VIOLATIONS AND PENALTIES
The provisions of this Code shall be enforced by the city council and the administrator or his/her designee through their authority to abate any violations, enjoin, restrain, and prosecute any person violating this Code pursuant to North Carolina law.
In case any structure or use is erected, constructed, reconstructed, altered, repaired, converted, or maintained in violation of this Code as herein provided, an action for injunction, or mandamus, or other appropriate action or proceeding to prevent such violation may be instituted by the administrator, the building inspector, any other appropriate city authority; or any person who may be damaged by such violation.
Whenever a violation of this Code occurs, or is alleged to have occurred, any person may file a written complaint. Any written complaint stating fully the cause and basis thereof shall be filed with the administrator or his/her designee who shall properly record such complaint, immediately investigate, and take action as provided by this Code.
1.
The administrator or his/her designee shall have the power to conduct such investigations as he/she may reasonably deem necessary to carry out his/her duties as prescribed in this Code, and for this purpose to enter at reasonable times upon any property or premises, public or private, to perform any duty imposed upon them by this Code.
2.
No person shall refuse entry or access to the administrator or his/her designee or other authorized representative of the city who requests entry for the purpose of inspection, and who presents appropriate credentials, nor shall any person obstruct, hamper, or interfere with that representative while in the process of carrying out official duties.
3.
The administrator or his/her designee shall have consent of the premises owner or an administrative search warrant to inspect areas not open to the public.
1.
Notice of violation. If it is determined that a person has failed to comply or is no longer in compliance with the provisions of this Code, a notice of violation shall be served by the city upon that person by one of the service methods specified in paragraph 2. The notice shall set forth that which will be necessary to comply with the Code.
2.
Methods of service. The notice of violation shall be delivered to the holder of the development approval and to the landowner of the property involved, if the landowner is not the holder of the development approval, by personal delivery, electronic delivery, or first-class mail and may be provided by similar means to the occupant of the property or the person undertaking the work or activity. The notice of violation may be posted on the property. The notice shall include a description of the violation and its location, the measures necessary to correct it, the possibility of civil penalties and judicial enforcement action and notice of right to appeal. The notice shall also state the time allowed, if any, to correct the violation, which time may vary depending on the nature of the violation and knowledge of the violator. The administrator or his/her designee shall certify to the city that the notice was provided, and the certificate shall be deemed conclusive in the absence of fraud. Except as provided by G.S. 160D-1123 or G.S. 160D-1206 or otherwise provided by law, a notice of violation may be appealed to the board of adjustment pursuant to G.S. 160D-405. When a person has failed to comply with a notice of violation as described above, the administrator or his/her designee shall not be required to provide further notices of violation to that person with regard to the same property before taking any of the enforcement actions authorized by this Code.
Violation of this Code shall not be a crime under G.S. § 14-4 or other law.
The administrator or his/her designee may apply to a court of competent jurisdiction for any appropriate equitable remedy to enforce the provisions of this Code. It is not a defense to the administrator or his/her designee's application for equitable relief that there are other remedies provided under general law or this Code.
1.
Injunction. Enforcement of the provisions of this Code may also be achieved by injunction. When a violation occurs, the administrator or his/her designee may, either before or after the institution of other authorized action, apply to the appropriate division of the general court for a mandatory or prohibitory injunction commanding the defendant to correct the unlawful condition or cease the unlawful use of the property.
2.
Order of abatement. In addition to an injunction, the administrator or his/her designee may apply for and the court may enter an order of abatement as part of the judgment in the case. An order of abatement may direct any of the following actions:
a.
Buildings or other structures on the property be closed, demolished, or removed.
b.
Fixtures, furniture, or other moveable property be moved or removed entirely.
c.
Improvements, alterations, modifications, or repairs be made; or
d.
Any other action be taken that is necessary to bring the property into compliance with this Code.
3.
Execution of court decisions. If the defendant fails or refuses to comply with an injunction or with an order of abatement within the time allowed by the court, he or she may be cited for contempt. The administrator or his/her designee may execute the order of abatement and will have a lien on the property in the nature of a mechanic's and material man's lien for the cost of executing the order. The defendant may secure cancellation of an order of abatement by paying all costs of the proceedings and by posting a bond for compliance with the order. The bond must be given with sureties approved by the Clerk of Superior Court in an amount approved by the judge before whom the matter was heard and shall be conditioned on the defendant's full compliance with the terms of the order of abatement within the time fixed by the judge. Cancellation of an order of abatement does not suspend or cancel an injunction issued in conjunction with the order.
Whenever a building, structure or part thereof is being constructed, demolished, renovated, altered, or repaired in substantial violation of any applicable provision of this Code, the administrator or his/her designee may order the specific part of the work that is in violation, or would be when the work is completed, to be immediately stopped. The stop work order shall be in writing, directed to the person doing the work, and shall state the specific work to be stopped, the specific reasons for cessation and the action(s) necessary to lawfully resume work.
