requirements

A request for interpretation shall be submitted in writing.

3.1.3. Action by Planning Director

A. The Planning Director shall:

1. Review and evaluate the request in light of the text of this UDO, the Official Zoning Map, the Comprehensive PlanClosed and any other relevant information;

2. Consult with the Inspections Director or designee and coordinate with other staff, including the City or County Attorney, as necessary; and

3. Render an opinion.

B. The interpretation shall be provided to the applicant in writing.

3.1.4. Official Record

The Planning Director or designee shall maintain an official record of all interpretations. The record of interpretations shall be available for public inspection during normal business hours.

3.1.5. Constructive Notice

Pursuant to NCGS § 160D-403(b), an applicant seeking an interpretation shall take the steps to provide constructive notice of the interpretation on the subject property as follows:

A. Sign

1. A signClosed visible from each street frontageClosed shall be posted on the property for at least 10 days.

2. The signsClosed shall contain the words “Official Interpretation” in letters at least 6 inches high and shall identify the means to contact a local government staff member for information about the interpretation.

B. Verification

Verification of the posting in compliance with these requirements shall be provided to the staff member responsible for the interpretation.

3.1.6. Appeal

Final action on an official interpretation of this Ordinance by the Planning Director or designee may be appealedClosed in accordance with Sec. 3.15, Appeal of Administrative Decision.

3.2.1. Applicability

The review procedures described below apply to the types of applications listed below, as may be limited by the individual subsections that follow.

A. Comprehensive PlanClosed Amendment

B. Zoning Map Change

C. SubdivisionClosed, including Conservation SubdivisionClosed

D. Site PlanClosed

E. Special UseClosed Permit

F. SignClosed Permit

G. Temporary UseClosed Permit

H. Home OccupationClosed Permit

I. VarianceClosed

J. AppealClosed of Administrative Decision

K. Historic District/Landmark Designation

L. Certificate of Appropriateness

M. UDO Text Amendment

N. Vested RightsClosed Determination

O. Floodplain Development PermitClosed

P. Architectural Review

Q. Reasonable Accommodation

R. Street Closing/Withdrawal

S. Street Renaming

T. Annexation

U. Statutory DevelopmentClosed Agreement

3.2.2. Pre-Application Conference

A. Before submitting an application for developmentClosed approval that does not require a pre-submittal conference, it is recommended that a pre-application conference be scheduled with the Planning Director or designee to discuss the procedures, standards and regulations required for developmentClosed approval in accordance with of this Ordinance.

B. A mandatory pre-application conference with the Planning Director or designee shall be required for the following developmentClosed reviews:

1. Comprehensive PlanClosed amendments (text or map) not initiated by the City or County;

2. Zoning map changes and UDO text amendments, including petitions to initiate a neighborhood protection overlay, not initiated by the City or County;

3. Site planClosed or preliminary platClosed applications for property zoned or in the process to be zoned:

a. Design District; or

b. With a development planClosed.

4. Conservation subdivisionClosed (after preparation of site analysis map);

5. Minor or major special use permit;

6. VarianceClosed;

7. Reasonable accommodation;

8. Landmark designation;

9. Major works certificate of appropriateness;

10. Annexation

11. Street Closing

12. Street Renaming; and

13. Statutory DevelopmentClosed Agreement

C. A mandatory pre-application conference with the City Transportation Director or designee shall be required for the following developmentClosed reviews:

1. Traffic impact analysis; and

2. Transportation special use permit.

D. Validity Time-Period

If an application is not submitted within six months of the date of the pre-application conference, a new pre-application conference is required.

3.2.3. Neighborhood Meeting

A. At least one neighborhood meeting shall be held according to the Planning Department procedures for any application indicated as requiring a neighborhood meeting as specified per this Ordinance.

B. The purpose of the neighborhood meeting shall be to begin engagement with the neighborhood about the nature of the proposed land use and developmentClosed features, explain the site planClosed if any, solicit comments, and establish an engagement plan with the neighborhood to be undertakenClosed throughout the application submittal and review process. This requirement shall not mean that all residents and stakeholders are required to attend such a meeting.

C. Mailed Notice

The applicant shall provide notice to each ownerClosed of record of any land located within 600 feet of the subject property by first class mail at least 10 days prior to the date of the neighborhood meeting.

Commentary:  It is also recommended that the same notice, either by email or first class mail, be provided to any applicable neighborhood organization, homeowners’ association, or similar neighborhood community organization.

D. The neighborhood meeting notice shall include at a minimum the following:

1. The applicant’s name and telephone number;

2. The street address of the site with an identification map;

3. A clear explanation of what the applicant is proposing; and

4. The date, time, and location of the meeting.

E. The Planning Director or designee may developClosed administrative regulations setting forth guidelines pertaining to any additional requirements for the conduct of the meeting. Such guidelines shall be subject to review by the Joint City-County Planning Committee.

3.2.4. Application Requirements

The following requirements shall apply to all applications for developmentClosed approval identified in paragraph 3.2.1, Applicability.

A. Forms

Applications required under this Ordinance shall be submitted on forms and in such numbers as required by the appropriate department. All forms shall include, at a minimum, the following information:

1. Contact information for the individual or firm submitting the application.

2. Contact information for the individual or firm on whose behalf the application is being submitted.

3. Identification of the property affected by the application, such as a legal description, address, or REID as may be appropriate.

4. Any other information required by the director of the appropriate department, or designee, or the provisions of this Ordinance.

B. Fees

1. All applications and associated fees shall be filed with the appropriate department.

2. Filing fees shall be established from time to time to defray the actual cost of processing the application.

3. An applicant who has paid the appropriate fee pursuant to the submission of an application, but who chooses to withdraw such application prior to its distribution for review shall be entitled to a refund of the total amount paid, less ten percent for administrative costs, upon written request to the appropriate department. Once review has begun, no refund shall be available, except that unused notice surcharges shall be refunded less ten percent for administrative purposes. No refund of technology surcharges shall be provided.

C. Applications Sufficient for Processing

1. Applications shall include all required fees, and contain all required information as described on forms available from each department involved in the review process, unless modified by the department, in writing, pursuant to 2, below. Incomplete applications may be reviewed in extraordinary circumstance.

2. The presumption shall be that all of the information required in the application forms is necessary to satisfy the requirements of this section. However, it shall be recognized that each application is unique, and therefore more or less information may be required according to the needs of the particular case. The applicant may rely on the recommendations of the appropriate department as to whether more or less information should be submitted.

3. Once the application has been determined sufficient for processing, copies of the application shall be referred by the appropriate department to the appropriate reviewing entities.

4. The director of the appropriate department, or designee, may require an applicant to present evidence of the authority to submit an application.

5. An application shall be considered to have been accepted for review only after it has been determined to be complete as provided above, not upon submission to the appropriate department.

D. Application Deadline

Applications sufficient for processing shall be submitted to the director of the appropriate department, or designee, in accordance with the established schedule. Schedules indicating submittal dates shall be developedClosed each year and made available to the public.

E. Staff Consultation after Application Submitted

1. Upon receipt of an application sufficient for processing, the director of the appropriate department, or designee, shall review the application and confer with the applicant to ensure an understanding of the applicable requirements of this Ordinance; that the applicant has submitted all of the information they intend to submit; and that the application represents precisely and completely what the applicant proposes to do.

2. Once the applicant indicates that the application is as complete as the applicant intends to make it, the application shall be placed before the appropriate approving authority in accordance with standard procedures. However, if the director of the appropriate department, or designee, believes the application is incomplete, a recommendation to deny the application on that basis shall be provided to the appropriate approving authority.

F. Related Applications

1. Related applications necessary for developmentClosed approvals may be filed and reviewed simultaneously, at the option of the applicant. Any application that also requires a varianceClosed, special use permit, or certificate of appropriateness shall not be eligible for final approval until the varianceClosed, special use permit, or certificate of appropriateness has been granted.

2. Related applications submitted simultaneously are subject to approval of all other related applications; denial or disapproval of any concurrently submitted application shall stop consideration of any related applications until the denied or disapproved application is resolved.

G. Active Application Time Period

1. Requests for additional information, corrections, or other modifications for all applications, unless otherwise indicated in this Ordinance, shall be returned to the Planning Director or designee within six months from the date comments on the application are officially issued. Failure to meet this deadline shall result in the application being considered withdrawn and voided, thus requiring a new application, including all requirements associated with a new application.

2. Requests for additional information, corrections, or other modifications for applications submitted to address a notice of violationClosed shall be returned to the Planning Director or designee within 30 days from the date comments on the application are officially issued. Failure to meet this deadline shall result in the application being considered withdrawn and voided, thus requiring a new application, including all requirements associated with a new application.

3.2.5. Notice and Public Hearings

A. Summary of Notice Required

1. Notice shall be required for applications for developmentClosed approval as shown in the table below.

Procedure

Published

Mailed

Posted

Comprehensive PlanClosed Amendment

Zoning Map Change, including an initial zoning map changeClosed

Site PlanClosed

 

 

Minor Special UseClosed Permit

 

Major or Transportation Special UseClosed Permit

 

VarianceClosed

 

AppealClosed of Administrative Decision

 

Major Works Certificate of Appropriateness

 

Historic District Designation

Historic Landmark Designation

 

Historic Properties Local Review Criteria Text Amendment

 

 

Historic District Preservation Plan Text Amendment

UDO or Comprehensive PlanClosed Text Amendment

 

 

Vested RightsClosed Determination

Rectification Report

 

 

Reasonable Accommodation

 

Street Closing

Street Renaming

Annexation

 

 

Statutory DevelopmentClosed Agreement

 

2. Exceptions to the table above are as follows:

a. Mailed noticeClosed for site plansClosed shall be required only for major site plansClosed pursuant to paragraph 3.7.3B, Major Site PlansClosed.

b. Posting and mailing for Comprehensive PlanClosed amendments shall be required only for amendments that change a Tier designation or Place Type Map designation without an associated zoning map change.

c. For AppealClosed of Administrative Decision, posting is not required when the appealClosed is not site specific.

B. Public Notice Requirements

1. Published Notice

An advertisement shall be placed by the Planning Department in a local newspaper of general circulation once a week for two successive calendar weeks, the first notice being published not less than ten days nor more than 25 days before the date fixed for the public hearing.

2. Mailed Notice
a. Mailed Notice Table

The director of the appropriate department or designee shall provide notification as indicated in the notification table below:

ProcedureMailing Range
Subject Property, if applicableDistance of Property from Subject Property2 (ft.)

Comprehensive PlanClosed Place Type Map or Tier Map Amendment

1,000

Zoning Map Change, including an Initial Zoning Map ChangeClosed

1,000

Site PlansClosed1

600

Board of Adjustment

600

Governing Body Quasi-Judicial Hearings

1,000

Historic District Designation; Neighborhood Protection Overlay

100

Historic Landmark Designation and Certificate of Appropriateness (Major Works)

All adjacentClosed properties3

Historic District Preservation Plan Text Amendment

All adjacentClosed properties3

Vested RightsClosed Determination

All adjacentClosed properties3

Annexation

600

Street Closing

 

All adjacentClosed properties4

Street Renaming

 

All adjacentClosed properties

Statutory DevelopmentClosed Agreement

1,000

1 Mailed NoticeClosed shall be required only for major site plansClosed pursuant to paragraph 3.7.3B, Major Site PlansClosed.

2 When the extent of the bufferClosed falls within the right‐of‐way, the property adjacentClosed to the opposing side of the right‐of‐way shall be

included for notification.

3 Properties are “adjacentClosed” even if separated by a street, railroad, or other transportation corridor.

4 Mailed noticesClosed shall comply with the standards set forth in the North Carolina General Statutes (NCGS).

b. Mailed Notices

(1) All mailed notifications shall be performed through first class mail utilizing the County property tax listings for property ownership.

(2) Where the tax records reflect a different mailing address for an ownerClosed of the property and the actual property address, then notification shall also be mailed to the address of the property itself in addition to the property ownerClosed address, unless the property is vacant.

(3) If accurate individual mailing addresses of the residents of multifamilyClosed properties are not readily available, then the property shall be posted with a resident notice signClosed in the right‐of‐way immediately adjacentClosed to the multifamilyClosed property. The resident notice signClosed shall be posted in accordance with paragraph 3.2.5B.3.

(4) The notice shall be mailed at least 14 but not more than 25 days prior the date of the public hearing.

(5) Mailed noticeClosed under this section shall not be required if a zoning map change directly affects more than 500 properties owned by a total of at least 500 different property ownersClosed, and the Planning Director or designee elects to use the following expanded published notice requirements:

(6) An advertisement of not less than one-half page may be placed in a local newspaper of general circulation once a week for two successive calendar weeks, the first notice being published not less than 10 days nor more than 25 days before the date fixed for the public hearing.

(7) In addition to the published notice, the Planning Director or designee shall post one or more signsClosed on or immediately adjacentClosed to the subject area reasonably calculated to give public notice of the proposed change in accordance with paragraph 4.c., Posted Notice, below rather than the notice required pursuant to subsection 3, Posted Notice (SignClosed), below.

(8) Mailed noticeClosed shall be provided by first class mail to property ownersClosed who reside outside of the newspaper’s circulation area.

3. Posted Notice (Sign)

A signClosed noticing the public hearing shall be prominently posted by the director of the appropriate department, or designee, not less than 14 days prior to the public hearing at which the application shall be reviewed. The signClosed shall be posted on the property or at a point visible from the nearest improved street. Where a site fronts along multiple improved public streets, one signClosed is required for each street frontageClosed, unless such street frontageClosed has limited access and poses unsafe conditions for posting such as, but not limited to, freewaysClosed and expresswaysClosed. In the case of multiple parcelsClosed, sufficient signsClosed shall be posted to provide reasonable notice to interested personsClosed.

4. Content of Notice
a. Published or Mailed Notice

Except for applications in paragraph b below a published or mailed noticeClosed shall provide at least the following:

(1) A general description or address of the location of the land that is the subject of the application and, for mailed noticeClosed, a location map;

(2) A description of the action requested;

(3) Where a zoning map change or a Comprehensive PlanClosed Future Land UseClosed Map amendment is proposed, the current and proposed designations;

(4) The time, date and location of the public hearing;

(5) A phone number to contact the Planning Director or designee;

(6) A statement that interested parties may appear at the public hearing; and

(7) A statement that substantial changesClosed to the proposed action may be made following the public hearing.

b. b. Published Notice for UDO, Comprehensive Plan, Historic District Preservation Plan, or Historic Properties Local Review Criteria Text Amendments

A published notice shall include the following specific information:

(1) A summary description of the proposed change;

(2) The time, date and location of the public hearing;

(3) A phone number to contact the Planning Director or designee;

(4) A statement that interested parties may appear at the public hearing; and

(5) A statement that substantial changesClosed to the proposed action may be made following the public hearing.

c. Posted Notice

Required posted notices shall indicate the following:

(1) A case number;

(2) Type of action; and

(3) A phone number to contact the Planning Director, or designee.

C. Minor Defects in Notice

Minor defects in notice shall not impair the notice or invalidate proceedings pursuant to the notice if a bona fide attempt has been made to comply with applicable notice requirements. For instances where notice was not executed per the Durham Unified DevelopmentClosed Ordinance but meets the requirement set forth in the North Carolina General Statutes, notice will be deemed legally sufficient.

D. Public Notification Service

Any organization or individual may register with the Planning Department to receive, at a minimum, a monthly electronic notification.

1. The notification shall contain the scheduled public hearings for the procedures listed in paragraph 3.2.5A, Summary of Notice Required, and major site plansClosed.

2. To be eligible for registration, the applicant must provide the notification information required by the Planning Department.

3. Each organization or individual is responsible for providing updated information to the Planning Department in order to continue receiving notice.

4. The information provided shall be consistent with paragraph 3.2.5B.4, Content of Notice, as applicable for the specific application.

E. Required Hearing

1. A legislative public hearing or a quasi-judicial hearing shall be required for developmentClosed review as shown in the table below.

Applications for Approval

Historic Preservation Commission

Board of Adjustment

Planning Commission

Governing Body

Transportation Special UseClosed Permit

 

 

 

1

Comprehensive PlanClosed Adoption/Amendment

 

 

Zoning Map Change

 

 

Minor UseClosed Permit

 

1

 

 

Major Special UseClosed Permit

 

 

 

1

VarianceClosed

 

1

 

 

AppealClosed of Administrative Decision

 

1

 

 

Historic District Designation

 

Historic Landmark Designation

 

 

Certificate of Appropriateness (Major Works)

1

 

 

 

UDO Text Amendment

 

 

Historic District Preservation Plan Text Amendment

 

2

Historic Preservation Local Review Criteria Text Amendment

 

 

Site-Specific Vested RightsClosed Determination

 

 

 

Reasonable Accommodation

 

1

 

 

Annexation

 

 

 

Street Closing

 

 

 

Street Renaming

 

 

 

Statutory DevelopmentClosed Agreement

 

 

3

1 Requires a quasi-judicial hearing.

2 Required only if associated with adding or removing a local historic district designation.

3 Only if associated with a zoning map change or modifies an Ordinance standard, per Sec. 3.26, Statutory Development Agreement.

 

2. The day of the public hearing shall be considered the day the hearing is originally advertised for, unless a deferral is granted by the governing body upon a request that follows the procedures set forth in this Ordinance regarding timely submission of requests for deferrals.

3.2.6. Pending Jurisdiction

After a request for annexation into the city has been submitted and accepted as complete, an application per paragraph 3.2.1, Applicability, may be received and reviewed under the receiving jurisdictional regulations pursuant to NCGS § 160D-204. No final action shall be made until the change in jurisdiction is official.

3.3.1. Applicability

Unless exempted below, a traffic impact analysis (TIA) shall be required for changes of use to determine if roadway improvements will be required, zoning map changes utilizing a development planClosed, site plansClosed, and preliminary platsClosed that can be anticipated to generate at least 150 vehicleClosed trips at the peak hour (as determined by Institute of Transportation Engineers Standards). Trips generated by separate developmentsClosed meeting the criteria of paragraph 3.3.3, TIA Submission for Projects with Cumulative Impacts, shall be considered cumulatively.

3.3.2. Exemptions

The following projects shall not be required to submit a TIA:

A. Projects located within the Downtown Tier.

B. DevelopmentsClosed that submitted a TIA in conjunction with a zoning map change or previously approved site planClosed, special use permit, or other plan, where the TIA remains valid, consistent with the provisions of paragraph 3.3.6, Period of Validity.

C. Redevelopment of any site on which the increase in traffic at peak hour represents an increase of less than 150 trips from the previous developmentClosed, if the redevelopment is initiated within 12 months of the cessation of use of the previous developmentClosed so long as no access roadClosed that leads directly to the site is operating at a level of serviceClosed worse than the jurisdiction’s adopted level of serviceClosed.

3.3.3. TIA Submission for Projects with Cumulative Impacts

A. Unified, Phased, or Otherwise Aggregated Developments

An applicant shall be required to submit a TIA, or obtain a transportation special use permit (TSUP) pursuant to Sec. 3.9, Special Use Permit, for a development planClosed, site planClosed, preliminary platClosed, special use permit, or other similar plan that does not otherwise meet the thresholds for submission of a TIA or for obtaining a TSUP if the developmentClosed approval is for a project that:

1. Shares features such as site access or other roadways, design elements, or other infrastructure with nearby unbuilt, but pending developmentsClosed evidenced by valid, approved site plansClosed or preliminary platsClosed, or active site planClosed or preliminary platClosed submittals; and,

2. When complete, will function in conjunction with such nearby developmentsClosed as a single project, the impact on the infrastructure of which would exceed the thresholds for preparation of a TIA.

B. Determination

The City Transportation Director, or designee shall determine whether a developmentClosed application meets the criteria in paragraph A, above, and shall determine whether one TIA shall be required for all of the aggregated developmentClosed, or whether multiple TIAs may be employed for separate phases of the developmentClosed.

3.3.4. Pre-Application Conference

The applicant shall schedule a pre-application meeting with the City Transportation Director or designee to discuss procedures, standards, and regulations required for TIA submittal and approval.

3.3.5. Requirements

A. Content

The City Transportation Director or designee shall set forth specific guidelines for preparation of TIAs. A TIA shall, at a minimum, provide the following information:

1. An estimate of the traffic generated as a result of the proposed developmentClosed;

2. An analysis of the existing street system serving the proposed developmentClosed; and

3. An assessment of the improvements needed to the existing street system in order to support the traffic anticipated to be generated by the proposed developmentClosed.

B. Preparer

A TIA shall be prepared by a registered professional engineer with experience in traffic engineering.

C. Sources of Data

Estimates of vehicleClosed trips shall be calculated based on trip generation rates from the most recent edition of the Trip Generation Manual published by the Institute of Transportation Engineers, unless an alternative source of information is approved by the City Transportation Director or the NCDOT.

3.3.7. Coordination with Zoning Map Changes, Site Plans, and Preliminary Plats

Transportation mitigation measures may be required to address issues raised by a TIA, or as part of the approval of a Transportation Special UseClosed Permit (TSUP.) Such measures may include, but not be limited to, onsite and offsite improvements related to reduction of traffic impact on the surrounding roadClosed system, bicycle facilities, pedestrian movement, and the environment. These measures shall be conditions of developmentClosed approval. Deletion or modification of these conditions shall require the same approval process that was required for the original project, unless the approved mitigation measure is deemed to conflict with NCDOT or City Transportation Department requirements, in which case they shall be modified to resolve the conflicts through submittal of a revised site planClosed or preliminary platClosed, as applicable.

3.3.8. Coordination with a Transportation Special Use Permit (TSUP)

Projects that require a TIA may also require a TSUP pursuant to Sec. 3.9, Special Use Permit.

3.4.2. Coordination with Applications for Zoning Map Change or Annexation

A. Place Type Map

No separate application shall be required to amend a Place Type map designation that is inconsistent with a zoning map change request. In accordance with State statute, if the zoning map change is approved, the Place Type map shall be considered amended to the applicable place type designation. A recommendation on the land use designation shall be provided by the Planning Director or designee.

B. Tier Boundary Map

When a zoning map change request requires an amendment to a Tier boundary, an application for amending the Tier shall be submitted concurrently with the zoning map change application. The public hearings for both applications may be heard at the same time; however, decisions shall be rendered with separate motions.

C. Urban Growth Boundary Map

No separate application shall be required to amend the Urban Growth Boundary location that is inconsistent with a zoning map change request. In accordance with State statute, if the annexation is approved, the Urban Growth Boundary map shall be considered amended to the applicable location. A recommendation on the new location of the Urban Growth Boundary shall be provided by the Planning Director or designee. Requested changes to the Urban Growth Boundary not associated with a Zoning Map Change request shall submit an application in accordance with paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirementss.

D. Future Growth Area Map

No separate application shall be required to amend a Future Growth Area adopted in the Comprehensive PlanClosed. If the zoning map change is approved and the infrastructure for future growth as adopted in the Comprehensive PlanClosed have been met, then all or a portion of the Future Growth Area designation shall be modified as recommended by the Planning Director or designee. Requested changes to a Future Growth Area not associated with a Zoning Map Change request shall submit an application in accordance with paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirements.

3.4.3. Pre-Application Conference

Applicants applying for a plan amendment shall schedule a pre-application conference with the Planning Director or designee in accordance with paragraph 3.2.2, Pre-Application Conference.

3.4.4. Neighborhood Meeting

All applicants applying for a plan amendment shall hold a neighborhood meeting in accordance with paragraph 3.2.3, Neighborhood Meeting, except for the following:

A. Changes made pursuant to paragraph 3.4.10, Evaluation and Assessment Report; or

B. Amendments that are solely text amendments not specific to a particular site.

3.4.5. Application Requirements

An application for a plan amendment shall be submitted in accordance with paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirements.

3.4.6. Action by the Planning Commission

A. Before making any recommendation on a plan amendment, the Planning Commission shall consider any recommendations from the Planning Director or designee, and shall conduct a public hearing.

B. Notice and public hearing requirements shall be in accordance with paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings.

C. It is expected that the applicant or a representative of the applicant will appear at the meetings to explain why the Comprehensive PlanClosed should be changed.

D. Following the public hearing, the Planning Commission shall make a recommendation on the application to the governing body.

E. The Planning Commission shall make its recommendation within three consecutive regular Commission cycles (approximately 90 days total) of its initial public hearing on the amendment.

3.4.7. Criteria for Place Type Map Change Recommendations

The recommendations of the staff and Planning Commission to the governing body shall show that the following criteria were considered regarding a proposed change to the Place Type Map of the Durham Comprehensive PlanClosed:

A. Adequate public utilitiesClosed, emergency services, transportation services, and public schools are available to accommodate the request, and,

B. Durham’s ability to achieve the goals of the Comprehensive PlanClosed will be increased,

C. And, either:

1. Significant changes have occurred since the adoption of the Comprehensive PlanClosed and necessitate the proposed amendment; Or,

2. Inconsistencies in land use or other plan policies exist in the adopted Comprehensive PlanClosed that affect Durham’s orderly growth and developmentClosed.

D. In addition, Decisions on Place Type Map amendments shall include these additional considerations: For changes to a Place Type designation that changes the intensity of developmentClosed envisioned for an area, whether the proposal has demonstrated benefits to affordable housing production, environmental goals, and approaches to equitable engagement and outcomes.

3.4.8. Additional Criteria for Modification of Tier Boundary

Where a plan amendment involves modification of the Tiers established in the Comprehensive PlanClosed, the following criteria shall be considered.

