A. Purpose: This section is established to provide a zone to be used near city transportation corridors that allows a mix of specific land uses that are typically found separately in "mutually exclusive" zoning districts. Mixed use represents a departure from characteristic zoning to the extent that it encourages a combination of land uses which might normally be regarded as incompatible.
The intent of this zone is to create self-sustaining walkable neighborhoods in which residents may walk to work, to shopping, to recreational facilities, and have access to mass transit. These neighborhoods are to provide a variety of housing opportunities and choices that include a range of household types, family sizes, and incomes. They shall provide convenient pedestrian commercial services, employment opportunities, and shall be located in areas with existing, or probable future, multiple transportation choices. Design standards include requirements that help provide a true "neighborhood" by stipulating various mix of uses, "built to" lines, compact building design, preservation of open space, pedestrian friendly streets and streetscape, parking concealment, architectural control, and maintenance. Proposed developments with increased land intensity and housing density but without the above "walkable" elements are unacceptable and will not be approved.
1. All exterior building elevations visible from adjacent properties or streets may, upon the director's request, be reviewed and approved by the planning commission.
2. Prior to the planning commission taking action, plans must be submitted in accordance with this code.
3. All submissions shall be made well in advance of planned construction for proper coordination and feedback, and shall be reviewed at a city development review meeting and/or respective architectural review meeting before submittal to the planning commission.
4. For a typical building project, five (5) copies of the required information must be submitted for complete review and approval by the planning commission. One copy will remain on file with the city, and the second copy will be returned with comments. All communication with the planning commission shall be directed to the director.
5. The owner's representative, for ongoing coordination with the planning commission, must also be identified including address and telephone number.
C. Land Coverage: It is the intent to create efficient usage of land within the mixed use district by controlling the intensity of different types of land uses while providing sufficient size to create a walkable neighborhood.
1. Coverage for both buildings and paved areas (parking, loading, and circulation) shall not exceed eighty five percent (85%), thereby reserving a minimum of fifteen percent (15%) for landscaped areas and open space.
2. Parking terraces and underground parking is strongly encouraged. Surface parking (permanent or temporary) may be allowed in addition to, or in lieu of a parking structure, upon the approval of the planning commission, where it is screened from streets and where it can be shown that the phasing plan, design, size, and scope of the project substantially provides a walkable community.
D. Uses Allowed: In order to achieve an overall "walkable" development, appropriate land uses, pedestrian connections, cross easements, common driveways, consistent site standards, etc., must be coordinated, even though properties may be individually owned. In order to encourage pedestrian activity and to improve air quality, drive-through windows are not permitted in conjunction with uses such as fast food restaurants, dry cleaners, banks, etc.
1. Location Restrictions: Mixed use developments shall be located along transportation corridors and other locations where "walkable" components, i.e., housing choices, convenient commercial, employment, community facilities, transportation linkages, park or other open space, schools, churches, are already present, planned, or where the size and scale of development is such that said components can be provided within the project itself.
The actual blend of "vertical" and/or "horizontal" mixed use development shall be presented in the proposed plan. Where size and scale permit, housing units shall include a mix of housing types, housing size, and number of bedrooms, encouraging neighborhoods with a mix of family cycles and incomes.
2. Ancillary Uses: All permitted and conditional land uses within the MU zone may conduct ancillary uses, as specifically defined in the definitions chapter of this land development code, provided such use is not regulated by other sections or is listed as a prohibited land use in this zone.
E. Development Standards: The following standards are to be considered as applying specifically to development in the mixed use (MU) district in addition to general standards provided elsewhere in this code.
1. Mixed Use Master Plan: The plan must show all phases of the development, including any phasing plans, and both existing and reasonable projected development on adjoining properties, determined through consultation with city staff and adjoining property owners.
a. The intent of the above is to achieve a consistent overall mixed use development with uniform and compatible site standards when the project area is completely built out. Standards that will be applied to a master plan are set forth in this chapter.
b. Remnant parcels left from old developments, rebuilds of existing parcels, or pads within existing center developments, are required to make reasonable compliance with mixed use development standards through consultation with the director.
2. Parcel Size: Parcels shall be at least two (2) acres to assure compliance with building setbacks, landscaping, access, parking, and walkability standards.
