Paint. Painted, well-finished wood and metal were the most characteristic finish materials of the late nineteenth and early 20th century. Painted wood that has been properly prepared and finished presents a handsome, extremely durable and colorful surface for all buildings.
Semi-gloss alkyd enamel paint, when applied to a properly prepared surface, forms the best protection possible for wood and metal. Semi-gloss finish is recommended because it is easily cleaned, it enhances the color, yet does not severely highlight defects or surface irregularities. Labor is the costly factor in painting. Buying good quality materials insures a lower labor cost over a long period because of the extended life that can be expected from good quality materials.
Painting is as difficult to do well as any other aspect of the building trades. A roller does not yield the kind of finished, silky-painted surface that a good china bristle brush produces in the hands of a skilled craftsperson. The last coat of paint is the first thing seen. Good craftsmanship in this final step will guarantee a noticeable quality appearance.
Recent years have seen the popularity of unpainted, unfinished wood increase. Unfinished woods tend to have a more rustic look, which is less appropriate in the traditionally business-oriented mercantile section of West Orange than it would be in the more rural areas of town.
Well-finished materials give a more formal, "dressed" appearance to a portion of town where this "dress" has traditionally been the case.
Color decisions, although very subjective, can use objective criteria for narrowing choices and reducing the possibility of random and harmonious selection.