A. The site is contiguous to the proposed Tier;

B. The site is not in the drainage basin for Lake Michie or Little River or in the one-mile critical area around Jordan or Falls Reservoirs;

C. The extension does not violateClosed any agreements with neighboring jurisdictions; and

D. If the proposal is to expand the Suburban Tier, extending utilities to serve the site is determined to be technically feasible by the Public Works Director or designee and will not result in inordinate cost to the City.

3.4.9. Additional Criteria for Modification of the Urban Growth Boundary

A. Where a plan amendment involves modification of the Urban growth Boundary established in the Comprehensive PlanClosed, all the following criteria shall be considered:

1. The change does not expand the UGB further into a Critical WatershedClosed;

2. The change does not significantly increase long-term infrastructure maintenance costs for the City or County; and

3. The change would address a clear need for the community based on the adopted Comprehensive PlanClosed policies.

B. Notwithstanding the above criteria, the Governing Body shall consider whether those parcelsClosed were previously included in the 2005 Comprehensive PlanClosed’s Suburban DevelopmentClosed Tier.

 

3.4.10. Action by the Governing Body

A. Before taking action on a plan amendment, the governing body shall consider the recommendations of the Planning Commission and Planning Director, and shall conduct a public hearing.

B. Notice and public hearing requirements shall be in accordance with paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings.

C. It is expected that the applicant or a representative of the applicant will appear at the meetings to explain why the plan should be changed.

D. Following the public hearing, the governing body may approve the amendment, deny the amendment, or send the amendment back to the Planning Commission for additional consideration.

E. An approval shall be by written resolution. The approval may be contingent upon conditions specified by the governing body. The effective date may be immediate or may be a date otherwise specified in the approval.

3.4.11. Evaluation and Assessment Report

A. Every two years, the Planning staff will prepare an evaluation and assessment report for review and approval by the governing bodies. The report will include a rectification of any differences between the adopted Place Type Map of the City and County.

B. The governing bodies shall hold public hearings for the approval of the report. Notification of the public hearings shall be pursuant to paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings.

3.4.12. Amendments to the Text of the Comprehensive Plan

A. Submittal

Applications submitted by a private individual or entity shall first be considered for appropriateness and priority by the Joint City-County Planning Committee (JCCPC) on an annual basis.

1. Staff shall provide the JCCPC with a preliminary analysis for each application;

2. Staff shall set annual deadlines for application submittals.

3. Fees shall be paid upon application submittal. Notification fees can be refunded upon request of the applicant if the applicant withdraws the application within two weeks from the date the JCCPC has provided final comment on the application.

B. Review Criteria

The following criteria, as applicable, shall be addressed by the applicant:

1. The proposed amendment corrects an error or meets the challenge of some changing condition, trend or fact;

2. The proposed amendment is in response to changes in state law;

3. The proposed amendment constitutes a substantial benefit to Durham as a whole and is not solely for the good or benefit of a particular landowner or ownersClosed at a particular point in time;

4. The proposed amendment is consistent with other identified Plan policies and adopted area plans; and

5. The impact of the proposed amendment with regard to:

a. Established property or proposed developmentClosed in the vicinity of the proposed amendment;

b. Existing or future land use patterns;

c. Existing or planned public services and facilities;

d. Existing or planned roadways;

e. The natural environment, including air, water, noise, stormwaterClosed management, wildlife and vegetation; and

f. Other policies of the Comprehensive PlanClosed.

3.5.1. Description

A. Purpose

The purpose of a zoning map is to amend the zoning district boundaries of the Official Zoning Map.

B. Initiation

A zoning map change may be initiated by the governing body, the Planning Commission, the Board of Adjustment, the Planning Director or designee, a citizen or the property ownerClosed or their agent, except as follows:

1. A petition for a zoning map change with a development planClosed may only be initiated by the property ownerClosed or their agent.

2. A petition for a zoning map change that is considered a “down-zoning,” as defined per NCGS §160D-601(d), as applicable, shall only be initiated by the applicable governing body, unless written consent is provided by all ownersClosed of property subject to the zoning request.

C. Development Plans

The development planClosed shall become a part of the zoning map change petition and shall be reviewed concurrently with the zoning map change petition. Subsequent site plansClosed or platsClosed shall not deviate from the plan, unless otherwise allowed, or required under this Ordinance. Deviation may require a zoning map change, as established in paragraph 3.5.12, Deviations from Approved Development Plans. Unless a development planClosed also functions as a site planClosed, it is not a site specific vesting plan pursuant to Sec. 3.20, Vested Rights. The right to developClosed pursuant to a development planClosed, whether approved under this Ordinance or any previous ordinance, accrues only for any portion of the plan for which a site planClosed or preliminary platClosed is approved, and then only for the period of validity specified in this Ordinance, or where a vested rightClosed is established pursuant to Sec. 3.20, Vested Rights.

D. Optional and Mandatory Development Plans

The development planClosed may be used by the petitioner in any zoning district; however, the development planClosed shall be required as follows:

1. Rezoning to the PDR, CC, MU, and IP districts;

2. Additions to the UC District after the initial zoning map changeClosed establishing the District on each campus; and

3. As otherwise required in this Ordinance.

E. Traffic Impact Analysis

A traffic impact analysis may be required if the proposed zoning map change meets the threshold requirements established in Sec. 3.3, Traffic Impact Analysis.

3.5.2. Pre-Application Conference

Pursuant to paragraph 3.2.2, Pre-Application Conference, a pre-application conference is required prior to the submittal of a zoning map change application.

3.5.3. Neighborhood Meeting

An applicant petitioning for a zoning map change, including an initial zoning due to annexation, shall hold neighborhood meeting(s) as set forth in paragraph 3.2.3, Neighborhood Meeting.

3.5.4. Consistency with the Comprehensive Plan

A. Consistency with the Comprehensive PlanClosed shall be considered with all petitions for a zoning map change.

B. If a zoning map change request is approved, but determined inconsistent with the Place Type Map of the Comprehensive PlanClosed, the Place Type Map shall be considered amended to the applicable land use designation. A recommendation on the land use designation shall be provided by the Planning Director or designee.

C. When a zoning map change request requires an amendment to a Tier boundary, an application for amending the Tier boundary shall be submitted concurrently with the zoning map change application. The public hearings for both applications may be heard at the same time; however, decisions shall be rendered with separate motions.

3.5.5. Application Requirements

A. An application for zoning map change shall be submitted in accordance with paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirements.

B. Zoning map changes should correspond with the boundary lines of existing plattedClosed lots or tractsClosed. If the boundaries of a zoning map change request stop short of an exterior property line, that portion of the property outside the proposed zoning map change boundary shall be capable of being subdivided and developedClosed in accordance with the existing zoning and other requirements of this Ordinance.

C. All zoning requirements shall be met within the boundaries of the area being proposed for change, unless the area being changed is utilizing a development planClosed and is an addition to an existing area zoned with a development planClosed. If all of the requirements cannot be met on the site being changed, the zoning map change shall be expanded to include necessary property being used to meet zoning requirements. Projects utilizing a development planClosed may be expanded without meeting this criterion if, considering the original development planClosed area, the requirement can be met without violatingClosed any committed elementsClosed. Projects utilizing this provision shall provide graphics and/or a chart demonstrating how the requirements are met.

D. (County Only) If the boundaries of a zoning map change request in process are modified so as to 1) remove property from the request, and 2) have the effect of separating other adjoining properties from the boundaries of the modified request, that change shall be considered a substantial changeClosed from the original request and shall result in the modified request being considered a new zoning map change request and requiring resubmittal with a new application and applicable fees.

3.5.6. Development Plan

A. Purpose

A development planClosed provides additional information with a zoning map change petition and establishes the level of developmentClosed that will be allowed on the property. A development planClosed is also intended to identify proffered commitmentsClosed that are greater than Ordinance requirements.

B. Designation/Effect

When a proposed zoning map change includes a development planClosed, the letter “D” shall follow the proposed zoning district designation. If approved, the letter “D” shall remain as a part of the zoning designation of the property. The proffered elements submitted as part of the development planClosed, called "commitmentsClosed" must be enforced by staff. Approved commitmentsClosed are binding on the property and establish the level of permitted developmentClosed. "CommitmentsClosed" may also be referred to as "committed elementsClosed" throughout this Ordinance.

Commentary: The Planning Department will require a mechanism to ensure compliance with commitmentsClosed. Depending upon the nature of the commitment, a written compliance document may be required.

C. Authority of Planning Director

The Planning Director is authorized to:

1. Delegate authority under this section to a designee;

2. Determine whether modification of an unapproved development planClosed or deviation from an approved development planClosed is significant/substantial or minor, or more or less stringent, if not specified in this section;

3. Determine whether a conflict exists between commitmentsClosed. Any conflict between commitmentsClosed, including design commitmentsClosed, shall be resolved in favor of the most stringent;

4. Determine whether an element is a commitment if it is not specified as such in this section; and

5. Determine whether additional staff review time is necessary following addition of commitmentsClosed at hearings through proffers or illustrative graphic depictions.

6. When an element not listed needs to be determined to be allowed on a textual development planClosed, or requires a graphic development planClosed, the Planning Director shall have the authority to determine whether the commitment is allowed.

D. Requirements

A development planClosed shall comply with all applicable laws and guidelines. Requirements under this section shall consist of the following, which may be supplemented by guidelines of the Planning Department.

1. Contiguous Development

ParcelsClosed within a development planClosed (graphic or textual) must be contiguous. ParcelsClosed directly across from each other, and separated by intervening existing or proposed right-of-wayClosed, are considered contiguous for the purposes of this section. Non-contiguous parcelsClosed that don’t meet this criteria must be submitted as separate applications.

E. Types of Development Plans

This section permits two types of developmentClosed plans in association with a zoning map change request, a textual development planClosed and a graphic development planClosed. A graphic or textual development planClosed describes or depicts aspects of developmentClosed that exceed regulatory requirements. Districts that require a development planClosed, including the PDR district, may have the requirement met through either a textual or graphic development planClosed if all requirements of the district can be met.

1. Textual Development Plan

A textual development planClosed is one where only text is used to describe the commitmentsClosed. Descriptive information shall be denoted within a textual description. These commitmentsClosed will become the zoning standards in which developmentClosed within the district must comply with.

a. Required Elements of a Textual Development Plan

(1) A textual development planClosed shall, at a minimum, proffer a commitment that specifies, limits, and/or prohibits uses within the zoning district requested pursuant to Sec. 5.1, Use Table.

(2) If the Planning Director determines a committed element cannot be clearly described through a textual development planClosed, the applicant must submit a graphic development planClosed.

2. Graphic Development Plan

A graphic development planClosed describes and depicts commitmentsClosed in graphic form. CommitmentsClosed in an approved development planClosed are standards that apply to any subsequent land use applications for the property. At a minimum, a proposed graphic development planClosed shall include the following information:

a. Required Elements of a Graphic Development Plan

(1) References to adopted plans, including transportation plans, open spaceClosed plans, parks and trails plans, that apply to the site;

(2) Existing and proposed Zoning districts and overlays on the site;

(3) Existing and proposed Intensity/densityClosed for each zoning district or overlay (square feet if non-residential, units if residential);

(4) A chart or table including the minimum ordinance requirements and proposed amounts of the following:

(a) BuildingClosed setbacksClosed;

(b) Project boundary buffers;

(c) Maximum impervious area for the site and for each separately zoned portion of the site, indicated numerically for the overall site and each portion;

(d) Tree preservation and/or replacement; and

(e) Open spaceClosed.

(5) Graphic developmentClosed plans shall also include the following information depicted in graphic form:

(a) General location of external access points and connections to existing roadsClosed;

(b) DedicationsClosed or reservationsClosed made for consistency with adopted plans, including transportation plans, or as otherwise required by this Ordinance or other law;

(c) Railroad corridors as required under Sec. 12.6, Railroad Corridors;

(d) Any proposed private streets pursuant to paragraph 12.2.2A.1, Private Streets and Roads.

(e) Areas committed for preservation, including but not limited to steep slopes; stream buffersClosed; wetlandClosed buffers; InventoryClosed sites; sites on maps or lists maintained by the State Historic Preservation OfficeClosed (SHPO), including but not limited to maps for sites listed in the National Register of Historic Places, the Study List for potential designation, determination of eligibility sites, and surveyed sites; sites identified in the Durham Architectural and Historic InventoryClosed and applicable local historic preservation plans; and sites identified in the Durham County Archaeological InventoryClosed and other identified archaeological sites, including cemeteriesClosed and burial grounds;

(f) Tree preservation areas and tree replacement areas.

F. Commitments Allowable Under Development Plans

1. Types of Commitments

CommitmentsClosed can consist of, but are not limited to, the following within either a graphic or textual development planClosed:

a. Description of number, type, or range of uses and/or housing types;

b. General location of on- or off-site roadClosed improvements, including pedestrian and bicycle improvements;

c. Depiction or description of the location and area of open spaceClosed, recreation areas, trails and greenways, tree preservation areas, or buffers other than project boundary or stream buffersClosed;

d. additional bufferClosed width or opacityClosed;

e. Specific landscaping features or vegetation types and opacityClosed;

f. BuildingClosed specifications such as number, location, maximum floor areaClosed, or maximum height;

g. StormwaterClosed control measures;

h. Sustainability measures, including solar and electric vehicleClosed commitmentsClosed;

i. Depiction or description of areas where mass gradingClosed will not occur (only if being described by acreage or volume);

j. Other buildingClosed or site design elements, such as distinctive architectural features or specific materials; and

k. Affordable housing commitmentsClosed;

l. Public artClosed commitmentsClosed;

m. Financial proffers;

n. Transit improvements;

o. ErosionClosed and sedimentClosed control measures.

G. Traffic Improvement(s)

A graphic or textual development planClosed shall include improvements or measures required to address any deficiencies identified by a Traffic Impact Analysis. If required, such measures shall be in text or graphic form, as appropriate. Such improvements shall be developmentClosed requirements, unless otherwise modified as allowed per 3.5.12.

H. Procedure(s)

An application that does not include a development planClosed can changed to include a development planClosed at any time during the application review process. This allowance shall not supersede any authority granted to the Planning Director or designee, or Governing Bodies. In addition, the following procedures apply to textual and graphic developmentClosed plans:

1. Text commitment(s) will be incorporated into the ordinance adopting the  zoning designation.

2. A graphic or textual development planClosed shall include a signedClosed acknowledgement from each property ownerClosed. A signature from an ownerClosed’s representative cannot serve as a substitute for the ownerClosed's signature unless a document establishing legal authority to act as the ownerClosed’s representative is provided.

3. Modifications to a development planClosed that are proffered at a public hearing before the governing body shall be incorporated into the approved commitmentsClosed upon approval of the zoning by the governing body. Verbal commitmentsClosed approved at a governing body public hearing are considered binding commitmentsClosed and must be added to the graphic or text-only development planClosed.  The property ownersClosed must signClosed the development planClosed with the complete set of commitmentsClosed prior to an approved development planClosed being stamped by Planning staff. (Proffers that prove to be illegal or less stringent than existing commitmentsClosed shall be referred to the Planning Commission or governing body for an additional hearing.

4. Modifications that are made to a development planClosed after the Planning Commission recommendation, but before the governing body hearing, shall be referred to the Planning Commission for an additional hearing as required under paragraph 3.5.9B, Changed Application, (when determined by the Planning Director).

5. A graphic development planClosed shall be signedClosed and sealed by a Professional Engineer, Registered Architect, or Registered Landscape Architect. All graphic depictions shall be accurately scaled, and separate or additional sheets may be required by the Planning Department.

I. Statutory Development Agreements

A statutory developmentClosed agreement, pursuant to Sec. 3.26, Statutory Development Agreements, proposed in association with the zoning map change application shall be a commitment of the development planClosed.

J. Phasing Plans

1. A phasing plan may be provided with any graphic development planClosed but shall be required in the Mixed-UseClosed District. The phasing plan shall ensure that residential and non-residential components are constructed to satisfy the intent and requirements of the Ordinance.

2. The phasing plan shall be in graphic form as appropriate and included in the graphic development planClosed. It shall identify the sequence and timing of the developmentClosed phases and include utility improvements, land use categories, and areas in square feet or acres. Phasing plan elements shall become committed developmentClosed requirements.

K. Uses and Minor/Major Special Use Permits

No minor or major special use permit is required for uses that otherwise need such a permit pursuant to paragraph 5.1.2, Use Table; Sec 5.3, Limited Use Standards; or for standards specified elsewhere within the Ordinance, if:

1. The use or standard is specified on the approved development planClosed; and

2. The location, access, buildingClosed height, and size, as applicable, for the proposed use or standard is specified on the development planClosed

3.5.7. Deferral and Withdrawal of an Application for Zoning Map Change

A. Deferral Requests Approved by the Planning Director

1. Deferrals shall be granted by the Planning Director, or designee, under the following criteria:

a. The applicant or an opponent may each seek not more than one deferral for each zoning map change requested. No more than two deferrals (one each from the applicant and an opponent) shall be allowed per proposed zoning map change;

b. Each deferral request shall be for a maximum of one month. Any deferral request shall be made in writing, citing reasons for requesting the deferral; and

c. If the request for deferral is received by the Planning Director or designee and the reasons for the request are made in writing prior to notification being performed for the first Planning Commission or governing body meeting where the item would otherwise be considered.

2. Any other deferrals which do not meet the above criteria shall be treated as a continuance.

3. If the Planning Commission or governing body, as applicable, grants a deferral then new notification and associated fees shall be required.

4. The above procedures are not applicable to proposed zoning map changes that have been designated as “expedited” by a governing body.

B. Withdrawal Request by Applicant

1. The applicant petitioning for a zoning map change may withdraw the application provided that a written request stating the reason for the withdrawal is received by the Planning Director, or designee, at least ten days prior to the public hearing.

2. The request shall be accompanied by mailing labels imprinted with the names and addresses of the previously notified property ownersClosed and a fee sufficient to cover the postage for renotification of surrounding property ownersClosed if the withdrawal occurs after the Planning Commission hearing.

3. The applicant petitioning for a zoning map change with a development planClosed may withdraw the application at any time prior to the opening of the public hearing before the governing body by withdrawing consent to the development planClosed being imposed on the applicant’s property.

4. The governing body may vote to allow the applicant to withdraw an application for a zoning map change at any time.

C. Administrative Voiding of an Application

The Planning Director or designee may consider applications withdrawn and voided due to the failure of the applicant to submit required information within 90 days of a request for such information.

D. Resubmittal of Withdrawn Applications

Except in the case of an application where the applicant withdrew consent to a development planClosed, no application that was previously withdrawn or voided may be resubmitted until at least six months have elapsed since the date of withdrawal. In the case of applications withdrawn or voided as a result of the withdrawal of consent to a development planClosed after publication of a notice of a public hearing, no new application may be resubmitted until at least 12 months have elapsed since the date of withdrawal. The Planning Director or designee may waive this waiting period if the application has been substantially modified or if there has been a significant change in facts or circumstances since the application was withdrawn.

3.5.8. Action by the Planning Director

A. The Planning Director or designee shall prepare a staff report that reviews the zoning map change request in light of any applicable plans and the general requirements of this Ordinance.

The staff report shall consider the entire range of permitted uses in the requested classification regardless of any representations made that the use will be limited, unless a development planClosed is submitted that restricts the permitted range of uses to specific uses. The staff report shall include an evaluation of the consistency of the requested classification with adopted plans and the impact of the requested classification on public infrastructure, as well as any specific requirements of the requested classification.

B. The Planning Director or designee shall forward completed zoning map change requests and any related materials to the Planning Commission for a hearing and recommendation at the first regularly scheduled meeting following completion of the technical reviews by staff.

C. The Planning Director or designee shall forward completed zoning map change requests and any related materials, including the Planning Commission recommendation, to the governing body for a public hearing and decision prior to the first regularly scheduled meeting after the Planning Commission hearing.

3.5.9. Action by the Planning Commission

A. General Procedures

1. Before making any recommendation on a petition for zoning map change, the Planning Commission shall consider any recommendations from the Planning Director and shall conduct a public hearing where interested parties may be heard.

2. Notice and public hearing requirements shall be in accordance with paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings.

3. Except in the case of expedited hearings pursuant to paragraph 3.5.9C, Expedited Hearings, the Commission shall make its recommendation within three consecutive regular Commission cycles (approximately 90 days total) of its initial public hearing. The time period for a recommendation may be altered, as in the case of significant modifications, in which case three additional consecutive regular cycles shall be granted before the case shall go to the governing body.

4. When a recommendation is not made within the time periods established in this section, the governing body may process the request without a Commission recommendation.

5. A zoning map change proposed as a County case shall not require rehearing by the Planning Commission if the property subject to the proposed change is annexed into the City before the Board of Commissioners has acted on the case and the annexation is within 12 months of the original Planning Commission recommendation on the zoning map change, unless the applicant has made a significant modification to the application.

B. Changed Application

If the applicant makes a significant modification to an application for a zoning map change after the Commission has made its recommendation, the Planning Director shall refer the modified request back to the Commission for an additional public hearing. In such case, the Commission shall make a recommendation to the governing body within 90 days of the public hearing on the modified application. If a recommendation is not made within this time frame, the governing body may hear the application without a recommendation from the Planning Commission.

C. Expedited Hearing

1. If the governing body has set an expedited hearing concerning a request, in accordance with paragraph 3.5.11B, Expedited Hearing, a public hearing before the Planning Commission shall be held at the first available hearing date or prior to the hearing before the governing body.

2. The Commission shall make a recommendation at this hearing based on the Review Criteria in paragraph 3.5.10, Written Recommendation, Review Criteria, below. The Planning Commission shall not continue a request for which an expedited hearing has been set, nor shall any deferrals be granted for such a request.

3.5.10. Written Recommendation, Review Criteria

The Planning Commission shall provide a written recommendation regarding whether each proposed map change is consistent with the comprehensive plan and other applicable adopted plans. The recommendation shall be based on the reasons articulated by Commission members voting in the majority, and the recommendation shall be developedClosed as determined in the Commission’s Rules of Procedure. In addition to plan consistency, Commissioners may also consider other matters deemed appropriate by the Commission, which may include but are not limited to:

A. Compatibility with the present zoning and conforming uses of nearby property and with the character of the neighborhood;

B. Suitability of the subject property for uses permitted by the current versus the proposed district;

C. Whether the proposed change tends to improve the balance of uses, or meets a specific demand in the City and County; and

D. The availability of adequate school, roadClosed, parks, wastewater treatment, water supply and stormwaterClosed drainage facilities for the proposed use.

3.5.11. Action by the Governing Body

A. General Procedures

1. Before taking action on a zoning map change request, the governing body shall consider any recommendations of the Planning Commission, Planning Director or designee, and of staff agenciesClosed, and shall conduct a public hearing where interested parties may be heard.

2. Notice and public hearing requirements shall be in accordance with paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings.

3. Continuances may be granted before action on the request.

4. Following the public hearing, the governing body may approve the request, deny the request, or send the request back to the Planning Commission for additional consideration.

5. In adopting or rejecting a zoning map change, the governing body shall adopt a statement describing whether its action is consistent with the Comprehensive PlanClosed, and why the action is reasonable and in the public interest. The governing body may adopt the statement furnished by staff or agenciesClosed, including but not limited to the Planning Director or the Planning Commission, or it may formulate its own statement.

6. The map change request approved by the governing body may include changes from the request presented. Changes to a development planClosed may be made upon the proffer by the applicant of such changes.

7. Approval of a petition gives the applicant the ability to proceed with any additional required approvals.

B. Expedited Hearing

1. The governing body, in situations in which it determines certain standards have been met, may expedite the hearing process on a proposed zoning map change.

2. The governing body may consider a written request from a potential applicant, or from staff, requesting an expedited hearing process. The request shall identify and support the reasons for such expedited consideration.

3. In order to grant the request, the governing body shall find that at least one of the criteria below have been met:

a. Deadlines set by the local, State, or Federal government for receipt of applications for needed funding, designation, or other regulations concerning the property make expedited consideration necessary;

b. The prospective zoning map change request results from an emergency beyond the control of the applicant, such as response to a disaster;

c. The prospective zoning map change request addresses an urgent matter of public health or safety; or

d. There are special circumstances that will have a substantial negative impact on the developmentClosed which could not have reasonably been anticipated and which make expedited consideration necessary.

4. In no event may the governing body hearing occur less than 30 days after the item was granted expedited status.

3.5.12. Deviations from Approved Development Plans

The following deviations from an approved development planClosed require a zoning map change or an amendment to the development planClosed, as indicated below.

A. Deviations that Require a Zoning Map Change

1. A decrease by more than 20% in total densityClosed of the residential developmentClosed, except in a Design District zoning district;

2. A decrease by more than five percent in total densityClosed in residential projects located within a Design District zoning district, unless that decrease results from the application of UDO requirements relating to size or design.

3. In a nonresidential or mixed-use developmentClosed on a site adjacentClosed to a residential districtClosed, a cumulative expansion by more than five percent of total buildingClosed floor areaClosed or 4,000 square feet, whichever is greater, or a cumulative decrease of more than 20% of total buildingClosed floor areaClosed.

4. Changes to the proposed phasing of the project where phasing plans are required or commitmentsClosed.

5. Changes to the use category (for example, residential to officeClosed, officeClosed to commercial, commercial to industrial, as described in Article 5, Use Regulations), if limitations on the number, range, or types of uses were proposed with the development planClosed and the governing body limited its consideration of uses to those uses;

6. A change to the number, location, and/or type (i.e. full versus limited movements) of access points along the same right-of-wayClosed or cardinal directionClosed of the developmentClosed that does not provide equal or improved safety, circulation, and connectivity.