3. Building Placement And Massing:
a. Setbacks: Building facades shall comprise at least seventy percent (70%) of each street edge identified as "build-to lines". To meet this requirement, building facades must be zero to five feet (5') from streetside (typically inside edge of sidewalk) where build-to lines are drawn. Awnings and architectural features may project beyond build-to lines, as approved by the planning commission. Streetside setback variations may be used when an activity related to pedestrian use is maintained, i.e., special landscaping, outside seating for a restaurant. Recessed plazas, courtyards, and trellises are encouraged.
b. Side And Rear Setbacks: Zero lot line side setbacks with attached structures, in compliance with the international building code, may be required except for necessary driveway access, pedestrian access, open space, and landscape areas. Rear setbacks shall be of sufficient depth to allow proper parking and landscaped areas to the rear of the buildings. Unless otherwise approved by the planning commission, rear yards and the rear of buildings shall not directly abut streets. If the rear of building is approved adjacent to a street, pedestrian access and street oriented building treatment must be adequately addressed.
c. Building Orientation: The entrances of all retail, civic, residential, and office buildings shall front onto streets with the exception of center block residences (which still must front pedestrianways) and anchor stores greater than thirty thousand (30,000) square feet in size. Secondary entries may be required at the rear of street facing buildings. Where possible, like land uses shall face like land uses or open space, i.e., retail across the street from retail, townhomes from townhomes, etc. Loading docks and service areas must be screened from streets and adjacent properties through architectural design and landscaping. Anchor store entrances must be connected to adjacent streets via landscaped, public accessible walkways. Access from parking areas may be via mid block passageways or "paseos" to the street.
BUILDING MASSING ADJACENT TO STREETS - ENCOURAGED
BUILDING MASSING ADJACENT TO STREETS - ENCOURAGED
WALKWAYS THROUGH PARKING LOTS - ENCOURAGED
d. Building Height: Buildings at build-to lines shall have a minimum and maximum height as indicated on the table below by building type, with height to be measured in accordance with the city's adopted ordinances and standards. Buildings of greater height than allowed in the table below may be approved by the planning commission on a limited basis, based upon the size, scale, topography, and uniqueness of the development. Approved structures with additional height may be required to include suitable "step back" architecture and other architectural features which are of pedestrian scale on street level.
| | | | |
Minimum building height | 2 stories | 2 stories | 1 story | 1 story |
Maximum building height | 4 stories | 3 stories | 2 stories | 3 stories |
e. CPTED (Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design): Where practically possible, CPTED principles shall be used in the design and layout of buildings, streets, accesses, and open space areas. Design shall promote natural surveillance, access control, territorial reinforcement, sense of ownership, management, and maintenance. CPTED landscaping guidelines shall be used, including planting shrubs with a maximum height of two (2) to three feet (3') and trees with a proper ground clearance six (6) to eight feet (8') above walkways and eight (8) to ten feet (10') above vehicular travel and parking lanes.
In order to encourage public safety through natural surveillance, natural access control and territorial reinforcement blank walls are not permitted adjacent to streets, pedestrian areas, and open space amenities. Symbolic barriers, such as low lying fences/walls, landscaping and signage shall be used, as appropriate, to discourage crime and to promote safety. Ground floor parking garages are not permitted immediately adjacent to streets. Developments shall have street side building elevations with extensive windows, balconies, decks, or landscape terraces being encouraged.
CPTED NATURAL SURVEILLANCE
4. Land Use Impact And Buffering: Landscape buffers are preferred over fences and walls where a separation is desirable. A visually open look should be encouraged between compatible uses. Visual screening which creates "outdoor rooms" is often more important than a physical separation. Fences or walls, if determined to be necessary or desirable, must be reviewed for their effectiveness in protecting private space while not creating isolated uses or dead space void of natural surveillance. Fences or walls shall be compatible in color, texture, and design in relationship to building materials. In order to mitigate any negative impacts, the director may modify building setbacks and heights and require additional architectural and/or landscape elements, as needed, between uses, within or without a mixed use development.
5. Architectural Design And Materials: Design and materials shall comply with the architectural design standards.
6. Signage: Proper design and placement of signs and their lighting is critical and shall be compatible with structures and uses. Mixed use developments shall have a sign theme which promotes mixed use compatibility. Permitted signs within the MU zone shall be in compliance with the city sign ordinance except that freestanding and off premises signs or billboards shall not be permitted. Wall signs, projecting wall signs, and window signs, approved as part of a sign theme, are encouraged.
