search icon

Malabar City Zoning Code

SECTION 1

15.8. - Permits available; criteria for issuing permits; permit determinations; required replacements or relocations.

A.

Permits available. The following permits with stated limitations shall be available upon proper application to the Town Manager or Designee and compliance with this ordinance.

1.

Tree removal permit: A tree removal permit shall not authorize the destruction of a mangrove unless criteria governing mangrove alteration is satisfied.

2.

Land clearing permit: A land clearing permit does not authorize the removal or destruction of protected trees, nor does it authorize any alteration to a mangrove.

3.

Mangrove alteration permit: No mangrove shall be altered unless the Town Manager or Designee has issued appropriate permits based on a determination that all criteria governing both tree removal and mangrove alteration permits have been satisfied.

B.

Criteria for issuing permits. The following criteria shall be satisfied prior to issuance of a tree removal, mangrove alteration, or land clearing permit, respectively.

1.

Criteria for issuing a land clearing or tree removal permit. In determining whether or not a permit required by this ordinance should be issued, the Town Manager or Designee shall consider the following criteria:

a.

The condition of the tree with respect to disease, insect attack, danger of falling, proximity to existing or proposed structures and interference with utilities services;

b.

The necessity of removing a tree to construct proposed improvements in order to allow reasonable economic use of the property;

c.

The topography of the land where the tree is located and the effect removal of the same would have on: erosion, soil moisture retention, increased or decreased flow or diversion in the flow of surface waters, and impact on overall surface water, management;

d.

The number and density of trees existing on site;

e.

The relative significance or uniqueness of the tree as a historic or specimen tree;

f.

Impact on the natural environment, including: ground and surface water stabilization, water quality and aquifer recharge, ecological impacts, noise buffer, air quality, and wild life habitat;

g.

The ease with which the applicant can alter or revise the proposed development or improvement in order to accommodate existing mangrove or trees; and

h.

The economic hardship which would be imposed upon the applicant should the permit not be granted.

2.

Criteria for issuing a mangrove alteration permit. In determining whether or not to issue a permit, as required by this ordinance to alter a mangrove, the Town Manager or Designee shall consider not only tree removal criteria of subparagraph B(1) of this section, but shall also consider the following criteria and incorporate them as conditions of the permit if issued. A violation of any of these provisions shall be deemed to be unlawful and subject to all penalties provided for herein.

a.

At least fifty (50) percent of the original canopy of any mangrove trees shall be continuously retained.

b.

White mangroves and buttonwood shall not be trimmed at all at a distance less than two (2) feet above the natural ground elevation. All resultant sprout re-growth shall be allowed to attain a height of a minimum of three (3) feet above natural ground elevation.

c.

On red mangroves, no prop roots shall be damaged, removed or buried by fill or other means.

d.

Red mangroves may be hedged down to a minimum height of six (6) feet, providing the limitations in subparagraphs a. and g. above [sic] are not exceeded.

e.

On a black mangrove of ten (10) feet or less in height there shall be no cutting or trimming below the lowest two (2) living lateral limbs, unless a significant canopy area is left at the top of the tree. Further, no pneumatophores shall be damaged or removed nor shall they be buried by fill or other means.

f.

No large mangrove cuttings shall be discarded into any estuary, marsh, river, or adjacent water course.

g.

Pruning, removal and relocation of mangroves shall be prohibited between December 1 st and February 15 th .

h.

All cuts shall be made cleanly and at the base of the branch or limb cut, except when done with respect to the shaping of a hedge.

i.

A mangrove alteration permit shall not authorize removal of any mangrove unless the applicant replaces or relocates that number of mangroves necessary to revegetate an area approximately equal to the area destroyed, on the same development site. The applicant must provide an affirmative program satisfactory to the Town Manager or Designee to assure survival of the replaced or relocated mangroves and to stabilize the shoreline from which mangroves were removed. The approved program shall be considered an express condition of the permit.

j.

Notwithstanding the criteria of subparagraph B(2) of this section, the property owner/applicant may elect a replanting and hedging program, under direction and control of the Town Manager or Designee, and under which replacement juvenile red mangroves may be hedged several times each year and maintained at a height after periodic hedging of three (3) feet. A mandatory and integral part of this program is that hedged material (clippings) shall be left atop the hedged mangroves until leaf drop from the hedged material (clippings) has occurred. The dropped leaves shall then become part of the estuary food chain.

3.

Criteria for issuing a land clearing permit. In determining whether or not to issue a permit to clear or grub land as required by this ordinance, the Town Manager or Designee shall consider whether the applicant has or is complying with all tree and land clearing provisions of this ordinance and shall base a decision regarding issuance of a permit on the following criteria:

a.