7. A change in the location of a buildingClosed for sites adjacentClosed to a property with a residential districtClosed or use .

8. An increase of more than three percent in impervious surfaceClosed area.

9. A change to an environmental protection, including tree coverage, that exceeds current ordinance requirements.

10. Any graphic or text commitmentsClosed or committed elementsClosed not identified as qualifying as an amendment, below.

11. Any other change to a development planClosed depiction, unless such depiction is clearly identified as "conceptual" or "illustrative", and not identified as qualifying as an amendment below.

B. Deviations that Require Amendments to Development Plans

The purpose of this paragraph is to allow for a limited range of changes (referred to as “amendments”) to an existing development planClosed that would not require a new zoning map change. If the proposed amendment would require a new or revised TIA, then it shall require a new zoning map change.

1. The process for amendments shall follow the same adoption process for a zoning map change, but does not change the zoning designation.

2. A petition to change a development planClosed must include the previously approved development planClosed documents in their entirety with elements proposed for change clearly delineated (graphically and in text format). Previously approved documentation will be supplemented or replaced in its entirety with the modified development planClosed.

3. The following qualify as amendments. Proposals utilizing more than two of the categories listed below shall require a zoning map change.

a. Changes to architectural or other buildingClosed design or layout commitmentsClosed, guidelines, or depictions, including specific limits on height.

b. A change to the requirement on the plan using definitive terms such as, but not limited to, “shall”, “must”, or “will”.

c. Additional, or the removal of, depicted internal access points or connectivity between sections of the developmentClosed.

d. An increase in allowed densityClosed through the use of a densityClosed bonus other than an affordable housing bonus.

e. A change in housing type(s) or proportion of housing type mix.

f. A change to identified buildingClosed or parking envelopes.

C. Changes to Portions of Development Plans

If a zoning map change request seeks to rezone a portion of a site under an existing development planClosed, it shall be demonstrated that the remaining site under the existing development planClosed can meet all ordinance requirements including committed elementsClosed of the development planClosed. Otherwise, the entire site under the existing development planClosed shall require a zoning map change.

D. Changes Following Transfers to Residential Owners

Where a change is proposed to a development planClosed and a portion of the developmentClosed has been transferred to residential ownerClosed(s), ownerClosed acknowledgment from those ownerClosed(s) is not required if the proposed zoning map change or amendment requires no developmentClosed improvements on those properties.

E. Changes Required by Ordinance or Other Law

Notwithstanding the other requirements of this section and except as stated below, a site planClosed or preliminary platClosed shall deviate from an approved development planClosed to conform to the requirements of a new ordinance or other law adopted after development planClosed approval, and a zoning map change shall not be required. Exceptions are:

1. Where the development planClosed is vested pursuant to the vested rightsClosed procedure; and

2. As authorized under paragraph 1.10.3A, Approved Site Plans, Plats, and Permits and Completed Applications.

3. Under such exceptions, the site planClosed or preliminary platClosed shall conform to the approved development planClosed.

F. Changes Allowed by an Affordable Housing Bonus

Amendments to an existing development planClosed, or a new zoning map change approval, are not required in order to utilize and comply with the requirements of the affordable housing bonuses within this Ordinance, as applicable.

G. Development Plans that Required a TIA

1. Except for developmentClosed projects that will utilize the affordable housing bonus of this Ordinance, a new zoning map change is required for any proposal that exceeds the peak hour trip generation of the TIA that was performed with the original zoning map change by more than three percent. If a TIA was not required for the development planClosed, but the proposed developmentClosed requires it, then a zoning map change is required.

2. Committed Public Road Improvements.

a. RoadClosed improvements that were committed as recommended by the TIA performed with the original zoning map change are exempted at the time of full build-out through a new TIA that demonstrates the intensity of the full build-out of the overall developmentClosed no longer warrants the improvement.

b. The City Transportation Department, and NCDOT, as applicable, shall review the new TIA to verify the accuracy of the analysis, and that the previously recommended and committed improvements are no longer warranted. However, if the new TIA indicates that additional improvements are needed, then those new improvements shall be required of the developmentClosed

3.5.13. Protest Petition Sufficiency and Procedures (County only)

A. Protest Petition Defined

A petition in opposition to a zoning map change shall be considered a "valid protest petition" if the petition meets the requirements of applicable state law.

Commentary:    Session Law SL2015-160 repealed the protest petition process for municipalities, effective upon zoning map change applications submitted after August 1, 2015. This law did not repeal Session Law SL2010-80, which allows protest petitions for zoning map change applications within Durham County’s jurisdiction.

B. Standards

1. The petition must meet the substantive requirements of Session Law 2010-80, and in particular must be signedClosed by the ownersClosed of either:

a. 20% or more of the area included in the proposed change or

b. Five percent of the area of a 100-foot wide bufferClosed extending along the entire boundary of each discrete or separate area proposed to be rezoned. In evaluating the sufficiency of a protest under this provision:

(1) A discrete or separate area shall be calculated for any noncontiguous part of an area proposed for zoning map change that is physically separated from other areas proposed for change by property (not including right of way) that is not part of the requested zoning map change;

(2) A street right of way shall not be considered in computing the 100 foot bufferClosed area as long as the street right of way is 100 feet wide or less.

(3) When less than an entire parcelClosed of land is being rezoned, the 100 foot bufferClosed shall be measured from the property line of the entire parcelClosed.

2. Property Ownership

Property ownership shall be determined based on available recorded property records. In the event of records that are incomplete or in conflict, County tax listings may be used to determine ownership.

3. Other Required Information

The petition shall contain all information required on the form supplied by the Planning Director or designee, or the Clerk to the Board of Commissioners.

C. Procedure

1. A form for a protest petition shall be available from the Planning Director or designee, or the Clerk to the Board of Commissioners.

2. Completed petitions shall be submitted to the Clerk to the Board of Commissioners at least four working daysClosed prior to the day of the public hearing.

3. The Planning Director, or designee, in consultation with the County Attorney, shall determine if the petition meets the criteria for classification of "valid protest petition". The Clerk shall inform the governing body that a petition has been filed and indicate the determination by the Planning Director - or designee - whether the petition is valid or invalid. The Planning Director, or designee, shall notify the petitioner as to the validity of the protest petition.

4. Where a substantial modification to a zoning map change application that requires resubmission to the Planning Commission has been submitted, the Planning Director, or designee, shall notify the petitioner, in writing, that a new protest petition is required.

5. Petitions for zoning map change for which a protest petition has been determined to be valid shall require a ¾ vote of the governing body for approval rather than a simple majority. Vacant positions and members who have been excused from voting because of a conflict of interest shall not be considered in computing governing body membership.

D. Withdrawal

PersonsClosed or entities who have signedClosed protest petitions may withdraw their signatures at any time prior to the vote on the proposed map change. Any withdrawal must meet standards established for such withdrawals by the Planning Department. Withdrawals submitted less than two working daysClosed prior to the public hearing may result in a continuance of the hearing if the effect of the withdrawal on the validity of the protest cannot be determined prior to the public hearing.

E. Exemption

The foregoing provisions concerning protest petitions shall not be applicable to any zoning map change that establishes the County’s zoning designation on property that has been relinquished from the City’s jurisdiction, except as provided by general or local law.

3.5.14. Coordination with Site Plans

Approval of a zoning map change with a development planClosed shall enable the ownerClosed or an authorized agent of the ownerClosed to prepare a site planClosed in conformance with the zoning map change and development planClosed for the property. The site planClosed may be prepared for the entire property or phases of the developmentClosed project in accordance with Sec. 3.7, Site Plan Review.

3.5.15. Subsequent Applications

A. When the governing body has denied a zoning map change, no new application may be filed for a similar zoning map change on the subject site until at least 12 months have elapsed since the date of the previous action. The Planning Director - or designee - may waive this requirement if the application has been significantly modified or there has been a significant change in the facts or circumstances since the previous request.

B. When the governing body has denied an annexation petition, the concurrent zoning map change shall be administratively withdrawn.

3.6.2. Actions Exempt from Subdivision Requirements (Exempt Plats)

A. The following shall not be considered “subdivisionClosed” and are exempt from the provisions of this section:

1. The combination or recombination of lots, or portions of lots, previously created and recorded, if the total number of lots is not increased and the resultant lots are equal to or exceed the standards of this Ordinance;

2. The division of land into parcelsClosed greater than ten acres if no street right-of-wayClosed dedicationClosed is involved;

3. The public acquisition by purchase of strips of land for widening or opening streets or for public transportation system corridors;

4. The division of a tractClosed in single ownership of which the entire area is no greater than two acres into not more than three lots, if no street right-of-wayClosed dedicationClosed is involved and if the resultant lots are equal to or exceed the standards of this Ordinance; and

5. The division of a tractClosed into parcelsClosed in accordance with the terms of a probated will or in accordance with intestate succession under Chapter 29 of the General Statutes.

B. The Planning Director - or designee - certification of exempt status is required. Exempt platsClosed shall be stamped by the Planning Director or designee, noting their exemption, and signedClosed so that they can be recorded by the OfficeClosed of the Register of Deeds.

C. Exempt platsClosed shall only be required to conform to applicable lot dimensional requirements within Article 6, District Intensity Standards; Article 7, Design Standards; and any other section in this Ordinance where lot dimensional standards are regulated. Exempt platsClosed shall also conform to applicable nonconformity requirements within Article 14, Nonconformities.

D. The subdivider shall have 180 days after the certification of exempt status is granted to file and record the approved platClosed with the OfficeClosed of the Register of Deeds before the exemption status becomes void.

3.6.3. No Subdivision without Plat Approval

A. No subdivisionClosed of land within the jurisdiction of either the City or County may be filed or recorded with the OfficeClosed of the Register of Deeds until it has been submitted to and approved by the Planning Director or designee, and until the approval is entered on the face of the platClosed.

B. Any personClosed who, being the ownerClosed or the agent of the ownerClosed of any land located within the jurisdiction of this Ordinance, subdivides land in violationClosed of this Ordinance, or transfers, or sells land by reference to, exhibition of, or any other use of a platClosed showing a subdivisionClosed of the land before the platClosed has been properly approved under this Ordinance, and recorded in the OfficeClosed of the Register of Deeds, shall be punishable pursuant to state and local law.

C. The description by metes and bounds in the instrument of transfer, or other document used in the process of selling or transferring land, does not exempt the transaction from penalties. The City or County, as appropriate, may bring an action for injunction of any illegal subdivisionClosed, transfer, conveyance, or sale of land, and the court shall, upon appropriate findings, issue an injunction and order for compliance.

3.6.4. Conservation Subdivision/Preliminary Plat Pre-Application Conference and Neighborhood Meeting

3.6.5. Sketch/Concept Plans

It is recommended, but not required, that the applicant applying for subdivisionClosed approval submit a sketch/concept plan for review by the Planning Director or designee. This plan should, in simple sketch form, show the proposed layout of streets, lots and other features in relation to existing conditionsClosed.

3.6.6. Preliminary Plat Requirements

An application for preliminary platClosed review shall be submitted in accordance with paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirements. Preliminary platClosed documents showing the proposed subdivisionClosed of the land into lots shall contain, as a minimum, the information listed below unless the Planning Director, or designee, makes the determination that less detailed information is required for adequate review. No processing or review of a preliminary platClosed will proceed without the required information. Detailed standards and specifications for design and construction are available from City, County and State agenciesClosed, as applicable.

A. General Requirements

1. Title BlockClosed – Name of project, labeled Preliminary PlatClosed; submittal and revision dates; sheet size (36 inches by 48 inches maximum) with index map and match lines if multiple sheets are required; graphic scale (not smaller than one inch to 200 feet on a standard engineering scale); north point; property identification number; vicinity map clearly establishing the location of the proposed project, with readily recognizable landmarks, stream buffersClosed, flood plain boundaries, property zoning districts and any overlay zones.

2. Name, address and telephone number of ownerClosed, applicant and agent; name, address and telephone number of surveyor, engineer, landscape architect, or other designer, with seal.

3. In addition, State or Federal regulations may require that additional information be supplied to the Planning Department as a part of a submittal.

B. Existing Conditions

1. Boundary of the property, using metes and bounds with angle of departure of adjacentClosed properties; site size and amount to be developedClosed; lot lines; buildingClosed foot prints and square footage; improvements, such as loading areasClosed, parking areas, drivewaysClosed, alleysClosed, streets, sidewalks, etc.; any septic tanks, drain fields and wells; culverts and other subsurface features; all utility easementsClosed, above and below ground, including information on type, size, and elevation; railroads; cemeteriesClosed; setbackClosed requirements; zoning of the site and adjacentClosed zoning, including any overlay zones; land use of the site and adjacentClosed land uses including major improvements within 50 feet of the subject property; adjacentClosed property ownersClosed; adjacentClosed streets, including name and right of way width. Existing features shall be clearly distinguishable from proposed developmentClosed.

2. Topographic contours at two-foot intervals for all property within 100 feet of a proposed developmentClosed area and topographic contours at five-foot contour intervals for the remainder of the property including a source reference; locations and names of water features including shorelines, water bodies, intermittent and perennial streamsClosed; a major specimen tree survey; locations of drainage ways, stream buffersClosed, floodwaysClosed, floodwayClosed fringes, wetlandsClosed and wetlandClosed buffers; locations of vegetation, rock outcrops, steep slope areas, Durham Natural InventoryClosed sites and Durham Historic InventoryClosed Sites.

3. A list of any conditions applied to the property as part of any previous approvals.

C. Proposed Conditions

1. Street Improvements (Public and Private): location of improvements or widenings, names, widths of rights of way and pavement, design criteria including sight triangles and a typical cross section; Traffic Impact Analysis, if required.

2. Pedestrian Circulation: location of sidewalks and other pedestrian ways including dimensions and surfacing, along streets and other locations; provision of crosswalks.

3. Landscaping: location of all plant materials and other landscaping features, including calculations of amount required and the amount provided; the number, size, and description of plant materials, fences, walls and berms; provisions for screeningClosed specialized features, such as storage areas; calculations of the amount of tree coverage required and the amount and percentage of tree coverage provided by tree preservation and tree replacement; calculation of the amount of street trees and the amount provided by tree preservation and tree installation; a land disturbance tree survey; and the location and a description of all proposed and required tree protection measures.

4. GradingClosed: location of vegetation to be retained including approximate sizes and protection measures to be used; a depiction of contours at two foot intervals, supplemented with spot elevations when necessary, including location, description, and size of any retaining walls; dimensions of stream buffersClosed.

5. Utilities: location and width of all easementsClosed and rights of way for water, sewer, storm sewers, gas, electric, communication facilities, or any other utility facility.

6. Storm Drainage: location and description of temporary and permanent storm drainage pipes and swales; amount of impervious surfaceClosed; provisions for erosionClosed and sedimentationClosed controls, including retention and detention facilities; mechanisms for complying with paragraph 8.5.5, Diffuse Flow Requirements; as well as professionally sealed engineering calculations used in the design.

7. Water and Sewer: location and description of public and private water and sanitary sewer improvements including connections to existing facilities and maintenance provisions.

8. Property DedicationsClosed/ReservationsClosed: location and description of dedicatedClosed or reservedClosed properties under public or private ownership including the boundaries, size, purpose, future ownership and maintenance provisions for the property. This category includes but is not limited to rights-of-way, rail corridors, greenways, recreation facilities, open spaceClosed and common areas.

9. Specific performance standards as required by other Articles of the UDO.

10. Within Special Flood Hazard Areas and Future Conditions FloodClosed Hazard Areas: demonstration that the subdivisionClosed will minimize flood damage through the location and construction of all public utilitiesClosed and facilities, including water and sewer systems; adequate drainage in accordance with adopted standards to reduce exposure to flood hazards.

D. Traffic Impact Analysis

A traffic impact analysis (TIA) pursuant to Sec. 3.3, Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA) may be required.

3.6.7. Preliminary Plat Approval

A. Applicability

1. A preliminary platClosed shall be required for all subdivisionClosed of land within the jurisdiction of this Ordinance for developmentsClosed of more than six lots. A preliminary platClosed is required for developmentClosed of six lots or less unless there is no public dedicationClosed of land, no streets, no utility extensions, no required diffuse flow mechanisms, and no required stormwaterClosed management facilities.

2. SubdivisionClosed approval requires the submission of both preliminary and final platsClosed and full interagency review for conformity with the requirements of this Ordinance and other development-related ordinances.

3. Where site plansClosed, as required by this Ordinance, serve as preliminary platsClosed for subdivisionsClosed, they shall satisfy these submission requirements in addition to those required for zoning compliance.

B. Public Notice

Any preliminary platClosed application that involves criteria pursuant to paragraph 3.7.3B, Major Site Plans, shall be noticed pursuant to 3.2.5D, Public Notification Service.

C. Action by the Planning Director

Staff review agenciesClosed shall complete review and transmit comments back to the Planning Director or designee.

D. Action by the Approving Authority

The preliminary platClosed shall be approved by the approving authority if it meets the following criteria:

1. Conforms with all the provisions and requirements of applicable adopted plans, including but not limited to the Comprehensive PlanClosed, historic preservation plans, open spaceClosed plans, greenways plans, transportation plans, gateway plans, corridor plans, collector streetClosed plans, and bicycle plans;

2. Conforms with all the provisions and requirements of this Ordinance; and

3. Conforms with all the provisions and requirements of other applicable ordinances not included in this Ordinance.

E. Reservation of Public Facility Sites and Lands

This section does not apply to the reservationClosed of lands for public streets and roadsClosed.

1. The review of preliminary platsClosed may be delayed by no more than 45 calendar days if the proposed subdivisionClosed contains sites which appear in an adopted plan or policy documents as a future site for a public school or other public facilityClosed, recreation area, park, greenway or other open spaceClosed. During preliminary platClosed review, the appropriate entity responsible for future site acquisition shall be given 45 calendar days from date of platClosed submission to decide if it wishes to reserveClosed the site.

2. If the site is not to be reservedClosed, the subdivisionClosed shall be processed in the normal fashion. If the agencyClosed wishes to reserveClosed the site and specifies such intent in writing to the Planning Director or designee, the subdivisionClosed shall not be approved without the reservationClosed.

3. Public school authorities shall have 18 months from the date of preliminary platClosed approval to acquire the site by purchase, by receipt of dedicationClosed, or by initiating condemnation proceedings. If, at the end of the 18-month period, none of the above actions has occurred, the subdivider may consider the land free from reservationClosed and apply for revised preliminary platClosed approval for its use.

Commentary: See NCGS §160D-804(f).

4. Public agenciesClosed other than schools shall have 120 calendar days from the date of preliminary platClosed approval to arrange for site acquisition for public facilitiesClosed by option to purchase, by purchase, by receipt of dedicationClosed, or by initiating condemnation proceedings. If, at the end of the 120-day period, none of the above actions has occurred the subdivider may consider the land free from reservationClosed and apply for revised preliminary platClosed approval for private use of the property.

F. Issuance of Required Permits

1. Upon preliminary platClosed approval, the applicant may apply for the required permits to begin site work and the installation of improvements.

2. All site work shall be performed in compliance with the requirements of this section and other applicable regulations of the City, County, and State.

3. No required permit may be issued until the required preliminary platClosed is approved.

G. Preliminary Plat Revisions

1. Minor revisions to approved preliminary platsClosed, which reflect the same basic street and lot configuration as used for the original approval, may be approved by the Planning Director or designee.

2. Significant changes to an approved preliminary platClosed, as determined by the Planning Director or designee, shall be resubmitted for review and approval as if it is a new application.

H. Continuing Validity of Preliminary Plat

1. An approved preliminary platClosed shall retain its validity for four years, if:

a. A permit to begin developmentClosed pursuant to the platClosed, such as a land disturbance permit, a building permitClosed, or an improvement permit has been issued and has remained continuously valid thereafter; and,

b. BuildingClosed or land disturbing activityClosed has begun on the property.

2. The issuance of a building permitClosed or a certificate of complianceClosed within a phase of a project shall not extend the validity of the preliminary platClosed for the unbuilt portions of that phase or any future phases of the project for which buildingClosed permits have not been issued.

3. Preliminary platClosed amendments shall not extend the validity of the original approved preliminary platClosed.

4. Validity may be extended if vesting is determined per Sec. 3.20, Vested RightsClosed.

3.6.8. Final Plat Approval

A. Applicability

1. A final platClosed shall be required for all subdivisionClosed of land within the jurisdiction of this Ordinance except as allowed under North Carolina General Statute.

2. Minor Plats

A minor platClosed is a final platClosed for subdivisionClosed that does not qualify as an exempt platClosed or require a preliminary platClosed approval pursuant to paragraph 3.6.7, Preliminary Plat Approval. In addition to the applicable requirements pursuant to paragraph 3.6.8E, Action by the Planning Director, the following shall apply:

a. No part of the tractClosed or parcelClosed to be divided has been divided 10 years prior to the application.

b. A stormwaterClosed impact analysis shall be submitted that documents and supports how the project foregoes any stormwaterClosed control measure(s).

c. The subdivisionClosed shall comply with all applicable City and/or County utility requirements.

B. Conformity with Preliminary Plat

1. The final platClosed shall conform to the approved preliminary platClosed, if any.

2. The final platClosed may constitute only that portion of the preliminary platClosed which is proposed for recordation.

C. Application Requirements

1. When the installation of required site improvements is nearing completion, the subdivider shall submit a final platClosed for review and approval.

2. An application for final platClosed approval shall be submitted in accordance with paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirements.

3. The final platClosed shall be drawn in accordance with North Carolina General Statute 47-30, PlatsClosed and Subdivisions-Mapping Requirements; standard land surveying and mapping practices; and city/county engineering standards.

D. Endorsements on Final Plats

The following certificates shall be placed upon all final platsClosed:

1. Certificate of accuracy and mapping signedClosed by a registered surveyor;

2. Certificate of ownership and dedicationClosed signedClosed and notarized, including all individuals, partnerships, and corporations, and lenders with financial security interests;

3. Attorney’s certification of ownership for any final platClosed involving a right-of-wayClosed dedicationClosed signedClosed and notarized; and

4. Review officerClosed’s certification.

E. Action by the Planning Director

Staff review agenciesClosed shall complete review and transmit comments back to the Planning Director, or designee. The Planning Director or designee shall approve the platClosed as is, defer action for additional information and corrections, or disapprove it. If the final platClosed is disapproved or deferred, the Planning Director or designee shall notify the applicant of the reasons for such disapproval or deferral. The final platClosed shall be approved by the Planning Director or designee if it meets the following criteria:

1. Conforms with all the provisions and requirements of applicable adopted plans, including but not limited to the Comprehensive PlanClosed, historic preservation plans, open spaceClosed plans, greenways plans, transportation plans, gateway plans, corridor plans, collector plans, and bicycle plans;

2. Conforms with all the provisions and requirements of this Ordinance;

3. Conforms with all the provisions and requirements of other applicable ordinances not included in this ordinance;

4. Conforms with the preliminary platClosed, if any;

5. Conforms with completed and approved construction drawings for public infrastructure, where such construction drawings are required by this Ordinance or other applicable ordinance; and

6. Is accompanied by a performance guarantee deemed adequate by the requesting department, if required infrastructure, including but not limited to stormwaterClosed, street, or water and sewer improvements, has not been completed in accordance with approved construction drawings, and if the department responsible for such infrastructure has consented to final platClosed approval pending its completion.

F. Expiration of Approval

The subdivider shall have 180 days after approval to file and record the final platClosed with the OfficeClosed of the Register of Deeds before the approval becomes void.

3.6.9. Alternative Subdivision for Financing Purposes

For purposes of financing or refinancing developmentClosed, it is sometimes necessary to subdivide a previously approved developmentClosed complex (including but not limited to a shopping centerClosed, an officeClosed or industrial park, or a housing complex) originally located on a single parcelClosed into two or more lots, where a subdivisionClosed would vary dimensional, parking, or landscaping requirements of this Ordinance. The Planning Director or designee is authorized to permit such subdivisionClosed to occur subject to the following criteria:

A. A valid, approved site planClosed exists for the overall complex;

B. The complex, in its entirety, satisfies all Ordinance requirements; and

C. Each final platClosed created contains a note stating that the ownersClosed acknowledge that the individual parcelClosed is a part of the named developmentClosed complex, and that deeds of easementClosed, restrictive covenants, and/or other legal documents necessary for the perpetual functioning of the developmentClosed complex shall be executed and recorded with the final platClosed.

3.7.1. General

Site planClosed review, when applicable, shall verify that proposed developmentClosed:

A. Complies with all applicable Ordinance requirements, including any applicable development planClosed;

B. Complies with all previously approved applicable plans, including open spaceClosed and trails plans, and bicycle and pedestrian plans;

C. Provides for trash handling, recycling, grease bins, and other wasteClosed related facilities employed in the normal operation of the use;

D. Provides adequate locations of parking areas, and pedestrian and vehicular access points and circulation;

E. Provides adequate design of traffic patterns, traffic control measures, and street pavement areas, with provisions for maintaining traffic flows and reducing unfavorable effects of traffic on nearby properties;

F. Provides adequate stormwaterClosed facilities, water supply, sanitary sewer service, and fire protection, as evidenced by conformance with department standards, specifications, and guidelines;

G. Complies with requirements for easementsClosed and dedicationsClosed;

H. Where a TIA has been submitted, accommodation for the traffic generated by the developmentClosed with the existing or funded transportation system, or adequate traffic mitigation measures, are provided.