The administrator or his/her designee may revoke any permit (e.g., building certificate of occupancy) by written notification to the permit holder when violations of this Code have occurred. The administrator or his/her designee shall follow the same development review and approval process required for issuance of the permit approval, including any required notice or hearing, in the review and approval of any revocation of that approval. Permits may be revoked when false statements or misrepresentations were made in securing the permit, work is being or has been done in substantial departure from the approved application or plan, there has been a failure to comply with the requirements of this Code, or a permit has been mistakenly issued in violation of this Code.
In addition to the other remedies cited in this Code for the enforcement of its provisions, and pursuant to NCGS 160A-175, the regulations and standards in this Code may be enforced through the issuance of civil penalties by the administrator or his/her designee.
1.
Procedures for civil citations. Subsequent citations for the same violation may be issued by the administrator or his/her designee if the offender does not pay the citation (except as otherwise provided in a warning situation) after it has been issued, unless the offender has sought an appeal to the actions of the administrator or his/her designee through the board of adjustment. Once the ten-day warning period has expired, each day which the violation continues shall subject the violator to additional citations to be issued by the administrator or his/her designee.
2.
Schedule of civil penalties. Unless otherwise provided in this Code, the following penalties are hereby established:
a.
Warning citation. Correct violation within ten days
b.
First citation. $50.00
c.
Second citation for same offense. $100.00
d.
Third and subsequent citations for same offense. $500.00
3.
Recovery of penalties. If the offender fails to pay the civil penalties within 15 days after having been cited, the city may recover the penalties in a civil action in the nature of debt.
1.
Applicability.
a.
General. Violations of Bessemer City Land Development Code Section 3.5 Landscaping and Screening shall be subject to penalties, enforcement, and the procedures relating thereto set forth in section 9.3. Any landscape areas, trees and vegetation preserved or planted as part of an approved landscape plan or permit shall be continually maintained in good condition by the property owner.
b.
Violations.
(1)
Damage. Failure to comply with the landscaping and maintenance requirements of section 3.5 of this Code, or the disturbance, damage or removal of any trees or vegetation prohibited by this Code, shall constitute a violation. This includes the intentional material damage to, or the intentional material alteration of, any landscaped area, tree, or vegetation required to be planted and/or maintained as part of an approved plan or permit. All violations shall be reported by the property owner to the administrator or his/her designee immediately, prior to any corrective action.
(2)
Failure to remedy. It shall likewise constitute a violation of this Code for a property owner to fail, within a reasonable period of time or as specified by this Code, to remedy any material damage to, or alteration of, any landscaped area, tree, or vegetation required to be planted and/or maintained as part of an approved plan or permit, irrespective of whether such damage or alteration was the result of causes beyond the property owner's control, including but not limited to natural forces.
c.
Enforceability. Where a landscaping violation is found to have occurred, the remedies specified in this Code shall be enforced and any civil penalties shall be punishable in accordance with the provisions of this Code. Note: Violations pursuant to this section are not enforceable under N.C.G.S. 14-4.
2.
Replacement.
a.
Extent. All landscaped areas, trees, and vegetation required by this Code which are disturbed or damaged shall be replanted to meet the standards of this Code as well as the approved site/master plan or permit. This includes any tree designated for preservation or installation as part of the approved landscape plan or permit that is removed or dies as a result of negligence or natural forces.
b.
Replanting.
(1)
New vegetation. New trees or vegetation required as part of an approved plan that are damaged or die within 18 months of installation shall be removed and replaced with new vegetation of equal or greater size according to the standards of this Code.
(2)
Existing vegetation. Where the trees or vegetation that have been disturbed or damaged existed on the site at the time the development application was filed, all replacement trees and vegetation shall meet the standards set forth in this Code and take into account any unique site conditions as well as significant vegetation remaining within the landscaped area.
(a)
Location. Replanting shall be located within the vicinity of the violation. If the area is too small for sufficient growth, a more suitable location on the site may be selected as permitted by the administrator or his/her designee in consultation with an arborist, urban forester, or landscape architect.
(b)
Vegetation. Damaged or destroyed vegetation in both perimeter and/or interior landscaped/vegetated areas shall be replaced with an equal amount of new vegetation according to the size of vegetation removed. For buffer areas, understory plantings may also be required to restore the disturbed area to meet Code requirements.
(c)
Trees. Any tree with a caliper of at least 12 inches that is damaged or removed shall be replaced with one or more trees of the same species, as determined by an arborist, urban forester, or landscape architect that have a caliper of at least 2.5 inches and a cumulative caliper equal to one and a half times the total caliper inches of original damaged or removed tree. Trees less than 12 inches in diameter in developments subject to an approved plan and damaged or destroyed shall be replaced to meet Code requirements or the total caliper inches of the trees removed or damaged, whichever is greater.
c.