The minimum necessary vegetation removal on the property for purposes of land surveying or land preparation for development or other economic uses;

b.

Whether visual access is necessary to comply with tree survey requirements;

c.

Whether the applicant has provided protective barriers around all protected trees on the site or will utilize light machinery, which does not penetrate or severely compact the soil, for clearing understory vegetation in protected areas;

d.

The impact upon natural and man-made systems including erosion and surface water management and other impacts identified in section 1-15.8. To this end the applicant shall provide a reasonable written plan for controlling erosion which may be expected to occur as a result of the proposed clearing or grubbing. The plan shall incorporate some or all of the following measures necessary to achieve soil stabilization, prevent erosion, and promote efficient surface water management, including: temporary seeding and mulching, sodding, diversion berms, interceptor ditches, sediment barriers, sediment basins, and related appurtenances or devices. All provisions of an erosion control plan shall be incorporated as express conditions of the land clearing permit issued and a violation of any of the conditions or provisions of the plan shall be considered a violation of this ordinance, and subject to all enforcement provisions. The Town Manager or Designee may require written elaboration of a proposed plan prior to issuance of a permit in order to clarify the nature and design of measures intended by the applicant.

4.

The Town Manager or designee shall consider accessibility to the property and may require a culvert for property access, whether temporary or permanent, prior to the issuance of any permit type in this section.

C.

Tree removal, mangrove alteration, and land clearing permit determinations. The Town Manager or Designee shall only issue a tree removal, mangrove alteration or land clearing permit upon a finding that all applicable requirements of this ordinance have been satisfied including criteria for issuance as set forth in section 1-15.8(B) as well as provisions governing required replacements in section 1-15.8(D). Notwithstanding, no permit shall be granted if the Town Manager or Designee determines that any one of the following conditions exists:

1.

Ability to reasonably shift location of proposed improvements. That the applicant can reasonably shift the location of the structure, building or improvement which he wishes to construct on the site, while maintaining the existence of the subject trees or mangroves and still permitting the construction of such building or improvement on the site;

2.

Ability to reasonably modify design concept. That the applicant can reasonably modify the design of a structure, building or other proposed improvement while maintaining the existence of the trees or mangroves proposed to be removed and still permit construction of a substantially similar building on the site; or

3.

Land clearing or removal generates substantial adverse impact. That the land clearing or the removal of the subject trees or mangroves will have a substantial adverse impact on the urban and natural environment.

D.

Required replacement or relocation of trees. All trees that are removed or destroyed shall be replaced by a species of protected trees to be approved by the Town Council and to be kept on file in the Office of the Town Clerk. The cost of replacing trees shall be incurred by the applicant/developer. The specifications regulating the replacement of trees are cited below:

1.

Characteristics of replacement trees. The replacement tree(s) shall have at least equal shade potential screening properties; and/or other characteristics comparable to that of the trees(s) requested to be removed.

2.

Size of replacement trees. Replacement tree(s) are to be made according to a standard of one (1) inch diameter at breast height (DBH) total replacement for each one (1) inch DBH removed, unless otherwise agreed upon by both the Town Manager or Designee and applicant. Any number of trees may be utilized to meet the inch-for-inch requirement provided acceptable spacings and design are maintained.

3.

Tree species. Relocated or replacement trees shall include only species defined as protected trees under this ordinance.

4.

Minimum standards for replacement trees. All replacement tree(s) must have a minimum overall planted height of eight (8) feet at the time of planting and a Florida Department of Agriculture Nursery Grade Standard (quality) of No. 1 or better.

5.

Transplanting and maintenance requirements. All trees transplanted pursuant to this ordinance shall be maintained in a healthy, living condition. Any such trees which die shall be replaced by the applicant. The Town Manager or Designee shall retain jurisdiction to insure compliance with this section.

6.

Waivers of replacement tree(s) specifications. The Town Manager or Designee may waive the size or minimum standards specifications if the applicant can demonstrate that the current market conditions are such that replacement tree(s) meeting these specifications are not readily available. Similarly the number of required replacements may be waived by the Town Manager or Designee if the Town Manager or Designee determines that the remaining number of trees to be preserved on site are of sufficient number and quality to substantially comply with the purpose and intent of the tree protection ordinance. Substitute tree(s) allowed under this waiver provision must have the approval of the Town Manager or Designee.

(Ord. No. 03-17, § 1, 1-5-04; Ord. No. 2021-19, §§ 1—4, 9-27-21)