3.7.2. Applicability

All proposed developmentClosed or changes of use, except as indicated below, shall be subject to the site planClosed review process. DevelopmentClosed that is part of a Common Plan of DevelopmentClosed as defined in the City of Durham Code of Ordinances shall be subject to regulations and requirements therein. The following are exempt from site planClosed review:

A. Single-familyClosed and two-familyClosed developmentClosed on existing single lots of recordClosed.

B. TownhouseClosed or detached rowhouse developmentClosed consisting of 10 units or fewer where each unit has a maximum footprint of 1,000 square feet. Additionally, land disturbance shall be less than 1 acre in the Jordan Reservoir WatershedClosed, 12,000 square feet in the Falls Reservoir WatershedClosed, and 0.5 acre in the Neuse River Basin.

C. Accessory dwelling unitClosed developmentClosed where the primary use is civic, consisting of 20 units or fewer where each unit has a maximum footprint of 1,000 square feet. Additionally, land disturbance shall be less than 1 acre in the Jordan Reservoir WatershedClosed, 12,000 square feet in the Falls Reservoir WatershedClosed, and 0.5 acre in the Neuse River Basin.

D. DevelopmentClosed of lots 20,000 square feet or less located in the CI District or utilizing the CI District dimensional standards. For residential uses, CI District densityClosed standards shall apply to any project utilizing the CI district dimensional standards. Additionally, land disturbance shall be less than 12,000 square feet in the Falls Reservoir WatershedClosed.

E. DevelopmentClosed that does not require review by any City or County department for conformance with the standards of this Ordinance; or does not require a permit such as but not limited to fences or flagpoles. In instances where these types of developmentClosed require a certificate of appropriateness (COA) or a special use permit, a site planClosed will not be required.

F. Change of use where no additions to buildings or structures, or exterior land improvements, are proposed and the change of use:

1. Does not require additional parking or stacking.

2. Does not require additional landscaping.

3. Does not require a Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA) or no improvements are required as a result of a TIA analysis.

4. Only requires Architectural Review per Sec. 3.22, Architectural Review.

G. Public Right-of-Way Improvements

DevelopmentClosed projects consisting only of public utilityClosed improvements within the public right-of-wayClosed, improvements to the public right-of-wayClosed (repairing, surfacing, striping, widening, stabilizing, landscaping), or other improvements in the right-of-wayClosed where the Planning Director, or designee, determines another City or County approval process verifies conformance to this Ordinance. Exceptions are as follows:

1. In Design Districts, a separate site planClosed application can be filed or site planClosed review can occur through another technical review by the City or County for that developmentClosed project.

2. In local historic districts, a separate site planClosed application can be filed or site planClosed review can occur through review of the required COA application.

3.7.3. Types of Site Plans

A. Administrative Site Plans

The approving authority is the Planning Director or designee.

B. Major Site Plans

1. The approving authority is the Governing Body.

2. Criteria:

a. The request is for approval pursuant to a standard established in the Ordinance that requires Governing Body approval; or

b. Involves the requirement of a major or transportation special use permit; or

c. Is located in a WatershedClosed Protection Overlay Critical Area (A), as defined in Sec. 4.11, Watershed Protection Overlay, with impervious surfaceClosed that exceeds the maximum permitted by the Low Density OptionClosed under Sec. 8.7, Watershed Protection Overlay Standards.

C. Site Plan Amendments

1. The Planning Director, or designee, is authorized to approve minor changes to the approved site planClosed, resulting from field conditions and which result in an equivalent or better performance.    

2. Significant changes to the approved site planClosed, such as but not limited to a change in access points, relocation of buildings or parking areas, relocation of stormwaterClosed facilities, and changes of use that require different developmentClosed standards, shall be resubmitted for site planClosed approval as a new site planClosed application.

3. Changes to an approved, valid site planClosed required as a result of an update to the applicable Flood InsuranceClosed Rate Map(s) (FIRM) or other detailed flood data pursuant to paragraph 8.4.2, Applicability, shall be submitted as a site planClosed amendment.

4. A site planClosed amendment request shall clearly identify the elements for which approval is sought in both text and graphic form. Only those elements so identified shall be reviewed and considered for approval. If any element of an approved plan is changed but not identified, the amendment request shall be denied in its entirety or, if already approved, the amendment shall be deemed null and void in its entirety.

5. Site planClosed amendments to plans approved under the 1994 Merged Zoning Ordinance, as amended, shall follow approval procedures of this paragraph 3.7.3C, Site Plan Amendments.

3.7.5. Site Plan Requirements

A. A pre-application conference shall be required pursuant to paragraph 3.2.2, Pre-Application Conference.

B. An application for site planClosed review shall be submitted in accordance with paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirements.

C. Site plansClosed shall demonstrate compliance with all applicable Ordinance requirements, including any varianceClosed obtained pursuant to Sec. 3.14, Variance, and any other applicable developmentClosed requirements. Site planClosed documents shall contain the information required within the site planClosed checklists maintained by the Planning Department unless expressly exempted by another provision of this Ordinance, or unless the Planning Director or designee makes the determination that less detailed information is adequate for review.

D. No processing or review of a site planClosed will proceed without the required information.

E. Site planClosed applications shall utilize applicable forms maintained by the applicable City, County, or State department or agencyClosed.

F. A site planClosed shall conform to an approved development planClosed except as required under paragraph 3.5.12D, Changes Required by Ordinance or Other Law, or as authorized under paragraph 3.5.12, Deviations from Approved Development Plans, and paragraph 3.5.6C, Authority of the Planning Director.

G. All requirements imposed through a site planClosed shall run with the land and shall apply against any ownerClosed, subsequent ownerClosed, or occupant.

3.7.8. Inspections of Required Improvements

Inspections of site improvements shall be made by the entity responsible for such improvements as required to certify compliance with approved site plansClosed. No improvements shall be accepted for maintenance by the governing jurisdiction unless and until the requirements regarding public improvements have been met.

3.7.9. Issuance of Certificate of Compliance

Improvements specified in the approved plan shall be made prior to issuance of a certificate of complianceClosed unless an extension of compliance has been prepared and approved in conformance with the requirements of this Ordinance.

3.7.10. Coordination with Major Special Use Permits

Applications for major special use permits may be submitted concurrently with a site planClosed.

However, decisions shall be rendered with a separate motion.

3.7.11. Coordination with Construction Drawings

3.7.12. Continuing Validity of Site Plans

A. An approved site planClosed shall retain its validity for four years, and shall remain valid if:

1. A permit to begin developmentClosed pursuant to the site planClosed, such as a land disturbance permit, a building permitClosed, or an improvement permit, has been issued and has remained continuously valid thereafter; and,

2. BuildingClosed or land disturbing activityClosed has begun on the property.

B. The issuance of a building permitClosed or a certificate of complianceClosed within a phase of a project shall not extend the validity of the site planClosed for the unbuilt portions of that phase or any future phases of the project for which buildingClosed permits have not been issued.

C. Requests for extensions of validity for site plansClosed approved under the previous 1994 Merged Zoning Ordinance, as amended, shall comply with the review criteria specified within that ordinance. The approving authority, however, shall be the Planning Director or designee, utilizing the same findings specified in that Ordinance.

D. Site planClosed amendments shall not extend the validity of the original, approved site planClosed.

E. Validity may be extended if vesting is determined per Sec. 3.20, Vested Rights.

3.8.1. Applicability

A. If required under Sec. 12.10, Sedimentation and Erosion Control, an approved sedimentationClosed and erosion control planClosed and/or a land-disturbing permit shall be obtained before commencing land-disturbing activity.

B. Pursuant to Sec. 113A-57(4) of the North Carolina SedimentationClosed Pollution Control Act of 1973, no personClosed shall initiate any land-disturbing activity that will disturb more than one acre or requires a sedimentationClosed and erosion control planClosed under Sec. 12.10 unless, 30 or more days prior to initiating the activity, an erosionClosed and sedimentationClosed control plan for the activity is filed with and approved by the County SedimentationClosed and ErosionClosed Control OfficeClosed.

3.8.2. Application Requirements

A. Erosion and Sedimentation Control Plan

1. A sedimentationClosed and erosion control planClosed shall be filed with the County SedimentationClosed and ErosionClosed Control OfficeClosed by either hard copy or digitally.  A digital copy of approved construction drawings and approved site planClosed, where applicable, shall also be provided upon their approval.

2. A sedimentationClosed and erosion control planClosed shall contain site drawings, vicinity maps, assumptions, calculations, narrative statements, and a construction sequence as needed to adequately describe the proposed developmentClosed and the measures proposed to comply with the requirements of this Article.

3. A sedimentationClosed and erosion control planClosed shall be prepared by, and bear the seal and signature of, a registered professional engineer, registered landscape architect, registered architect, registered land surveyor, or certified professional in erosionClosed and sedimentClosed control. The County SedimentationClosed and ErosionClosed Control OfficerClosed or designee may, however, deem such a seal and signature not necessary due to site simplicity (as the absence of sensitive geographical features and receiving watercoursesClosed) and the limited nature of the sedimentationClosed and erosionClosed control measures required. In the case of a single-familyClosed lot in a common plan of developmentClosed where the developerClosed and builder are different, such a seal and signature is not required unless there is a design feature requiring such under federal or State law or regulation.

4. The approval of sedimentationClosed and erosion control planClosed is conditioned on the applicant’s compliance with Federal, State and local water quality laws, regulations, and rules.

5. An approved sedimentationClosed and erosion control planClosed shall be kept on file at the job site.

B. Land-Disturbing Permit

1. A land-disturbing permit may be obtained by submitting the following:

a. Applicable fee;

b. Verification of an approved site planClosed or written approval issued by the Durham City-County Planning Department;

c. Completed Durham County Financial Responsibility/Ownership Form With Landowner Consent Form (FRO);

d. Approved sedimentationClosed and erosion control planClosed, if required;

e. Improvement security, if required;

f. Certification that tree protection fencing has been installed, if required; and

g. Approval of the proposed project by the City or County as applicable.

2. No permit shall be issued until such time as the SedimentationClosed and ErosionClosed Control OfficerClosed or designee is assured that the proposed land-disturbing activity will be carried out in accordance with this section and Sec. 12.10, Sedimentation and Erosion Control, and the approved sedimentationClosed and erosion control planClosed, if required. A land-disturbing permit application may be disapproved for the same reasons that a sedimentationClosed and erosion control planClosed may be disapproved, as set forth in paragraph 3.8.7, Disapproval of Plan, of this Ordinance.

3. The SedimentationClosed and ErosionClosed Control OfficerClosed or designee shall require security to assure performance of the conditions of the permit whenever a land-disturbing activity is in excess of five acres or whenever the OfficerClosed or designee determines that the activity may result in significant off-site damage. The applicant shall file with the OfficerClosed or designee an improvement security in the form of a performance bond or letter of credit. The amount shall be that which the OfficerClosed or designee deems sufficient to cover all costs of protection or other improvements required for conformity with standards specified in this section and Sec. 12.10, Sedimentation and Erosion Control. The security may be adjusted or released as the amount of disturbed area changes. The security shall be released when the OfficerClosed or designee has certified that all of the requirements of such sections have been met. Forfeiture of the improvement security shall not release the personClosed conducting the land disturbing activityClosed of their obligation to install and maintain necessary erosionClosed control measures, to stabilize the site, or any other obligation of this section or Sec. 12.10, SedimentationClosed and ErosionClosed Control, or any rule or order promulgated in furtherance thereof.

4. Prior to initiating land-disturbing activity, the permitee shall notify the SedimentationClosed and ErosionClosed Control OfficeClosed of the date that such activity will begin.

5. A land-disturbing permit issued shall be prominently displayed at the job site until all construction is completed, all permanent sedimentationClosed and erosionClosed control measures are removed, and the site has been stabilized as required.

3.8.3. Fees

The fees charged for the administration and enforcement of this Article shall be as prescribed by the Board of Commissioners.

3.8.4. Action by Sedimentation and Erosion Control Office

A. The County SedimentationClosed and ErosionClosed Control OfficerClosed or designee shall review each complete sedimentationClosed and erosion control planClosed submitted and within 30 days of receipt shall notify the personClosed submitting the plan that it has been approved, approved with modifications, or disapproved. Failure to approve, approve with modifications, or disapprove a complete plan within 30 days of receipt shall be deemed approval. Failure to approve, approve with modifications, or disapprove a revised plan within 15 days of receipt shall be deemed approval. Disapproval of a plan must specifically state in writing the reasons for disapproval.

B. If, following commencement of a land-disturbing activity pursuant to an approved sedimentationClosed and erosion control planClosed, the County SedimentationClosed and ErosionClosed Control OfficerClosed or designee determines that the plan is inadequate to meet the requirements of this section or Sec. 12.10, Sedimentation and Erosion Control, the OfficerClosed or designee may require such revisions as it deems necessary to comply with such sections. Failure to approve, approve with modifications, or disapprove a revised plan within 15 days of receipt shall be deemed approval. Pending approval of a revised plan, work shall cease or shall continue only as authorized by the OfficerClosed or designee.

C. The County SedimentationClosed and ErosionClosed Control OfficerClosed or designee shall review each permit application that does not require an approved sedimentationClosed and erosion control planClosed and within 14 calendar days of receipt shall notify the personClosed submitting the application that it has been issued or denied.

3.8.6. Self-Inspections

The landowner, the financially responsible party, or the landowner’s or the financially responsible party’s agent of all permit holders, except for individual residential lots smaller than 1 acre, shall perform an inspection of the area covered by the plan after each phase of the plan has been completed and after establishment of temporary ground coverClosed in accordance with Sec. 12.10. The personClosed who performs the inspection shall maintain and make available a record of the inspection at the site of the land-disturbing activity. The record shall set out any significant deviation from the approved erosion control planClosed, identify any measures that may be required to correct the deviation, and document the completion of those measures. The record shall be maintained until permanent ground coverClosed has been established as required by the approved erosionClosed and sedimentationClosed control plan. The inspections required by this subsection shall be in addition to inspections conducted by the Durham County SedimentationClosed and ErosionClosed Control OfficeClosed.

3.8.7. Disapproval of Plan

A. An erosion control planClosed may be disapproved upon a finding that an applicant, or a parentClosed, subsidiaryClosed or other affiliateClosed of the applicant:

1. Is conducting or has conducted land-disturbing activity without an approved plan;

2. Has received notice of violationClosed of a plan previously approved by the North Carolina SedimentationClosed Control Commission or a local government pursuant to the North Carolina SedimentationClosed Pollution Control Act of 1973, as amended, and all rules and orders adopted pursuant to it (the Act) or local ordinance adopted pursuant to the Act, and has not or had not complied with the notice within the time specified in the notice;

3. Has failed to pay a civil penalty assessed pursuant to the Act or a local ordinance adopted pursuant to the Act by the time the payment is due; or

4. Has failed to substantially comply with State rules or local ordinances and regulations adopted pursuant to the Act.

B. For purposes of this subsection, an applicant’s record may be considered for only the two years prior to the application date.

C. Any personClosed engaged in land-disturbing activity who fails to file a plan in accordance with this Article, or who conducts a land-disturbing activity except in accordance with provisions of an approved plan, shall be deemed in violationClosed of this Article.

3.8.9. Appeals

A. Except as provided in paragraph B. of this subsection, the appealClosed of a disapproval or approval with modifications of a plan shall be governed by the following provisions:

1. The disapproval or modification of any proposed erosion control planClosed or the refusal to issue a land-disturbing permit by the SedimentationClosed and ErosionClosed Control OfficerClosed or designee shall entitle the personClosed submitting the plan, or applying for the permit, to a hearing if such personClosed submits written demand to the Clerk to the Board of Commissioners for a hearing within 15 days after receipt of written notice of disapproval or modifications. The written demand must specify, with particularity, the factual and/or legal basis for the appealClosed. No grounds, other than those so specified, may be argued;

2. Hearings held pursuant to this section shall be conducted by the Board of Commissioners within 15 days after the date of the appealClosed or request for a hearing, or at the next regularly scheduled meeting, whichever is later; and

3. If the Board of Commissioners upholds the disapproval or modification of a proposed erosion control planClosed or refusal to issue a permit following the public hearing, the personClosed submitting the plan or permit application shall then be entitled to appealClosed the Board of Commissioners’ decision to the State SedimentationClosed Control Commission as provided in NCGS § 113A-61(c) and Title 15 NCAC 4B.0018(d).

B. Appeals

In the event that an erosion control planClosed is disapproved pursuant to paragraph 3.8.7, Disapproval of Plan, the County SedimentationClosed and ErosionClosed Control OfficeClosed shall notify the Director of the Division of Energy, Mineral, and Land Resources (within the North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality [DEQ]) of such disapproval within ten days. The OfficeClosed shall advise the applicant and the Director in writing as to the specific reasons that the plan was disapproved. The applicant may appealClosed the OfficeClosed’s disapproval of the plan pursuant to paragraph 3.8.7, Disapproval of Plan, directly to the State SedimentationClosed Control Commission.

3.8.10. Expiration

A. A land-disturbing permit shall expire at the end of:

1. One year from the date of issuance if no land-disturbing activity has been undertakenClosed in that period. No land-disturbing activity may take place following expiration until the personClosed responsible has applied for, and received, a new land-disturbing permit. The fee for the new permit shall be 100% of the current applicable fee; or

2. A two-year period, unless it is extended by the SedimentationClosed and ErosionClosed Control OfficerClosed or designee upon written request of the permit holder. The request for extension shall include reasons for incompletion of the work. After review of the original plan and an on-site inspection of the completed work, the permit may be extended effective for a period not to exceed six months from the date of expiration of the original permit. The fee for the extended permit shall be 25% of the current applicable fee. If work cannot be completed and the site permanently stabilized prior to expiration of the permit extension, then a new land-disturbing permit must be applied for and obtained as described in this section.

B. An approved sedimentationClosed and erosion control planClosed for which no permit has been issued shall expire one year from the approval date. If a plan has been disapproved, a revised plan must be submitted within one year from the disapproval date or the file will be closed.

3.8.11. Transfer of Permits

Land disturbance permits may be transferred from one financially responsible party to another within the permit term.  Transfer of a permit does not extend the permit term.

A. All Permit Transfers 

1. In order to transfer a land disturbance permit from one financially responsible party to another, the following documents must be submitted under the name of the new financially responsible party:

a. Completed Durham County Financial Responsibility/Ownership Form with Landowner Consent Form (FRO);

b. Improvement security, if required.

2. Transfer of permit shall include entirety of original permitted area, unless approved in writing by the Durham County ErosionClosed Control OfficeClosed.

B. Single Family Lots:

For land-disturbing activities on a single-familyClosed residential lot involving new constructionClosed with land disturbance of less than one acre where the builder or developerClosed is the ownerClosed of the lot being developedClosed and the personClosed financially responsible for the land-disturbing activity, the financial responsibility for land-disturbing activity on that lot transfers to the new ownerClosed upon the builder's or developerClosed's conveyance of the lot to the new ownerClosed, recording of the deed in the officeClosed of the register of deeds, and notification to the Durham County ErosionClosed control OfficeClosed.

3.9.1. Applicability

A. Special uses within the zoning districts are considered to be uses which are appropriate in a particular zoning district but because of their potential for incompatibility with surrounding uses require individual review.

B. A minor special use permit shall be required for all minor special uses as set forth in the use table in Sec. 5.1, Use Table, and as may be specified elsewhere in this Ordinance. Minor special use permits require approval by the Board of Adjustment, except pursuant to paragraph 3.9.1E, below.

C. A major special use permit shall be required for all major special uses as set forth in the use table in Sec. 5.1, Use Table; for spray irrigation in a conservation subdivisionClosed pursuant to paragraph 6.2.4, Conservation Subdivision; and as specified elsewhere in this Ordinance. Major special use permits require approval by the appropriate governing body.

D. A transportation special use permit shall be required for developmentClosed projects with corresponding site plansClosed and preliminary platsClosed pursuant to paragraph 3.9.10, Transportation Special Use Permit. Transportation special use permits require approval by the appropriate governing body.

E. Projects that require not only a major and/or transportation special use permit, but also a minor special use permit, may have the use permits consolidated into a single hearing before the appropriate governing body so long as all required findings for each special use permit are made. Separate orders for each special use permit shall be issued.

3.9.2. Pre-Application Conference

All applicants applying for a special use permit shall schedule a pre-application conference in accordance with paragraph 3.2.2, Pre-Application Conference.

3.9.3. Application Requirements

All applications for special use permits shall be submitted in accordance with paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirements.

3.9.4. Notice and Public Hearings

Once the application has been determined complete, the Planning Director or designee shall schedule a public hearing and give public notice as set forth in paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings.

3.9.5. Action by the Planning Director

The Planning Director or designee shall prepare a report that reviews the special use permit in light of any requirements of this Ordinance. A copy shall be provided to the Board of Adjustment or the governing body, as appropriate, and the applicant.

3.9.6. Approval of a Minor Special Use Permit

A. Prior to scheduling the public hearing on the minor special use permit, the corresponding site planClosed or architectural review application, as applicable, shall be ready for action by the approving authority.

B. The applicant seeking the special use permit shall have the burden of presenting evidence sufficient to allow the approving authority to reach the conclusions set forth below, as well as the burden of persuasion on those issues.

C. After conducting the public hearing and hearing the recommendations of the Planning Director or designee, the Board of Adjustment shall:

1. Approve the request;

2. Approve the request with conditions.

3. Deny the request; or

4. Continue the hearing.

D. Conditions may be incorporated as part of the approval of the special use permit to assure that adequate mitigation measures are associated with the use or design pursuant to NCGS §160D-705(c), as applicable. The conditions shall become a part of the minor special use permit approval. ViolationsClosed of any of the conditions shall be treated in the same manner as other violationsClosed of this Ordinance.

3.9.7. Approval of a Major or Transportation Special Use Permit

A. Prior to scheduling the public hearing on the major or transportation special use permit, the corresponding site planClosed shall be ready for action by the approving authority.

B. After conducting the public hearing and hearing the recommendations of the Planning Director, Transportation Director, or their designee as appropriate, the governing body shall:

1. Approve the request;

2. Approve the request with conditions.

3. Deny the request; or

4. Continue the hearing.

C. The governing body may place conditions on the use as part of the approval to assure that adequate mitigation measures are associated with the use. The conditions shall become a part of the major special use permit approval. ViolationsClosed of any of the conditions shall be treated in the same manner as other violationsClosed of this Ordinance.

3.9.8. Criteria for Approval of Major or Minor Special Use Permits

A. General Findings

Unless otherwise specified in this Ordinance, applications for major or minor special use permits shall be approved only if the approving authority finds that the use as proposed, or the use as proposed with conditions, is:

1. In harmony with the area and not substantially injurious to the value of properties in the general vicinity;

2. In conformance with all special requirements applicable to the use;

3. Will not adversely affect the health or safety of the public; and

4. Will adequately address the review factors identified below.

B. Review Factors

The applicant shall demonstrate that the review factors listed below have been adequately addressed. If an application is denied, the approving authority shall specify which of these review factors, if any, were not adequately addressed.

1. Circulation

Number and location of access points to the property and the proposed structures and uses, with particular reference to automotive, bicycle, mass transit and pedestrian safety and convenience, traffic flow and control, and access in case of fire or catastrophe.

2. Parking and Loading

Location of off-street parking and loading areasClosed.

3. Service Entrances and Areas

Locations of refuse and service areasClosed with particular reference to ingress and egress of service vehiclesClosed.

4. Lighting

Locations of exterior lighting with reference to glare, traffic safety, economic effect and compatibility with other property in the area.

5. Signs

Appropriateness of signsClosed considering location, color, height, size, and design within the context of other property in the area.

6. Utilities

Location and availability of utilities.

7. Open Spaces

Location of required yardsClosed and other open spacesClosed and preservation of existing trees and other natural features.

8. Environmental Protection

Preservation of tree cover, Durham InventoryClosed Sites, floodplain, stream buffersClosed, wetlandsClosed, steep slopes, open spaceClosed and other natural features, and protection of water quality.

9. Screening, Buffering and Landscaping

Installation of screeningClosed, buffering, fencing and landscaping where necessary to protect adjacentClosed property.

10. Effect on Nearby Properties

Effects of the proposed use on nearby properties, including, but not limited to, the effects of noise, odor, lighting, and traffic.

11. Compatibility

The level of general compatibility with nearby properties and impacted neighborhoods, including but not limited to the appropriateness of the scale, design, and use in relationship to other properties.

12. Consistency with Policy

Consistency with the Comprehensive PlanClosed and applicable developmentClosed tier guidelines, overlay purposes, and zoning district intent statements in Article 4, Zoning Districts.

13. Other Factors

Any other review factors which the approving authority considers to be appropriate to the property in question.

C. Additional Review Factors for Development in Special Flood Hazard Areas and Future Conditions Flood Hazard Areas

The applicant for a minor special use permit under this section shall demonstrate that the additional review factors listed below have been adequately addressed. If the application is denied, the Board of Adjustment shall specify which of these review factors, if any, were not adequately addressed.