Where approved, a monument sign must comply with chapter 13.26 of this title. Monument signs shall be constructed with the materials similar to that of the main building. Monument signs may not extend into the required sign visibility triangle unless otherwise approved by the director.
7. Open Space: Usable open space shall be provided within the mixed use development and is dependent upon size, scale, and nature of the development as determined by the director. Approved open space may include, but is not limited to, commons, pocket parks, plazas, courtyards, landscape features, water fountains and features, greenbelts, and trail connections. A "village green", as a common area, may be required adjacent to mass transit connections or other significant activity. Building materials used within open space areas shall be related to the materials of adjacent buildings and shall be a nonskid finish. Design shall encourage comfortable and safe pedestrian use including landscaping, seating areas, and lighting, as appropriate.
Areas of environmental concern or interest may be required to be preserved, e.g., drainages, steep slopes, connections to trail systems, and water features. Unless otherwise specified through special agreement or understanding with the city, all open space areas shall be maintained by property owners or homeowners' associations.
8. Landscaping: Landscaping guidelines are established to improve and then maintain site qualities while minimizing alteration, removal, or degradation of approved landscaping. Landscaping, in general, shall follow CPTED (crime prevention through environmental design) principles.
a. Landscaping in accordance with the plans submitted must be installed within thirty (30) days following the occupancy of the site or as otherwise approved by the director as seasonal conditions may dictate.
b. Future development areas or land area not occupied by buildings, structures, hard surfacing, vehicular driveways, or pedestrian walkways shall be kept in a weed free condition or landscaped.
c. The developer shall bond for such landscape improvements to ensure that installations are completed as submitted and approved. Performance assurance requirements for landscape improvements shall be the same as required by the city for street improvements.
(1) Sixty percent (60%) medium size trees; deciduous trees with a caliper from two (2) to three inches (3"), and evergreen trees with a height from five (5) to eight feet (8'). Forty percent (40%) small size trees and shrubs in a combination with deciduous trees with a caliper of one and one-half (11/2) to two inches (2") and evergreen trees with a minimum height of four feet (4'). Where possible, a 50/50 mix of deciduous and evergreen trees and shrubs shall be used for on site landscaping.
(2) Street trees with a minimum two inch (2") caliper shall be installed along all public rights of way by the developer. The species type, location, and spacing of trees shall be as shown on the approved landscape plan in compliance with designated streets within the city streetscape plan. For streets not specified in the streetscape plan, the following trees may be used as part of an approved landscape plan, depending upon space requirements:
(3) For planted medians and accent trees, both on site and at intersections, the following trees may be used:
e. Installation: It shall be the responsibility of the developer to grade, place topsoil, seed, sod, install sprinkler irrigation systems, and properly plant trees, shrubs, and other approved plant materials.
f. Maintenance: It shall be the responsibility of the developer and/or property association to properly maintain landscaped areas including watering, mowing, pruning, fertilizing, and the removal and replacement of dead plant materials in a timely manner.
g. Vegetation Modification/Removal: Pruning vegetation for "exposure" which results in unnatural plant specimens is prohibited. Necessary vegetation removal shall be replaced with equal or better quality plant materials. Trees that are out of necessity removed shall be replaced with trees with minimum two inch (2") caliper and at maturity shall achieve comparable or superior size and quality. Street trees replacement shall be in compliance with the city's streetscape plan unless otherwise approved by the director.
h. Utility Connections: When disturbances are made to existing landscaped areas, the existing landscaping must be replaced to its previous condition. Other modification of landscaped areas shall require approval by the director.
9. Outdoor Lighting: The lighting of streets, pedestrian areas, parking lots, and open space is required. Exterior wall mounted floodlights are expressly prohibited. Indirect lighting, bollard lighting, and landscape lighting is encouraged. Lighting of a building and site identification signs are permitted as allowed elsewhere in this code.
Design and location of standards and fixtures shall be specified on the site development drawings. Intensities shall be controlled so that "safety" lighting is provided while neighboring areas are protected from glare or excessive direct light. Streetlight design fixtures shall be of pedestrian scale and be installed as required by applicable city policy.
10. Streets And Pedestrianways:
a. Streets: All accesses within a mixed use development shall have connectivity with existing and future street patterns. A grid street pattern or modified grid pattern is required. Cul-de- sac streets will not be approved unless it can be demonstrated that no other practical way exists to make connectivity. In order to uphold and enhance traditional neighborhood development principles, private streets are discouraged and gated communities are prohibited.