Approval.
(1)
Plan. All new trees and vegetation must be approved by the administrator or his/her designee, in consultation with an arborist, urban forester, or landscape architect. A replanting plan denoting the proposed installation(s) shall be submitted to the administrator or his/her designee for approval in consultation with an arborist, urban forester, or landscape architect. The replacement plan shall take into consideration the development condition of the site, significant vegetation remaining within landscaped areas, and the required replacement of plant materials.
(2)
Board of adjustment. The administrator or his/her designee may elect to present the replanting plan to the board of adjustment for final approval, as necessary.
d.
Timeline. The responsible party shall replace the required vegetation within the current planting season, next planting season, or as approved by the administrator. If such replacement does not occur within the specified time period, the landscape maintenance bond or other performance guarantee may be drawn upon in order to pay for the cost of replacement. In such case, the replacement tree(s) and vegetation shall be installed by or at the direction of an arborist, urban forester, or landscape architect.
3.
Penalties.
a.
General.
(1)
Responsible parties: Any person or entity who violates any of the sections of this Code, or rules or orders adopted or issued pursuant to these sections, shall be subject to civil penalties as prescribed by this section. The person performing the work, the property owner and the person contracting for the performance shall be jointly and severally liable for any penalty or other enforcement action imposed pursuant to this chapter or other provisions of law on account of work performed in violation of this Code.
(2)
Scope:Penalties assessed under this chapter are in addition to and not in lieu of compliance with the requirements of this Code.
b.
Penalties. Civil penalties for violations of this chapter shall be assessed pursuant to the following:
(1)
Required installations. Failure to plant original or replacement trees and vegetation in accordance with this chapter shall be $100.00 for each tree and $50.00 for each shrub/other vegetation not planted. If the site is not brought into compliance within the time specified in the notice of violation, a civil penalty may be assessed from the date the notice of violation is received until it is adequately corrected, as confirmed by inspection. In the event of a failure to comply with the replacement provisions, the failure to plant each individual tree and/or shrub/vegetation shall constitute a separate, daily, and continuing violation from the day the notice of violation is received.
(2)
Total loss. The intentional or grossly negligent injury or damage to, or destruction of, trees and shrubs/vegetation protected by this Code that result in the total loss of the tree or shrub/vegetation shall be assessed according to the following:
(a)
Penalties for losses in areas regulated by approved plans (master plans, conditional master plans, individual building, or other site plans); in designated tree save or preservation areas; outside of site areas approved for pre-application clearing; or, within the public right-of-way:
(i)
Tree. $500.00 per caliper inch.
(ii)
Shrub. $100.00 per shrub.
(iii)
Vegetated cover. $10.00 per SF of disturbed area.
(iv)
Specimen tree. $500.00 caliper inch up to 24 inches; $800.00 per caliper inch over 24 inches.
Note: The maximum civil penalty for each tree injured, damaged, or destroyed shall not exceed $25,000.00. No notice of violation is needed prior to the assessment of a civil penalty issued pursuant to this subsection.
(b)
Where the exact number of trees/shrubs is unable to be determined, a civil penalty in the amount of $1,000.00 plus $5.00 per square foot of tree canopy removed/critical root zone disturbed shall be exacted.
(c)
Penalties for losses in areas not regulated by an approved plan/permit but where irreparable damage to or removal of existing trees takes place on a site that is subject to the standards of this chapter, but a forestry plan has not been submitted, a landscape plan or an existing conditions plan has not been approved, or where a tree survey has not yet been submitted, a civil penalty shall be imposed in the amount of $5.00 per square foot of tree canopy removed/critical root zone disturbed.
(i)
If the applicant is able to submit the required information and determine the area/number of trees that should have been preserved and with the Town approval, the applicant may reduce the fee imposed to be based on the square footage of the land area that would have been located within all the required tree protection areas, had been established.
(ii)
In all cases, tree replacement is required, in accordance with section 3.5.
(iii)
Development delays in accordance with [G.S. §] 160D-921 may also be enforced.
(3)
Partial damage. The intentional or grossly negligent injury or damage to, or destruction of, trees and shrubs/vegetation protected by this Code that do not result in the total loss of the trees or shrub/vegetation shall be assessed according to the following:
Penalties for partial damage in areas regulated by approved plans (master plans, conditional master plans, individual building, or other site plans); in designated tree save or preservation areas; or, within the public right-of-way:
(a)
Tree. $500.00 per tree.
(b)
Shrub. $50.00 per shrub.
(c)
Vegetated cover. $5.00 per SF of disturbed area.
(d)
Specimen tree. $1,000.00 per tree.
No notice of violation is needed prior to the assessment of a civil penalty issued pursuant to this subsection. Note: Partial damage shall not include general maintenance activities performed in accordance with ANSI A300 Part 1 Pruning, Tree Care Industry Association.