1. Susceptibility of the proposed facility, structureClosed, or other developmentClosed and its contents to flood damage and the effect of such damage on the individual property ownerClosed and others as a result of flood damage;

2. Importance of the services provided by the proposed facility, structureClosed, or other developmentClosed to the community;

3. Necessity to the facility, structureClosed, or other developmentClosed of a waterfront location, where applicable;

4. Compatibility of the proposed use with existing and anticipated developmentClosed;

5. Safety of access to the property in times of flood for ordinary and emergency vehiclesClosed;

6. Expected heights, velocity, duration, rate of rise, and sedimentClosed transport of the flood waters and the effects of wave action, if applicable, expected at the site;

7. Costs of providing governmental services during and after flood conditions including maintenance and repair of public utilitiesClosed and facilities such as sewer, gas, electrical and water systems, and streets and bridges;

8. Relationship of the proposed use to the comprehensive plan and floodplain management program for that area;

9. The proposed fill or developmentClosed provides for a better balance between overall efficiency of the site design and improved conservation elsewhere on the site than would be possible without intrusion into the floodway fringeClosed, non-encroachment area fringeClosed, Future Conditions FloodClosed Hazard Areas, or Areas of Shallow Flooding ZoneClosede AO);

10. The proposed fill or developmentClosed represents the minimum amount of floodway fringeClosed, non-encroachment area fringeClosed, Future Conditions FloodClosed Hazard Areas, or Areas of Shallow Flooding ZoneClosede AO) intrusion to achieve this better balance; and

11. Any other relevant factors, technical evaluations, or standards specified in other sections of this Ordinance.

3.9.9. Transportation Special Use Permit

A. Requirements

A transportation special use permit shall be required for developmentClosed projects that are expected to generate:

1. 600 or more vehicleClosed trips at peak hour; or

2. 300 or more vehicleClosed trips at peak hour, if any roadClosed serving the project is operating at a level of serviceClosed lower than the jurisdiction’s adopted level of serviceClosed.

B. Exemptions

The following projects shall be exempt from the requirement of a transportation special use permit, even if they meet or exceed the thresholds specified above.

1. Projects that do not require a TIA per Sec. 3.3, Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA).

2. Projects within the UC, UC-2, or SRP zoning districts.

3. Projects outside of the City jurisdiction.

4. Projects which have submitted a TIA in connection with a zoning map change with a development planClosed, and which are developingClosed consistent with the approved development planClosed, if the TIA is valid pursuant to paragraph 3.3.6, Period of Validity.

5. Schools as defined in NCGS §160A-307.1.

C. Criteria for Approval

Applications for a transportation special use permit shall be approved only if the governing body makes the following findings:

1. The traffic generated by the developmentClosed and associated improvements to the street system will not have a significant adverse impact on the surrounding area. Significant adverse impact shall include:

a. Substantial increases in traffic on local residential streetsClosed such that the majority of the traffic is not associated with the residential properties which front on the street; or

b. The need to widen local residential streetsClosed, which would detract significantly from the character or basic function of the nearby streets.

2. Adequate provisions have been made for safe and efficient vehicular circulation, parking and loading, and pedestrian access.

3. The traffic generated by the proposed developmentClosed and any proposed improvements to the street system will not have a significant adverse impact on the environment. Significant adverse impacts shall include but not be limited to undue concentration of air pollutants, or excessive noise or vibrations.

4. The traffic generated by the developmentClosed can be accommodated by the existing or funded transportation system, or adequate traffic mitigation measures have been proposed as part of the developmentClosed application. Proposed mitigation measures shall become conditions of the special use permit. The adopted level of serviceClosed for the adjacentClosed roadways may be considered in making this determination but shall not be the sole factor considered by the governing body.

3.9.11. Coordination with Zoning Map Change Applications

An application for a special use permit may be reviewed concurrently with a zoning map change application. However, decisions shall be rendered with separate motions.

3.9.12. Resubmittals

An application for a special use permit which has been denied may be resubmitted if there has been a change in circumstances, as determined by the Planning Director or designee.

3.9.13. Expiration

A special use permit shall become null and void in any of the following cases:

A. If a site planClosed or architectural review, as applicable, is not approved within 12 months of the date of permit approval.

B. If an approved site planClosed, architectural review application, or building permitClosed expires.

C. If a building permitClosed is not issued within two years of the date of approvalClosed, in cases where a corresponding site planClosed or architectural review is not required.

D. If a substantial violationClosed of the conditions of the permit, as determined by the Planning Director or designee occurs. The addition of language to the special use permit regarding such voiding shall not be required.

E. Validity may be extended if vesting is determined per Sec. 3.20, Vested Rights.

3.9.14. Appeal

AppealClosed from final action can be taken by filing a petition for certiorari with the Durham County Superior Court.

3.9.15. Recordation

3.10.1. Applicability

A. Certain signsClosed shall be allowed without signClosed permits (as set forth in Article 11, Signs). SignsClosed requiring permits shall be allowed in accordance with the following procedures.

Commentary: A common signage planClosed may be required before a signClosed permit can be issued (see Sec. 3.11, Common and Way-Finding Signage Plans).

B. Internally orientedClosed signsClosed not legible from the public right-of-wayClosed shall not require a signClosed permit; however, electrical or other permits may be required.

3.10.2. Application Requirements

A. Except as provided in Article 11, Signs, no signClosed may be erected, moved, enlarged, or altered except in accordance with this Ordinance and pursuant to the issuance of a signClosed permit.

B. A signClosed permit application shall be submitted in accordance with paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirements.

3.10.3. Action by the Planning Director

A. Upon review of the application, the Planning Director or designee shall approve the signClosed permit provided the signClosed meets all requirements of this Ordinance, and all other applicable electrical and North Carolina BuildingClosed Code requirements.

B. SignsClosed shall be installed in accordance with the approved signClosed permit within one year of the date of official permit approval or the permit shall expire and require a new signClosed permit application and approval. The Planning Director or designee may extend the validity of the signClosed permit with documentation that a good faith effort is being made to install and receive final approval of the subject signClosed(s).

3.10.4. Inspection of Permanent Signs

A. The applicant shall request an inspection after installation of the signsClosed.

B. If the signsClosed are found to be in compliance, the applicant shall receive a permanent seal which identifies the signClosed. The applicant shall attach the identification in a conspicuous location which is accessible to the Planning Director or designee. It is recommended that businesses place the permit in a lower corner of the front door of the business in those cases where the seal is not affixed to the signClosed.

C. The signClosed permit shall be null and void if signClosed installation is not completed within six months or the signsClosed are not in conformance with the approved application.

D. Valid signClosed permits may be assigned to a successor as holder of a business license for the same premises.

3.10.5. Temporary Sign Permits

A temporary signClosed permit shall be issued in accordance with Article 11, Signs. A common signage planClosed pursuant to Sec. 3.11, Common and Way-Finding Signage Plans, shall not be required for applications for temporary signClosed permits.

3.10.6. Revocation of a Sign Permit

The signClosed permit shall be revoked if a signClosed is found to be in violationClosed of the requirements of this Ordinance, or other applicable electrical and North Carolina State BuildingClosed Code requirements.

3.11.1. General

A. A common signage planClosed is required for all signsClosed for one or more buildings or businesses within a unified developmentClosed complex, as demonstrated through a development planClosed or approved site planClosed(s), even if the property is subdivided and has various ownersClosed.

1. Approval of a common signage planClosed is required prior to the issuance of a signClosed permit.

2. Internally-oriented signsClosed not visible from the public right-of-wayClosed shall not be required to be included in a common signage planClosed.

3. Applications for temporary signClosed permits shall not be required to submit an approved common signage planClosed.

4. Common signage plansClosed are not required in UC, UC-2, and Design districts and in a local Historic Districts Overlay. (County Only) Common signage plansClosed are not required in the SRP-C District.

B. A way-finding signage planClosed is required to allow signsClosed pursuant to paragraph 11.6.2A.9, Way-Finding Signs.

1. Approval of a way-finding signage planClosed is required prior to the issuance of a signClosed permit.

2. A way-finding signage planClosed can be approved separately, or as part of, a common signage planClosed.

3. Internally-oriented signsClosed not visible from the public right-of-wayClosed shall not be required to be included in a way-finding signage planClosed.

4. (County Only) Way-finding signage plansClosed are not required in the SRP-C District.

3.11.3. Action by the Planning Director

A. The Planning Director, or designee, is the approving authority for common and way-finding signage plansClosed.

B. The Planning Director, or designee, may allow modifications to the lettering style of a common signage planClosed to accommodate state and federally registered trademarks (logos) if the Planning Director, or designee, determines that the intent of the common signage planClosed requirements shall be maintained. In allowing the modifications, the Planning Director, or designee, may limit the logo size.

C. Minor alterations in signClosed locations resulting from unexpected conditions on the site may be approved by the Planning Director, or designee.

3.11.4. Revisions and Amendments

3.12.1. Applicability

A. Temporary uses occurring on property outside of the public right-of-wayClosed shall be allowed upon the issuance of a temporary use permit, except as set forth in, Sec. 5.5, Temporary Uses.

Commentary:   Standards for specific uses are included in Sec. 5.5, Temporary Uses.

B. The provisions of this section shall not apply to temporary uses occurring within the public right-of-wayClosed.

Commentary:   For further details on temporary uses occurring within the public right-of-wayClosed see the applicable City or County Code.

3.12.2. Application Requirements

A temporary use permit application shall be submitted in accordance with paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirements.

3.12.3. Action by the Planning Director

A. After receiving the application, the Planning Director or designee shall have up to 30 days to review the application.

B. Upon hearing recommendations from all appropriate departments, the Planning Director or designee shall approve the issuance of a temporary use permit subject to the following:

1. No lighting or electrical service shall be provided without an electrical permit;

2. No temporary use structureClosed shall be erected without a building permitClosed;

3. No temporary use structureClosed shall blockClosed fire lanes or pedestrian or vehicular access;

4. The site of the temporary use shall be cleared of all debris at the end of the temporary use. All temporary structures shall be cleared from the site within five days after the use is terminated;

5. Written permission of the property ownerClosed for the temporary use shall be provided;

6. Adequate parking shall be provided, considering both the required parking for other uses and the parking for the proposed temporary use;

7. Adequate traffic control measures shall be provided;

8. Required landscaped and vegetated areas remain undisturbed;

9. Adequate provisions for trash disposalClosed and sanitary facilities shall be provided; and

10. When appropriate, adequate provisions for crowd control shall be provided.

C. Temporary use permits may be renewed one time by the Planning Director or designee, unless other renewal standards are specified in Sec. 5.5, Temporary Uses, or in other provisions of this section.

3.12.4. Revocation of a Temporary Use Permit

3.14.1. Applicability

A. The Board of Adjustment may vary certain requirements of this Ordinance, in harmony with the general purpose of these regulations, where unnecessary hardships would result from carrying out the strict letter of the Ordinance.

B. Despite the above and pursuant to 15A NCAC 02B .0233 and 15A NCAC 02B .0267, a “major varianceClosed” from the requirements of Sec. 8.5, Riparian Buffer Protection Standards, including where incorporated by reference, shall be granted only by the North Carolina Environmental Management Commission. A “minor varianceClosed” may be granted by the approval authority in accordance with paragraph 8.5.12, Variances.

C. No varianceClosed shall be granted that would have the effect of allowing a use not permitted in the use table in Sec. 5.1, Use Table, by Sec. 8.4, Floodplain and Flood Damage Protection Standards, or elsewhere within this Ordinance.

Commentary:  VariancesClosed may be granted for, among other things, height, structureClosed size, lot dimensions, and setbacksClosed.

3.14.4. Notice and Public Hearings

Once the application has been determined complete, the Planning Director or designee shall schedule a public hearing and give public notice as forth in paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings.

3.14.5. Burden of Proof

The applicant seeking the varianceClosed shall have the burden of presenting evidence sufficient to allow the Board of Adjustment to reach the conclusions set forth below, as well as the burden of persuasion on those issues.

3.14.6. Action by the Planning Director

The Planning Director, or designee, shall provide the Board of Adjustment with a copy of the application and all relevant materials pertaining to the request prior to the public hearing.

3.14.7. Action by the Board of Adjustment

A. Each decision shall be accompanied by a finding of fact by the Board of Adjustment which specifies the reasons for the decision.

B. The Board of Adjustment may approve the request, deny the request, or continue the request. In approving the varianceClosed, the Board of Adjustment may prescribe reasonable and appropriate conditions provided that the conditions are reasonably related to the varianceClosed.

3.14.8. Findings

In granting any varianceClosed, the Board of Adjustment shall make the following findings:

A. Unnecessary hardship would result from the strict application of the Ordinance. It shall not be necessary to demonstrate that, in the absence of the varianceClosed, no reasonable use can be made of the property.

B. The hardship results from conditions that are peculiar to the property, such as location, size, or topography. Hardships resulting from personalClosed circumstances, as well as hardships resulting from conditions that are common to the neighborhood or the general public, may not be the basis for granting a varianceClosed.

C. The hardship did not result from actions taken by the applicant or the property ownerClosed. The act of purchasing property with knowledge that circumstances exist that may justify granting a varianceClosed shall not be regarded as a self-created hardship.

D. The requested varianceClosed is consistent with the spirit, purpose, and intent of the Ordinance, such that public safety is secured, and substantial justice is achieved.

3.14.9. Watershed Protection

A. A request for a varianceClosed from any requirement of Sec. 8.7, Watershed Protection Overlay Standards, that violatesClosed any provision in Title 15 NCAC 2B, Sections .0100, .0200, and .0300, as amended, shall be first heard by the Board of Adjustment in accordance with this section and after notification of the appropriate governing body, except that a request for a varianceClosed from the requirements of Sec. 8.5, Riparian Buffer Protection Standards, as referenced by paragraph 8.7.2E, Riparian Buffers, shall proceed under paragraph 8.5.12, Variances. A recommendation from the Board of Adjustment for a varianceClosed shall constitute a request by the local government for a varianceClosed from the North Carolina Environmental Management Commission. Such variancesClosed shall be considered “major variancesClosed” in accordance with Title 15A NCAC .0104(r).

B. For all varianceClosed requests from Sec. 8.7, Watershed Protection Overlay Standards, except those from Sec. 8.5, Riparian Buffer Protection Standards, as referenced therein, the local government with jurisdiction shall notify and allow reasonable comment period for all local governments having jurisdiction within the watershedClosed area of the water supply source and the entity using the water supply for consumption.

C. The Planning Director, or designee, shall keep a record of variancesClosed to Sec. 8.7, Watershed Protection Overlay Standards. This record of variancesClosed, not including those from Sec. 8.5, Riparian Buffer Protection Standards, as referenced in Sec. 8.7, shall be submitted to the Division of Water Resources, North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality by January 1st of each year. The record shall provide a description of each project receiving a varianceClosed and the reasons for granting a varianceClosed. The record of variancesClosed from Sec. 8.5, Riparian Buffer Protection Standards shall be included in the annual report to the North Carolina Division of Water Resources summarizing activities implementing the requirements of that section.

3.14.10. Expiration

A varianceClosed shall become null and void in any of the following cases:

A. If a site planClosed, preliminary platClosed, or architectural review is not approved within 12 months of the date of approvalClosed of the varianceClosed.

B. If an approved site planClosed, preliminary platClosed, architectural review, or building permitClosed expires.

C. In cases when a site planClosed, preliminary platClosed, or architectural review is not required:

1. If a building permitClosed is not issued within two years of the date of approvalClosed.

2. If the Ordinance standard subject to the varianceClosed has been amended prior to the issuance of a building permitClosed.

D. If a substantial violationClosed of the conditions of the varianceClosed approval is determined by the Planning Director or designee.

3.15.1. Applicability

An appealClosed by any personClosed aggrieved by a final order, interpretation, or decision of any administrative official authorized to make decisions in regard to the provisions of this Ordinance shall be taken to the Board of Adjustment, except as otherwise provided in this Ordinance or State statute.

3.15.2. Application Requirements

A. A written notice of appealClosed of an administrative decision shall be filed as an application specifying the grounds for the appealClosed, and in accordance with other applicable provisions of paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirementss.

B. The appealClosed shall be considered filed when the complete application is delivered to the Durham City-County Planning Director. The date and time of filing shall be entered on the notice application.

3.15.3. Submission of Application

3.15.4. Notice and Public Hearings

Once the application has been submitted, the Planning Director or designee shall schedule a public hearing at the first available Board of Adjustment meeting and give public notice pursuant to paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings.

3.15.5. Action by the Planning Director

A. The Planning Director or designee shall transmit to the Board of Adjustment all the documents and exhibits constituting the record upon which the action appealedClosed from is taken.

B. The Planning Director or designee shall provide a copy of the record to the appellant and to the ownerClosed of the property that is subject to the appealClosed, if different than the appellant.

3.15.6. Action by Board of Adjustment

The Board of Adjustment may reverse or affirm (wholly or partly) or may modify the decision appealedClosed from and shall make any order, requirement, decision, or determination that ought to be made in the case before it. To this end, the Board of Adjustment shall have all the powers of the official from whom the appealClosed is taken.

3.15.7. Effect of Appeal

A. An appealClosed of a notice of violationClosed or other enforcement order stays enforcement of the action appealedClosed from, including any accumulation of fines, during the pendency of the appealClosed to the Board of Adjustment and any subsequent appealClosed in accordance with NCGS §160D-1402, or during pendency of any civil proceeding authorized by law, including NCGS §160D-1403.1, or appealsClosed therefrom, unless the official who made the decision certifies to the Board of Adjustment after notice of appealClosed has been filed that because of the facts stated in an affidavit, a stay would cause imminent peril to life or property; or because the violationClosed is transitory in nature, a stay would seriously interfere with enforcement of the Ordinance. In that case, enforcement proceedings shall not be stayed except by a restraining order, which may be granted by a court.

B. If enforcement proceedings are not stayed, the appellant may file a request for an expedited hearing of the appealClosed, and the Board of adjustment shall meet to hear the appealClosed within 15 days after such a request is filed.

C. Notwithstanding the foregoing, appealsClosed of decisions granting a developmentClosed approval or otherwise affirming that a proposed use of property is consistent with the Ordinance shall not stay the further review of an application for permits or permissions to use such property; in these situations, the appellant may request and the Board may grant a stay of a final decision of permit applications or buildingClosed permits affected by the issue being appealedClosed.

3.15.8. Appeal

AppealClosed from the Board of Adjustment action can be taken by filing a petition in the nature of certiorari with the Durham County Superior Court.

3.16.1. Applicability

A. The City Council and the Board of Commissioners, as applicable, may designate an area as an historic district or a property as an historic landmark, or amend or remove a local historic district designation or landmark designation.

B. A property owner or ownersClosed may request an area to be designated as an historic district or that a property be designated as an historic landmark, or to amend or remove a local historic district designation or landmark designation.

3.16.2. Designation of an Historic District

A. Application Process

1. General

Petitions to initiate the establishment of a local historic district are granted or denied by the applicable governing body, depending upon jurisdiction. Petitions shall first be considered by the Historic Preservation Commission (HPC), which shall make a recommendation to the governing body as to whether the governing body should or should not initiate the request. If the governing body initiates the request, staff will proceed as directed with the designation of a local historic district zoning overlay (-H), including developmentClosed of the required Historic District Preservation Plan.

Commentary:  As noted below, the HPC must consider findings before sending the request to the governing body. The governing body will consider information provided by the applicant, the HPC, and staff. Information provided by the applicant will include a percent of property ownerClosed support for the designation, which may factor in the governing body’s decision to initiate the establishment of the proposed historic district designation.

2. Submittal

a. Requests to establish a local historic district shall be submitted to the Planning Department, which shall in turn send the request to the HPC for its recommendation to the governing body.

b. The Planning Department shall give notice in accordance with paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings, that a request has been filed and shall be considered by the HPC at a specified date and time.

3. HPC Recommendation

The HPC shall conduct a preliminary consideration of the request and, at this time, shall make a recommendation to the governing body based upon the following findings:

a. That the area is of special significance in terms of its prehistorical, historical, architectural or cultural importance; and

b. That the area possesses integrity of design, setting, materials, feeling and association.

4. Governing Body Action

Upon reviewing information provided by the applicant and staff, and the findings and recommendation from the HPC, the governing body shall determine whether to initiate a formal designation process of the proposed local historic district, including developmentClosed of the Historic District Preservation Plan. If the governing body determines a local historic district designation process shall proceed, it shall also determine when staff and the HPC should begin work based upon departmental staffing and work program priorities.

B. Historic District Preservation Plan

1. An Historic District Preservation Plan shall include an investigation and report describing the significance of the buildings, structures, features, sites, or surroundings included in the proposed historic district and a description of the boundaries of the proposed historic district, in accordance with NCGS §160D-944; principles and design review criteria (guidelines) for certificates of appropriateness as required in NCGS §160D-947; and a preservation strategy tailored to the individual needs of the specific area.

2. Historic Properties Local Review Criteria

The Historic Properties Local Review Criteria, as amended, shall be the adopted principles and design review criteria applicable to all local historic districts, and shall be specifically referenced within the Historic District Preservation Plan.

C. Action by the NC Department of Natural and Cultural Resources

In accordance with NCGS §160D-944, the NC Department of Natural and Cultural Resources shall make an analysis of and recommendations concerning the investigation and report contained in the Historic District Preservation Plan. Failure of the NC Department of Natural and Cultural Resources to submit its written analysis and recommendations within 30 days after a written request for such analysis has been received by the Department shall relieve the governing body of any responsibility for awaiting such analysis, and the governing body may at any time thereafter take action on the proposed historic district and Historic District Preservation Plan.

D. Action by the Historic Preservation Commission

1. The HPC shall conduct a public hearing and give notice in accordance with paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings, on the proposed historic district designation and the Historic District Preservation Plan, prior to making a recommendation for approval or denial to the appropriate governing body.

2. The HPC shall review the proposed historic district designation and the Historic District Preservation Plan and shall recommend to the appropriate governing body denial of the request or designation of the area.

3. The HPC shall forward its recommendation on historic district designation to the Planning Commission and to the governing body with a recommended Historic District Preservation Plan. Consideration of the Historic District Preservation Plan shall be part of the consideration of the historic district designation.

E. Action by the Planning Commission

1. The Planning Commission shall conduct a public hearing and give notice in accordance with paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings, on the proposed historic district designation and the Historic District Preservation Plan.

2. The Planning Commission shall review the proposed historic district designation and the Historic District Preservation Plan and shall recommend denial or designation of the area.

F. Action by the Governing Body

1. The governing body shall set a public hearing and shall notify property ownersClosed within the proposed historic district of the public hearing in accordance with the public hearing and notification provisions of paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings.

2. The governing body, shall hold a public hearing to consider the request to designate the historic district and the adoption of the Historic District Preservation Plan. The protest petition procedures as established for a petition for zoning map change in paragraph 3.5.13, Valid Protest Petition, may apply to the designation or amendment of an historic district.

3. If the governing body denies a request for designating an historic district, property ownersClosed may not initiate a new request to designate an historic district for the same area until at least one year after the governing body’s action to deny the request.

4. When the governing body designates an area as an historic district, the Historic District Preservation Plan for the particular historic district shall become City or County policy and all appropriate public bodies or administrative officials cited as having implementation responsibilities shall be directed to use their best efforts to ensure the effective implementation of the Plan as it is written.

3.16.3. Designation of an Historic Landmark

A. Application

1. An application for an historic landmark designation shall be submitted in accordance with paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirementss.

2. Requests for designation shall include the specific elements of the property for which historic landmark designation is proposed.

B.   Action by the Historic Preservation Commission

1. In accordance with NCGS §160D-946, the HPC shall make or cause to be made an investigation and report on the prehistorical, historical, architectural, educational or cultural significance of each buildingClosed, structureClosed, site areaCloseda or object proposed for designation or acquisition. The investigation and report shall be forwarded to the OfficeClosed of Archives and History, North Carolina Department of Natural and Cultural Resources.

C. Criteria for Designation

1. A buildingClosed, structureClosed, site areaCloseda or object may be considered for designation as an historic landmark only if all of the following three criteria are met:

a. The property must not currently be undergoing renovation unless it has been approved for state or federal tax credits in accordance with the Secretary of Interior Standards;

b. The HPC must deem and find that the buildingClosed, structureClosed, site areaCloseda, or object meets at least one of the three following criteria:

(1) Individual listing on the National Register of Historic Places or on the Study List;

(2) Statewide Significance status granted by the State Historic Preservation OfficeClosed;

(3) Integrity of location, design, setting, materials, and workmanship, feeling and association on the whole, and:

(a) Is associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of local, regional, or national history; or

(b) Is associated with the lives of personsClosed significant in local, regional, national history; or

(c) Embodies the distinctive characteristics of a type, period, or method of construction; represents the work of a master; possesses high artistic values (i.e., the architecture alone is significant in its own right); or

(d) Has yielded, or may be likely to yield, information important to Durham’s history or prehistory.

c. The governing body must deem and find that the property possesses distinction within the context or period of significance.

Commentary:  A buildingClosed, structureClosed, site areaCloseda or object whose components lack individual distinction may still be considered a landmark if the whole is significant.

2. A property shall be designated as a historic landmark only with the consent of the property owner or ownersClosed.

D. Action by the Historic Preservation Commission

1. In accordance with NCGS §160D-946, the HPC shall make or cause to be made an investigation and report on the prehistorical, historical, architectural, educational or cultural significance of each buildingClosed, structureClosed, site areaCloseda or object proposed for designation or acquisition. The investigation and report shall be forwarded to the Division of Archives and History, North Carolina Department of Cultural Resources.