DISCONNECTED STREET SYSTEM - DISCOURAGED
CONNECTED MODIFIED GRID SYSTEM - ENCOURAGED
b. Widths: Street widths shall comply with applicable city standards. In general, streets shall be designed to meet the level of travel and service while incorporating principles of traffic calming and pedestrian compatibility, i.e., tree lined streets with pedestrianways and linkages, decreasing the need for pavement width by spreading traffic through a grid or modified street hierarchy system.
c. Sidewalks And Walkways: The design of pedestrianways may include a solitary meandering pathway or trail, a "pedestrian street" and the many possible designs in between. Walkways and connections to trail systems shall be incorporated into the project. Choice of appropriate pedestrian access will be made based upon the scale and type of mixed use project being proposed and by the way uses are intermingled. The standard ten foot (10') cross section (5 foot park strip, 5 foot sidewalk) is a minimum, while a wider park strip and/or sidewalk may be required depending upon the land use and the desired effect. All streets shall have sidewalks and curbside streetscape.
Pavers, borders, and other sidewalk design materials with compatible colors shall be used as needed in order to break up expanses of hard surfacing and to encourage pedestrian interest and activity.
In "vertical mixed use" areas, a minimum of eight foot (8') sidewalks are required in order to enhance street and land use connectivity. Portions of the park strip may be paved to accommodate street furniture, leaving tree wells for street trees. Street furniture, including, but not limited to, benches, trash receptacles, artwork, drinking fountains, bike racks, and newspaper racks, if allowed, may be required depending upon the nature of approved uses. Street furniture requirements shall include an overall design theme for compatibility.
d. Crosswalks: Extensive use of crosswalks shall be incorporated within the project at intersections, midblocks, within parking lots, or other needed pedestrian connections. A pedestrian inconvenience distance of one hundred fifty feet (150') should be used as a guideline. Crosswalks shall be so configured to be a design feature of the development, i.e., heavy painted lines, pavers, edges, and other methods of emphasizing pedestrian use. Bulb outs and other pedestrian designs shall be used to shorten walking distances across open pavement. Planted medians shall be used in appropriate areas to encourage walking and to act as a "refuge" for crossing pedestrians.
11. Other Forms Of Transportation: All forms of transportation shall be considered within and without the mixed use development with the intent to improve convenience and reduce automobile trips. All forms of transportation should be encouraged including bus, bicycle, and pedestrian. Access connections shall be required where deemed essential to provide circulation or access to churches, schools, playgrounds, shopping centers, transportation, and other community facilities.
Appropriate bus turnouts and stops shall be coordinated and planned as part of the development review process. Based upon land use and the level of demand, bicycle parking shall be provided in appropriate locations, i.e., visible from storefronts and entrances to office buildings and residential structures.
12. Parking Areas: Parking areas shall be addressed in the design process since they present a three-dimensional appearance when occupied.
a. Location: Location of parking shall be determined not only from its visual relationship to the building and site, but also as it relates to safe convenient pedestrian and vehicular circulation patterns. The placing of building and parking elements on a site shall be evaluated by the director on the basis of the following factors:
(1) Type of land use and structure.
(2) Building height and configuration.
(3) Relationship to other buildings, both horizontally and vertically.
(4) Natural land features such as slopes and vegetation.
(5) Physical features such as rail lines, canals, and controlled ingress and egress.
(6) Visibility from vehicular approaches and distant highways.
(7) Safe pedestrian connections to buildings, walkways, open space, and streets.
b. Outdoor Rooms: Where possible, parking lots shall be broken up and planned as "outdoor rooms" through the use of buildings, walkways, open space, and landscape design. When approved, larger parking lots shall be broken up with substantial tree and ground cover. Large parking lots should be broken up into "rooms" of no more than three hundred (300) parking stalls through the use of connecting walkways.
c. Parking Structures: Underground parking, deck or terrace parking, and parking garages are encouraged and may be required in conjunction with structures of three (3) stories or more. Said structures shall have architectural treatments compatible with adjoining buildings. Parking structures shall be designed around natural light with "safety" lighting added as needed. Landscaping, within and without, may be required to enhance compatibility and safety.
F. Environmental Concerns:
1. Building, landscape, and solar design should be adjusted, where possible, to be compatible with the local climate. Such design should include, but may not be limited to, window placement, building recesses, overhangs, trellises, awnings, porches, and landscape placement planned in such a way to enhance livability and reduce energy costs.