(4)
Tree protection measures. Failure to install or maintain required tree protection measures in accordance with section 3.5 shall be punishable up to $1,000.00 per violation. No civil penalty shall be assessed until the person has been notified of the violation as provided in section 9.2.C. If the site is not brought into compliance within the time specified in the notice of violation, a civil penalty may be assessed from the date the notice of violation is received until it is adequately corrected, as confirmed by inspection. The failure to install the required tree protection measures shall constitute a separate, daily, and continuing violation. Injury or damage to, or destruction of, trees in the tree protection zone and tree save area resulting from the failure to install or maintain required tree protection measures in accordance with section 3.5 constitutes a separate violation which may subject the violator to any other applicable penalty set forth in this section.
(5)
Miscellaneous violations. Any other action that constitutes a violation of this chapter may subject the violator to a civil penalty of $50.00, and each day of continuing violation shall constitute a separate violation. However, the maximum amount of the penalty shall not exceed $1,000.00. If the site is not brought into compliance within the time specified in the notice of violation, a civil penalty may be assessed from the date the notice of violation is received until it is adequately corrected, as confirmed by inspection.
(6)
Non-monetary penalties. At the discretion of the administrator or his/her designee in consultation with the arborist, alternative non-monetary penalties or replanting strategies may be assessed in addition to or in lieu of any monetary penalties prescribed under this section. Plantings shall be approved in accordance with the replacement provisions of this Code.
(7)
Penalties cumulative. The civil penalties provided for in this section may be assessed cumulatively. By way of example only, if a specimen tree and the vegetated cover surrounding it are damaged due to inadequate tree protection measures, a total of at least three separate penalties may be assessed: (i) one for partial loss of the specimen tree; (ii) one for partial loss of the vegetative cover; and (iii) one for the failure to install or maintain required tree protection measures.
c.
Assessment, notice of violation, and payment. The administrator or his/her designee, in consultation with the arborist, shall determine the amount of the civil penalty and shall notify the person who is assessed the civil penalty of the amount of the penalty and the reason for assessing the penalty. The notice of violation shall be served as provided in section 9.2.C and shall direct the violator to either pay the assessment or contest the assessment as specified in this Code. If payment of assessed penalties is not received within 30 days after it is due, or if no request for a hearing has been made as provided in this Code, the assessment shall be considered a debt due and owing to the city, and the matter shall be referred to the city attorney for institution of a civil action to recover the amount of the debt. The civil action may be brought in the Gaston County Superior Court or in any other court of competent jurisdiction.
d.
Civil action for unpaid assessment. A civil action must be filed within three years of the date the assessment was due. An assessment that is not contested is due when the violator is served with a notice of violation. A violation that is contested is due at the conclusion of the administrative and judicial review of the assessment.
4.
Appeals and variances.
a.
General. Any party dissatisfied with a decision of the city adversely affecting such party in the application or enforcement of this Code, including notices of violations and assessments of civil penalties, may request a public hearing before the board of adjustment.
b.
Request. The issuance of a decision, including a notice of violation or assessment of a civil penalty by the city, shall entitle the party subject to the decision or responsible for the violation (petitioner) to a hearing before the board of adjustment if such party submits a written request for a hearing to the administrator or his/her designee within 30 days of the receipt of a decision, notice of violation or assessment of a civil penalty. The right to a hearing shall be communicated by the city as part of its decision, notice of violation, or assessment.
c.
Procedure. Appeals and variances shall follow the rules and procedures set out in NCGS § 160D-406 and § 160D-705, as amended, and Chapter 7 of the Bessemer City Land Development Code.
Any sign that has been installed without a permit or is otherwise in violation of this Code must be removed by the owner or property manager after notice has been given by the administrator or his/her designee. Provided the time to remove the sign is not less than 24 hours, notice shall be considered sufficient. Notice shall only be provided once for the violation. Repeat violations, occurring within 12 months, using the same or a similar sign at the same location (e.g., use of a plastic A-frame sign after being given notice of violation or continued use of an off-site sign to advertise a business) will not be provided another notice of violation but, instead, will be issued a civil citation.
1.
For the second through fifth violations, $100.00 per offense.
2.
For the sixth through tenth violations, $500.00 per offense.
3.
For the eleventh and all future violations, $1000.00 per offense.
Each day the illegal sign is in use is considered a separate offense. If the responsible person fails to pay the civil penalty or appeal the assessment within 15 days of being notified of the amount due, the city may recover the penalties in a civil action in the nature of a debt. An appeal of a civil penalty assessment may be made to the board of adjustment.
Violation of the floodplain provisions of this Code including violation of conditions and safeguards established in connection with grants of floodplain development permits or variances shall be corrected in accordance with the provisions of section 5.1.