2. The HPC shall hold a public hearing and give notice in accordance to paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings, on the proposed ordinance of designation. It shall recommend to the governing body, denial of designation or approval of designation of the proposed historic landmark.

E. Action by the NC Department of Natural and Cultural Resources

In accordance with NCGS §160D-946, the NC Department of Natural and Cultural Resources shall make an analysis of and recommendations concerning the investigation and report. Failure of the NC Department of Natural and Cultural Resources to submit its written analysis and recommendations within 30 days after a written request for such analysis has been received by the Department shall relieve the governing body of any responsibility for awaiting such analysis, and the governing body may at any time thereafter take action.

F. Action by the Governing Body

1. The governing body, after ensuring that the other governing body has been notified, shall hold a public hearing and give notice in accordance paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings, on the proposed ordinance of designation.

2. Following the public hearing, the governing body may adopt the ordinance of designation as proposed, adopt the ordinance of designation with any amendments it deems necessary, or reject the proposal.

G. Adoption of an Ordinance of Designation

Upon compliance with the required procedures of this section, the governing body may, for its respective jurisdiction, adopt and from time to time amend or repeal an ordinance designating one or more historic landmarks. The ordinance shall include the following information:

1. A legal description of each property designated by the ordinance, including the tax identification number for the property. The ordinance shall clearly indicate what elements of the property are designated as an historic landmark. Examples of those elements are a buildingClosed’s interior, its exterior, any specific or all outbuildings, other site elements or the entire site;

2. The name or names of the ownerClosed or ownersClosed of the property;

3. A description of those elements of the landmark that are integral to its educational, cultural, historical, architectural or prehistorical value;

4. The land area of the property;

5. A note that structural and site improvements shall require approval of a certificate of appropriateness pursuant to Sec. 3.17, Certificate of Appropriateness, if applicable; and that, for each buildingClosed, structureClosed, site areaCloseda or object, the waiting period set forth in paragraph 3.17.6, COA for Demolition, Destruction and Relocation of this Ordinance shall be observed prior to its demolition; and

6. Any other information the HPC deems necessary.

H. Historic Markers

The ordinance designating the landmark may also provide for suitable markers on the property noting that the landmark has been so designated, including but not limited to signsClosed, plaques or other appropriate indicators. If the ownerClosed consents, the signClosed shall be placed upon the property. If the ownerClosed objects, the signClosed shall be placed on a nearby public right-of-wayClosed.

I. Action Following Designation

Upon adoption of the ordinance of designation, the following provisions shall apply:

1. The ownersClosed and occupants of each designated historic landmark shall be given written notification of such designation by the Planning Director, or designee, insofar as reasonable diligence permits.

2. One copy of the ordinance and each amendment thereto shall be filed by Planning Director, or designee, in the OfficeClosed of the Register of Deeds of Durham County. Each historic landmark designated in the ordinance shall be indexed according to the name of the ownerClosed of the property in the grantee and grantor indexes in the OfficeClosed of the Register of Deeds.

3. One copy of the ordinance and each amendment thereto shall be given to the Inspections Director, or designee.

4. For historic landmarks, one copy of the ordinance and each amendment thereto shall be kept on file in the OfficeClosed of the City or County Clerk, as appropriate, and made available for public inspection at any reasonable time.

5. The fact that a buildingClosed, structureClosed, site areaCloseda or object has been designated as an historic landmark shall be clearly indicated on all maps maintained by Durham County for tax purposes for such period as the designation remains in effect.

6. The Planning Director, or designee, shall give notice of the adoption of an ordinance of designation and any amendment thereof to the Durham County Tax Supervisor. The designation and any recorded restriction upon the property limiting its use for preservation purposes shall be considered by the Tax Supervisor in appraising it for tax purposes.

J. Effect of Subdivision or Recombination

1. Designation shall remain applicable to all properties subdivided from the originally designated property.

2. When designated property is recombined with non-designated property, the designation shall remain applicable only to the improvements and portion of property originally designated, and shall not extend to improvements and the portions of the recombined property not originally designated.

3.16.4. Designation of a Landmark Sign

A. Procedure

The following procedure shall be used to designate signsClosed as Landmark SignsClosed. No signClosed shall be considered a Landmark SignClosed unless it has received that designation through this process.

1. An application for a landmark signClosed designation shall be submitted in accordance with paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirementss.

2. The Planning Director, or designee, shall forward the application and all supporting material to the Historic Preservation Commission.

3. The applications shall be considered by the Historic Preservation Commission. The Commission shall review the application and may designate the signClosed as a Landmark SignClosed, deny the designation, or request additional information in order to make a decision. A signClosed which is denied a designation shall be considered a nonconforming signClosed which shall be removed.

4. If the signClosed is designated as a Landmark SignClosed, a copy of the application shall be submitted to the Inspections Department.

5. The  Planning Department shall issue a signClosed permit for the signClosed if the signClosed is found to be structurally safe. Landmark SignsClosed shall conform to all other provisions of this section not in conflict with the privileges of the landmark designation.

6. Landmark signsClosed shall be subject to the privileges and regulations of Sec. 11.7, Landmark Signs, but Article 11, Sign Standards, shall otherwise not apply.

B. Approval Criteria

1. The Historic Preservation Commission may establish a schedule to review applications for Landmark SignClosed designations.

2. To qualify as a Landmark SignClosed, the signClosed shall meet all of the following criteria:

a. Be recognized as important to the culture or history of the jurisdiction, or possess unique characteristics, or incorporate materials or craftsmanship not commonly found in newer signsClosed.

b. Bear a close resemblance to its appearance when it was installed.

c. The current state of the signClosed is determined to be structurally sound, and it does not pose a safety hazard due to its location relative to street intersections or by extension into the public right-of-wayClosed

d. The HPC may impose conditions on the approval of a designation to address safety issues, required maintenance, or required preservation of the signClosed.  

3.16.5. Repeal of Historic District or Historic Landmark Designation

A. A petition to remove a local historic district overlay designation on property, along with revision to the applicable preservation plan, shall follow the same procedures for a zoning map change, and shall also require the following prior a public hearing with the Planning Commission:

1. The petition shall be sent to the State Historic Preservation OfficeClosed for a review consistent with paragraph 3.16.2C, Action by the NC Department of Cultural Resources.

2. A public hearing for review and recommendation by the Historic Preservation Commission consistent with paragraph 3.16.2D, Action by the Historic Preservation Commission.

B. The governing body may repeal an ordinance designating an historic district or an historic landmark. The repeal process shall be consistent with the adoption process prescribed within NCGS §160D-946. The governing body’s action to repeal an ordinance of designation shall include the reasons for the repeal and a review by the State Historic Preservation OfficeClosed.

C. When such repeal occurs, the Planning Director, or designee, shall notify the HPC and the property owner or ownersClosed. When such repeal occurs of an historic landmark designation, the Planning Director, or designee, shall also notify the Register of Deeds for Durham County and the Durham County Tax Supervisor.

3.17.1. Applicability

A. From and after the designation of an historic district or historic landmark, no exterior feature or designated portion of any buildingClosed or other site work (including masonry walls, fences, light fixtures, steps, pavement, above-ground utility and mechanical equipment, signsClosed, landscaping, and other appurtenant features) shall be erected, altered, restored, moved or demolished within a historic district or on such historic landmark until after an application for a certificate of appropriateness (COA) as to the exterior feature or designated portion has been submitted to and approved by the Historic Preservation Commission (HPC).

B. Work done by the City and County and by public utilityClosed companies shall be subject to the provisions of this section.

C. For the purposes of this section, the term "exterior feature" shall include the architectural style, general design, and general arrangement of the exterior of a buildingClosed or other structureClosed, including the kind and texture of the buildingClosed material, the size and scale of the buildingClosed, and the type and style of all windows, doors, light fixtures, signsClosed and other appurtenant features. In the case of outdoor advertising signsClosed, the term "exterior features" shall be construed to mean the style, material, size and location of all such signsClosed. These "exterior features" may include historic signsClosed and significant landscape, archaeological and natural features of the area.

D. For the purposes of this section, the term "designated portion" shall mean any portion of an historic landmark that was included in the ordinance designating the landmark, including the main structureClosed or structures, the interior or portions of the interior, any outbuildings or secondary structures, site elements and landscaping.

E. A COA shall be required whether or not another permit is required.

F. Work Not Requiring a COA

1. Nothing in this Ordinance shall be construed to prevent the ordinary maintenance or repair of any exterior feature in the historic district or on an historic landmark which does not involve a substantial changeClosed in the design, material, or outer appearance thereof, as described in the Historic Properties Local Review Criteria, as amended.

2. Nor shall this Ordinance be construed to prevent the construction, reconstruction, alteration, restoration or demolition of any such feature which is determined to be a threat to the public safety. The Inspections Director, or designee, shall certify in writing to the approving authority that such action is required for the public safety because of an unsafe or dangerous condition.

3. Nothing herein shall be construed to prevent a property ownerClosed from making any use of his or her property not prohibited by other statutes, ordinances or regulations.

4. No certificate of appropriateness shall be required for interior changes. However, this does not excuse the property ownerClosed from obtaining required buildingClosed permits for interior work.

3.17.3. Application Requirements

A. An application for a COA shall be submitted in accordance with paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirementss.

B. An applicant may file with the application any additional relevant information bearing on the application.

3.17.4. Minor Works COA

A. Pursuant to the HPC rules of procedure, the Planning Director, or designee, may approve or amend COAs for the following activities, or may refer them to the HPC for a decision:

1. Activities expressly authorized by the HPC;

2. Minor design changes to projects for which a COA has been issued by the HPC; or

3. Anything not specifically covered by this section that the Planning Director or designee determines is not so significant as to impair or affect historic, architectural, or aesthetic character.

B. A public hearing or public notice shall not be required unless the application is referred to the HPC for a major works COA.

C. Conformance to the applicable design review criteria within the adopted Historic Properties Local Review Criteria, as amended, shall be required in order to approve or amend a COA.

D. Conditions may be placed upon a COA as part of the approval in order to facilitate compliance with the Historic Properties Local Review Criteria, as amended. A violationClosed of any conditions shall be considered a violationClosed of the COA.

3.17.5. Major Works COA

The HPC shall be the approving authority for any improvement to property within a local historic district or with a local historic landmark designation that requires a COA, but does not qualify as a minor COA.

A. Notification of the Commission

The Planning Director, or designee, shall notify the members of the HPC at least seven calendar days before its regularly scheduled meeting of any pending applications scheduled for the public hearing.

B. Action by the Historic Preservation Commission

1. The HPC shall hold a public hearing for a major works COA. Public notice of applications shall be provided pursuant to paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings.

2. As part of its review procedure, the HPC may view the premises and seek the advice of the North Carolina Department of Natural and Cultural Resources or other expert advice as it may deem necessary under the circumstances.

3. The HPC shall approve, approve with modifications or conditions, or disapprove an application for a major works COA.

4. Prior to final action on an application for a certificate of appropriateness in an historic district, the HPC, using the applicable design review criteria adopted within the Historic Properties Local Review Criteria, as amended, shall make findings of fact indicating the extent to which the application is or is not consistent with the historic character and qualities of the historic district.

5. Prior to final action on an application for a certificate of appropriateness for an historic landmark, the HPC, using the and applicable design review criteria adopted within the Historic Properties Local Review Criteria, as amended, shall make findings of fact indicating the extent to which the application is or is not consistent with the historic character and qualities of the historic landmark property.

6. The HPC may not deny a certificate of appropriateness for demolition except as specified in paragraph 3.17.6, COA for Demolition, Destruction and Relocation.

C. Approval Criteria for Historic Districts

1. For historic districts, the intent of these regulations is to ensure, insofar as possible, that buildings or structures in the historic district shall be in harmony with other buildingClosed or structures located therein. However, it is not the intention of these regulations to require the reconstruction or restoration of individual or original buildings or to prohibit the demolition or removal of such buildings or to impose architectural styles from particular historic periods. In considering new constructionClosed, the HPC shall encourage contemporary design which is harmonious with the character of the historic district.

2. In granting a COA, the HPC shall take into account, in accordance with the Historic Properties Local Review Criteria, as amended:

a. The historic or architectural significance of the structureClosed under consideration in relation to the historic value of the district;

b. The exterior form and appearance of any proposed additions or modifications to that structureClosed; and

c. The effect of such additions or modifications upon other structures in the vicinity.

3. The HPC may place conditions upon a COA as part of the approval in order to facilitate compliance with the Historic Properties Local Review Criteria, as amended. A violationClosed of any condition shall be considered a violationClosed of the COA.

D. Approval Criteria for Historic Landmarks

1. In granting a COA, the HPC shall take into account in accordance with the principles and design review criteria adopted for historic landmarks, namely the Historic Properties Local Review Criteria, as amended:

a. The historic or architectural significance of the structureClosed, site or setting under consideration; and

b. The exterior form and appearance of any proposed additions or modifications to the structureClosed, site or setting.

2. The intent of these regulations is to ensure, insofar as possible, that changes to buildings or structures designated as historic landmarks shall be in harmony with the historic character that was cited as the reasons for designation.

3. The HPC may place conditions upon a COA as part of the approval in order to facilitate compliance with the Historic Properties Local Review Criteria, as amended. A violationClosed of any condition shall be considered a violationClosed of the COA.

E. Deferral of Application

1. An applicant for a COA may request that the HPC’s consideration of the application be deferred to a specific date.

2. Upon such request, the Planning Director, or designee, shall have the authority to grant the deferral.

3. A request for deferral shall be made in writing to the Planning Director, or designee, at least ten days prior to the scheduled consideration of the application and shall indicate the date to which the deferral is requested and the reasons for the deferral. Only one deferral shall be permitted for each application.

F. Time Limits

1. Final action shall be taken upon any application for a COA within 180 days after the complete application is submitted to the Planning Director or designee. Such 180-day time period shall include any continuance or deferred consideration by the HPC or deferral granted as requested by the applicant under paragraph 3.17.5E, Deferral of Application. If final action is not taken within such 180-day time period, the application shall be deemed approved.

2. A master COA shall expire four years after the effective date, and all other COAs shall expire two years after the effective date, if:

a. A building permitClosed or other developmentClosed permit has not been issued;

b. A buildingClosed or other developmentClosed permit has expired; or

c. If work not requiring a permit has not been initiated.

3.17.6. COA for Demolition, Destruction, and Relocation

A. An application for a certificate of appropriateness authorizing the demolition, destruction or relocation of a structureClosed in a designated historic district or of a designated historic landmark shall not be denied. However, the effective date of such a certificate of appropriateness may be delayed for a period of up to 365 days from the date of approvalClosed. This maximum period of delay shall be reduced by the HPC when it finds that the ownerClosed would suffer extreme hardship or be permanently deprived of all beneficial use of or return from such structureClosed or landmark by virtue of the delay. During such period, the HPC may negotiate with the ownerClosed and with any other parties in an effort to find a means of preserving the structureClosed or landmark.

B. If the HPC finds that the structureClosed has no particular significance or value toward maintaining the character of an historic district, it shall waive all or part of such period and authorize earlier demolition or removal.

C. If the HPC finds that the structureClosed has no particular significance or value toward maintaining the character of an historic district, it shall waive all or part of such period and authorize earlier demolition or removal. An application for demolition, destruction and relocation of a buildingClosed, site or structureClosed determined by the State Historic Preservation OfficerClosed as having statewide significance as defined in the criteria of the National Register of Historic Places may be denied except where the HPC finds that the ownerClosed would suffer extreme hardship or be permanently deprived of all beneficial use or return from such structureClosed or landmark by virtue of the denial.

3.17.7. Master COA for Public Projects

A. Rather than obtaining individual COA for each proposed project in an historic district, the City and County and public utilityClosed companies may instead obtain a master COA from the HPC.

B. The provisions of this section that apply to COAs shall also apply to master COAs.

C. In addition to acquiring a master COA, the City and County and any public utilityClosed companies shall notify the City Manager or County Manager, as appropriate, prior to performing any work within any historic district. In emergency situations, as determined by the Inspections Director, or designee, notification by the next work dayClosed is acceptable. Such work shall be done in accordance with the Historic Properties Local Review Criteria, as amended, adopted for the historic district as part of the Historic District Preservation Plan. The City Manager or County Manager, as appropriate, may inspect all work done pursuant to a master COA.

3.17.8. Submission of New Application

If the HPC denies an application for a COA, a new application affecting the same property may be submitted only if substantial changesClosed are made in plans for the proposed construction, reconstruction, alteration, restoration, moving or demolition, or if conditions related to the historic district or historic landmark or surrounding uses have changed substantially.

3.17.9. Local and State Coordination

The HPC shall use all reasonable efforts to expedite any concurrent process with the North Carolina Department of Natural and Cultural Resources if such a process is desired by the applicant for the purpose of securing both a certificate of appropriateness and a Federal historic preservation tax credit.

3.17.10. Specific Enforcement

A. Compliance with the terms of a COA shall be enforced by the Inspections Director, or designee. Construction or other work which fails to comply with a COA shall be a violationClosed of this Ordinance and subject to Article 15, Enforcement. The discontinuance of work for a period of six months shall be considered a failure to comply with a COA.

B. Nothing contained in this section shall prohibit, impair or limit in any way the power of the City or County to prevent the construction, reconstruction, alteration, restoration or removal of buildings, structures, appurtenant fixtures or outdoor signsClosed in the historic district in violationClosed of the provisions of this Ordinance. The enforcement of any remedy provided herein shall not prevent the enforcement of any other remedy or remedies provided herein or in other ordinances or laws.

C. Failure to obtain a required COA prior to commencing work shall be subject to Article 15, Enforcement.

3.17.11. Appeal

An appealClosed of a decision of the Commission in granting or denying any certificate of appropriateness is taken by filing a petition for certiorari with the Durham County Superior Court.

3.18.1. Applicability

OwnersClosed of certain historic properties are required to maintain their properties and not allow them to fall into disrepair. The requirements of this subsection are applicable only to certain properties, termed "historic properties" in this subsection. That term as used in this subsection is defined to include designated historic landmarks and properties identified as "contributing" or "pivotal" in designated historic districts.

A. Conditions of Neglect Defined and Prohibited

OwnersClosed shall maintain or cause to be maintained the exterior and structural features of their historic properties and not allow conditions of neglect to occur on such properties. Conditions of neglect are as defined below. It shall be a violationClosed of this Ordinance to not remedy a condition of neglect within the period of time set by a final administrative determination, as described in subsequent subsections of this Ordinance. Conditions of neglect include the following:

1. Deterioration of exterior walls, foundations, or other vertical support that causes leaning, sagging, splitting, listing, or buckling.

2. Deterioration of flooring or floor supports, roofs, or other horizontal members that causes leaning, sagging, splitting, listing, or buckling.

3. Deterioration of external chimneys that causes leaning, sagging, splitting, listing, or buckling.

4. Deterioration or crumbling of exterior plasters or mortars.

5. Ineffective waterproofing of exterior walls, roofs, and foundations, including broken windows or doors.

6. Defective protection or lack of weather protection for exterior wall and roof coverings, including lack of paint, or weathering due to lack of paint or other protective coveringClosed.

7. Rotting, holes, and other forms of decay.

8. Deterioration of exterior stairs, porches, handrails, window and door frames, cornices, entablatures, wall facings, and architectural details that causes delamination, instability, loss of shape and form, or crumbling.

9. Heaving, subsidence, or cracking of sidewalks, steps, or pathways.

10. Deterioration of fences, gates, and accessory structures.

11. Deterioration that has a detrimental effect on the surrounding historic district, or on the special character of the historic landmark.

12. Deterioration that contributes to a hazardous or unsafe condition.

3.18.2. Process and Administration

A. Director Investigation and Determination

1. Initiation by Petition

The initial determination that there is a condition of neglect shall be made by the Planning Director, or designee, after an investigation that is initiated by a petition from any personClosed who is familiar with the subject property, which may include but not be limited to a City employee.

2. Notice of Investigation

On receipt of a petition, the Director, or designee, shall notify the ownersClosed in writing of the allegation and the process for making a decision regarding the petition, including any applicable deadlines. Among other things, the notice shall offer the ownerClosed the opportunity to meet in personClosed with the Director, or designee, and to present any relevant information. Notice shall be delivered by personalClosed service, or by certified or registered mail, return receipt requested. If certified mail is refused or unclaimed, notice may be delivered by first class mail, and shall be considered effective if such mail is not returned by the post officeClosed within 15 days of mailing. In the case of notice by first class mail noticeClosede shall also be posted on the property. Notice of the investigation may also be given to the ownersClosed of nearby or adjacentClosed properties or neighborhood associations.

3. Responsibilities of Director

The Planning Director or designee shall:

a. Investigate the allegation that a condition of neglect exists;

b. Hold one or more meetings at a time to be set by the Director, or designee, in which the ownerClosed, other personsClosed who have received notice, or other interested personsClosed may give information;

c. Issue a written determination, supported by findings of fact, regarding the allegation within 45 days of the ownerClosed’s receipt of notice;

d. Include within the determination a time period for correcting the condition of neglect, if a condition of neglect has been found;

e. Retain all information presented by the ownerClosed or other personsClosed;

f. Deliver the written determination through any of the means for delivery of notice, as described above;

g. Designate the written determination as a final administrative determination with the right of appealClosed to the HPC; and

h. Include information regarding rights to a de novo hearing before the HPC.

B. Suspension of Process

The above process may be suspended in the event the ownerClosed agrees in writing to correct the alleged condition of neglect within a time period determined to be reasonable by the Director, or designee. If the condition is not corrected within that time period, the process shall continue where it was suspended.

C. Appeal of Director’s Determination

1. If the property ownerClosed disagrees with the Director’s determination, the ownerClosed can appealClosed and may request a de novo hearing before the HPC.

2. The request shall be delivered to the Planning Department, in writing, within 30 days of receipt of the Director’s determination.

3. The HPC shall hold a quasi-judicial hearing on the issue of whether demolition by neglect is occurring on the property. Procedures that would be followed by the Board of Adjustment (BOA) in a quasi-judicial proceeding shall be used. The Director’s determination shall be considered an administrative determination, which has been appealedClosed to the HPC as allowed pursuant to paragraph 2.5.4B, Demolition by Neglect.

4. The HPC’s determination to overturn the administrative determination shall be passed by the standards established in paragraph 2.4.6.

a. The HPC’s written decision shall include findings of fact and conclusions regarding demolition by neglect consistent with this subsection.

b. It shall be delivered to the appealingClosed party by certified mail, return receipt requested.

5. AppealClosed from the determination can be taken by filing a petition in the nature of certiorari with the Durham County Superior Court. If the decision is not appealedClosed it shall be considered a final decision subject to enforcement with no rights of appealClosed.

D. Safeguards from Undue Economic Hardship

1. Right of Claim of Economic Hardship

The property ownerClosed is entitled to make a claim of undue economic hardship if the ownerClosed is unable to make needed repairs to the property because it is economically unfeasible.

2. Issuance of Stay for Economic Hardship

In the event that the ownerClosed and/or other parties in interest do not wish to contest the determination regarding the condition of neglect, but do wish to petition for a claim of undue economic hardship, the Director’s order shall be stayed until after the HPC’s determination regarding the claim.

3. Process

If a claim of undue economic hardship is made, the Planning Director or designee shall receive all information from the property ownersClosed that the HPC is entitled to receive pursuant to this Ordinance, make a determination regarding whether there is undue economic hardship, and developClosed a plan for dealing with such hardship, if it is found to exist. The recommendation and plan shall be sent to the ownerClosed, by certified mail, return receipt requested, with notice of the ownerClosed’s rights to appealClosed to the HPC within 30 days of receipt. If the ownerClosed disagrees with the recommendation and plan, the ownerClosed may request a hearing before the HPC. In the event of such a request, the hearing shall be a quasi-judicial hearing, in the nature of a BOA hearing and the decision shall be in writing, supported by findings and conclusions. The Planning Director’s determination as to economic hardship and the plan for dealing with that hardship shall be considered a final administrative determination, and any HPC decision altering such recommendation or plan shall be passed by the standards established in paragraph 2.4.6, Decisions.

4. Evidence Regarding Undue Economic Hardship

When a claim of undue economic hardship is made owing to the effects of this Article, the ownerClosed and/or parties in interest shall, where reasonably possible, provide the evidence below, describing the circumstances of hardship, and any additional evidence requested by the Director, or designee, or HPC or evidence the ownerClosed considers relevant.

a. Nature of ownership (individual, business, or nonprofit) or legal possession, custody, and control.

b. Financial resources of the ownerClosed and/or parties in interest.

c. Cost of repairs.

d. Assessed value of the land and improvements.

e. Real estate taxes for the previous two years.

f. Amount paid for the property, date of purchase, and party from whom purchased, including a description of the relationship between the ownerClosed and the personClosed from whom the property was purchased, or other means of acquisition of title, such as by gift or inheritance.

g. Annual debt service, if any, for previous two years.

h. Any listing of the property for sale or rent, price asked, and offers received, if any.

i. Annual gross income, if any, from the property for the previous two years.

j. Itemized operating and maintenance expenses for the previous two years, including proof that adequate and competent management procedures were followed.

k. Annual cash flow, if any, for the previous two years.

5. Plan to Relieve Economic Hardship

A recommended plan to relieve the economic hardship shall include, but is not limited to, property tax relief as may be allowed under North Carolina law, loans or grants from the City, the County, or other public, private, or nonprofit sources, acquisition by purchase or eminent domain, changes in applicable zoning regulations, or relaxation of the provisions of this Article sufficient to mitigate the undue economic hardship. The Director, or designee, shall issue an order regarding the time period during which the property should be repaired, taking into account the provisions of the recommended plan.