2. The use of lighter colored building materials, i.e., rooftops, fences/walls, and extensive deciduous and evergreen tree cover, shall be incorporated into developments in order to reduce the urban heat island effect. Where possible, streets, driveways, parking lots, etc., should use concrete or other materials which absorb less sunlight. Parking lot landscaping shall be provided at the ratio of at least one tree per six (6) parking stalls.
3. Where possible, drought resistant ground covers, shrubs, and trees shall be incorporated into the landscape to reduce water usage and storm runoff. Extensive areas of grass or other high water use plants without a public purpose are discouraged.
G. Requirements Unique To Residential Uses: The following shall apply to residential uses:
1. Multi-Family Residential: Multi-family residential uses shall comprise a variety of types of housing, fulfilling housing needs with a wide assortment of housing options and shall be designed using traditional neighborhood development (TND) design principles. The number of bedrooms per unit and other housing design options shall be varied in proportions to assist in providing suitable housing for a market range of household incomes, family size, and life cycles. The site plan design of multi-family development shall conform to requirements heretofore presented. Setbacks shall be determined by the planning commission based upon acceptable layout and design.
a. Required Standards: The following TND standards shall be required for multi-family residential:
(1) Properly designed off street surface parking hidden from streets, parking terraces, or underground parking. Garage units associated with multi-family development should be rear loaded. Where only front loaded garages are possible, they shall be subservient to the residential structure.
(2) Roofs with a four to twelve (4/12) pitch or greater.
(3) Dwelling and garage gables facing streets or alleys.
(4) Extensive windows facing streets, alleys, and pedestrian connections.
(5) Covered entrance porches.
(6) Entry sidewalks that connect directly to public sidewalks.
b. Encouraged Standards: The following TND standards for multi- family residential shall be encouraged:
(1) Multilevel structures.
(2) Dormers and/or shutters and other window treatments.
(3) Streetside balconies/decks.
(4) Streets which deemphasize the need and speed of automobiles.
(5) Other pedestrian oriented design.
GARDEN APARTMENTS - PLAN VIEW
GARDEN APARTMENTS - ELEVATIONS
CONDOS WITH UNDERGROUND PARKING - PLAN VIEW
CONDOS WITH UNDERGROUND PARKING - ELEVATIONS
2. Single-Family Residential: Single-family residential uses, if approved, shall be designed using traditional neighborhood development (TND) design principles. Front setbacks shall range between twelve (12) and twenty feet (20') typically measured from the inside edge of sidewalk to the porch. Front loaded garages shall be subservient to the dwelling and shall not have a setback less than eighteen feet (18'). Side and rear setbacks shall be determined by the planning commission based upon acceptable subdivision layout and design.
a. Required Standards: The following TND standards shall be required for single-family residential:
(1) Subservient garages, e.g., back loaded detached with alley access, front loaded detached, attached but set back from the front line of the home by at least five feet (5'), side entry attached, or a combination of the above.
(2) Roofs with a four to twelve (4/12) pitch or greater.
(3) Dwelling and garage gables facing streets and alleys.
(4) Covered open front porches comprising at least fifty percent (50%) of the front elevation (not including the garage), in no case being no less than fifteen feet (15') in width.
(5) Entry sidewalks that connect directly to public sidewalks.
b. Encouraged Standards: The following TND standards for single- family residential shall be encouraged:
(2) House dormers and/or shutters and other window treatments.
(3) Streetside balconies/decks.
(4) Wraparound porches, particularly on corner lots.
(5) Streets which deemphasize the need and speed of automobiles.
(6) Other pedestrian oriented design.
SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL - PLAN VIEW
SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENTIAL - ELEVATIONS
H. Service Areas: Loading and refuse collection areas must be screened from public view. These areas are not permitted between buildings and streets unless they can be adequately screened through landscaping and architectural design. Streets shall not be used directly for commercial loading, unloading, or refuse collection. Building and improvements upon lots must be designed to properly accommodate loading, unloading, and refuse collection. Screen walls and enclosures shall be constructed with materials compatible with the structures they serve. Loading and refuse collection areas shall be properly maintained in a debris free condition. Except for approved and screened RV storage lots associated with a residential use, storage areas, including the storage of materials, merchandise, pallets, etc., shall be within buildings. (Ord. 12-15, 7-11-2012)