E. Other City Powers; City’s Election of Remedies

Nothing contained within this Article shall diminish the City’s power to declare a buildingClosed unsafe or in violationClosed of the minimum housing code or any other applicable statute or code. In addition, the procedures described herein are mandatory only for determinations being made solely under the authority of this section. Where other sections of the City Code apply, the City may, in its discretion, choose to process any action regarding the property under such other provisions alone, or under such provisions along with these provisions concurrently, or solely under these provisions. The City may also suspend the procedures of this section at any time if an action has been initiated under other applicable law.

F. Penalties and Remedies

Enforcement of this Article shall be by any one or more of the following methods, and the institution of any action under any of these methods shall not relieve any party from any other civil or criminal proceeding prescribed for violationsClosed and prohibitions.

1. Equitable Remedy

The City may apply for any appropriate equitable remedy to enforce the provisions of this Article.

2. Order of Abatement

The City can apply for and the court may enter an order of abatement. An order of abatement may direct that improvements or repairs be made, or that any other action be taken that is necessary to bring the property into compliance with this Article. Whenever the party is cited for contempt by the court and the City has executed the order of abatement, the City shall have a lien on the property for the cost of executing the order of abatement.

3. Civil Penalty

Civil penalties can be assessed for failure to comply with a final administrative determination or an un-appealed HPC decision under the provisions and guidelines for assessing such penalties for zoning code violationsClosed. Prior to imposing a civil penalty, the City-County Planning Department shall deliver a written notice by personalClosed service or by registered mail or by certified mail, return receipt requested, to the personClosed responsible for the violationClosed indicating the nature of the violationClosed and ordering corrective action. Where the violationClosed is the failure to remedy a condition of neglect within the time periods provided by the Director, or designee, or the HPC no additional time period for compliance need be given. The notice shall include information regarding the possible assessment of civil penalties and other possible enforcement actions. If this notice is appealedClosed to the Board of Adjustment, the Board shall not rehear any issue that was heard by the HPC or could have been so heard had an appealClosed to the HPC been made. Rather, the Board of Adjustment shall limit the scope of its review to whether there has been compliance with the Director’s determination or the HPC’s determination, as applicable.

3.19.1. General

A. The governing bodies are the approving authority for amendments to the text of this Ordinance.

B. Amendments to the text of this Ordinance shall be made in accordance with the provisions of this section.

C. A request to amend the text of this Ordinance may be initiated by the governing body, the Board of Adjustment, the Planning Commission, the City Manager, the County Manager, the Planning Director, or designee, or a citizen.

D. Pre-Application Conference

Pursuant to paragraph 3.2.2, Pre-Application Conference, a pre-application conference is required prior to the submittal of a text amendment application.

3.19.2. Action by the Planning Director

A. The Planning Director, or designee, shall be responsible for review and recommendation regarding amendments to the text of this Ordinance that affect only City or County jurisdictions.

B. When a text amendment is initiated, the Planning Director, or designee, shall draft an appropriate ordinance and present that ordinance to the Planning Commission for review and recommendation at a public hearing.

C. A request to amend the text of this Ordinance may be initiated by the governing body, the Board of Adjustment, the Planning Commission, the City Manager, the County Manager, the Planning Director, or designee, or a citizen.

D. Voiding of an Application

The Planning Director or designee may consider applications withdrawn and voided due to the failure of the applicant to submit required information within 90 days of a request for such information.

3.19.3. JCCPC Review

The JCCPC shall be responsible for review and direction regarding amendments to the text of this Ordinance that affect both the City and County jurisdictions prior to review by the Planning Commission. This responsibility does not create a legal obligation for review of text amendments. Among other instances, review may not occur in the event that the City and County Managers, after consultation with the chair and vice-chair of the JCCPC, determine that delay is not in the public interest.

3.19.4. Action by the Planning Commission

A. General Procedures

1. Before making any recommendation on a text amendment, the Planning Commission shall consider any recommendations from the Planning Director, or designee, and shall conduct a public hearing where interested parties may be heard.

2. Notice and public hearing requirements shall be in accordance with paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings.

3. The Commission shall make its recommendation within 90 days of its initial public hearing unless the text amendment is granted expedited status.

4. When a recommendation is not made within the time periods established in this section, the governing body may process the request without a Commission recommendation.

B. Changed Application

If the applicant makes significant changes to the application for a text amendment after the Commission has made its recommendation, the Planning Director, or designee, may refer the modified request back to the Commission for an additional public hearing.

C. Expedited Hearing

1. If the governing body has set an expedited hearing concerning a request, in accordance with paragraph 3.19.5B, Expedited Hearing, a public hearing before the Commission shall be held at the first available hearing date or prior to the hearing before the governing body.

2. The Planning Commission may not continue, nor may a deferral be granted for, a request that is subject to an expedited public hearing.

3.19.5. Action by Governing Body

A. General Procedures

1. Before taking action on a text amendment, the governing body shall consider the recommendations of the Planning Commission and Planning Director, or designee, and shall conduct a public hearing.

2. Except for an emergency moratorium or a short term moratorium of 60 or fewer days (which shall comply with the provisions of paragraph 3.19.6, Development Moratoria), notice and public hearing requirements shall be in accordance with paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings.

3. Following the public hearing, the governing body may approve the amendment, deny the amendment, or send the amendment back to the Planning Commission or a committee of the governing body for additional consideration.

4. Text amendments, if approved, shall only have applicability within the jurisdiction of the governing body that approved the change.

B. Expedited Hearing

1. The governing body, in situations in which it determines certain standards have been met, may expedite the hearing process on a proposed or prospective amendment.

2. The governing body may consider a written request requesting an expedited hearing process. The request shall identify and support the reasons for such expedited consideration.

3. In order to grant the request, the governing body shall find that at least one of the criteria below has been met:

a. Deadlines set by the local, State or Federal government for receipt of application for needed funding, designation or other regulations concerning the property make expedited consideration necessary;

b. The prospective text amendment results from an emergency beyond the control of the applicant, such as response to a disaster;

c. The prospective text amendment addresses an urgent matter of public health or safety; or

d. The prospective text amendment addresses issues raised in threatened, actual, or potential litigation against the jurisdiction that made expedited consideration necessary.

4. A hearing before the governing body may occur upon the receipt of a Planning Commission recommendation, or the expiration of a 30-day period, whichever comes earlier.

3.19.6. Development Moratoria

A. Statutory Procedures

DevelopmentClosed moratoria, if necessary, shall be considered and processed in accordance with the special notice provisions, required statements, and other requirements of NCGS §160D-107.

B. Resolution

A public hearing to impose either a moratorium of 60 or fewer days (hereafter a “short-term moratorium”) or a lengthier moratorium of 61 days to a year may be initiated by a governing body for that body’s jurisdiction upon passage of a resolution, including appropriate supportive findings, that calls for a public hearing. Passage of such a resolution shall be considered a “call for public hearing” under the above-cited statutes and shall allow the jurisdiction to stop acceptance, review, and approval of applications for developmentClosed approvals described in the above-cited statutes or such other similar developmentClosed approvals created under this Ordinance or other developmentClosed ordinances.

C. Notice and Hearing

If the call is for a short-term moratorium, Planning Commission review shall not be required, and one published notice not less than seven days prior to the hearing shall be given, as allowed under the above-cited statutes, in lieu of other notices required by statute or this Ordinance. If the call is for a lengthier moratorium, the procedure followed shall be as set forth in the provisions for expedited hearings for text amendments above. The need for a moratorium shall be considered “an urgent matter of public health or safety” as required for approval of an expedited hearing. Emergency moratoria shall not require compliance with any procedures set forth in this Ordinance, other than an unadvertised public hearing, and an ordinance making the findings required below.

D. Duration

The duration of any moratorium shall be reasonable in light of the specific conditions that warrant imposition of the moratorium and may not exceed the period of time necessary to correct, modify, or resolve such conditions. Any ordinance establishing a lengthier moratorium shall include a provision that allows for termination of the moratorium by resolution of the governing body prior to the express expiration date if the conditions requiring the moratorium have been adequately addressed so that the moratorium is no longer necessary.

E. Required Statements

An ordinance establishing a moratorium shall contain all the required findings set forth in NCGS §160D-107, including but not limited to the conditions that necessitate the moratorium, alternatives, developmentClosed approvals subject to the moratorium, termination date, and reasonableness of the moratorium period.

F. Extensions

A moratorium shall only be extended upon compliance with NCGS §160D-107 and the existence of new facts and conditions warranting an extension.

G. Emergency Moratorium

In the event that there is an imminent and substantial threat to public health or safety, an ordinance imposing an emergency moratorium can be considered by a governing body without prior resolution or public notice of the hearing on such moratorium.

3.20.1. Applicability

A. This section establishes a procedure for obtaining a statutory vested rightClosed in conformance with NCGS §160D-108 and 160D-108.1.

B. New or amended zoning regulations shall not apply to a property with an established vested rightClosed until the vested rightClosed expires or is terminated.

C. Statutory Vested Rights

Pursuant to NCGS §160D-108, the following are the types of statutory vested rightsClosed that may be claimed:

1. DevelopmentClosed or subdivisionClosed permit approvals in accordance with NCGS §143-755;

2. A site-specific vesting plan;

3. A multi-phased developmentClosed pursuant to NCGS §160D-108(f); or

4. A developmentClosed agreement pursuant to NCGS §160D, Chapter 10.

3.20.2. Procedure for Determination

A. An application for a common law or statutory vested rightsClosed determination shall be submitted to the Planning director or designee in accordance with paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirementss, or as allowed per NCGS 160D-108. AppealClosed may be taken in accordance with NCGS 160D-108(h).

B. Applications shall include, at a minimum, the following information in addition to the standard information required pursuant to paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirementss:

1. Information on the proposed uses of the property that the applicant wishes to vest;

2. The length of time for which vesting is requested; and

3. A listing of those provisions of this Ordinance from which vesting is requested.

3.20.3. Duration

A. Vesting shall remain valid so long as the developmentClosed permit remains valid, or as otherwise allowed per this Ordinance. DevelopmentClosed permits shall be valid for one year unless otherwise indicated for a longer duration in this Ordinance.

B. Except where a longer vesting period is provided by statute or local regulation, the statutory vesting granted by this section, once established, expires for an uncompleted developmentClosed project if developmentClosed work is intentionally and voluntarily discontinued for a period of not less than 24 consecutive months, and the statutory vesting period granted by this section for a nonconforming use of property expires if the use is intentionally and voluntarily discontinued for a period of not less than 24 consecutive months. The 24-month discontinuance period is automatically tolled pursuant to 160D-108(d).

C. A vested rightClosed shall run with the land in accordance with NCGS 160D-108(i).

3.20.4. Site Specific Vesting Plan

The following is in accordance with NCGS 160D-108.1, and such statute shall apply where there are conflicts.

A. Applicability

1. In order to qualify as a "site specific vesting plan," a plan shall be a development planClosed approved as a site planClosed or preliminary platClosed in accordance with Sec. 3.5, Zoning Map Changes; a platClosed approved in accordance with Sec. 3.6, Subdivision Review; or a site planClosed approved in accordance with Sec. 3.7, Site Plan Review.

2. Landowners seeking vested rightsClosed on platsClosed, special use permit applications, or other plans that would not normally receive site planClosed approval, can apply for vested rightsClosed protection through submittal of an application which contains the identical information, fee, and plans required for a complete site planClosed application and an additional fee for a vested rightsClosed public hearing.

B. Action by the Planning Director

Once the application has been determined complete, the Planning Director, or designee, shall schedule a public hearing, give public notice as set forth in paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings, and forward a copy of the application with all related materials to the appropriate governing body.

C. Action by the Governing Body

1. The governing body shall hold a public hearing as required pursuant to NCGS § 160D-108.1.

2. Approval by the governing body shall confer upon the ownerClosed of the property a "vested rightClosed" as defined in NCGS §160D-108.1(b), effective on the date of approvalClosed. The governing body may condition the approval upon terms and conditions reasonably necessary to protect the public health, safety, and welfare.

D. Effect of Approved Vested Rights

1. Following approval of a site specific vesting plan, nothing in this section shall exempt such a plan from subsequent reviews and approvals to ensure compliance with the terms and conditions of the original approval, provided that such reviews and approvals are not inconsistent with the original approval.

2. Nothing in this section shall prohibit the revocation of the original approval or other remedies for failure to comply with applicable terms and conditions of the approval or with this Ordinance.

3. The establishment of a vested rightClosed shall not preclude the application of new laws or regulations as is allowed under NCGS §160D-108. In addition, it shall not preclude overlay zoning that imposes additional requirements, but does not affect the allowable type or intensity of use, or ordinances or regulations that are general in nature and are applicable to all property subject to land use regulation by the City or County. Otherwise applicable new or amended regulations shall become effective with respect to property that is subject to a site specific vesting plan upon the expiration or termination of the vested rightClosed in accordance with this section.

4. A vested rightClosed is not a personalClosed right, but shall be attached to and run with the applicable property. After approval of a site specific vesting plan, all successors to the original landowner shall be entitled to exercise such right while applicable.

E. Duration

1. A vested rightClosed for a site-specific vesting plan shall remain vested for the period specified by the governing body, which shall be a minimum of two years but no more than five years from the date of the vested rightsClosed determination. The expiration and validity of site plansClosed and platsClosed issued pursuant to the vested rightsClosed determination that extend beyond the vesting period shall be governed by the provisions of this ordinance. Substantial amendments and modifications to an approved site specific vesting plan shall not be accorded "vested rightsClosed" unless such changes are processed as a new "site specific vesting plan." Each approved site specific vesting plan shall contain the following notation: "Approval of this plan establishes a vested rightClosed under NCGS §160D-108.1. Unless terminated at an earlier date, the zoning vested rightsClosed shall be valid until (Insert date)."

2. A building permitClosed shall not expire or be revoked because of the passage of time while a zoning vested rightClosed under this section is outstanding.

3. A right which has been vested as provided in this section shall terminate at the end of the applicable vesting period with respect to portions of the developmentClosed that do not have approved and continuously valid site plansClosed and preliminary platsClosed, or buildings and uses for which no valid building permitClosed applications have been filed.

F. Termination

A vested rightClosed as provided in this section shall terminate when any one of the following circumstances apply:

1. At the end of the applicable vesting period;

2. With the written consent of the affected landowner;

3. Upon findings by the governing body by ordinance and after public hearing, that natural or man-made hazards on or in the immediate vicinity of the property, if uncorrected, would pose a serious threat to the public health, safety, and welfare if the project were to proceed as contemplated in the site specific vesting plan;

4. Upon payment of compensation to the affected ownerClosed for all costs, expenses, and other losses incurred by the landowner together with interest;

5. Upon findings by the governing body by ordinance and after public hearing, that the landowner or the landowner’s representative intentionally supplied inaccurate information or made material misrepresentations which made a difference in the approval by the governing body of the site specific vesting plan; or

6. Upon the enactment of a State or Federal law or regulation or local ordinances enacted in compliance with such laws or regulations that preclude developmentClosed as contemplated in the site specific development planClosed.

3.20.5. Annexation

A. Property that is annexed shall retain any vested rightsClosed throughout the original vesting period subject to the limitations of paragraph B below.

B. A property ownerClosed petitioning for annexation shall submit a signedClosed statement declaring any existing vested rightClosed with respect to the properties subject to annexation, if the ownerClosed wishes to maintain the vested rightClosed. The failure to signClosed such a statement shall terminate any such vested rightClosed.

3.20.6. Limitations

Nothing in this section shall be deemed to create any vested rightsClosed other than those established under NCGS §160D-108 and 108.1. In the event that NCGS §160D-108 is repealed, the provisions of this section are no longer effective.

3.21.2. Floodplain Administrator

A. Designation

The Planning Director, or designee, shall serve as the Floodplain AdministratorClosed. For this purpose, the Planning Director, or designee, shall receive training and certification from the Association of Floodplain Managers.

B. Duties and Responsibilities

Duties of the Floodplain AdministratorClosed shall include, but not be limited to:

1. Review all floodplain developmentClosed applications and issue permits for all proposed developmentClosed with in Special Flood Hazard Areas and Future Conditions FloodClosed Hazard Areas to assure that the requirements of this ordinance have been satisfied;

2. Advise permittees that additional Federal or State permits (i.e., WetlandsClosed, ErosionClosed and SedimentationClosed Control, Riparian Buffers, MiningClosed, etc.) may be required, and if specific Federal or State permits are known, require that copies of such permits be provided and maintained on file with the floodplain development permitClosed;

3. Notify adjacentClosed communities and the North Carolina Department of Crime Control and Public Safety, Division of Emergency Management, State Coordinator for the National Flood InsuranceClosed Program prior to any alteration or relocation of a watercourseClosed, and submit evidence of such notification to the Federal Emergency Management AgencyClosed;

4. Assure that maintenance is provided within the altered or relocated portion of said watercourseClosed so that the flood-carrying capacity is not diminished;

5. Prevent encroachmentsClosed within floodwaysClosed and non-encroachment areasClosed unless the certification and flood hazard reduction provisions of 8.4.3E, FloodwayClosed and Non-Encroachment AreasClosed, are met;

6. Obtain actual elevation (in relation to mean sea levelClosed) of the reference levelClosed (including basementClosed) of all attendant utilities of all new or substantially improvedClosed structures, in accordance with the certification requirements in Sec. 3.21, Floodplain Development PermitClosed;

7. Obtain the actual elevation (in relation to mean sea levelClosed) to which the new or substantially improvedClosed structures and all utilities have been floodproofed, in accordance with the certification requirements in Sec. 3.21, Floodplain Development PermitClosed;

8. Obtain actual elevation (in relation to mean sea levelClosed) of all public utilitiesClosed, in accordance with the certification requirements in Sec. 3.21, Floodplain Development PermitClosed;

9. When floodproofingClosed is utilized for a particular structureClosed, obtain certifications from a registered professional engineer or architect in accordance with the certification requirements in Sec. 3.21, Floodplain Development PermitClosed and paragraph 8.4.3, Standards;

10. Where interpretation is needed as to the exact location of boundaries of the Special Flood Hazard Areas or Future Conditions FloodClosed Hazard Areas (for example, where there appears to be a conflict between a mapped boundary and actual field conditions), make the necessary interpretation. The personClosed contesting the location of the boundary shall be given a reasonable opportunity to appealClosed the interpretation as provided in this Article;

11. When Base Flood Elevation (BFE)Closed data has not been provided in accordance with paragraph 8.4.2, Applicability, obtain, review, and reasonably utilize any Base Flood Elevation (BFE)Closed data, along with floodwayClosed data and/or non-encroachment areaClosed data available from a Federal, State, or other source, including data developedClosed pursuant to paragraph 8.4.3.C, Floodplains without Base FloodClosed Elevations, in order to administer the provisions of this ordinance;

12. When Base Flood Elevation (BFE)Closed data is provided but no floodwayClosed nor non-encroachment areaClosed data has been provided in accordance with paragraph 8.4.2, Applicability, obtain, review, and reasonably utilize any floodwayClosed data, and/or non-encroachment areaClosed data available from a Federal, State, or other source in order to administer the provisions of this ordinance;

13. When the lowest ground elevation of a parcelClosed or structureClosed located within Zone AE is above the Base Flood Elevation (BFE)Closed, advise the property ownerClosed of the option to apply for a Letter of Map Amendment LOMAClosedA) from FEMA. Maintain a copy of the Letter of Map Amendment LOMAClosedA) issued by FEMA in the floodplain development permitClosed file;

14. Permanently maintain all records that pertain to the administration of this ordinance and make these records available for public inspection, subject to the Privacy Act of 1974, as amended;

15. Make on-site inspections of work in progress. As the work pursuant to a floodplain development permitClosed progresses, the Floodplain AdministratorClosed shall make as many inspections of the work as may be necessary to ensure that the work is being done according to the provisions of the local ordinance and the terms of the permit. In exercising this power, the Floodplain AdministratorClosed, or designee, has a right, upon presentation of proper credentials, to enter on any premises within the jurisdiction of the community at any reasonable hour for the purposes of inspection or other enforcement action;

16. Issue stop-work orders as required. Whenever a buildingClosed or part thereof is being constructed, reconstructed, altered, or repaired in violationClosed of this ordinance, the Floodplain AdministratorClosed may order the work to be immediately stopped. The stop-work order shall be in writing and directed to the personClosed doing the work. The stop-work order shall state the specific work to be stopped, the specific reason(s) for the stoppage, and the condition(s) under which the work may be resumed;

17. Revoke floodplain developmentClosed permits as required. The Floodplain AdministratorClosed may revoke and require the return of the floodplain development permitClosed by notifying the permit holder in writing stating the reason(s) for the revocation. Permits shall be revoked for any substantial departure from the approved application, plans, or specifications; for refusal or failure to comply with the requirements of State or local laws; or for false statements or misrepresentations made in securing the permit. Any floodplain development permitClosed mistakenly issued in violationClosed of an applicable State or local law may also be revoked;

18. Make periodic inspections throughout all Special Flood Hazard Areas within the jurisdiction of the community. The floodplain administratorClosed and each member of his or her inspections department shall have a right, upon presentation of proper credentials, to enter on any premises within the territorial jurisdiction of the department at any reasonable hour for the purposes of inspection or other enforcement action;

19. Maintain a current map repository to include, but not limited to, the FIS Report, FIRM and/or other official flood maps/studies adopted under paragraph 8.4.2, Applicability, including any revisions thereto including Letters of Map Change, issued by the State and/or FEMA. Notify State and FEMA of mapping needs; and

20. Follow through with corrective procedures of Sec. 15.6, Floodplain and Flood Damage Protection Enforcement and Penalties.

21. Maintain records of all floodplain developmentClosed permits, actions by the DevelopmentClosed Review Board, and special use permits approving fill or developmentClosed in Special Flood Hazard Areas and Future Conditions FloodClosed Hazard Areas and report on them to the Federal Emergency Management AgencyClosed upon request.

3.21.3. Base Flood Elevations

A. Basis for Determination in Mapped Areas

Base floodClosed elevations shall be based upon the Flood InsuranceClosed Rate studies described in paragraph 8.4.2, Applicability, when such studies define a base floodClosed elevation.

B. DevelopmentClosed, including the construction of structures that only require buildingClosed permits and land disturbing activityClosed within Special Flood Hazard Areas or Future Conditions FloodClosed Hazard Areas, as identified by the Federal Emergency Management AgencyClosed in the most current Flood InsuranceClosed Rate Studies, which are hereby adopted by reference and declared to be a part of this section, shall be prohibited unless carried out pursuant to the general standards in paragraph 8.4.3, Standards, or expressly authorized pursuant to paragraph 8.4.4, DevelopmentClosed in Special Flood Hazard Areas and Future Conditions FloodClosed Hazard Areas.

C. When Base Flood has not been Determined

1. When base floodClosed elevations have not been determined, the Inspections Director, or designee, acting as the Floodplain AdministratorClosed, may require FEMA accepted hydrologic and hydraulic engineering studies, or may obtain, review, and reasonably utilize any base floodClosed elevation data and floodwayClosed or non-encroachment areaClosed data available from a Federal, State, or other source in determining the appropriate base floodClosed elevation.

2. On small streamsClosed where no base floodClosed data has been provided, no encroachmentsClosed, including fill, new constructionClosed, substantial improvementsClosed or new developmentClosed, shall be permitted within the setbacksClosed established in Sec. 8.5, Riparian Buffer Protection Standards, or Sec. 8.7, Watershed Protection Overlay Standards, or 20 feet each side from top of bank, or five times the width of the streamClosed, whichever is greatest.

3.21.4. Application Requirements

A. Application for a floodplain development permitClosed shall be made to the Floodplain AdministratorClosed, or designee, prior to any developmentClosed activities proposed to be located within Special Flood Hazard Areas and Future Conditions FloodClosed Hazard Areas. The following items/information shall be required as part of the application for a floodplain development permitClosed:

1. A plot plan drawn to scale which shall include, but shall not be limited to, the following specific details of the proposed floodplain developmentClosed:

a. the nature, location, dimensions, and elevations of the area of developmentClosed/disturbance; existing and proposed structures, the location of utility systems, proposed gradingClosed/pavement areas, fill materials, storage areas, drainage facilities, and other proposed developmentClosed;

b. the boundary of the Special Flood Hazard Area or Future Conditions FloodClosed Hazard Areas as delineated on the FIRM or other flood map as determined in paragraph 8.4.2, Applicability, or a statement that the entire lot is within the Special Flood Hazard Area or Future Conditions FloodClosed Hazard Areas;

c. flood zoneClosed(s) designation of the proposed developmentClosed area as determined on the FIRM or other flood map as determined in paragraph 8.4.2, Applicability;

d. the boundary of the floodwayClosed(s) or non-encroachment areaClosed(s) as determined in paragraph 8.4.2, Applicability;

e. the Base Flood Elevation (BFE)Closed or future conditions flood elevationClosed where provided as set forth in paragraph 8.4.2, Applicability; paragraph 3.21.2B (11 and 12), Duties and Responsibilities; or paragraph 8.4.3, Standards;

f. the old and new location of any watercourseClosed that will be altered or relocated as a result of proposed developmentClosed; and

g. preparation of the plot plan by or under the direct supervision of a registered land surveyor or professional engineer and certified by same.

2. Proposed elevation, and method thereof, of all developmentClosed within a Special Flood Hazard Area or Future Conditions Flood Hazard AreaClosed including but not limited to:

a. elevation in relation to mean sea levelClosed of the proposed reference levelClosed (including basementClosed) of all structures;

b. elevation in relation to mean sea levelClosed to which any non-residential structureClosed in Zone AE, A, AO, or X (Future) will be flood-proofed; and

c. elevation in relation to mean sea levelClosed to which any proposed utility systems will be elevated or floodproofed.

3. If floodproofingClosed, a floodproofingClosed certificate and back-up plans from a registered professional engineer or architect certifying that the non-residential flood-proofed developmentClosed will meet the flood-proofing criteria in paragraph 8.4.3, Standards.

4. A Foundation Plan drawn to scale which shall include details of the proposed foundation system to ensure all provisions of this ordinance are met. These details include but are not limited to:

a. Proposed method of elevation, if applicable (i.e., fill, solid foundation perimeter wall, solid backfilled foundation, open foundation on columns/piers); and

b. Should solid foundation perimeter walls be used in Zones AE and Zone X (Future), details of sufficient openings to facilitate the unimpeded movements of floodwaters in accordance with paragraph 8.4.3, Standards.

5. Usage details of any enclosed space below the regulatory flood protection elevation;

6. Plans and/or details for the protection of public utilitiesClosed and facilities such as sewer, gas, electrical, and water systems to be located and constructed to minimize flood damage;

7. Copy of all other Local, State and Federal permits required prior to floodplain development permitClosed issuance (i.e. WetlandsClosed, ErosionClosed and SedimentationClosed Control, Riparian Buffers, MiningClosed, etc.);

8. If floodplain development permitClosed is issued for placement of Recreational VehiclesClosed and/or Temporary Structures, documentation to ensure the recreational vehicleClosed and temporary structureClosed requirements of paragraph 8.4.3, Standards are met; and

9. If a watercourseClosed is proposed to be altered and/or relocated, a description of the extent of watercourseClosed alteration or relocation; an engineering report on the effects of the proposed project on the flood-carrying capacity of the watercourseClosed and the effects to properties located both upstream and downstream; and a map (if not shown on plot plan) showing the location of the proposed watercourseClosed alteration or relocation.

3.21.5. Floodplain Development Permit Data Requirements

The following information shall be provided at a minimum on the floodplain development permitClosed to ensure compliance with this code:

A. A description of the developmentClosed to be permitted under the floodplain development permitClosed issuance;

B. The Special Flood Hazard Area or Future Conditions Flood Hazard AreaClosed determination for the proposed developmentClosed per available data specified in paragraph 8.4.2, Applicability;

C. The regulatory flood protection elevation required for the reference levelClosed and all attendant utilities;

D. The regulatory flood protection elevation required for the protection of all public utilitiesClosed;

E. All certification submittal requirements with timelines;

F. State that no fill material shall encroachClosed into the floodwayClosed or non-encroachment areaClosed of any watercourseClosed, if applicable;

G. The flood openings requirements, if in Zone AE, A, O or X (Future).

3.21.6. Certification Requirements

A. An Elevation Certificate (FEMA Form 81-31) or FloodproofingClosed Certificate (FEMA Form 81-65) is required after the reference levelClosed is completed. Within twenty-one (21) calendar days of establishment of the reference levelClosed elevation, or floodproofingClosed, by whatever construction means, whichever is applicable, it shall be the duty of the permit holder to submit to the Floodplain AdministratorClosed a certification of the elevation of the reference levelClosed, or floodproofed elevation, whichever is applicable in relation to mean sea levelClosed. Said certification shall be prepared by or under the direct supervision of a registered land surveyor or professional engineer and certified by same. When floodproofingClosed is utilized, said certification shall be prepared by or under the direct supervision of a professional engineer or architect and certified by same. Any work done within the twenty-one (21) day calendar period and prior to submission of the certification shall be at the permit holder’s risk. The Floodplain AdministratorClosed shall review the certificate data submitted. Deficiencies detected by such review shall be corrected by the permit holder immediately and prior to further progressive work being permitted to proceed. Failure to submit the certification or failure to make said corrections required shall be cause to issue a stop-work order for the project.

B. A Final As-Built Elevation Certificate (FEMA Form 81-31) or FloodproofingClosed Certificate (FEMA Form 81-65) is required after construction is completed and prior to Certificate of ComplianceClosed/Occupancy issuance. It shall be the duty of the permit holder to submit to the Floodplain AdministratorClosed a certification of final as-built construction of the elevation or floodproofed elevation of the reference levelClosed and all attendant utilities. Said certification shall be prepared by or under the direct supervision of a registered land surveyor or professional engineer and certified by same. When floodproofingClosed is utilized, said certification shall be prepared by or under the direct supervision of a professional engineer or architect and certified by same. The Floodplain AdministratorClosed shall review the certificate data submitted. Deficiencies detected by such review shall be corrected by the permit holder immediately and prior to Certificate of ComplianceClosed/Occupancy issuance. In some instances, another certification may be required to certify corrected as-built construction. Failure to submit the certification or failure to make said corrections required shall be cause to withhold the issuance of a Certificate of ComplianceClosed/Occupancy.

C. If a manufactured home is placed within Zone AE, A, AO, or X (Future) and the elevation of the chassis is above 36 inches in height, an engineered foundation certification is required per paragraph 8.4.3, Standards.

D. If a watercourseClosed is to be altered or relocated, a description of the extent of watercourseClosed alteration or relocation; an engineering report on the effects of the proposed project on the flood-carrying capacity of the watercourseClosed and the effects to properties located both upstream and downstream; and a map showing the location of the proposed watercourseClosed alteration or relocation shall all be submitted by the permit applicant prior to issuance of a floodplain development permitClosed.

E. Certification Exemptions

The following structures, if located within Zone AE, A, AO, or X (Future), are exempt from the elevation/floodproofingClosed certification requirements specified in items 1 and 2 above:

1. Recreational VehiclesClosed meeting requirements of recreational vehiclesClosed in paragraph 8.4.3, Standards;

2. Temporary Structures meeting the temporary structureClosed requirements of paragraph 8.4.3, Standards; and

3. Accessory Structures less than 150 square feet meeting accessory structureClosed requirements of paragraph 8.4.3, Standards.

3.22.1. Applicability

The review procedures described below apply to changes to buildingClosed elevations where compliance with architectural standards is required, but no site planClosed approval or certificate of appropriateness is otherwise required. The requirements of paragraph 3.22.2B below also apply where architectural drawings are required for site planClosed approval.

3.22.2. Application Requirements

A. An architectural review application shall be submitted in accordance with paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirementss. Architectural review application documents shall contain, at a minimum, the information listed below unless expressly exempted by another provision of this Ordinance or if the Planning Director or designee makes the determination that less detailed information is required for adequate review. No processing or review of an architectural review application will proceed without the required information.

B. General Requirements

1. Title BlockClosed – Name of project, type of review labeled. Architectural Review; submittal and revision dates; sheet size 36 inches by 48 inches maximum with index map and match lines if multiple sheets are required; graphic scale (not smaller than one inch to 32 feet on a standard architectural scale); property identification number.

2. Name, address and telephone number of ownerClosed, applicant and agent; name, address and telephone number of architect or other designer.

3. Elevations of all buildingClosed façades, to scale, and labeled with materials, colors, finished floor elevations, glazingClosed calculations, and other details as necessary to demonstrate compliance with applicable standards.

3.22.3. Action by the Planning Director

Upon review of the application and subject to the requirements of paragraph 3.22.2, Application Requirements, the Planning Director or designee shall approve the architectural review application provided the design meets all applicable requirements of this Ordinance. An architectural review approval shall expire after four years unless a building permitClosed or other developmentClosed permit has been issued and remains continuously valid or if work not requiring a permit has been initiated, except that an architectural review application that proposes amending an approved site planClosed shall be considered a site planClosed amendment under paragraph 3.7.3C, Site Plan Amendments, and its approval shall expire at the same time as the approved site planClosed as amended.

3.23.1. Purpose

This section provides a procedure for making requests for reasonable accommodation to land use and zoning regulations, policies, practices, and procedures of the City and County of Durham to comply fully with the intent and purpose of Federal laws.

3.23.2. Applicability

A. This section shall apply to those personsClosed who are defined as disabled or handicapped under Federal law. A personClosed recovering from substance abuse is considered a personClosed with a disability or handicap; however, a personClosed who is currently engaging in the illegal use of controlled substances is not.

B. A request for a reasonable accommodation may be made by any personClosed with a disability or handicap, his or her legal representative, or a provider of housing for personsClosed with disabilities or handicaps in the city’s and county’s land use and zoning regulations, when the application of such may act as a barrier to affording such personClosed(s) equal opportunity to use and enjoy a dwelling in accordance with the law.

C. A request for a reasonable accommodation may include a modification or exception to the rules, standards, and/or practices for the siting, developmentClosed, and use of housing or housing-related facilities in this ordinance, that would eliminate regulatory barriers and provide a personClosed with a disability or handicap an equal opportunity to a dwelling of his or her choice.

D. Nothing in this section requires personsClosed with disabilities or handicaps, or operators of family care homesClosed, or group homesClosed for personsClosed with disabilities, or handicaps acting or operating in accordance with applicable zoning, licensing or land use laws or practices, to seek reasonable accommodation under this section.

3.23.3. Other Regulatory Obligations

A reasonable accommodation shall not affect an individual’s obligations to comply with other applicable regulations not at issue in the requested accommodation.

3.23.4. Pre-Application Conference

If an individual needs assistance in making the request for reasonable accommodation, the Planning Department will provide assistance to ensure that the process is accessible. Applicants seeking reasonable accommodation may request a pre-application conference with the Planning Director or designee to discuss the procedures, standards, and regulations applicable for submittal of an application. Such requests shall be made at least 10 days prior to the date of submittal.

3.23.5. Application Requirements

A. An application for reasonable accommodation shall be submitted in accordance with paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirementss. In addition, the following information shall be provided by the applicant:

1. The current actual use of the property;

2. The basis for the claim that the applicant is considered disabled or handicapped under Federal law;

3. The UDO provision(s) or regulation(s) from which reasonable accommodation is being requested; and

4. An explanation of why the reasonable accommodation is necessary to make the specific property available for the individual.

B. An application for a reasonable accommodation under this section shall be submitted to the Planning Director or designee.

3.23.6. Notice and Public Hearings

Once the application has been determined complete, the Planning Director or designee shall schedule a public hearing and give notice as set forth in paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings.

3.23.7. Burden of Proof

The applicant seeking reasonable accommodation shall have the burden of presenting evidence sufficient to allow the Board of Adjustment to make the findings set forth below, as well as the burden of persuasion on those issues.

3.23.8. Action by the Planning Director

The Planning Director or designee shall provide the Board of Adjustment with a copy of the application and all relevant materials pertaining to the request prior to the public hearing.

3.23.9. Action by the Board of Adjustment

A. Each decision shall be accompanied by a written finding of facts by the Board of Adjustment which specifies the reasons for the decision; and

B. The Board of Adjustment may prescribe whether the reasonable accommodation is granted to the applicant or shall be allowed to pass with transfer of property.

C. The Board of Adjustment may approve the request, deny the request, or continue the request. In approving the request, the Board of Adjustment may prescribe reasonable and appropriate conditions provided that the conditions are reasonably related to the request.

3.23.10. Findings

A. In granting a reasonable accommodation request, the Board of Adjustment shall find based on competent, material, and substantial evidence, that the proposed accommodation:

1. Will be used by an individual or individuals with a disability or handicap protected under Federal law;

2. Is "reasonable." An accommodation is reasonable if it will not undermine the legitimate purposes and effects of existing zoning regulations, and if it will not impose significant financial and administrative burdens upon the city or county and/or constitute a substantial or fundamental alteration of the ordinance provisions; and

3. Is "necessary." An accommodation is necessary if it will provide direct or meaningful therapeutic amelioration of the effects of the particular disability or handicap, and it will afford handicapped or disabled personsClosed equal opportunity to enjoy and use housing in residential districtsClosed in the city or county.

B. The Board of Adjustment shall issue a written order on a request for reasonable accommodation within 60 days of the date of the quasi-judicial decision.

3.23.11. Appeal

AppealClosed from final action by the Board of Adjustment on a reasonable accommodation request can be taken by filing a petition in the nature of certiorari with the Durham County Superior Court.

3.24.1. Street Closing

A. General

1. For the purposes of this Ordinance, a “street closing” application shall be considered an application to permanently close a public right-of-wayClosed in the City or County performed pursuant to NCGS §160A-299 or §153A-241, applicable NCDOT regulations, Sec. 51 of City of Durham Charter, Secs. 62-17 and -18 of the Durham City Code, and this Ordinance.

2. The governing bodies are the approving authority for the permanent closing of a public street or alleyClosed, or other public right-of-wayClosed.

3. A request to close a public right-of-wayClosed may be initiated by any personClosed, entity, or organization.

B. Pre-Application Conference

The applicant(s) applying for a closing shall schedule a pre-application conference in accordance with paragraph 3.2.2, Pre-Application Conference.

C. Application Requirements

1. A street closing application shall be submitted to the Planning Department.

2. A street closing application shall be submitted pursuant to paragraph 3.2.4, Application Requirementss, and Secs. 62-17 of the City of Durham Code of Ordinances if within the city jurisdiction.

3. The following shall also be addressed by the applicant for a street closing application:

a. The closing does not cause a parcelClosed to lack frontage along a public right-of-wayClosed.

b. How the parcelsClosed are accessed other than from the closed right-of-wayClosed, if applicable.

c. How the closing of the right-of-wayClosed impacts current or potential connectivity within a developmentClosed or neighborhood.

d. The circumstances that warrant the closing if connectivity is negatively impacted.

e. A discussion of the public interest in closing the right-of-wayClosed.

D. Action by the Planning Director

1. Review of Application

After receiving the application, the Planning Director or designee, along with other applicable agenciesClosed, shall be responsible for review and recommendation regarding closing requests.

2. Public Hearing Notification

The Planning Director or designee shall schedule a public hearing and give public notice as set forth in NCGS §160A-299 or §153A-241, Durham City Charter Secs. 51 and 62-18, and this section and paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings, as applicable.

E. Action by the Governing Body

1. Within the City 
a. Right-of-Way under NCDOT Control

Pursuant to NCGS §160A-299, no street or alleyClosed under the control of the North Carolina Department of Transportation (NCDOT) may be closed without the NCDOT consent.

Commentary: This action is needed for improved and maintained roadsClosed within City jurisdiction. Approval by NCDOT removes the roadsClosed from its list for maintenance.

(1) In order to request consent, a resolution from the City Council shall be sent to the NCDOT requesting removal of the right-of-wayClosed from its maintenance list. Consent shall be obtained prior to setting a public hearing date.

(2) Once NCDOT has granted this request, City Council shall set a public hearing date in accordance with City Charter Secs. 51 and 62-18.

(3) Before taking action on a street closing, the governing body shall consider the recommendations of the Planning Director or designee, and shall conduct a public hearing.

b. All Other City Public Right-of-Way

For public right-of-wayClosed not under NCDOT control:

(1) The City Council shall set a public hearing date in accordance with City Charter Secs. 51 and 62-18.

(2) The City Council shall consider the recommendations of the Planning Director, or designee, and shall conduct a public hearing prior to taking final action on the request.

2. Within the County

Pursuant to NCGS §153A-241, closure of public right-of-wayClosed shall require consent by NCDOT.

a. In order to request consent, a resolution from the Board of County Commissioners shall be sent to the NCDOT requesting removal of the right-of-wayClosed from its maintenance list. Consent shall be obtained prior to setting a public hearing date.

Commentary: This action is needed for improved and maintained roadsClosed within the County. Approval by NCDOT removes the roadsClosed from its list for maintenance.

b. Once NCDOT has granted this request, the Board of County Commissioners shall set a public hearing date so that notice of such hearing shall be published once a week for four successive weeks prior to the hearing date.

c. The Board of County Commissioners shall consider the recommendations of the Planning Director or designee, and shall conduct a public hearing prior to taking final action on the request.

F. Appeal

AppealClosed from final action can be taken by filing a petition for certiorari with the Durham County Superior Court.

G. Recordation

The approved order and platClosed for a closing that has not been appealedClosed, or has survived appealClosed, shall be recorded at the applicable Register of Deeds.

3.24.2. Right-of-Way Withdrawal

A. Applicability

1. For the purposes of this Ordinance, a “right-of-wayClosed withdrawal” application shall be considered an application to permanently withdraw a public right-of-wayClosed in the City or County performed pursuant to NCGS §136-96, applicable NCDOT regulations, applicable charter provisions for the city of Durham, and this Ordinance.

2. If the right-of-wayClosed does not qualify for withdrawal, then closing of the right-of-wayClosed shall be performed through the street closing process pursuant to paragraph 3.24.1, Street Closing.

B. Application

1. An application for withdrawal shall be submitted in accordance with paragraphs 3.2.4, Application Requirementss, and 3.6.8, Final PlatClosed Approval.

2. An application for withdrawal for right-of-wayClosed under control of NCDOT shall also be processed and approved in accordance with the regulations established by NCDOT for such a request.

C. Action by the Planning Director

The Planning Director or designee shall review applications for withdrawal pursuant to the requirements of this section, NCGS §136-96, and Durham City Charter Sec. 51.2, as applicable.

3.25.2. Street Renaming

A. Applicability

For the purposes of this Ordinance, a “street renaming” application shall be considered an application to change the official name of a street, alleyClosed, or private drive.

B. Pre-Application Conference

The applicant(s) applying for a street renaming shall schedule a pre-application conference in accordance with paragraph 3.2.2, Pre-Application Conference.

C. Application

1. An application for renaming shall be submitted in accordance with paragraphs 3.2.4, Application Requirementss; 3.6.8, Final PlatClosed Approval; and 12.3.2, Street Names.

2. An application for the renaming of right-of-wayClosed under control of NCDOT shall also be processed and approved in accordance with the regulations established by NCDOT for such a request.

D. Action by the Planning Director

1. Review of Application

a. After receiving the application, the Planning Director or designee, along with other applicable agenciesClosed, shall be responsible for review and recommendation regarding renaming requests.

b. If the right-of-wayClosed is under NCDOT control, approval from NCDOT is required prior to scheduling a hearing with the governing body.

c. Public Meeting Requirement

Prior to the scheduling of the public hearing, at least one public meeting shall be scheduled by the Planning Director or designee regarding the renaming request. OwnersClosed of all property fronting along the subject “street” shall be notified of the meeting.

2. Public Hearing

The Planning Director or designee shall schedule a public hearing and give public notice pursuant to paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings.

E. Action by the Governing Body

The City Council or Board of County Commissioners, as applicable, shall be the approving authority for renaming right-of-wayClosed, subject to approval by NCDOT if applicable, and hold a public hearing prior to taking final action on the request.

1. Before taking action on a street renaming request, the governing body shall consider any recommendations of the Planning Director or designee, and of staff agenciesClosed, and shall conduct a public hearing where interested parties may be heard.

2. The governing body may continue a public hearing prior to closing the hearing and taking action on the request.

3. Following the public hearing, the governing body may approve the request, deny the request, or send the request back to the administration for additional consideration.

F. Approved Requests

A request that is approved by the applicable governing body shall be recorded at the Register of Deeds with an associated final platClosed, along with any additional requirements by NCDOT as applicable.

3.26.1. Purpose

Statutory developmentClosed agreements are intended to provide for community benefits within developmentsClosed that are difficult to accommodate within traditional zoning processes. Additionally, they can provide regulatory certainty, a schedule for developmentClosed, coordination for the provision of public facilitiesClosed, sustainable design, and improved management of environmentally sensitive lands, as applicable. This section provides a procedure for requests for statutory developmentClosed agreements pursuant to NCGS Chapter 160D, Article 10, DevelopmentClosed Agreements; and 160D-704, Incentives.

3.26.6. Requirements and Limitations

A. Statutory Requirements

A developmentClosed agreement shall adhere to the requirements of NCGS Chapter 160D, Article 10, DevelopmentClosed Agreements.

B. Limitations

A developmentClosed agreement may modify the standards of this Ordinance except:

1. The process for adoption and execution of a developmentClosed agreement shall not be modified.

2. A developmentClosed agreement shall not allow uses and/or housing types that are not allowed in the underlying zoning district of the subject property.

3. A developmentClosed agreement shall not reduce environmental requirements within Article 4, Zoning Districts; and Article 8, Environmental Protection, with the exception of Sec. 8.3 Tree Protection and Tree Coverage.

4. A developmentClosed agreement shall not reduce requirements within Article 12, Infrastructure and Other Public Improvements

3.26.9. Action by the Planning Commission

A. General Procedures

1. Before making any recommendation on a petition for a statutory developmentClosed agreement, the Planning Commission shall consider any recommendations from the Planning Director and any other department or agencyClosed, and shall conduct a public hearing where interested parties may be heard.

2. Notice and public hearing requirements shall be in accordance with paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings.

3. Except in the case of expedited hearings pursuant to paragraph 3.26.10B, Expedited Hearing, the Commission shall make its recommendation within three consecutive regular Commission cycles (approximately 90 days total) of its initial public hearing. In case of significant modifications, the time period for a recommendation may be altered, in which case a maximum of three additional consecutive regular cycles may be granted before the case shall go to the governing body.

4. When a recommendation is not made within the time periods established in this section, the governing body may process the request without a Commission recommendation.

3.26.10. Action by the Governing Body

A. General Procedures

1. Before taking action on a developmentClosed agreement request, the governing body shall consider any recommendations of the Planning Commission, Planning Director or designee, and of staff agenciesClosed, and shall conduct a public hearing where interested parties may be heard.

2. Notice and public hearing requirements shall be in accordance with paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings.

3. The governing body may continue a public hearing prior to closing the hearing and taking action on the request.

4. Following the public hearing, the governing body may approve the request, deny the request, or send the request back to the Planning Commission for additional consideration.

5. The developmentClosed agreement request approved by the governing body may include changes from the request presented.

B. Expedited Hearing

1. The governing body, in situations in which it determines certain standards have been met, may expedite the hearing process on a proposed developmentClosed agreement.

2. The governing body may consider a written request from a potential applicant, or from staff, requesting an expedited hearing process. The request shall identify and support the reasons for such expedited consideration.

3. In order to grant the request, the governing body shall find that at least one of the criteria below have been met:

a. Deadlines set by the local, State, or Federal government for receipt of applications for needed funding, designation, or other regulations concerning the property make expedited consideration necessary;

b. The prospective request results from an emergency beyond the control of the applicant, such as response to a disaster;

c. The prospective request addresses an urgent matter of public health or safety; or

d. There are special circumstances that will have a substantial negative impact on the developmentClosed which could not have reasonably been anticipated and which make expedited consideration necessary.

3.26.11. Recordation

Pursuant to NCGS 160D-1011, an approved developmentClosed agreement shall be recorded with the Register of Deeds.

A. The approved developmentClosed agreement shall be recorded within 14 days from the date the city or county, as applicable, and the applicant execute the agreement approved by the governing body.

B. No developmentClosed approvals shall be issued until the developmentClosed agreement is recorded.

3.27.1. Purpose

The purpose of this section is to establish the procedures by which a property ownerClosed may request the City of Durham to annex property and thus establish the City’s jurisdiction onto the subject property, pursuant to the Durham City Code and applicable state statutes. This section does not override or nullify any other local or state law regarding annexation and applicable rules or laws resulting from the establishment of the City’s jurisdiction.

3.27.2. Pre-Application Conference

All applicants applying for annexation shall schedule a pre-application conference in accordance with paragraph 3.2.2, Pre-Application Conference.

3.27.3. Application

A. An application for annexation shall be submitted in accordance with paragraphs 3.2.4, Application Requirementss.

B. Utility Extension Agreement (UEA)

Unless incorporated into a concurrent approval by City Council, such as a zoning map change or statutory developmentClosed agreement, the applicable utility extension agreement shall be included with the annexation request.

C. Concurrent Zoning Map Change

An annexation application shall be submitted concurrently with any associated zoning map change application.

3.27.4. Review of Application

A. After receiving the application, the Planning Director or designee, and any other applicable department or agencyClosed, shall be responsible for review and comment regarding the request.

B. Administrative Voiding of an Application

The Planning Director or designee may consider applications withdrawn and voided due to the failure of the applicant to submit required information within 90 days of a request for such information.

3.27.5. Action by the Governing Body

A. General Procedures

1. Before taking action on an annexation request, the governing body shall consider any recommendations of the Planning Director or designee, and of staff agenciesClosed, and shall conduct a public hearing where interested parties may be heard.

2. Notice and public hearing requirements shall be in accordance with paragraph 3.2.5, Notice and Public Hearings.

3. The City Council may continue a public hearing prior to closing the hearing and taking action on the request.

4. Following the public hearing, the governing body may approve the request, deny the request, or refer the request back to the administration for additional consideration.

5. The annexation approved by the governing body may include changes from the request presented.

B. Concurrent Approvals

The City Council may consider concurrent requests for the subject site with the annexation request. However, separate motions for each requested action shall be required.

3.27.6. Initial Zoning Map Change

Pursuant to an initial zoning map changeClosed as defined in Article 17, Definitions, the City Council may establish its zoning authority by adopting the current zoning designation, or by adopting a different designation.

3.27.7. Effective Date

The effective date of an annexation shall be a date determined by City Council.